Can interest rises work?
I wouldn't describe tripling US government debt from $10 Trillion to over $30 Trillion since 2008 as "loosening" policy.
Reply
I'm sorry what? The Fed cut interest rates and increased the money supply to stimulate the US economy through buying bonds - that is the dictionary definition of loose monetary policy.

Also, it worked. As evidenced by the GDP/Capita boom the US has experienced over the last 15 years.
Reply
I was suggesting that "loosening" is a very very mild term. I'd prefer incontinence.

Stimulus stimulates, it generally does - but to state "It worked" is also a premature judgement.

What "worked" for Germany for 20 years is now largely the reason Germany isn't working and is rapidly becoming the sick man of Europe.
Reply
The purpose of the Fed under Bernanke loosening monetary policy was to stimulate the economy, this has objectively worked by all quantifiable metrics. You just need to look at the GDP figures. If the US economy fails it won't be because of the decisions made by the Fed in 2008/09 nor now (seeing as the Fed has been fairly aggressive in tightening). I also don't see how a sustained economic boom from 2009 onwards as being "premature", that's 14 years of results not replicated by any other medium-sized to large westernised economy.

As for Germany, their issue was a failing to invest in infrastructure development during the productivity boom because of overly cautious fiscal consensus coupled with Merkel being the German version of Margaret Thatcher and unable to see beyond the end of her own nose as she was that short-termist, even going so far as to literally copy and paste the same stupid energy policy mistakes as Thatcher.
Reply
This morning's nasty PMI survey numbers are among the first bits of economic data to properly point to a slowdown in the UK economy.

Naturally, the reaction of stocks was to go up.

Why? Because inflation at this level has never been defeated without a recession. Now if a recession or just a prolonged slowdown is looming, that makes the BoE less likely to keep raising interest rates. That in turn is good news for the most interest rate-sensitive sectors, which have been beaten down badly (particularly commercial property and all PE backed firms).

Of course, the pound didn't like it (and bear in mind a weaker pound is worth watching, because all else being equal, it's inflationary). But overall, the promise of an imminent peak in interest rates is something most people will be happy about.

Or at least, they'll be happy about it for a short period, until the real economic nasties, such as rising unemployment, start to materialise. But let's not jump the gun.

(08-22-2023, 04:33 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The purpose of the Fed under Bernanke loosening monetary policy was to stimulate the economy, this has objectively worked by all quantifiable metrics.

All quantifiable metrics apart from the Tripling of US government debt, which will all have to be refinanced in future at much higher rates than it was created at.
Reply
(08-23-2023, 01:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 04:33 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The purpose of the Fed under Bernanke loosening monetary policy was to stimulate the economy, this has objectively worked by all quantifiable metrics.

All quantifiable metrics apart from the Tripling of US government debt, which will all have to be refinanced in future at much higher rates than it was created at.

Except that the debt/GDP ratio for the US had stabilised and peaked by the time Bernanke had left the Fed and was due to trend down before the GOP's stupid fiscal policies happened on top of the debt attributable to COVID.

And we know from historic precedent that the best way to manage any debt is to grow the economy, as that ultimately covers debt servicing as well as lets inflation eat away at the nominal value. Which is again why the US debt-GDP ratio stabilised before the GOP were able to set fiscal policy.
Reply
Again, if you believe the sheer scale of the increase in debt AND the debt / GDP ratio under Bernanke was a price worth paying (rather than the deeper recession which was necessary to restore a degree of equilbrium) then we will diverge.

As it is, Between 06-14 Bernanke released the US debt genie and it's never going back into the lamp. In fact, it's only going to get worse.

[Image: united-states-government-debt-to-gdp.png...1=19730904]
Reply
That graph proves my point though, it stabilised around 2014 by the time he left. The projected trend based on the end of the Obama admin was for it to decline as it would have tracked with the rate slowing, but then Trump's fiscal policies failed to match the decline and then COVID happened. Fundamentally there was nothing else the Fed could do because the US economy was heading into a doom spiral and needed to loosen monetary conditions to provide an economic stimulus. It is then up to the fiscal side to manage conditions to allow for monetary tightening, Trump and the Covid stopped that. That is not Bernanke's fault.

US debt also spiked as a result of dealing with the Great Depression in the 1930s, and then after it had stabilised WWII happened and it hit 110%. Guess what? An economic stimulus happened post-WWII and it declined up until Reagan came in. It's happened before and the US came out fine.

I know you have some Rothbardian aversion to central banks and think they're to blame for all of the world's ills but this is ridiculous doom-mongering that is not only ignorant on the impact of fiscal policy but also historic precedent.
Reply
A dollar was intrinsically worth more than a promise before 1971. That's the difference BB.
Reply
Proth, the value of gold is because of its perceived value as a shiny and pretty rock and not for it's chemical properties with respect to practical usage, in parallel to fiat currencies. Please look at the inflationary crisis in Spain as an example. Unless you are buying gold as foil to use as heat shielding don't even bother bringing up its intrinsic value.

Need I also mention that there's been historic precedent of the gold standard being worthless as there's been several times where countries have moved off it to deal with economic crises, including in the US in 1933 - which also operated with the same conditions for the massive expanse in economic growth in the US domestically where the dollar was entirely fiat and not at all influenced by the Bretton-Woods system. And the Bretton-Woods system is parallelled by the current consensus for the dollar being the global reserve even without it being backed by a gold standard to trade internationally.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)