Just stop oil protests
(07-20-2023, 03:35 PM)Fido Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:32 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:23 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 02:18 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: extinction event 

Are we really?

Yes, we are. Really.

Extinctions are at over 1,000 the rate of the background extinction event since 1900, that meets the definition of an extinction event.

How many animals do we know about now as opposed to in 1900? Genuine question.

I don't know, I'm not a biologist. I'm just going off the data they've presented.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 03:10 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 02:50 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: It's terrifying people refuse to accept global warming and climate change is real and genuine threat to society and life as we know it.

That may be the case.

But isn't it utterly absurd that those who do accept its real, and think there needs to be action, can't explain (or agree on) how much action, what is required, whether it needs to be drastic, whether severe restrictions are required, how much this impacts quality of life, how much this impacts the public financially etc etc.

They just say "I support JSO, extinction rebellion etc", often without having a single clue what it actually means in changing society and the way of life, or being able to provide any sort of cost benefit analysis in taking these actions. They just come out with broad statements and ideas without knowing how much they'll work, whether they'll have any significant impact on global warming, and whether we're fucked anyway even if it'll help. But the answer is "well we've got to do something" I'm afraid if we're changing ways of life and behaviours, people want far far more detail than that!

Some say restrictions are required physically limiting people's carbon consumption. Some say that's nonsense and a conspiracy theory and it can be done through other means. Some say its all too late. All these groups slag off people who don't believe in climate change, yet can't even come close to agreeing what needs to be done.

This is why I think, going back to my original post, the debate needs detail, and actual real world solutions and cost benefit analysis.

What's absurd is you expecting people on a football forum to be able to provide cost-benefit analyses on what needs to be done to avoid a climate catastrophe.

The measures required are outlined in a series of videos produced by the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). I think we can safely assume that all the experts that such a body can call on know what they're talking about.

The aptly titled "Climate Solutions 101" videos can be found here if people can be arsed to watch them. Most people won't be arsed to watch them and/or aren't prepared (or can't afford) to do what's needed where they themselves can make a difference. Because of that, governments won't implement the measures required for fear of losing elections over it.

Edit: also just uploaded - Eating less meat 'like taking 8m cars off road'
Reply
(07-20-2023, 03:40 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:35 PM)Fido Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:32 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:23 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 02:18 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: extinction event 

Are we really?

Yes, we are. Really.

Extinctions are at over 1,000 the rate of the background extinction event since 1900, that meets the definition of an extinction event.

How many animals do we know about now as opposed to in 1900? Genuine question.
We actually have no idea how many species there are on the planet Fido. It's been estimated by those ITK types within expert fields there may be 50% of creatures we have not discovered.

Extinctions are also part of the big rich tapestry of nature.

I think though when mankind does shit like drain a lake to make cotton, or pump shit in a stream due to building a chemicals factory, it's pretty clear we are the cause of a lot of nature's current issues.

How can they be ITK then?
Reply
(07-20-2023, 03:43 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:10 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 02:50 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: It's terrifying people refuse to accept global warming and climate change is real and genuine threat to society and life as we know it.

That may be the case.

But isn't it utterly absurd that those who do accept its real, and think there needs to be action, can't explain (or agree on) how much action, what is required, whether it needs to be drastic, whether severe restrictions are required, how much this impacts quality of life, how much this impacts the public financially etc etc.

They just say "I support JSO, extinction rebellion etc", often without having a single clue what it actually means in changing society and the way of life, or being able to provide any sort of cost benefit analysis in taking these actions. They just come out with broad statements and ideas without knowing how much they'll work, whether they'll have any significant impact on global warming, and whether we're fucked anyway even if it'll help. But the answer is "well we've got to do something" I'm afraid if we're changing ways of life and behaviours, people want far far more detail than that!

Some say restrictions are required physically limiting people's carbon consumption. Some say that's nonsense and a conspiracy theory and it can be done through other means. Some say its all too late. All these groups slag off people who don't believe in climate change, yet can't even come close to agreeing what needs to be done.

This is why I think, going back to my original post, the debate needs detail, and actual real world solutions and cost benefit analysis.

What's absurd is you expecting people on a football forum to be able to provide cost-benefit analyses on what needs to be done to avoid a climate catastrophe.

The measures required are outlined in a series of videos produced by the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). I think we can safely assume that all the experts that such a body can call on know what they're talking about.

The aptly titled "Climate Solutions 101" videos can be found here if people can be arsed to watch them. Most people won't be arsed to watch them and/or aren't prepared (or can't afford) to do what's needed where they themselves can make a difference. Because of that, governments won't implement the measures required for fear of losing elections over it.

I'm not asking for a pound my pound breakdown Worc. My point is that there is such a huge discrepancy between, for example what Borinbaggie says needs to be done, compared to what you say. And a very general "i support JSO and extinction rebellion" theme from many without actually accepting or explaining what this means.

So can you tell me, do those videos suggest restrictions are required in terms of people's choices, lifestyle, amount of carbon used etc? Or can it be done through government decisions which still allow the public to not impact their quality of life/travel etc at all? Or does it say what needs to be done, without saying how it can actually be implemented? (which is the key!)

Edit:

I've read the artIcle on the red meat, and as usual it just says what needs to be done. not HOW CAN IT BE DONE.

The usual "we need to eat less red meat". Well great, that means sweet FA. What means something is how you get to that to happen. This is why I ask.... personal restrictions?

Actual real life impacts are what people want to know. Otherwise its just "yes I support eating less red meat", while I tuck into a steak. And yes I know a few may reduce consumption willingly, but not enough if we're in a catastrophe..... Its just meaningless lip service.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 03:51 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:43 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:10 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 02:50 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: It's terrifying people refuse to accept global warming and climate change is real and genuine threat to society and life as we know it.

That may be the case.

But isn't it utterly absurd that those who do accept its real, and think there needs to be action, can't explain (or agree on) how much action, what is required, whether it needs to be drastic, whether severe restrictions are required, how much this impacts quality of life, how much this impacts the public financially etc etc.

They just say "I support JSO, extinction rebellion etc", often without having a single clue what it actually means in changing society and the way of life, or being able to provide any sort of cost benefit analysis in taking these actions. They just come out with broad statements and ideas without knowing how much they'll work, whether they'll have any significant impact on global warming, and whether we're fucked anyway even if it'll help. But the answer is "well we've got to do something" I'm afraid if we're changing ways of life and behaviours, people want far far more detail than that!

Some say restrictions are required physically limiting people's carbon consumption. Some say that's nonsense and a conspiracy theory and it can be done through other means. Some say its all too late. All these groups slag off people who don't believe in climate change, yet can't even come close to agreeing what needs to be done.

This is why I think, going back to my original post, the debate needs detail, and actual real world solutions and cost benefit analysis.

What's absurd is you expecting people on a football forum to be able to provide cost-benefit analyses on what needs to be done to avoid a climate catastrophe.

The measures required are outlined in a series of videos produced by the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). I think we can safely assume that all the experts that such a body can call on know what they're talking about.

The aptly titled "Climate Solutions 101" videos can be found here if people can be arsed to watch them. Most people won't be arsed to watch them and/or aren't prepared (or can't afford) to do what's needed where they themselves can make a difference. Because of that, governments won't implement the measures required for fear of losing elections over it.

So can you tell me, do those videos suggest restrictions are required in terms of people's choices, lifestyle, amount of carbon used etc? Or can it be done through government decisions which still allow the public to not impact their quality of life/travel etc at all? Or does it say what needs to be done, without saying how it can actually be implemented? (which is the key!)

Watch them yourself. That you (and others) probably won't brings me back top what I wrote earlier, part of which is something you seem to agree with at least:

Education of the general public needs to improve drastically, not just by national and local government but also by the media, particularly newspapers. It's also beholden on us to seek answers to questions that we have relating to climate change and not just wait for info to be fed to us.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 03:40 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:35 PM)Fido Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:32 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:23 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 02:18 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: extinction event 

Are we really?

Yes, we are. Really.

Extinctions are at over 1,000 the rate of the background extinction event since 1900, that meets the definition of an extinction event.

How many animals do we know about now as opposed to in 1900? Genuine question.
We actually have no idea how many species there are on the planet Fido. It's been estimated by those ITK types within expert fields there may be 50% of creatures we have not discovered.

Extinctions are also part of the big rich tapestry of nature.

I think though when mankind does shit like drain a lake to make cotton, or pump shit in a stream due to building a chemicals factory, it's pretty clear we are the cause of a lot of nature's current issues.

Think we're at the point now where new discoveries are just slight variations on existing insects/molluscs.

Personally I'm happy with there just being one type of snail.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 04:14 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:51 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:43 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 03:10 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 02:50 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: It's terrifying people refuse to accept global warming and climate change is real and genuine threat to society and life as we know it.

That may be the case.

But isn't it utterly absurd that those who do accept its real, and think there needs to be action, can't explain (or agree on) how much action, what is required, whether it needs to be drastic, whether severe restrictions are required, how much this impacts quality of life, how much this impacts the public financially etc etc.

They just say "I support JSO, extinction rebellion etc", often without having a single clue what it actually means in changing society and the way of life, or being able to provide any sort of cost benefit analysis in taking these actions. They just come out with broad statements and ideas without knowing how much they'll work, whether they'll have any significant impact on global warming, and whether we're fucked anyway even if it'll help. But the answer is "well we've got to do something" I'm afraid if we're changing ways of life and behaviours, people want far far more detail than that!

Some say restrictions are required physically limiting people's carbon consumption. Some say that's nonsense and a conspiracy theory and it can be done through other means. Some say its all too late. All these groups slag off people who don't believe in climate change, yet can't even come close to agreeing what needs to be done.

This is why I think, going back to my original post, the debate needs detail, and actual real world solutions and cost benefit analysis.

What's absurd is you expecting people on a football forum to be able to provide cost-benefit analyses on what needs to be done to avoid a climate catastrophe.

The measures required are outlined in a series of videos produced by the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC). I think we can safely assume that all the experts that such a body can call on know what they're talking about.

The aptly titled "Climate Solutions 101" videos can be found here if people can be arsed to watch them. Most people won't be arsed to watch them and/or aren't prepared (or can't afford) to do what's needed where they themselves can make a difference. Because of that, governments won't implement the measures required for fear of losing elections over it.

So can you tell me, do those videos suggest restrictions are required in terms of people's choices, lifestyle, amount of carbon used etc? Or can it be done through government decisions which still allow the public to not impact their quality of life/travel etc at all? Or does it say what needs to be done, without saying how it can actually be implemented? (which is the key!)

Watch them yourself. That you (and others) probably won't brings me back top what I wrote earlier, part of which is something you seem to agree with at least:

Education of the general public needs to improve drastically, not just by national and local government but also by the media, particularly newspapers. It's also beholden on us to seek answers to questions that we have relating to climate change and not just wait for info to be fed to us.

I may well later, but can't you tell me? I trust you to let me know the truth here as I guess you've watched them. Do they actually explain whether governments would need to force these things through methods such as restrictions on the public that impact their lifestyles/ability to travel etc? Or can the required reductions in emissions be done another way?

The meat article simply says how much reducing meat helps the environment. It doesn't touch on how we actually physically get there on a personal level (ie what changes are required to get there and how it will impact our lives).

The media literally run climate change articles every day for the last god knows how many years. And unfortunately for you, people may not want to know about these things. Its a choice whether to be educated on these issues, and people don't have to. They're entitled to do something else if they want.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 04:22 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: The media literally run climate change articles every day for the last god knows how many years. And unfortunately for you, people may not want to know about these things. Its a choice whether to be educated on these issues, and people don't have to. They're entitled to do something else if they want.

I suspect there aren't too many articles in right-wing tabloids or coverage on the likes of GB News (at least not that isn't promoting a conspiracy theory).

Oh, and it's not just unfortunate for me but for society as a whole that the planet is being decimated.

I'm now done with discussing this with you.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 04:29 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 04:22 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: The media literally run climate change articles every day for the last god knows how many years. And unfortunately for you, people may not want to know about these things. Its a choice whether to be educated on these issues, and people don't have to. They're entitled to do something else if they want.

I suspect there aren't too many articles in right-wing tabloids or coverage on the likes of GB News (at least not that isn't promoting a conspiracy theory).

Oh, and it's not just unfortunate for me but for society as a whole that the planet is being decimated.

I'm now done with discussing this with you.

It’s exhausting I wouldn’t bother. It’s not worth it trust me.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 04:29 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 04:22 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: The media literally run climate change articles every day for the last god knows how many years. And unfortunately for you, people may not want to know about these things. Its a choice whether to be educated on these issues, and people don't have to. They're entitled to do something else if they want.

I suspect there aren't too many articles in right-wing tabloids or coverage on the likes of GB News (at least not that isn't promoting a conspiracy theory).

Oh, and it's not just unfortunate for me but for society as a whole that the planet is being decimated.

I'm now done with discussing this with you.

Well again the tabloids can choose to write what they want can't they? I don't understand your point. You basically seem to be saying "people should read about what I want them to and think like I want them to".

Why are you done discussing it?

All I've asked for is some indication as to HOW we get to where the scientific consensus is saying we need to get to. Would it require:

A. personal restrictions on carbon consumption/travel
B. carbon heavy activities to become more expensive to the public, or
C. could it all be done through other means (affordable alternatives, non-polluting cars etc)?

The answer to this is literally what people need to know IMO. Is that fair?

Because my hunch is that a hell of a lot of people who say they support JSO/extinction rebellion etc, would soon change their mind if the answer is any combination of A and/or B. (in some cases because it would create serious difficulties for them, and in some cases because they simply don't want to)

If its C, I reckon you'll get at least 95% of the population on board.

Surely these are literally the key issues which should be discussed? (and not the usual vague and ultimately meaningless "I support JSA", " we need to do more" etc, vs full blown climate change denial).

(07-20-2023, 04:37 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 04:29 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 04:22 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: The media literally run climate change articles every day for the last god knows how many years. And unfortunately for you, people may not want to know about these things. Its a choice whether to be educated on these issues, and people don't have to. They're entitled to do something else if they want.

I suspect there aren't too many articles in right-wing tabloids or coverage on the likes of GB News (at least not that isn't promoting a conspiracy theory).

Oh, and it's not just unfortunate for me but for society as a whole that the planet is being decimated.

I'm now done with discussing this with you.

It’s exhausting I wouldn’t bother. It’s not worth it trust me.

Why DH? I'm literally asking for real world solutions and answers, not vague meaningless "we need to do something" vs "climate change denial" which goes absolutely nowhere?

I'm interested to know why you think I'm wrong to ask this?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)