Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(08-22-2023, 01:01 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Carlos is a young manager who's still learning his trade and, so far, making a decent fist of it, doesn't mean he's impervious to criticism. If he's got anything about him, which I'm sure he has, then his biggest critic will not be anyone on this bored, but will in fact be himself!
Genuine criticism and calling for him to be sacked are two very different things.
No-one's saying he's beyond criticism, but if you regard saying "what's he ever done apart from getting Huddersfield from being in the relegation zone to the play-off final and then getting us from the relegation zone nearly into the play-offs?" and saying he thinks he's Guardiola as "genuine criticism" then that's up to you. I don't.
His managerial record so far speaks for itself and prior to that he was a highly-regarded coach. There are lengthy videos espousing his style of play and managerial philosophies. When he left Huddersfield they dropped like a stone, so it seems reasonable to conclude that them reaching the play-off final was primarily down to him. He's in an extremely difficult situation where the club will sell any of our players at the drop of hat without any guarantee of them being replaced. He still currently has a 50+% win record with us, so it doesn't seem to be asking much for people to cut him some slack rather than sniping.
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
3 managers have declined to use TGH on a regular basis. No one knows his best position. Would i prefer him to come on instead of Chalobah? Yes. But unfortunately we're not in a position to be picky. He's a squad player, and if someone else wants to pay his wages for a year then off he goes. Until the Chinese feck off this is our lot.
Posts: 10,700
Threads: 674
Joined: Feb 2020
(08-22-2023, 01:31 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (08-22-2023, 01:01 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Carlos is a young manager who's still learning his trade and, so far, making a decent fist of it, doesn't mean he's impervious to criticism. If he's got anything about him, which I'm sure he has, then his biggest critic will not be anyone on this bored, but will in fact be himself!
Genuine criticism and calling for him to be sacked are two very different things.
No-one's saying he's beyond criticism, but if you regard saying "what's he ever done apart from getting Huddersfield from being in the relegation zone to the play-off final and then getting us from the relegation zone nearly into the play-offs?" and saying he thinks he's Guardiola as "genuine criticism" then that's up to you. I don't.
His managerial record so far speaks for itself and prior to that he was a highly-regarded coach. There are lengthy videos espousing his style of play and managerial philosophies. When he left Huddersfield they dropped like a stone, so it seems reasonable to conclude that them reaching the play-off final was primarily down to him. He's in an extremely difficult situation where the club will sell any of our players at the drop of hat without any guarantee of them being replaced. He still currently has a 50+% win record with us, so it doesn't seem to be asking much for people to cut him some slack rather than sniping.
Yep, see if we can play all our games at home.
The new manager bounce went as did making substitutions that improved the team and result.
Posts: 7,994
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(08-22-2023, 01:31 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (08-22-2023, 01:01 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Carlos is a young manager who's still learning his trade and, so far, making a decent fist of it, doesn't mean he's impervious to criticism. If he's got anything about him, which I'm sure he has, then his biggest critic will not be anyone on this bored, but will in fact be himself!
Genuine criticism and calling for him to be sacked are two very different things.
No-one's saying he's beyond criticism, but if you regard saying "what's he ever done apart from getting Huddersfield from being in the relegation zone to the play-off final and then getting us from the relegation zone nearly into the play-offs?" and saying he thinks he's Guardiola as "genuine criticism" then that's up to you. I don't.
His managerial record so far speaks for itself and prior to that he was a highly-regarded coach. There are lengthy videos espousing his style of play and managerial philosophies. When he left Huddersfield they dropped like a stone, so it seems reasonable to conclude that them reaching the play-off final was primarily down to him. He's in an extremely difficult situation where the club will sell any of our players at the drop of hat without any guarantee of them being replaced. He still currently has a 50+% win record with us, so it doesn't seem to be asking much for people to cut him some slack rather than sniping. The first two are factual, the comparison to Guardiola, well, he's overrated anyway!
Posts: 516
Threads: 23
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
1
Seems to be a trend at the Albion not to give youth a chance but happy enough to buy rubbish like reach and challobah .and to keep picking the woeful furlong
Posts: 1,352
Threads: 22
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
7
(08-22-2023, 01:42 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (08-22-2023, 01:31 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (08-22-2023, 01:01 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Carlos is a young manager who's still learning his trade and, so far, making a decent fist of it, doesn't mean he's impervious to criticism. If he's got anything about him, which I'm sure he has, then his biggest critic will not be anyone on this bored, but will in fact be himself!
Genuine criticism and calling for him to be sacked are two very different things.
No-one's saying he's beyond criticism, but if you regard saying "what's he ever done apart from getting Huddersfield from being in the relegation zone to the play-off final and then getting us from the relegation zone nearly into the play-offs?" and saying he thinks he's Guardiola as "genuine criticism" then that's up to you. I don't.
