TGH
#51
(08-22-2023, 10:31 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 09:30 AM)Atomic Wrote: Absolutely ridiculous to let a young kid in TGH's position out on loan. To Britol City?, who will probably finish above us. So he's not considered good enough by us but he is good enough for Bristol City. Much as Mowatt last season, went to Boro who finished above us.

The running of this club has been shambolic for years and so it continues. I had hoped in CC we had actually found a good head coach but more and more as time goes on I'm convinced this is not the case. He apparently blew Gourlay away when interviewed. I bet he did. He (CC) can talk for Spain but all the clever talk doesn't make a good manager. It might make you a good pundit.

We have no money and we have a head coach that thinks he's Guardiola.

We have a group of players that are competent if asked to do what suits them. They aren't being. We are attempting a philosophy that doesn't suit most of our squad: Bartley, Wallace, Swift, Yokuslu, Molumby, Mowatt to name a few.

All Corberan had to do stick to the formula that took us up the table last season and add a couple of quality players to improve the squad but no, he's making a mess of the situation.

TGH has talent but has never been given a proper run nor has he ever had a clear role. We should be integrating him into a settled side.

I long for the day when we finally get new owners. Hopefully, proper owners, who sack the whole lot of these officials inside of the club

You've gone out on a limb Atomic, but sure you'll handle the pelters coming your way.

Absolutely. I say it as I see it whether it's popular or not. Not bothered about upsetting the masses, the masses once thought Jimmy Saville was a nice guy.
Reply
#52
Oh, if anyone think CC is calling the shots with transfers, you're mistaken, literally every single player we have is up for transfer if any offers come in. No exceptions.

He doesn't rate TGH highly, not helped by off field matters, sadly not even directly him, but he didn't cover himself with glory on the pitch either to make up for it.
Reply
#53
(08-22-2023, 10:16 AM)Atomic Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 09:49 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 09:30 AM)Atomic Wrote: Absolutely ridiculous to let a young kid in TGH's position out on loan. To Britol City?, who will probably finish above us. So he's not considered good enough by us but he is good enough for Bristol City. Much as Mowatt last season, went to Boro who finished above us.

The running of this club has been shambolic for years and so it continues. I had hoped in CC we had actually found a good head coach but more and more as time goes on I'm convinced this is not the case. He apparently blew Gourlay away when interviewed. I bet he did. He (CC) can talk for Spain but all the clever talk doesn't make a good manager. It might make you a good pundit.

We have no money and we have a head coach that thinks he's Guardiola.

We have a group of players that are competent if asked to do what suits them. They aren't being. We are attempting a philosophy that doesn't suit most of our squad: Bartley, Wallace, Swift, Yokuslu, Molumby, Mowatt to name a few.

All Corberan had to do stick to the formula that took us up the table last season and add a couple of quality players to improve the squad but no, he's making a mess of the situation.

TGH has talent but has never been given a proper run nor has he ever had a clear role. We should be integrating him into a settled side.

I long for the day when we finally get new owners. Hopefully, proper owners, who sack the whole lot of these officials inside of the club


What a ridiculous post.  CC is the best coach we’ve had in years, trying to do his job with both hands tied behind his back, and having to make silk purses out of a pigs ear. 

Corberan is the best coach we've had in years? Based on what?

One season reaching the play offs with Huddersfield and a ten game spell is nothing more than Valerien Ismael achieved. So again I ask the question - based on what evidence? 

The fact that you, and other fans, have just taken to him? If not that then what?

As all of our players are effectively for sale, I'm not sure why you're using TGH being one who we (supposedly) have an offer for as a justification to rant about Carlos? It doesn't matter if Carlos wants to keep TGH or not, we're having a fire sale and players will go in the order that deals are agreed.
Reply
#54
(08-22-2023, 10:37 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 10:33 AM)Atomic Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 10:24 AM)NewWanker Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 10:22 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: He also has spent far less than recent managers. Although worryingly his signings to date have not been very good.

If we are keen to get rid of Chalobah, why did we sign him in the first place, he has only been here six months!

Probably looked better than he turned out to be, like the old fugger last year. TBF the recent managers are a massive part of CC's problem, all the money we spunked on them fuckers CC could've bought half a team.


