Posts: 3,733
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
My son has been having trouble getting his car repaired. It's been off the road for 7 weeks now, over 3 weeks at the garage. He's understandably depressed about it, I'm worried he's going to get seriously out of pocket.
The situation is this: he owns a high spec modded car, which one day when trying to move from 2nd to 3rd, he went into 1st. Car made a horrible noise but was still drivable, but from then on, when idling in neutral, he could hear a knocking noise. Some people said issue was gearbox, others clutch. He ordered a new clutch that took weeks to arrive. Garage doing the repair modified the clutch for some reason but when everything was put back together, the gears don't engage, the car simply won't move now. There's an impasse. Clutch suppliers (from outside UK) and garage at loggerheads. Supplier suggesting either son ordered wrong one or garage shouldn't have modified clutch; garage suggesting suppliers sent wrong one.
I think my son is tempted to take car to another garage. Where does he stand? From my POV, garage hasn't fixed the car so shouldn't get paid anything. If my son has ordered wrong part, how can he return it given garage modified it? It's a bit of a shitshow and could cost my son thousands.
Any advice?
Posts: 10,866
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
08-29-2023, 06:09 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-29-2023, 06:15 AM by Peachy.)
(08-29-2023, 12:31 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: My son has been having trouble getting his car repaired. It's been off the road for 7 weeks now, over 3 weeks at the garage. He's understandably depressed about it, I'm worried he's going to get seriously out of pocket.
The situation is this: he owns a high spec modded car, which one day when trying to move from 2nd to 3rd, he went into 1st. Car made a horrible noise but was still drivable, but from then on, when idling in neutral, he could hear a knocking noise. Some people said issue was gearbox, others clutch. He ordered a new clutch that took weeks to arrive. Garage doing the repair modified the clutch for some reason but when everything was put back together, the gears don't engage, the car simply won't move now. There's an impasse. Clutch suppliers (from outside UK) and garage at loggerheads. Supplier suggesting either son ordered wrong one or garage shouldn't have modified clutch; garage suggesting suppliers sent wrong one.
I think my son is tempted to take car to another garage. Where does he stand? From my POV, garage hasn't fixed the car so shouldn't get paid anything. If my son has ordered wrong part, how can he return it given garage modified it? It's a bit of a shitshow and could cost my son thousands.
Any advice?
Firstly no one takes a car to be repaired at a garage and expects to get it back in worse condition. Especially if the car is undrivable.
Secondly, even if the clutch was wrong, then the garage (the experts) should have noticed this long before fitting it and certainly shouldn't have modified it without being 100% certain they knew what they were doing. By modifying it they have almost certainly invalidated any warranty that would have come with it meaning your son will be out of pocket. That would be my argument for not paying the garage a penny. You entrusted them with that part which they have broken.
If the part was incorrect its largely a moot point as like I said above it should have been bought to your attention straight away and then you could have taken it up with the supplier.
All said and done I would try and resolve the whole issue with the current garage as starting again with another will undoubtedly cost you more money in the long run. If they are a decent garage they should have insurance for this sort of thing happening.
Try settling it as amicably as possible and if it escalates and all else fails then threaten them with legal action.
Posts: 47
Threads: 3
Joined: Apr 2023
Reputation:
0
(08-29-2023, 06:09 AM)Peachy Wrote: (08-29-2023, 12:31 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: My son has been having trouble getting his car repaired. It's been off the road for 7 weeks now, over 3 weeks at the garage. He's understandably depressed about it, I'm worried he's going to get seriously out of pocket.
The situation is this: he owns a high spec modded car, which one day when trying to move from 2nd to 3rd, he went into 1st. Car made a horrible noise but was still drivable, but from then on, when idling in neutral, he could hear a knocking noise. Some people said issue was gearbox, others clutch. He ordered a new clutch that took weeks to arrive. Garage doing the repair modified the clutch for some reason but when everything was put back together, the gears don't engage, the car simply won't move now. There's an impasse. Clutch suppliers (from outside UK) and garage at loggerheads. Supplier suggesting either son ordered wrong one or garage shouldn't have modified clutch; garage suggesting suppliers sent wrong one.
I think my son is tempted to take car to another garage. Where does he stand? From my POV, garage hasn't fixed the car so shouldn't get paid anything. If my son has ordered wrong part, how can he return it given garage modified it? It's a bit of a shitshow and could cost my son thousands.
Any advice?
Firstly no one takes a car to be repaired at a garage and expects to get it back in worse condition. Especially if the car is undrivable.
Secondly, even if the clutch was wrong, then the garage (the experts) should have noticed this long before fitting it and certainly shouldn't have modified it without being 100% certain they knew what they were doing. By modifying it they have almost certainly invalidated any warranty that would have come with it meaning your son will be out of pocket. That would be my argument for not paying the garage a penny. You entrusted them with that part which they have broken.
If the part was incorrect its largely a moot point as like I said above it should have been bought to your attention straight away and then you could have taken it up with the supplier.
All said and done I would try and resolve the whole issue with the current garage as starting again with another will undoubtedly cost you more money in the long run. If they are a decent garage they should have insurance for this sort of thing happening.
Try settling it as amicably as possible and if it escalates and all else fails then threaten them with legal action.
Very sound advice from Peachy , in my view
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
08-29-2023, 07:56 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-29-2023, 08:15 AM by Fulham Fallout.)
My advice is this
1) get your son to check if he bought the clutch or not? My guess is he did and he doesn’t want to tell you he bought the wrong one. He will have a record on his email account if he bought it online, or on his bank statement if purchased over the counter / online. He’d have a receipt either way. And let's be honest, he will know whether he bought the clutch or not without having to check.
2) if your son did buy the clutch, was it the wrong one he ordered or did the supplier send the wrong one?
After establishing the answers to 1 & 2 above and in possession of all the facts, contact both of the following for free advice
Citizens advice bureau
Trading standards
Them are my onions. Good luck, as it must be a stressful time for your son and yourself and family.
oh and having a read online, the damage due to going from 2nd to 1st is most likely the valves. I personally doubt the clutch would fail for the engine high revving having changed to 1st gear.
Posts: 17,081
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
No one should modify a clutch whether it was the right one or not. Having said that have the modifications to the car made it a necessity that any clutch will need to be modified? If the latter is the case I have no idea where you start as I imagine any tinkering with the clutch will automatically fug the warranty up.
Posts: 4,323
Threads: 139
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
What car is it and where (roughly) is he based?
Posts: 3,733
Threads: 116
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
08-29-2023, 12:52 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-29-2023, 12:53 PM by chasetownbaggie.)
FF, my son ordered the clutch from a supplier in EU. Whether it is correct part or not is still being debated but I agree with Peachy and Derek that if it was wrong one, garage should have said, not attempt a bodge. I'll bear CAB in my mind though
Parrot, he's got a VW Polo GTI. We're in Chasetown
Posts: 4,323
Threads: 139
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
Sounds like a money shift and as above, Its more likely to be damage to the valves and pistons or cylinder head than the clutch.
They have probably cocked up setting the gear linkage cables, or damaged them, the wrong clutch would make shifts jumpy but wouldn't stop gears engaging.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
08-29-2023, 10:30 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-29-2023, 10:38 PM by Tom Joad.)
I suspect it may be more tricky than at first it may seem. From your post I gather your son's car is high spec, I presume modified? And he bought the clutch himself? What was the actual brief to the garage? Fit the clutch or solve the problem? It would probably be better for the garage to order the part as they will use regular suppliers and have some scope/goodwill for returning any parts which may not fit, it does happen, a lot. After market parts can vary and if the vehicle itself has been modified there may be an element of "try this". Clutch removal often involves leaving tippex style marks to guide fitting the new one. There can be some trial and error in these cases which not all garages want to take on.
I can only suggest engaging with the garage to get to the bottom of what has been done and what can be done to fix it properly. A different garage would almost certainly do a series of examinations to arrive at what they deem necessary to put the car right, it's the right thing to do but will come with it's own bill regardless of what has been previously spent.
|