Posts: 190
Threads: 9
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(07-24-2023, 12:47 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I’m currently in Rhodes now. I watched the stampede when one of Rishi’s emergency money-making texts arrived on my phone, telling us to evacuate. Literally hundreds putting knives, forks, drinks etc. down to dash back to their apartments and pack, and leg it to the square where I’m staying. To be ferried to alternative (‘safe’) hotels only to be holed up in deckchair accommodation (apparently a lot of decent hospitality was laid on to be quite fair) but ultimately to have their holidays curtailed.
I find it odd there is no sympathy from some for that, when the locals aren’t worried about the danger (hence neither was I), that the phenomenon of wildfires in Greece is quite natural, and why some apologists aren’t a little more sympathetic to the business still struggling from COVID here. Some people really do believe every little bit of Orange-coloured shite they read.
Climate change is most likely real. But it’s being very much exploited.
+ 1
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
07-24-2023, 01:22 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-24-2023, 01:43 PM by fuzzbox.)
(07-24-2023, 01:11 PM)Stourbridge Baggie Wrote: (07-24-2023, 12:47 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: I’m currently in Rhodes now. I watched the stampede when one of Rishi’s emergency money-making texts arrived on my phone, telling us to evacuate. Literally hundreds putting knives, forks, drinks etc. down to dash back to their apartments and pack, and leg it to the square where I’m staying. To be ferried to alternative (‘safe’) hotels only to be holed up in deckchair accommodation (apparently a lot of decent hospitality was laid on to be quite fair) but ultimately to have their holidays curtailed.
I find it odd there is no sympathy from some for that, when the locals aren’t worried about the danger (hence neither was I), that the phenomenon of wildfires in Greece is quite natural, and why some apologists aren’t a little more sympathetic to the business still struggling from COVID here. Some people really do believe every little bit of Orange-coloured shite they read.
Climate change is most likely real. But it’s being very much exploited.
+ 1
I have sympathy with this argument. But when money making insurance companies outright refuse to take your money for loss of a house due to fires, you know this isn't just a 'green narrative'. It's more likely to get worse than better....
(07-24-2023, 11:24 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (07-24-2023, 11:14 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: "Rhodes is burning...What really matters is not that a Tourist playground burns, its the animals burned, wildlife lost and Nature destroyed...but our headlines talk of cancelled flights and holidays. If we think this is inconvenient..you wait to see the inconvenience of climate refugees, lack of food and water....floods, droughts and war....but let's just carry on leave that to our kids to deal with" - Deborah Meaden
My issue is what can we do, we as normal Joe Public?
As China, India and America etc all pollute on a grand scale with Africa being mined for minerals at an alarming rate really what can we do other than fill our green bins.
It has to be a global movement, as our tiny island seems soo insignificant in fighting this.
China and India still pollute less per person than we do. This is even taking to account that a lot of what they use the energy for goes to Western countries as exports.
We have a brief window where we could force China to reduce emissions by applying a duty on their exports, but consumers don't want to pay the price.
Western governments are only too happy to increase the duty but are afraid of the backlash of increasing prices.
There is a lot 'Joe Public' can do, but it's going to cost us. We need to be more honest. If we don't want to pay the price - which I understand and is a legitimate argument - we should just be honest and say so. However, the argument that India and China are to blame just isn't true.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(07-24-2023, 01:22 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-24-2023, 11:24 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (07-24-2023, 11:14 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: "Rhodes is burning...What really matters is not that a Tourist playground burns, its the animals burned, wildlife lost and Nature destroyed...but our headlines talk of cancelled flights and holidays. If we think this is inconvenient..you wait to see the inconvenience of climate refugees, lack of food and water....floods, droughts and war....but let's just carry on leave that to our kids to deal with" - Deborah Meaden
My issue is what can we do, we as normal Joe Public?
As China, India and America etc all pollute on a grand scale with Africa being mined for minerals at an alarming rate really what can we do other than fill our green bins.
It has to be a global movement, as our tiny island seems soo insignificant in fighting this.
China and India still pollute less per person than we do. This is even taking to account that a lot of what they use the energy for goes to Western countries as exports.