Recent managers, recent heads of recruitment, recent CEO'S, and of course the owners, are all part of the problem. 

The decline really begun when Dan Ashworth left. It may not have been noticed to begin with but the club has had a slow puncture ever since. 

Until we get new owners (please god), sometime soon, it really now is a case of making do and putting plasters over the cuts. 

If Carlos Corberan wants to implement his footballing philosophy, I'm afraid it's wrong club, wrong time.

Thing is, as I, and others have said.

There is no suitable style for these type of players, none. 

No manager can succeed with this squad, it's impossible. 

I don't believe that at all. It's no worse on paper than Luton's squad was. 

If you'd asked anybody at the start of last season who's squad was better, ours or Ipswich's, given that we were in the higher league, 90% would said ours.

We had an eleven last season that was capable of reaching the top six, we didn't have the squad depth to make the top six though. 

Apart from Dara, those other ten are still at the club. 

Yes it's difficult to improve a squad when you have no money, but it's not impossible, others have done it many times.
Reply
#55
(08-22-2023, 10:48 AM)Atomic Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 10:37 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 10:33 AM)Atomic Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 10:24 AM)NewWanker Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 10:22 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: He also has spent far less than recent managers. Although worryingly his signings to date have not been very good.

If we are keen to get rid of Chalobah, why did we sign him in the first place, he has only been here six months!

Probably looked better than he turned out to be, like the old fugger last year. TBF the recent managers are a massive part of CC's problem, all the money we spunked on them fuckers CC could've bought half a team.


Recent managers, recent heads of recruitment, recent CEO'S, and of course the owners, are all part of the problem. 

The decline really begun when Dan Ashworth left. It may not have been noticed to begin with but the club has had a slow puncture ever since. 

Until we get new owners (please god), sometime soon, it really now is a case of making do and putting plasters over the cuts. 

If Carlos Corberan wants to implement his footballing philosophy, I'm afraid it's wrong club, wrong time.

Thing is, as I, and others have said.

There is no suitable style for these type of players, none. 

No manager can succeed with this squad, it's impossible. 

I don't believe that at all. It's no worse on paper than Luton's squad was. 

If you'd asked anybody at the start of last season who's squad was better, ours or Ipswich's, given that we were in the higher league, 90% would said ours.

We had an eleven last season that was capable of reaching the top six, we didn't have the squad depth to make the top six though. 

Apart from Dara, those other ten are still at the club. 

Yes it's difficult to improve a squad when you have no money, but it's not impossible, others have done it many times.

I don't rate a lot of these players that highly, and as I said, it's an issue of playing style. What suits them? There is no coherent style among them at all. What is that squads strength overall? Luton were exceptionally well organised and resilient, our players are not resilient, at all. We aren't quick, we don't retain the ball well, we lack concentration and organisation whoever coaches them. We don't score goals easily, and we have a defence that quite frankly would concede every game in league 2.
Reply
#56
I see some are busy oiling the revolving managerial door yet again. This time for a manager who has a win percentage of over 50% with us!

Never patience and support, just tantrums and hysteria.
Reply
#57
(08-22-2023, 10:31 AM)strawman Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 10:16 AM)Atomic Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 09:49 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 09:30 AM)Atomic Wrote: Absolutely ridiculous to let a young kid in TGH's position out on loan. To Britol City?, who will probably finish above us. So he's not considered good enough by us but he is good enough for Bristol City. Much as Mowatt last season, went to Boro who finished above us.

The running of this club has been shambolic for years and so it continues. I had hoped in CC we had actually found a good head coach but more and more as time goes on I'm convinced this is not the case. He apparently blew Gourlay away when interviewed. I bet he did. He (CC) can talk for Spain but all the clever talk doesn't make a good manager. It might make you a good pundit.

We have no money and we have a head coach that thinks he's Guardiola.

We have a group of players that are competent if asked to do what suits them. They aren't being. We are attempting a philosophy that doesn't suit most of our squad: Bartley, Wallace, Swift, Yokuslu, Molumby, Mowatt to name a few.

All Corberan had to do stick to the formula that took us up the table last season and add a couple of quality players to improve the squad but no, he's making a mess of the situation.

TGH has talent but has never been given a proper run nor has he ever had a clear role. We should be integrating him into a settled side.

