TGH
(08-22-2023, 08:46 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:44 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:38 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:34 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:28 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Pay off with what? 

A player on £30k a week with 12 months left is over £1.5mill!!! 

It’s simple maths! 

Said player is wanted by let’s say Coventry…..they can’t afford the £30k a week….and offer £15k a week! That means player for first season only at Coventry is already £750k worse off…..so WBA have to stump up the £750k.   It’s then for the player to agree that year two / year three he’s happy to be paid £15k.  If yes…. Deal is possible but still costing WBA £750k!!!! 

That example is for someone with 12 months left….. if even more it’s even more costly!
That sounds rather like Mowatt. 

Yes - that clearly happened with Button. There could be an incentive offered to do so. I’d prefer to pay say Chalobah £20k a week and have him gone than £30k and have him in the squad. That is a saving of £500k per annum plus bonuses, employers NI etc.

Players rarely end contracts by mutual consent…. Eg. Pay off.   Huge insecurity for player. 

Chalobah only been at club 5 minutes as well. Board quite rightly will be wanting to get best possible deal for them.  Giving him a lump sum for doing nothing would be madness when squad is threadbare.  He then takes let’s say £500k from us…. A week later gets himself another deal and we get nothing.  At least we can try and secure the cost of his wages over the term of his contract!
It happens loads in January with players whose contracts expire in the summer. I haven’t mentioned a lump sum at all. If you agree to subsidise salary and the player backs himself to get a decent contract it is win-win isn’t it?

Not for most players. 
Injuries theyd have no security. The lump sum would be the ‘pay off’ equivalent to the wages or 80-90% of wages for remaining term of contract as you described to “get him gone”.
Yep you’re right - we’re lumbered with overpaid players offering nothing for the next year and are stuck. There are no solutions. I’m sure Peace and Jenkins would have given up too.
Reply
(08-22-2023, 08:36 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: What a terrible deal, whether CC fancied him or not it’s still an awful negotiation and shows what a fucking mess we’re in.

£1.3m is stupidly low, but to allow it to be an option in their favour is criminal.  I doubt there’s any type of anti-embarsssment clause either.

If he’s shit they send him back.  If he’s mid-table Champ they’ve had a bargain and if he has a very good season they’ll make themselves £5-10m profit by signing him and selling him instantly.

With a smaller squad surely a utility player is useful.  We can’t have been paying him enough to make a difference when trying to sign a replacement (assuming we do). 

I fully understand that it’s difficult to find buyers for players who are overpaid but surely we’d have been better off with a Grant-esque deal for Mowatt?  Save £10-20k off the wage bill and retain a player that covers the holes in the squad a little.

I reiterate - shit deal whether CC wanted him or not.
Can’t see it as a shit deal hardly played for us, he didn’t want to be here we 700 grand loan fee plus 1.3 mill if he goes and there is a sell on fee. If he comes back (hopefully not) we can still either keep or sell on. For me it’s a win win for a player who attitude seems to be going down hill.  I’ve heard Mowatt will go also I’m not ITK never have been but from snippets I’ve heard he will be gone. I can think of a player with more experience than TGH that cost us 300 grand and plays regularly for us and yet you think we’ve made a bad deal. This is where we are at present and this is a good deal.
Reply
(08-22-2023, 08:48 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: As has been discussed on many, many threads, too many of our players are on big fat payday contracts and we’ve failed to effectively manage that. A more sensible football department would have planned for this eventuality but we were either too deluded or incompetent to even bother.

The hard truth is we have very few saleable assets, and those that we have are by their very nature the ones we want to keep. We are currently in the worst part of this mess, where we have to raise whatever value we can short term by selling any long term assets just to pay today’s bills. What we need now is a fucking good plan and a bit of luck to ensure when the money we are currently raising runs out again in 12 months time, we have something more to sell.

I really hope Taylor, Dike, Ingram, Fellows and Co come good as without them next season is looking fucking bleak.

Reach, Mowatt, Kipré, Phillips, Bartley, Pieters all see their contracts expire this summer which is fine, except we don’t really have anyone or any money to replace them!

(08-22-2023, 08:47 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:43 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What is a workable budget that is sustainable? Still haven’t got an answer from those who seem to know the intricacies of our clubs finances.

About a third of our current wage budget.

How many clubs are in debt in the Championship? How many are self sustainable? How many clubs have similar loans to us? Just trying to ascertain how realistic the current plan and future plan is for the club.

I don’t think any of them have loans or ownership structures like we do. They’re either sustainable businesses or being propped up by owners.

Swansea the closest to our ownership in that their owners were asset stripping after relegation, but they at least invest in players with a very to selling on and promote 2-3 academy lads every year.

Which is why club officials are doing all they can to a) pay bills for 12-18 months and at the same time B) provide CC with a competitive squad. 

It’s takes creativity and bravery in some of the decisions. 

We also are crave C) and are actively pursuing buyers….. we get buyers and we achieve A and B……we survive and start again! The hope will be back. 

If we achieve A and B without C…… next season is even tougher but again survivable!  

Not achieving A and B…. Is unthinkable.
Reply
(08-22-2023, 08:44 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:36 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: What a terrible deal, whether CC fancied him or not it’s still an awful negotiation and shows what a fucking mess we’re in.

£1.3m is stupidly low, but to allow it to be an option in their favour is criminal.  I doubt there’s any type of anti-embarsssment clause either.

If he’s shit they send him back.  If he’s mid-table Champ they’ve had a bargain and if he has a very good season they’ll make themselves £5-10m profit by signing him and selling him instantly.

With a smaller squad surely a utility player is useful.  We can’t have been paying him enough to make a difference when trying to sign a replacement (assuming we do). 

I fully understand that it’s difficult to find buyers for players who are overpaid but surely we’d have been better off with a Grant-esque deal for Mowatt?  Save £10-20k off the wage bill and retain a player that covers the holes in the squad a little.

I reiterate - shit deal whether CC wanted him or not.

But the player WANTED to leave and Carlos wasn’t picking him….
Oh ok.  Why did we bother asking for a fee then? We should have just let him leave for nowt.

It’s a shit deal, i can understand (to an extent) our need to sell is paramount, but it’s still a shit deal. 

He hasn’t even left, merely on loan.  If he’s shit he’s back to being our problem, if he’s a star they’ll sigh and sell on.

I’m not bothered that he’s left (if CC has sanctioned it) just that it’s a really bad deal for us.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
How have we gained £1m from this? An option is just that, if he does not do well then he's back with us...

Just hope there is a replacement lined up
Reply
It’s another crap deal negotiated by the divs in charge by the sounds of it. What happened to Mark promising we would get market value or over for any departures after the sale of O’Shea? Since then we’ve loaned out Grant for free and two academy players with pathetic future fee options. All good and well saying we’ve saved however much in wages but we now need right back and CM cover anyway. TGH has played in 3 out of the 4 games this season
Reply
(08-22-2023, 08:56 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:44 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:36 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: What a terrible deal, whether CC fancied him or not it’s still an awful negotiation and shows what a fucking mess we’re in.

£1.3m is stupidly low, but to allow it to be an option in their favour is criminal.  I doubt there’s any type of anti-embarsssment clause either.

If he’s shit they send him back.  If he’s mid-table Champ they’ve had a bargain and if he has a very good season they’ll make themselves £5-10m profit by signing him and selling him instantly.

With a smaller squad surely a utility player is useful.  We can’t have been paying him enough to make a difference when trying to sign a replacement (assuming we do). 

I fully understand that it’s difficult to find buyers for players who are overpaid but surely we’d have been better off with a Grant-esque deal for Mowatt?  Save £10-20k off the wage bill and retain a player that covers the holes in the squad a little.

I reiterate - shit deal whether CC wanted him or not.

But the player WANTED to leave and Carlos wasn’t picking him….
Oh ok.  Why did we bother asking for a fee then? We should have just let him leave for nowt.

It’s a shit deal, i can understand (to an extent) our need to sell is paramount, but it’s still a shit deal. 

He hasn’t even left, merely on loan.  If he’s shit he’s back to being our problem, if he’s a star they’ll sigh and sell on.

I’m not bothered that he’s left (if CC has sanctioned it) just that it’s a really bad deal for us.

“Why did we ask for a fee then? We should have let his leave for nowt?!”

That statement explains a lot. 

Player is under contract under 2026 and has been with us since the age of 9 (could have been 8)….. of course we demand a loan fee and a transfer fee if we eventually sell or should I say, Bristol agree to buy.