We have a brief window where we could force China to reduce emissions by applying a duty on their exports, but consumers don't want to pay the price.
Western governments are only too happy to increase the duty but are afraid of the backlash of increasing prices.
There is a lot 'Joe Public' can do, but it's going to cost us. We need to be more honest. If we don't want to pay the price - which I understand and is a legitimate argument - we should just be honest and say so. However, the argument that India and China are to blame just isn't true.
There are ways around that, namely offsetting the revenues from a regressive tax (like income tax) with the revenues generated from carbon taxes. It would motivate people in the middle to lower their tax liabilities, and would predominantly affect big consumers (namely the wealthy) so it's a progressive solution.
But obviously the big consumers don't want that so try to obfuscate the message, same with how they've obfuscated the message on land value taxes.
Posts: 516
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
So let's say we do get everyone to give up gas boilers, drive an EV car and never fly again due to a massive increase in taxes / pushing from the Government. Then what? Because if we all did that here in the UK and the global emissions are still roughly similar to where they are today, what's the plan?
We sit in energy blackouts, wondering why we are cycling to work while other nations are happily still using their cars, boilers, AC units etc. People would leave the country in their droves (that could), then your tax take is down and your basically going backwards as a society.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(07-24-2023, 03:03 PM)boingingjim Wrote: So let's say we do get everyone to give up gas boilers, drive an EV car and never fly again due to a massive increase in taxes / pushing from the Government. Then what? Because if we all did that here in the UK and the global emissions are still roughly similar to where they are today, what's the plan?
We sit in energy blackouts, wondering why we are cycling to work while other nations are happily still using their cars, boilers, AC units etc. People would leave the country in their droves (that could), then your tax take is down and your basically going backwards as a society.
Yeah, because we definitely weren't just subject to huge energy price hikes because of our reliance on gas and bailed out by a warm winter from winter blackouts, were we...
What's the cheapest electricity generation type in the UK by LCOE? Oh yeah onshore wind, which is banned.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(07-24-2023, 02:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (07-24-2023, 01:22 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(07-24-2023, 11:24 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (07-24-2023, 11:14 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: "Rhodes is burning...What really matters is not that a Tourist playground burns, its the animals burned, wildlife lost and Nature destroyed...but our headlines talk of cancelled flights and holidays. If we think this is inconvenient..you wait to see the inconvenience of climate refugees, lack of food and water....floods, droughts and war....but let's just carry on leave that to our kids to deal with" - Deborah Meaden
My issue is what can we do, we as normal Joe Public?
As China, India and America etc all pollute on a grand scale with Africa being mined for minerals at an alarming rate really what can we do other than fill our green bins.
It has to be a global movement, as our tiny island seems soo insignificant in fighting this.
China and India still pollute less per person than we do. This is even taking to account that a lot of what they use the energy for goes to Western countries as exports.
We have a brief window where we could force China to reduce emissions by applying a duty on their exports, but consumers don't want to pay the price.
Western governments are only too happy to increase the duty but are afraid of the backlash of increasing prices.
There is a lot 'Joe Public' can do, but it's going to cost us. We need to be more honest. If we don't want to pay the price - which I understand and is a legitimate argument - we should just be honest and say so. However, the argument that India and China are to blame just isn't true.
There are ways around that, namely offsetting the revenues from a regressive tax (like income tax) with the revenues generated from carbon taxes. It would motivate people in the middle to lower their tax liabilities, and would predominantly affect big consumers (namely the wealthy) so it's a progressive solution.
But obviously the big consumers don't want that so try to obfuscate the message, same with how they've obfuscated the message on land value taxes.
Makes sense in terms of carbon offset. The logic is there in accounting/ERP systems but is something that, for the most part, is voluntary. It should be a cost that can be written off in terms of the software/set up but then should 1) be an auditable item and 2) be taxable as a disincentive to waste. Easier to do this than impose tariffs on consumers directly.
Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
Does anyone else remember than poster in Athena with a native American chappy saying you can't eat cash?