I long for the day when we finally get new owners. Hopefully, proper owners, who sack the whole lot of these officials inside of the club


What a ridiculous post.  CC is the best coach we’ve had in years, trying to do his job with both hands tied behind his back, and having to make silk purses out of a pigs ear. 

Corberan is the best coach we've had in years? Based on what?

One season reaching the play offs with Huddersfield and a ten game spell is nothing more than Valerien Ismael achieved. So again I ask the question - based on what evidence? 

The fact that you, and other fans, have just taken to him? If not that then what?

FWIW - Last 5 managers win %ages (ignoring temps)

Bilic 40%
Allardyce 15.4%
Valerian 38.71%
Bruce 25%
Corberan 51.51%

Very flawed stats…

They didn’t all manage in the Championship 
They haven’t all had the same squad or transfer budget
They are all operating with different people and structure in the background 
The Championship quality changes every season 
They haven’t all played the same number of games as manager 

I suspect Allardyce would have done better than Valball for example in the Championship but we will never know.
Reply
#58
TGH getting a lot of academy bias in this thread. A solid utility option but hasn't been good enough to really force his way into the team under our last three managers. He's 22, has played over fifty games for us and do any of us even know his best position? Does he even know his best position? With this one I think there is every chance we can replace him with better.
Reply
#59
(08-22-2023, 10:52 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: I see some are busy oiling the revolving managerial door yet again. This time for a manager who has a win percentage of over 50% with us!

Never patience and support, just tantrums and hysteria.

Who is doing that? One poster has questioned why there is so much faith in the manager. Hardly tantrums or hysteria. You could argue the ott reaction to daring to ask the question is though. 

For what it’s worth I’m not questioning the position of our manager. However people are entitled to and they may have some valid points along the way.
Reply
#60
(08-22-2023, 10:51 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 10:48 AM)Atomic Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 10:37 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 10:33 AM)Atomic Wrote:
(08-22-2023, 10:24 AM)NewWanker Wrote: Probably looked better than he turned out to be, like the old fugger last year. TBF the recent managers are a massive part of CC's problem, all the money we spunked on them fuckers CC could've bought half a team.


Recent managers, recent heads of recruitment, recent CEO'S, and of course the owners, are all part of the problem. 

The decline really begun when Dan Ashworth left. It may not have been noticed to begin with but the club has had a slow puncture ever since. 

Until we get new owners (please god), sometime soon, it really now is a case of making do and putting plasters over the cuts. 

If Carlos Corberan wants to implement his footballing philosophy, I'm afraid it's wrong club, wrong time.

Thing is, as I, and others have said.

There is no suitable style for these type of players, none. 

No manager can succeed with this squad, it's impossible. 

I don't believe that at all. It's no worse on paper than Luton's squad was. 

If you'd asked anybody at the start of last season who's squad was better, ours or Ipswich's, given that we were in the higher league, 90% would said ours.

We had an eleven last season that was capable of reaching the top six, we didn't have the squad depth to make the top six though. 

Apart from Dara, those other ten are still at the club. 

Yes it's difficult to improve a squad when you have no money, but it's not impossible, others have done it many times.

I don't rate a lot of these players that highly, and as I said, it's an issue of playing style. What suits them? There is no coherent style among them at all. What is that squads strength overall? Luton were exceptionally well organised and resilient, our players are not resilient, at all. We aren't quick, we don't retain the ball well, we lack concentration and organisation whoever coaches them. We don't score goals easily, and we have a defence that quite frankly would concede every game in league 2.

When CC took over from Bruce he found a way of playing that suited the players. We then won 9 out-of 10 or whatever it was, can't remember exactly. 

Once Matt Phillips got injured CC lost his way. Firstly by moving Wallace or Swift out of position to compensate. That's two positions weakened. Then he brought in Albrighton and carried on tinkering. 

This is where he went wrong initially. 

Now, at the start of this season, instead of just trying to improve on what we had he's trying to implement a new philosophy with players nowhere near suitable, nor in some cases, good enough, to make it work.

It's not what we need right now. That sort of change in approach needs several transfer windows and money which we just don't have.

Given our position, I honestly don't know why CC decided to remain here. He left Huddersfield under not dissimilar circumstances.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: