Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
08-02-2023, 09:58 AM
(This post was last modified: 08-02-2023, 10:02 AM by Borin' Baggie.)
(08-02-2023, 09:09 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (08-02-2023, 06:46 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Saying we need oil and gas is purely a copout to excuse doing anything to wean ourselves off it.
How do you expect us to cost effectively wean ourselves off gas for domestic heating in particular? The cost of doing so is absolutely prohibitive for the vast majority of people in existing homes, never mind the practicalities of doing so. I also read MOTO is complaining that they can't turn on the vehicle chargers they've been told by the government to install up and down the country because the network hasn't been reinforced - so how on Earth would the network be able to cope with hundreds of thousands of new heat pumps?
The easy wins in the pursuit of net zero have already been made. The pursuit of further gains is now colliding with the reality of the cost. The bizarre onshore wind moratorium will have to go, we'll have to burn gas for baseload for another generation at least in the absence of new nuclear.
I will be keen to see how the next Labour government proposes to deal with the challenges of cost and practicality - as historically neither has been their strength any more than it has been for the Tories.
All I see at the moment is the end of cheap / convenient mass personal transportation as we know it, huge costs and practical challenges for most households to come off gas and the denial of foreign holidays to all but the elite within a generation.
No one voted for any of that.
You may believe it's a cop out, I don't believe the public will put up with literal impoverishment, or the impoverishment of aspiration in the pursuit of the pyrrhic attainment of net zero by some arbitrary false deadline.
Heating - Heat pumps (they manage to install them at a higher rate and at a lower cost in other European countries, including colder ones. Ground source should have been mandated for all new builds a decade ago), distributed heat schemes (idea solution for dense urban areas, the model being Copenhagen).
Easy wins - Electrified public transport (why are we building a new railway line that isn't electrified? Not to mention that Bristol doesn't have an electric rail corridor), the aforementioned heat pumps for new builds, solar for new builds and things like covering parking and irrigation channels with photovoltaic cells. Also, stop pricing renewables based on what the gas price is because renewable OpEx is virtually null unlike gas.
Gas for electricity generation - Look at the LCOE for it (I look at it daily, gas turbines make zero economic sense without huge subsidies that should be plowed into nuclear, renewables and R&D for nuclear and renwables), it's now more cost efficient to oversupply with renewables than use gas as a baseload. The only generation type baseload applies to is nuclear, the argument for fossil fuels is dead and has been since the Russia-Ukraine war. Our gas production does not adequately stabilise the market and we have just suffered for that with the volatility in global markets, the process of winding down the gas turbines towards decommissioning over the next 20 years needs to start to happen now alongside scaling up renewables to cover short-term demand and nuclear for medium-term demand. Living in a fantasy world where gas is still a player by 2050 for heating and power generation is making the same mistakes of the 1980s.
Costs and practicality - The longer we wait, the more it costs us to both adapt and mitigate. We're already seeing climate change affecting migrationary patterns, that's purely a social cost. I don't even think I need to mention infrastructure adaptions. You cannot just deflect away from the massive medium-term and long-term costs if we don't sort this ASAP.
Transport - Absolute horseshite argument, based on fear mongering. Decarbonise freight transport (new rail freight corridors and rail electrification) because it is 8% of global emissions. Rebalancing airline tax to focus the burden of frequent flyers and not people going on holiday once a year.
As for your last sentence, it is the choice between moving towards green solutions now or impoverishing future generations. If we don't accelerate this in the next 10 years, your children will be paying for our mistakes both in terms of costs to adapt and reduced quality of life (that's already trending down with my generation behind yours and the boomers). If you want to stop impoverishment, you'd be all in for net-zero as that's the only pathway out of it.
And yes, it is a copout. An excuse to do nothing because you don't want to face the realities of the shit state we've found ourselves in. The reality is if we do what you want it will cost us a lot more and is the actual pathway to impoverishment, so model the costs of doing little to nothing and present that if you want a fair argument. Global GDP to shrink by 37% by 2100, that's the projected cost of not reaching net zero if you want the economic arguments. Flood walls, polders, irrigation channels, dealing with climate migration, resource management, storm management, water management, agriculture on reduced arable land - not cheap, is it? Not good for quality of life, is it?
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
Lot's of hindsight, wishful thinking and dismissive contentions there.
In a country that's got used to handout after handout you will have one hell of a political battle on your hands at the point the cost becomes clear. No matter how noble and scientifically cogent the cause.
I'm not arguing against the road to net zero. I'm pointing out the practical impediments that are likely to become insurmountable due to the cost, and where that burden falls. There will be some very difficult political decisions to make.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
08-02-2023, 03:35 PM
(This post was last modified: 08-02-2023, 03:44 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(08-02-2023, 02:52 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Lot's of hindsight, wishful thinking and dismissive contentions there.
In a country that's got used to handout after handout you will have one hell of a political battle on your hands at the point the cost becomes clear. No matter how noble and scientifically cogent the cause.
I'm not arguing against the road to net zero. I'm pointing out the practical impediments that are likely to become insurmountable due to the cost, and where that burden falls. There will be some very difficult political decisions to make.
What you're doing is fearmongering. None of what I said is magical fairy dust, all of it falls into either being something other Western European countries have done (with comparable or better quality of life to the UK) or are (costed) Lib Dem policy proposals. Meanwhile, what you're arguing is to repeat the exact same mistakes of the 1980s and not learn from the fallout of an oil and gas crisis (as France did, successfully) and properly electrifying, in-turn repeating the OPEC crisis of the 1970s or the recent energy price crisis when our reliance on fossil fuels comes home to roost. How much has not following through on building AGR reactors in the 1980s because of CapEx concerns cost us in the medium term? A lot. Community heat schemes (Denmark), rail electrification and capacity expansion (started in the UK back in the bloody 1930s before being abandoned), new build regulations on heating and power (Norway, and proposed for the UK by the Lib Dems back in 2015), solar power covering (India of all places is doing this with canals, right now). These aren't hypotheticals or small scale research plans, these are all manageable and deployable at scale with current technologies and all of it improves quality of life and access to energy and should be plowed ahead with over the next 25 years.
As for the costs, keeping with any level of reliance on oil and gas will cost us more in the long run and current LCOEs are suggesting it would cost more in the short run than oversupplying renewables - what you want is also stupidly expensive. That's not to mention the huge costs associated with not doing enough, getting to net zero is the cheaper option and a simple surface level analysis of infrastructure and social costs of not getting there spells that out in black and white. Just plan out how you will deal with water irrigation, flooding, rising sea levels, storms, reduced arable land and dealing with hundreds of millions to billions of displaced people and get back to me on what is actually insurmountable due to cost. Net zero is the cheap way out, quite frankly - not to mention is the only practical means to decouple ourselves from global market instability.
The problem is purely dire press coverage on energy, bad actors only presenting half the argument to push their narratives and chronic short-termism.
I'll ask you this, do you know how much money the British taxpayer is on hook for in dealing with already existing North Sea oil infrastructure up to 2030? I'll give you a clue, you can build 5 Hornsea One-sized offshore wind farms (6GW of installed wind grid capacity) for it.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
Yes yes yes I know we’re dealing with the art of the possible and yes I understand that the opportunity cost for the country is probably stacked in favour of the solutions you seek.
However. Who is paying for all this?
That is the biggest single impediment. It’s not fearmongerimg to point out that out. It’s being honest.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(08-02-2023, 08:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Yes yes yes I know we’re dealing with the art of the possible and yes I understand that the opportunity cost for the country is probably stacked in favour of the solutions you seek.
However. Who is paying for all this?
That is the biggest single impediment. It’s not fearmongerimg to point out that out. It’s being honest.
Who is paying for not doing it?
That is the question nobody is addressing, that is the question you are avoiding. Mitigation against climate change isn't free, servicing gas infrastructure isn't free. Getting to net zero is going to cost significantly less than not getting to net zero, that's the whole point.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(08-02-2023, 08:23 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Getting to net zero is going to cost significantly less than not getting to net zero, that's the whole point.
Yes, that is the whole point. You're asking millions to pay, and to make sacrifices on their personal freedom NOW for outcomes that are uncertain, maybe even nebulous and rely an awful lot on the actions of totalitarian governments globally.
All the while, in every developed country an aging population means there are also huge pressures on health and social care spending which have far more direct impact on people's daily lives - never mind the current cost of living pressures too, never mind the lamentable level of pension savings, never mind a lack of affordable housing.
Reality bites.
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
A very simple question Proth - What happens to the oil that is extracted from the North Sea? With a follow up, how will that benefit the UK?
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(08-03-2023, 08:11 AM)baggy1 Wrote: A very simple question Proth - What happens to the oil that is extracted from the North Sea? With a follow up, how will that benefit the UK?
Oil and gas will be sold on world markets providing quality employment and tax revenues for the Treasury. By all means export those jobs and receipts to the the Middle East and North American shale industry if you like. I can't believe it's escaped your attention that exploration and exploitation of oil and gas reserves continues apace worldwide - particularly in Latin America.
It seems bizarre to me that the UK would give up on proven reserves.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
Woohoo. Jobs and income for all as the world burns and sinks
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 8,953
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(08-03-2023, 08:26 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (08-03-2023, 08:11 AM)baggy1 Wrote: A very simple question Proth - What happens to the oil that is extracted from the North Sea? With a follow up, how will that benefit the UK?
Oil and gas will be sold on world markets providing quality employment and tax revenues for the Treasury. By all means export those jobs and receipts to the the Middle East and North American shale industry if you like. I can't believe it's escaped your attention that exploration and exploitation of oil and gas reserves continues apace worldwide - particularly in Latin America.
It seems bizarre to me that the UK would give up on proven reserves.
I'm asking a simple question to get understanding - do you think that the tax revenues will be larger than the subsidies given to the oil companies?
|