His managerial record so far speaks for itself and prior to that he was a highly-regarded coach. There are lengthy videos espousing his style of play and managerial philosophies. When he left Huddersfield they dropped like a stone, so it seems reasonable to conclude that them reaching the play-off final was primarily down to him. He's in an extremely difficult situation where the club will sell any of our players at the drop of hat without any guarantee of them being replaced. He still currently has a 50+% win record with us, so it doesn't seem to be asking much for people to cut him some slack rather than sniping. The first two are factual, the comparison to Guardiola, well, he's overrated anyway! 
He probably is. Put him in charge of Huddersfield then see how he does.
The reference to Guardiola, was an indication that CC, like many coaches, is trying to implement a footballing philosophy that is born out of Guardiola's success.
The systems may not be exactly the same and there will be subtle differences with most coach's but the philosophy is similar.
Man City sold Joe Hart because he wasn't good enough on the ball and brought in Ederson. They have the means to do that.
We don't have a pot to piss in and so don't have the means to bring in players to play that way.
Posts: 1,987
Threads: 36
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation:
4
(08-22-2023, 01:52 PM)Atomic Wrote: (08-22-2023, 01:42 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (08-22-2023, 01:31 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (08-22-2023, 01:01 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Carlos is a young manager who's still learning his trade and, so far, making a decent fist of it, doesn't mean he's impervious to criticism. If he's got anything about him, which I'm sure he has, then his biggest critic will not be anyone on this bored, but will in fact be himself!
Genuine criticism and calling for him to be sacked are two very different things.
No-one's saying he's beyond criticism, but if you regard saying "what's he ever done apart from getting Huddersfield from being in the relegation zone to the play-off final and then getting us from the relegation zone nearly into the play-offs?" and saying he thinks he's Guardiola as "genuine criticism" then that's up to you. I don't.
His managerial record so far speaks for itself and prior to that he was a highly-regarded coach. There are lengthy videos espousing his style of play and managerial philosophies. When he left Huddersfield they dropped like a stone, so it seems reasonable to conclude that them reaching the play-off final was primarily down to him. He's in an extremely difficult situation where the club will sell any of our players at the drop of hat without any guarantee of them being replaced. He still currently has a 50+% win record with us, so it doesn't seem to be asking much for people to cut him some slack rather than sniping. The first two are factual, the comparison to Guardiola, well, he's overrated anyway! 
He probably is. Put him in charge of Huddersfield then see how he does. 
The reference to Guardiola, was an indication that CC, like many coaches, is trying to implement a footballing philosophy that is born out of Guardiola's success.
The systems may not be exactly the same and there will be subtle differences with most coach's but the philosophy is similar.
Man City sold Joe Hart because he wasn't good enough on the ball and brought in Ederson. They have the means to do that.
We don't have a pot to piss in and so don't have the means to bring in players to play that way.
Exactly, why copy a successful manager and his philosophy, who has only ever done it at big clubs anyway. Seems daft to think oh it works for Pep let's copy him down here int he lower dank depths, with no money to spunk month in month out.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
No one has said how they'd set this team up and hue it would be better.
Just that the manager isn't.
Posts: 1,636
Threads: 52
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
11
The one thing I can’t understand with Carlos is he came up with a system that worked, kept the same side as much as he could (barring injuries) and went on a splendid run. The minute we lost a game he turned into tinker man and made some and continues to make bizarre decisions. Love the bloke but like previous posts have said we do not have the technical players in the squad to play the way he wants. It will end in tears I’m afraid
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
08-22-2023, 02:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-22-2023, 02:43 PM by Ted Maul.)
Have any of you lot seen a Man City team in the last few months?
Guardiola currently has a team full of big bastards (with the exception of Grealish), often with four centre halves in the XI, playing a 4-4-2 with a classic little and large partnership up top. Perhaps it was Pulis that was the visionary after all.
(08-22-2023, 02:36 PM)johntoewba Wrote: The one thing I can’t understand with Carlos is he came up with a system that worked, kept the same side as much as he could (barring injuries) and went on a splendid run. The minute we lost a game he turned into tinker man and made some and continues to make bizarre decisions. Love the bloke but like previous posts have said we do not have the technical players in the squad to play the way he wants. It will end in tears I’m afraid
Other teams figure out how to beat you. That's how football works, we can't just turn up every week with a formation that won previously expecting to win. Teams worked out our weaknesses, we had a few injuries and then he had to change and adapt. All of the very best managers do it. Guardiola's team now play nothing like his Barcelona team of a decade ago, Arteta's Arsenal are nothing like the team he took over from Emery. If you don't change and keep finding ways to win, you get overtaken. We just don't have the means to change personnel as easily as others do.
|