TGH
(08-23-2023, 09:22 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 09:10 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 09:00 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 08:38 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 08:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think the problem was/is the owners don’t want the club so we’re looking at short term solutions to getting out of the club with as much money as they could. There was no plan as far as anyone can tell beyond this. This was my point when I said I didn’t want long term plans beyond the parachute payments as it was clear we didn’t have any money, any clue, or any interest in building for the future with long term solutions. You can argue that it would have aided the owners if they had put these in place but from their perspective I imagine as soon as the Chinese Government said it had no long term interested in football that was as far as their interest went and they have been looking to get out ever since.

Long term solutions only work with owners who are interested, they aren’t and a sale of the club to hopefully better owners who do have a long term vision can’t come quickly enough.

A good summary.  Although it’s still possible do have a long term strategy of recruiting younger, hungrier players with upside potential, than 32/33 year olds with no resale value on high wages looking for a final payday.  That strategy, together with maximizing our excellent academy, should prevail permanently 
regardless of whether we have a short, medium or long-term strategy. 

Recruitment. Scouting. Academy.  RSA.  That needs to be the mantra.

But that is the opposite of our strategy/ approach. In 2023 so far we have signed Albrighton and Chalobah. We are reluctant to give
academy players a go O'Shea has gone for a low price, TGH has gone for the season and we nearly let Plamer go. Who is next?

Yes - because we don’t have a head of recruitment, or a scouting network in place. 

TGH was given plenty of goes.  So was Ferguson.  Harper and Edwards were given lots of goes.  Clearey missed out as he was refusing to sign a new contract.  Palmer and Griffiths and O’Shea all came through the academy. Taylor has too - he’ll get his chance. 

There are plenty still to leave if we don’t get a new owner soon.  A £35m drop on revenue is a much larger hole to fill than some seem to realise.  

O’Shea only signed his new contract because he negotiated a release clause.  That set the price.  If we hadn’t agreed it then we’d have received nothing at the end of his contract (just like Johnstone) rather than the £7m that we did receive.

Bewilders me how the club seem to have no template whatsoever to follow from the Peace era, where we recruited well and had clear strategies on contracts etc.

Short-termism is an inevitable consequence of multiple short tenures of manager.  Squads become unbalanced and not compatible with how the new manager wants to play.  So he signs a few new players to try to play that way but needs 2 or 3 transfer windows to achieve it - if he can offload unwanted players.  Then he gets sacked halfway through that timescale.  Back to square one, and the squad is then even more disjointed.  

It’s like trying to do a jigsaw puzzle with pieces from other boxes.
Reply
without having any bearing on CC as a manager, our recent history of signings has been pretty dismal. lets hope the plans are improving and the latest 2 additions and any others incoming, prove to be more fruitful than recent options.
Reply
(08-23-2023, 10:31 AM)Pipes of Peace Wrote: without having any bearing on CC as a manager, our recent history of signings has been pretty dismal.  lets hope the plans are improving and the latest 2 additions and any others incoming, prove to be more fruitful than recent options.

Unfortunately we still need to move on players. We haven't chopped any staff so our running costs are still way to high. We need another £20m to break even this season. We have generated £8m from transfers and saved £5m in salaries.
But unless we get serious and slash our overhead were still going to be out of cash by the new year.
I'm still expecting a keeper and 2 other players to leave to help with cash flow. Our recruitment department may as well close as they have failed to find a new Cyril, Hughes, Olsen, McAuley anyone in fact. 
I'm a little concerned Carlos hasn't shown more faith in our youngsters ATM. I trust his judgement but where are our replacements coming from.
Reply
We can only hope for a new investor and promotion. Otherwise, we can forget it.
Reply
(08-23-2023, 10:48 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:31 AM)Pipes of Peace Wrote: without having any bearing on CC as a manager, our recent history of signings has been pretty dismal.  lets hope the plans are improving and the latest 2 additions and any others incoming, prove to be more fruitful than recent options.

Unfortunately we still need to move on players. We haven't chopped any staff so our running costs are still way to high. We need another £20m to break even this season. We have generated £8m from transfers and saved £5m in salaries.
But unless we get serious and slash our overhead were still going to be out of cash by the new year.
I'm still expecting a keeper and 2 other players to leave to help with cash flow. Our recruitment department may as well close as they have failed to find a new Cyril, Hughes, Olsen, McAuley anyone in fact. 
I'm a little concerned Carlos hasn't shown more faith in our youngsters ATM. I trust his judgement but where are our replacements coming from.