Would have been a disaster if he’d left for “nowt”
Reply
(08-22-2023, 08:48 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: As has been discussed on many, many threads, too many of our players are on big fat payday contracts and we’ve failed to effectively manage that. A more sensible football department would have planned for this eventuality but we were either too deluded or incompetent to even bother.

The hard truth is we have very few saleable assets, and those that we have are by their very nature the ones we want to keep. We are currently in the worst part of this mess, where we have to raise whatever value we can short term by selling any long term assets just to pay today’s bills. What we need now is a fucking good plan and a bit of luck to ensure when the money we are currently raising runs out again in 12 months time, we have something more to sell.

I really hope Taylor, Dike, Ingram, Fellows and Co come good as without them next season is looking fucking bleak.

Reach, Mowatt, Kipré, Phillips, Bartley, Pieters all see their contracts expire this summer which is fine, except we don’t really have anyone or any money to replace them!

(08-22-2023, 08:47 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:43 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: What is a workable budget that is sustainable? Still haven’t got an answer from those who seem to know the intricacies of our clubs finances.

About a third of our current wage budget.

How many clubs are in debt in the Championship? How many are self sustainable? How many clubs have similar loans to us? Just trying to ascertain how realistic the current plan and future plan is for the club.

I don’t think any of them have loans or ownership structures like we do. They’re either sustainable businesses or being propped up by owners.

Swansea the closest to our ownership in that their owners were asset stripping after relegation, but they at least invest in players with a very to selling on and promote 2-3 academy lads every year.

Quite, for all the talk of selling this player or another, this is not sustainable given our clubs circumstances and it’s very very optimistic that we will somehow find an even keel whilst servicing debts on loans and playing kids, buying cheap players and still competing at this level.
Reply
(08-22-2023, 08:59 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:56 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:44 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 08:36 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: What a terrible deal, whether CC fancied him or not it’s still an awful negotiation and shows what a fucking mess we’re in.

£1.3m is stupidly low, but to allow it to be an option in their favour is criminal.  I doubt there’s any type of anti-embarsssment clause either.

If he’s shit they send him back.  If he’s mid-table Champ they’ve had a bargain and if he has a very good season they’ll make themselves £5-10m profit by signing him and selling him instantly.

With a smaller squad surely a utility player is useful.  We can’t have been paying him enough to make a difference when trying to sign a replacement (assuming we do). 

I fully understand that it’s difficult to find buyers for players who are overpaid but surely we’d have been better off with a Grant-esque deal for Mowatt?  Save £10-20k off the wage bill and retain a player that covers the holes in the squad a little.

I reiterate - shit deal whether CC wanted him or not.

But the player WANTED to leave and Carlos wasn’t picking him….
Oh ok.  Why did we bother asking for a fee then? We should have just let him leave for nowt.

It’s a shit deal, i can understand (to an extent) our need to sell is paramount, but it’s still a shit deal. 

He hasn’t even left, merely on loan.  If he’s shit he’s back to being our problem, if he’s a star they’ll sigh and sell on.

I’m not bothered that he’s left (if CC has sanctioned it) just that it’s a really bad deal for us.

“Why did we ask for a fee then? We should have let his leave for nowt?!”

That statement explains a lot. 

Player is under contract under 2026 and has been with us since the age of 9 (could have been 8)….. of course we demand a loan fee and a transfer fee if we eventually sell or should I say, Bristol agree to buy.

Would have been a disaster if he’d left for “nowt”

It was sarcasm to your reply that the player wanted to leave.  

Just because he wanted to leave doesn’t mean we take the first god-awful offer going and allow things like an option in their favour with no conditions.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
(08-22-2023, 08:56 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I’m not bothered that he’s left (if CC has sanctioned it) just that it’s a really bad deal for us.

I don't think it matters whether Carlos wants a particular player or not. If what the club regards as an acceptable offer for any player he'll be off (assuming he wants to go). I don't think it'll matter whether Carlos sanctions it or not.

I'm not saying that Carlos would have wanted to have kept TGH, just that I don't think he's got a veto on anyone.

(08-22-2023, 08:58 PM)NewWanker Wrote: How have we gained £1m from this? An option is just that, if he does not do well then he's back with us...

It's been stated here that it's a £700k loan fee plus circa £300k save on his wages.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)