Posts: 516
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
Do we believe the Earth's temperature is cyclical?
Are we speeding this up?
Why wouldn't we plan to try to get a 1c temperature rise?
Fossil fuels have moved more people out of poverty than anything else, the idea to stop using them with a decade is nonsense. If you truly want to decarbonise in the long term, short term you are going to need oil. So just stop oil is nonsense.
The rest of the thread is basically people advocating that poor people stop using cars and stop eating red meat... The democratization of air travel for the masses is something we should be celebrating, for people that were deriding folk for a little England mentality not that long ago, it's now weirdly the same people wanting some return to 1950 or the Victorian slums.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(07-20-2023, 02:00 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (07-20-2023, 01:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (07-20-2023, 01:50 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (07-20-2023, 01:35 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (07-20-2023, 01:27 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I understand traffic filtering - and I'm just saying I don't think it will create more than a negligible uptake in cycling.
And as for carbon credits, did you actually read my post?!! It wasn't me suggesting limiting the public in this respect! I literally said I've never taken it seriously. Its others on here suggesting people will "have to" limit red meat consumption, and suggesting restrictions on flying could be a thing. I was asking were people seriously suggesting this could be a thing?
It's working in London. 40% rise in the number of cyclists in 3 years from 2019 to 2022. Also working in Paris. You can't handwave away those two examples like you tried with Copenhagen and Amsterdam.
And you're extrapolating things that should be disincentivised with bans. I've reduced my red meat consumption, primarily for carbon reasons (I work in the energy industry, climate change is the huge problem) through personal choice. Not just me either, despite a larger population meat consumption is down over the last decade. We've also seen the success of Lumo as an open access rail operator competing with low cost airlines, also the Italian high speed rail network has killed the market for flights in Italy. If you offer people workable, low carbon solutions as a genuine choice they will take them.
London is so different to other places. And a 40% rise still hardly equates to that many does it really?
40% over 3 years is huge.
Was that to do with ULEZ starting in 2019? (which IMO hammers the poor and 'forces' them out of cars at least to a degree, as they're likely to have the older non-complaint ones).
Plus, 40% increase is sweet FA if we're on the road to extinction.
There's a few on here suggesting we're literally on the brink (or past it). If that's the case, do you think a 40% rise in cyclists over 3 years is really going to help save us?
And what do you think of other's suggestions (not mine) that we require restrictions far in excess of this? Limiting red meat? Flying etc?
Given the fact we're apparently on the brink, doesn't that mean severe changes immediately are required? Or not?
A 40% rise from 570,000 daily journeys to 800,000 in 3 years is not sweet FA, and it's tracked with the increase in cycle infrastructure over that time. Build it and people will use it.
In terms of the wider decarbonisation strategy, big ticket movements will have greater impacts. I work in the sector that is the largest impact on emissions globally and in UK, and thanks to the shift we were at 67% renewable generation on average over the weekend. And more renewable capacity is coming on line. If people keep being defeatist like you are then we may as well just give up and condemn ourselves.
And I don't care what other people are saying, I've laid out what I expect.
Posts: 4,668
Threads: 183
Joined: Nov 2022
Reputation:
14
(07-20-2023, 09:44 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (07-20-2023, 09:42 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: They're cunts. There's no other way to dress it up. The irony is is that I (and I suspect most decent folks?) agree with what they're fighting for. But they're rubbing people up the wrong way and are causing more harm to their cause than good. They really are arrogant, thick, woke, ignorant cunts who don't give a shit about what impact they're having on genuine and innocent people. They can just fuck off.
Don't know why that's made me laugh so much. Well done Bob for the most heart on a sleeve post of the day.
I'm glad I've achieved my daily goal of making someone laugh!
They really do wind me up, though.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(07-20-2023, 02:15 PM)boingingjim Wrote: Do we believe the Earth's temperature is cyclical?
Are we speeding this up?
Why wouldn't we plan to try to get a 1c temperature rise?
Fossil fuels have moved more people out of poverty than anything else, the idea to stop using them with a decade is nonsense. If you truly want to decarbonise in the long term, short term you are going to need oil. So just stop oil is nonsense.
The rest of the thread is basically people advocating that poor people stop using cars and stop eating red meat... The democratization of air travel for the masses is something we should be celebrating, for people that were deriding folk for a little England mentality not that long ago, it's now weirdly the same people wanting some return to 1950 or the Victorian slums.