The way it's going he's going to have to show faith in the U10s....
Reply
(08-23-2023, 10:50 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: We can only hope for a new investor and promotion. Otherwise, we can forget it.

Why would anyone buy our club for say 60 million when they can get us for peanuts if we go bust ? 


We have a few serious people wanting to buy us it's a waiting game and hopefully lai folds his cards and sells us for peanuts it's our only hope .
Reply
(08-23-2023, 10:55 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:50 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: We can only hope for a new investor and promotion. Otherwise, we can forget it.

Why would anyone buy our club for say 60 million when they can get us for peanuts if we go bust ? 


We have a few serious people wanting to buy us it's a waiting game and hopefully lai folds his cards and sells us for peanuts it's our only hope .

Albion are worth 35m at the moment, but with the debts up it to 50-55m. I think around what the Dingles were bought for by Fosun. 
You basically agree with what I said. Unless Lai goes, forget it. Best option is admin, unless there's someone waiting  in the wings..

(08-23-2023, 10:55 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:50 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: We can only hope for a new investor and promotion. Otherwise, we can forget it.

Why would anyone buy our club for say 60 million when they can get us for peanuts if we go bust ? 


We have a few serious people wanting to buy us it's a waiting game and hopefully lai folds his cards and sells us for peanuts it's our only hope .

On top of this, surely these  people waiting, wouldn't want to see us fall too far into the shit, as it make sit harder to get us up o the required standard and later make a profit in selling. If they come in now, they still have a chance of not wasting the season.
Reply
Depends on how people want to value the club. They may not see us as a £60m club at the moment but they could see us as a bargain. Unfortunately, with the mess we’re in that everyone knows about, they will essentially buy us when the value falls as we are little but an investment to most. Someone my think the intrinsic value of us being an established PL side is around £120m so being able to buy us at £60m is too high and inevitably will wait until it’s more like £20m-£30m as that is more of a punt worth taking.

Lai will give it another 3-4months and see where we are. Chance of promotion and he’ll risk it to get most back as he can. No chance of promotion and he’ll have little choice but to drop the value more.

Buyers know all this and will wait in most cases unless they really, really want us.
Reply
(08-23-2023, 10:48 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:31 AM)Pipes of Peace Wrote: without having any bearing on CC as a manager, our recent history of signings has been pretty dismal.  lets hope the plans are improving and the latest 2 additions and any others incoming, prove to be more fruitful than recent options.

Unfortunately we still need to move on players. We haven't chopped any staff so our running costs are still way to high. We need another £20m to break even this season. We have generated £8m from transfers and saved £5m in salaries.
But unless we get serious and slash our overhead were still going to be out of cash by the new year.
I'm still expecting a keeper and 2 other players to leave to help with cash flow. Our recruitment department may as well close as they have failed to find a new Cyril, Hughes, Olsen, McAuley anyone in fact. 
I'm a little concerned Carlos hasn't shown more faith in our youngsters ATM. I trust his judgement but where are our replacements coming from.

Rubbish.  The £20m MSD loan provides us with enough certainty to see through this season, which is an undertaking that we are obliged to provide to the EFL.   That’s precisely why the £20m loan was taken out. Beyond next June is a different question.

(08-23-2023, 11:02 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:55 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:50 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: We can only hope for a new investor and promotion. Otherwise, we can forget it.

Why would anyone buy our club for say 60 million when they can get us for peanuts if we go bust ? 


We have a few serious people wanting to buy us it's a waiting game and hopefully lai folds his cards and sells us for peanuts it's our only hope .

Albion are worth 35m at the moment, but with the debts up it to 50-55m. I think around what the Dingles were bought for by Fosun. 
You basically agree with what I said. Unless Lai goes, forget it. Best option is admin, unless there's someone waiting  in the wings..

(08-23-2023, 10:55 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:50 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: We can only hope for a new investor and promotion. Otherwise, we can forget it.

Why would anyone buy our club for say 60 million when they can get us for peanuts if we go bust ? 


We have a few serious people wanting to buy us it's a waiting game and hopefully lai folds his cards and sells us for peanuts it's our only hope .

On top of this, surely these  people waiting, wouldn't want to see us fall too far into the shit, as it make sit harder to get us up o the required standard and later make a profit in selling. If they come in now, they still have a chance of not wasting the season.

Correct.  People are totally under-estimating just far going into admin would set us back.

