Defense
#51
(08-06-2023, 06:20 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(08-06-2023, 05:47 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(08-06-2023, 05:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(08-06-2023, 10:13 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: I don't think Ajayi is a bad player. I thought he did a half decent job yesterday. He does have a clanger in him, admittedly. I feel he's best used as a holding midfielder rather than a centre half.

Weird you hate Bartley, who is, in every way better than Ajayi as a defender, though not good himself, yet think Ajayi is ok. Don't get it, genuinely, don't understand the logic.

Just not true. 

Last season:

More interceptions per game: Ajayi
More tackles per game: Ajayi 
Ball retention (% Successful passes): Ajayi
More goals conceded per 90 minutes: Bartley (With Bartley playing we conceded a goal once every 66 minutes, the worst of any defender that played more than 5 games)
More fouls given away: Bartley
More Bookings: Bartley
More Red Cards: Bartley
I haven't checked the own goal stats but I assume Bartley has scored more of those too, there's definitely at least 2 that come to mind over the past few seasons.


He is a better header of the ball however. If you think that defending is exclusively being able to head the ball and has nothing to do with any of the above, then Bartley is a better defender.
You didn't mention his pointing. If nothing else, Bartley is world champion at finding someone to point at after allowing the opponent a free header.

That may be a very good point.
Reply
#52
(08-06-2023, 05:50 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Is there a category for most times you have ball watched and lost your man though?

This is a very good point. Over several seasons of not rating Ajayi very highly, I've observed how rarely he is even in the picture when I review action replays of goals we have conceded. If you aren't where you are supposed to be, the stats can't quantify your failure.

Jasper Carrott used to do a sketch about an elderly driver. "Been driving 60 years and I've never had an accident". "But he's seen hundreds".

(08-06-2023, 12:25 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm tired of saying it.

Defense makes a season, and ours is a joke. We had one, ONE competent centre back and we sold him for less than his already low release clause, an absolute joke 

We're left with:

Ajayi: Awful defender, forget this nonsense "oh he's good in a high line" defending is about three things only. Positioning, marking, tackling, he's poor at all three, therefore he's a poor defender. Nowhere in defending is athleticism, pace or passing important, and if CC thinks it is, he's wrong.

Bartley: Another Titus Bramble, the basic attributes are there, let down by lack of intelligence and concentration. 

Pieters: Best of a sorry bunch, a left back pretending to be a centre back.

Kipre: Multiple chances, proven shit each time, again, basics let him down.

Taylor: A kid who probably deserves a chance looking at the failures above.

Not at all helped by the clowns we have in the full back positions. Furlong is poor sometimes creeping to average and Townsend has gone backwards so much it's almost funny.

Keep a clean sheet you cannot lose, can score 4 goals a game and still finish on 0 points in a season, we need to sort this defence out, that simple.

I don't disagree with much of this, but I'm a bit dismayed by the sudden and final judgement of Kipre on this bored. He's played about 20 times for us. He was doing OK in Val's side before being bombed out by Bruce, who fell in love with Ajayi at first sight. Bruce never picked Kipre, as far as I recall, not for a single match of any type. Then sent him off on loan for the next season. It's just not true to suggest that he's been "proven shit each time".

Contrast this with Bartley (160 games) and Ajayi (130+ games) who have both tantalised us with decent runs of form before lapsing spectacularly to concede comedy goals at crucial times.

I don't know what our best CB combo is, and I fear there may not be a good combo amongst the options available, but I'm not prepared to identify Kipre as the sole cause or even the major cause of our defensive problems. Spacegoating might be therapeutic for some people, but it solves nothing.
Reply
#53
Ajayi has never had positional sense since he joined. There’s a reason Rotherham moved him into midfield.

However, I do think there is a good defender in him if he can cut out the regular brain farts which seem to be in all our defenders.

What we need is a commanding, aggressive defender that wins headers and is a threat in both boxes. Bring back Olssen and McAuley!
Reply
#54
FWIW I think Caleb Taylor is going to be a fantastic player. I saw him a lot for the kids/stiffs. A proper centre half. Never stopped shouting and organising when captaining the U23s. 6'7 and extremely athletlic. He could easily be the heir to Dara's throne.

The only thing going against him now is his age but IMO he has to start V stoke and he has to take his chance. Its the perfect game for Carlos to take a proper look at him. I noticed so many Championship sides giving debuts to their kids this past weekend yet, yet again, we don't seem to trust ours.
Reply
#55
Heir.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#56
(08-07-2023, 06:49 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Heir.