You are talking out of your arse pal. Anthropogenic climate change is a thing, it's happening, we're in an extinction event as a result of it and to pretend otherwise is outing yourself as a crank.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(07-20-2023, 02:13 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (07-20-2023, 02:06 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (07-20-2023, 01:14 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 01:14 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (07-20-2023, 12:49 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Attitudes like people want to enjoy life? That's hardly unusual!
People like to have choice? Again, hardly unusual!
What sort of society do you want to live in, where people don't want to enjoy life or have choice?
Since we first came onto the scene, mankind has selfishly plundered, pillaged and exploited the planet (and it's flora and fauna) in the name of "enjoying life" in one respect or another. The irony that the end result is going to be that planet will become unliveable on for humans if we carry on the same is obviously lost on you.
Its not lost on me! I understand we're working towards net zero by 2050. I have nothing against that at all, as long as it doesn't affect the poor and working classes. Nothing wrong with my view there.
So tell me, what's your vision for society on how you want to get people to stop having choices and enjoying life? Banning air travel? Severe restrictions? As I said in my earlier post, people want to know detail on how it actually affects life. By criticising enjoyment and choices, you're not being very persuasive.
So what's your vision on how we should save the planet? Restrictions? Limiting carbon use per person?
I see you've moved the goalposts from being astonished at the prospect of everyone not being able to do whatever they want to enjoy life to it only being an issue for the poor and working classes. Climate change doesn't distinguish between social classes of course, but it will be the poorest countries that will suffer more quickly and won't be able to mitigate for it.
I don't have a vision for the planet/society, I'll leave that to experts who know far more about such things than me. What I do know is that no vision will be implemented whilst the government on the day think it'll cause them to lose a general election. That's why they'll talk a lot about the importance of the climate crisis and set goals without explaining how they'll be achieved, but they'll keep kicking the can down the road when it comes to taking the required steps whilst hoping for a technological miracle to occur.
Nope, I've not moved any goalposts. I've simply said people wanting to enjoy life is normal. And working towards net zero is fine as long as its not at the expense of the working classes/vulnerable.
You don't have a vision, but you seem to dislike the fact people want to enjoy life. You criticise people making choices, you say this is what's ending the world as we know it, yet you can't come up with any answers or suggestions?
I hope you enjoy life more than you let on!
I'm comfortable with recognising that we're fucking up the planet with our behaviour whilst also recognising I don't understand enough to have lots or workable policies to change it all.
We have to work together globally to make a difference and we have to change our own transportation needs and how we trade internationally with the movement of goods and use of limited resources. Many answers can come from scientific advances and some may be from restrictions to behaviour.
It's not our job to have the answers and the implementation of these. That's what the government are for, they talk it but don't walk it, just push it on to the next lot to sort. Restrictions aren't vote winning and all they want is to win votes to stay in power.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 516
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
"we're in an extinction event" sounds a lot like crank talk to me.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(07-20-2023, 02:21 PM)boingingjim Wrote: "we're in an extinction event" sounds a lot like crank talk to me.
The real cranks are those denying that the Anthropocene extinction event is real. Extinction events have definitions and the decline of species over the last 200 years tracks with the definition.
Posts: 3,034
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
07-20-2023, 02:25 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-20-2023, 02:28 PM by backsidebaggie.)
(07-20-2023, 02:04 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: (07-20-2023, 01:39 PM)boingingjim Wrote: Can we also have a debate that a certain amount of temperature rise may be beneficial for many regions on earth? Nope... Okay back to impending doom.
And this reasoning is why we'll never get anywhere without enforcement.
To the other parts of the thread, I'm not advocating Air Mile restrictions I was just answering the question as to what sort of adaptions did I think we could face. That's one idea from my own mind.
Ultimately we need to be more self-sufficient as a nation and accept seasonal fruit and veg as a basic example of transporting fruit all round the world. Farming needs to be radically changed.
And yes, an acceptance that red meat may well be restricted. Not so much as rationing, just fewer produce available which will no doubt increase the price and make it a rich persons meat, but we accept not eating caviar and truffles.
I'd also attack the car manufacturers and engineers. Hydrogen vehicles can be made and are more likely to be a better option than electric, so force them to develop or remove there ability to trade. EVERYONE takes the path of least resistance and if they can get away with doing nothing they will do so. It's why we drive because public transport isn't convenient enough. It's why we buy new things instead of repairing. Don't darn your socks, go to Primark and buy 3 for £1 (or whatever they charge) without a thought for the fact they've probably been imported from half a world away.
Right, so you believe it'll require enforcement of some kind. Even if that's pricing the working classes out of red meat and it becoming a rich person's thing.
Boringbaggie, what do you say to that?
I'm not saying I know any answers, I'm trying to get to the bottom of what people want and how they think we can save the planet, and how immediate and severe actions would need to be. I see some people saying we're doomed and need severe change. Borinbaggie suggests cleaner ways of living can be achieved while still maintaining choice (fair play, but I think the effect is limited, and certainly not enough if we are at the brink, like some say).
This is why those who say they don't give a shit and won't do anything are at least consistent and clear.
Those who say they support JSO and other environmental groups seem to be a mish mash of:
1) We're doomed, we need severe change quickly as we're at the point of catastrophe (broadly Worc - sorry if I've misunderstood)
2) We're in trouble but can avoid catastrophe if we hurry up net zero a bit by providing various incentives (broadly Borinbaggie - again sorry if i've misunderstood)
3) Those who say they support but never actually give it a second thought unless asked
This is very broad brush I accept.
But the key to me is groups 1 and 2 are completely at odds with each other, yet both support a green agenda, and rarely discuss what the actual truth is here.
So which is it? How much shit are we in? How severe do societal changes need to be? How much will they impact the public in real terms, both financially and behaviourally?
I genuinely don't know, but this goes back to me saying people need DETAIL to form a proper view.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(07-20-2023, 02:15 PM)boingingjim Wrote: Do we believe the Earth's temperature is cyclical? - YES
Are we speeding this up? - YES
Why wouldn't we plan to try to get a 1c temperature rise? - BECAUSE IT WOULD BE CRAZY
Fossil fuels have moved more people out of poverty than anything else, the idea to stop using them with a decade is nonsense. If you truly want to decarbonise in the long term, short term you are going to need oil. So just stop oil is nonsense. - DON'T DISAGREE, WHERE'S THE PLAN?
The rest of the thread is basically people advocating that poor people stop using cars and stop eating red meat... The democratization of air travel for the masses is something we should be celebrating, for people that were deriding folk for a little England mentality not that long ago, it's now weirdly the same people wanting some return to 1950 or the Victorian slums. - YOU SEEM TO READ WHAT YOU WISH.
Proth, can you change back to your usual log-in instead of this alter ego. I'll be wanting my £5 otherwise.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 516
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
07-20-2023, 02:34 PM
(This post was last modified: 07-20-2023, 02:34 PM by boingingjim.)
(07-20-2023, 02:26 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: (07-20-2023, 02:15 PM)boingingjim Wrote: Do we believe the Earth's temperature is cyclical? - YES
Are we speeding this up? - YES
Why wouldn't we plan to try to get a 1c temperature rise? - BECAUSE IT WOULD BE CRAZY
Fossil fuels have moved more people out of poverty than anything else, the idea to stop using them with a decade is nonsense. If you truly want to decarbonise in the long term, short term you are going to need oil. So just stop oil is nonsense. - DON'T DISAGREE, WHERE'S THE PLAN?
The rest of the thread is basically people advocating that poor people stop using cars and stop eating red meat... The democratization of air travel for the masses is something we should be celebrating, for people that were deriding folk for a little England mentality not that long ago, it's now weirdly the same people wanting some return to 1950 or the Victorian slums. - YOU SEEM TO READ WHAT YOU WISH.
Proth, can you change back to your usual log-in instead of this alter ego. I'll be wanting my £5 otherwise. 
What would happen with a 1c increase in temperature? If I was as worried as you I'd start planning for it because the rate of change you believe is required isn't going to happen, there will be large scale riots before some of the ideas on here for consumption change happen. Then you've got to convince China and India to play ball. Good luck.
Nuclear power is probably the best medium term answer, stopping oil production doesn't make the need for it go away, you'll just end up paying more and importing it all. Net effect people are poorer.
No car travel, no red meat, no ability to travel globally sure feels like a step back to the 1950's to me.
Who on the thread is going to give a date (within 50 year band) at which they believe with a) no change and b) current rate of changes, that the world will be uninhabitable for humans? And what is the cause of that extinction?
|