(08-23-2023, 10:48 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:31 AM)Pipes of Peace Wrote: without having any bearing on CC as a manager, our recent history of signings has been pretty dismal.  lets hope the plans are improving and the latest 2 additions and any others incoming, prove to be more fruitful than recent options.

Unfortunately we still need to move on players. We haven't chopped any staff so our running costs are still way to high. We need another £20m to break even this season. We have generated £8m from transfers and saved £5m in salaries.
But unless we get serious and slash our overhead were still going to be out of cash by the new year.
I'm still expecting a keeper and 2 other players to leave to help with cash flow. Our recruitment department may as well close as they have failed to find a new Cyril, Hughes, Olsen, McAuley anyone in fact. 
I'm a little concerned Carlos hasn't shown more faith in our youngsters ATM. I trust his judgement but where are our replacements coming from.

Rubbish.  The £20m MSD loan provides us with enough certainty to see through this season, which is an undertaking that we are obliged to provide to the EFL.   That’s precisely why the £20m loan was taken out. Beyond next June is a different question.
Reply
(08-23-2023, 11:40 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:48 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:31 AM)Pipes of Peace Wrote: without having any bearing on CC as a manager, our recent history of signings has been pretty dismal.  lets hope the plans are improving and the latest 2 additions and any others incoming, prove to be more fruitful than recent options.

Unfortunately we still need to move on players. We haven't chopped any staff so our running costs are still way to high. We need another £20m to break even this season. We have generated £8m from transfers and saved £5m in salaries.
But unless we get serious and slash our overhead were still going to be out of cash by the new year.
I'm still expecting a keeper and 2 other players to leave to help with cash flow. Our recruitment department may as well close as they have failed to find a new Cyril, Hughes, Olsen, McAuley anyone in fact. 
I'm a little concerned Carlos hasn't shown more faith in our youngsters ATM. I trust his judgement but where are our replacements coming from.

Rubbish.  The £20m MSD loan provides us with enough certainty to see through this season, which is an undertaking that we are obliged to provide to the EFL.   That’s precisely why the £20m loan was taken out. Beyond next June is a different question.

(08-23-2023, 11:02 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:55 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:50 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: We can only hope for a new investor and promotion. Otherwise, we can forget it.

Why would anyone buy our club for say 60 million when they can get us for peanuts if we go bust ? 


We have a few serious people wanting to buy us it's a waiting game and hopefully lai folds his cards and sells us for peanuts it's our only hope .

Albion are worth 35m at the moment, but with the debts up it to 50-55m. I think around what the Dingles were bought for by Fosun. 
You basically agree with what I said. Unless Lai goes, forget it. Best option is admin, unless there's someone waiting  in the wings..

(08-23-2023, 10:55 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:50 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: We can only hope for a new investor and promotion. Otherwise, we can forget it.

Why would anyone buy our club for say 60 million when they can get us for peanuts if we go bust ? 


We have a few serious people wanting to buy us it's a waiting game and hopefully lai folds his cards and sells us for peanuts it's our only hope .

On top of this, surely these  people waiting, wouldn't want to see us fall too far into the shit, as it make sit harder to get us up o the required standard and later make a profit in selling. If they come in now, they still have a chance of not wasting the season.

Correct.  People are totally under-estimating just far going into admin would set us back.

(08-23-2023, 10:48 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(08-23-2023, 10:31 AM)Pipes of Peace Wrote: without having any bearing on CC as a manager, our recent history of signings has been pretty dismal.  lets hope the plans are improving and the latest 2 additions and any others incoming, prove to be more fruitful than recent options.

Unfortunately we still need to move on players. We haven't chopped any staff so our running costs are still way to high. We need another £20m to break even this season. We have generated £8m from transfers and saved £5m in salaries.
But unless we get serious and slash our overhead were still going to be out of cash by the new year.
I'm still expecting a keeper and 2 other players to leave to help with cash flow. Our recruitment department may as well close as they have failed to find a new Cyril, Hughes, Olsen, McAuley anyone in fact. 
I'm a little concerned Carlos hasn't shown more faith in our youngsters ATM. I trust his judgement but where are our replacements coming from.

Rubbish.  The £20m MSD loan provides us with enough certainty to see through this season, which is an undertaking that we are obliged to provide to the EFL.   That’s precisely why the £20m loan was taken out. Beyond next June is a different question.

That £20m won't provide certainty at all, it's all gone - it kept us out of administration for a short period. The player sales/departures are now keeping us afloat.

Admin is coming.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)