Or hair? Big Grin
Reply
#57
(08-07-2023, 06:48 AM)Peachy Wrote: FWIW I think Caleb Taylor is going to be a fantastic player. I saw him a lot for the kids/stiffs. A proper centre half. Never stopped shouting and organising when captaining the U23s. 6'7 and extremely athletlic. He could easily be the air to Dara's throne.

The only thing going against him now is his age but IMO he has to start V stoke and he has to take his chance. Its the perfect game for Carlos to take a proper look at him. I noticed so many Championship sides giving debuts to their kids this past weekend yet, yet again, we don't seem to trust ours.

Agree - the Stoke game is a nothing match so we need to give some game time to a few of the kids who could make an impression on the first team.

It's important we play enough first teamers so we can get a sense of the kids' abilities (not a Val against Arsenal 11 changes).

Taylor, Ingram and Fellows ought to start for me.
Reply
#58
(08-07-2023, 07:30 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(08-07-2023, 06:48 AM)Peachy Wrote: FWIW I think Caleb Taylor is going to be a fantastic player. I saw him a lot for the kids/stiffs. A proper centre half. Never stopped shouting and organising when captaining the U23s. 6'7 and extremely athletlic. He could easily be the air to Dara's throne.

The only thing going against him now is his age but IMO he has to start V stoke and he has to take his chance. Its the perfect game for Carlos to take a proper look at him. I noticed so many Championship sides giving debuts to their kids this past weekend yet, yet again, we don't seem to trust ours.

Agree - the Stoke game is a nothing match so we need to give some game time to a few of the kids who could make an impression on the first team.

It's important we play enough first teamers so we can get a sense of the kids' abilities (not a Val against Arsenal 11 changes).

Taylor, Ingram and Fellows ought to start for me.

Agree
Reply
#59
(08-06-2023, 10:10 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(08-06-2023, 05:50 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Is there a category for most times you have ball watched and lost your man though?

This is a very good point. Over several seasons of not rating Ajayi very highly, I've observed how rarely he is even in the picture when I review action replays of goals we have conceded. If you aren't where you are supposed to be, the stats can't quantify your failure.

Jasper Carrott used to do a sketch about an elderly driver. "Been driving 60 years and I've never had an accident". "But he's seen hundreds".

(08-06-2023, 12:25 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm tired of saying it.

Defense makes a season, and ours is a joke. We had one, ONE competent centre back and we sold him for less than his already low release clause, an absolute joke 

We're left with:

Ajayi: Awful defender, forget this nonsense "oh he's good in a high line" defending is about three things only. Positioning, marking, tackling, he's poor at all three, therefore he's a poor defender. Nowhere in defending is athleticism, pace or passing important, and if CC thinks it is, he's wrong.

Bartley: Another Titus Bramble, the basic attributes are there, let down by lack of intelligence and concentration. 

Pieters: Best of a sorry bunch, a left back pretending to be a centre back.

Kipre: Multiple chances, proven shit each time, again, basics let him down.

Taylor: A kid who probably deserves a chance looking at the failures above.

Not at all helped by the clowns we have in the full back positions. Furlong is poor sometimes creeping to average and Townsend has gone backwards so much it's almost funny.

Keep a clean sheet you cannot lose, can score 4 goals a game and still finish on 0 points in a season, we need to sort this defence out, that simple.

I don't disagree with much of this, but I'm a bit dismayed by the sudden and final judgement of Kipre on this bored. He's played about 20 times for us. He was doing OK in Val's side before being bombed out by Bruce, who fell in love with Ajayi at first sight. Bruce never picked Kipre, as far as I recall, not for a single match of any type. Then sent him off on loan for the next season. It's just not true to suggest that he's been "proven shit each time".

Contrast this with Bartley (160 games) and Ajayi (130+ games) who have both tantalised us with decent runs of form before lapsing spectacularly to concede comedy goals at crucial times.

I don't know what our best CB combo is, and I fear there may not be a good combo amongst the options available, but I'm not prepared to identify Kipre as the sole cause or even the major cause of our defensive problems. Spacegoating might be therapeutic for some people, but it solves nothing.
This entirely. I haven't seen enough of Kipre to judge him but I did notice he improved steadily when given a run. I've seen enough of Ajayi and Bartley to know they simply are not anywhere near the standard we want and will not get better. Now Dara has gone we are left with a pile of crap CBs, like Peachy I really rate Taylor but it isnt fair to lumber him with these donkeys at this stage in his career.
Reply
#60
I hope Kipre proves me wrong, we've seen enough of Ajayi and Bartley to know they won't.

I'm not against him having more games, but alongside Pieters preferably. Hopefully Taylor seizes his chance when he gets it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: