(09-06-2023, 09:47 PM)Protheroe Wrote: You've truly moonshot the semantics if you're claiming "small" is materially different to "significant but modest".
But I'm glad that you're not calling for anything more, at least not yet.
I'm not claiming it to be "significant but modest", that's what the authors of the published research are claiming from their analysis and inference of the data. That is a direct quote from the abstract.
Other quotes from the article (linked above if you don't believe me) with respect to significant being used for NO2 and NOx reductions:
"To briefly summarise our results, we find statistically significant reductions in NO2 and NOx (up to 4% and 7% reductions respectively) over the first 7-months (June to Dec 2021) post implementation period at two out of three roadside sites within the CAZ."
"To provide a broader picture, Figures A6 and A7 illustrate the weekly weather normalised NO2 trends at roadside and urban background sites, respectively, including both treatment and control sites. During the 3-month period after CAZ implementation (June to Aug 2021), the trend at the control sites behaved similarly to those in Birmingham. However, a significant and clear increase in weather normalised NO2 levels were observed around Sep 2021 for some roadside sites (both treatment and control sites), suggesting that the elevated emissions occurring around early Sep 2021 might complicate the CAZ evaluation during the 3–6 months post CAZ implementation (Sep to Nov 2021)."
"Figure 1 presents the ‘gap’ plot (i.e. the CAZ impact), which refers to the difference between weather normalised NO2 (NOX) and the synthetic counterfactuals. The shaded area refers to the 95% point-wise confidence intervals calculated using a Jackknife + procedure (Ben-Michael et al. 2021). Figure 1 suggests that, during the period June to Aug 2021 the weather normalised NO2 and NOX levels for roadside sites within the CAZ (St Chads Queensway, Colmore Row) were significantly reduced relative to the synthetic counterfactual."
"The average NO2 level of roadside sites within the CAZ was reduced immediately and significantly after the CAZ implementation and rebounded gradually after Jan 2022. The average NO2 level of roadside sites outside the CAZ and urban site within the CAZ showed similar trends (with slightly lower reductions compared with roadside sites within the CAZ), with no significant changes detected for urban sites outside CAZ."
"Our results (Fig. 1, Table 1, Figures A8, A9, and A10) suggest that, during the seven months post CAZ implementation period (June to Dec 2021), the significant reductions of both pollutants at roadside sites within the CAZ (St Chads Queensway for post 3-month, Colmore Row, Lower Severn Street) and outside the CAZ (Selly Oak, Stratford Road) may be attributed to the CAZ implementation."
"Figure A12 shows that there was no significant reduction of weather normalised NO2 detected at the two roadside sites within the CAZ, suggesting that our main results are not observed by accident. Interestingly, for St Chads Queensway, we also found a significant increase of NO2 around August and September 2019. Table A5 reports the CAZ impact of the main results (2021 data) and the in-time placebo tests (2019 data) for St Chads Queensway, suggesting that St Chads Queensway might have experienced greater NO2 elevation (as in 2019) around Aug/ Sep in 2021 if the CAZ were not implemented in Birmingham.Footnote17"
"Interestingly, we found significant reductions of NO2 and NOx for roadside sites outside CAZ (Selly Oak and Stratford Road), suggesting the “positive spill-over effect” of the CAZ, showing the possibility of traffic and journey reductions overall as a result of behavioural changes. However, more detailed traffic and pollution data from more sites is needed to provide a definitive understanding of the potential spillover effects for other areas outside the CAZ."
"We find significant reductions in NO2 (and NOx), relative to the non-CAZ control scenario, over a 7-month post implementation period at most roadside sites within the CAZ. As expected, the biggest reductions of NO2 are at busy roadside locations within the Clean Air Zone, while no significant changes were detected for the urban background site outside CAZ."