Makes yer fink.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(07-24-2023, 11:24 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (07-24-2023, 11:14 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: "Rhodes is burning...What really matters is not that a Tourist playground burns, its the animals burned, wildlife lost and Nature destroyed...but our headlines talk of cancelled flights and holidays. If we think this is inconvenient..you wait to see the inconvenience of climate refugees, lack of food and water....floods, droughts and war....but let's just carry on leave that to our kids to deal with" - Deborah Meaden
My issue is what can we do, we as normal Joe Public?
As China, India and America etc all pollute on a grand scale with Africa being mined for minerals at an alarming rate really what can we do other than fill our green bins.
It has to be a global movement, as our tiny island seems soo insignificant in fighting this.
As I said on here the other day, one Ineos plant in Cheshire uses the same amount of energy every day as the whole city of Liverpool.
Me and the plumber were laughing the other day that a just a Heat Pump (let alone £thousands on the additional insulation required) would take 39 years to break even at Casa Proth on the basis of £energy savings. I'd also have to drive my V8 another 70,000 miles until it breaks even with the embedded emissions in a new Nissan Leaf.
Green ideology is colliding with practicality and cost everywhere in the world. Whilst inflation rages and real wages remain suppressed it would be brave government to add yet more to our monthly bills.
Posts: 516
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(07-24-2023, 03:15 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (07-24-2023, 03:03 PM)boingingjim Wrote: So let's say we do get everyone to give up gas boilers, drive an EV car and never fly again due to a massive increase in taxes / pushing from the Government. Then what? Because if we all did that here in the UK and the global emissions are still roughly similar to where they are today, what's the plan?
We sit in energy blackouts, wondering why we are cycling to work while other nations are happily still using their cars, boilers, AC units etc. People would leave the country in their droves (that could), then your tax take is down and your basically going backwards as a society.
Yeah, because we definitely weren't just subject to huge energy price hikes because of our reliance on gas and bailed out by a warm winter from winter blackouts, were we...
What's the cheapest electricity generation type in the UK by LCOE? Oh yeah onshore wind, which is banned.
Quite, which is why we should have invested in nuclear and not knocked down the stations we had. Moving to wind / greener energy is great, but you need a path to get there and currently that would require - oil, fracking and nuclear building... The idea you give up on these things immediately and hold out for wind farms, is a bit short sighted to say the least.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(07-24-2023, 03:39 PM)boingingjim Wrote: (07-24-2023, 03:15 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (07-24-2023, 03:03 PM)boingingjim Wrote: So let's say we do get everyone to give up gas boilers, drive an EV car and never fly again due to a massive increase in taxes / pushing from the Government. Then what? Because if we all did that here in the UK and the global emissions are still roughly similar to where they are today, what's the plan?
We sit in energy blackouts, wondering why we are cycling to work while other nations are happily still using their cars, boilers, AC units etc. People would leave the country in their droves (that could), then your tax take is down and your basically going backwards as a society.
Yeah, because we definitely weren't just subject to huge energy price hikes because of our reliance on gas and bailed out by a warm winter from winter blackouts, were we...
What's the cheapest electricity generation type in the UK by LCOE? Oh yeah onshore wind, which is banned.
Quite, which is why we should have invested in nuclear and not knocked down the stations we had. Moving to wind / greener energy is great, but you need a path to get there and currently that would require - oil, fracking and nuclear building... The idea you give up on these things immediately and hold out for wind farms, is a bit short sighted to say the least.
Doesn't require fracking, anyone who thinks fracking is "an answer" is ignorant to both the fact that it wouldn't address the issue with gas price instability and the logistics required to deploy it make zero sense. Not to mention it sucks investment away from the actual solutions.
Fine with nuclear, much more sensible now that the realities of the LCOE Vs fossil fuels make it cheaper in the immediate term as well as the long term. But we can blame Maggie Thatcher for our dire lack of nuclear infrastructure (and another reason why any speculative gas investment can piss off). Most of the public are in support of nuclear, just need to shut the gas lobby up as they're the ones who have caused the most damage to nuclear power.
Also, onshore wind farms scale a lot quicker than other power generation types. You don't "need" to hold out for them, decouple energy prices from gas and private investment will explode as they're easy to put up, replicable, cheap, land can be multi-purpose and their OpEx is basically nowt.
|