Just stop oil protests
(07-20-2023, 01:39 PM)boingingjim Wrote: Can we also have a debate that a certain amount of temperature rise may be beneficial for many regions on earth?  Nope... Okay back to impending doom.

There's often apocalyptic bollocks spoken about migration from marginal areas affected by climate change. However history (all of history) teaches us that when poor rural or coastal people migrate to cities they become better housed, better fed, better educated and healthier. They also tend to have fewer kids.

But don't let that put you off the impending doom.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 01:35 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 01:27 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I understand traffic filtering - and I'm just saying I don't think it will create more than a negligible uptake in cycling.

And as for carbon credits, did you actually read my post?!! It wasn't me suggesting limiting the public in this respect! I literally said I've never taken it seriously. Its others on here suggesting people will "have to" limit red meat consumption, and suggesting restrictions on flying could be a thing. I was asking were people seriously suggesting this could be a thing?

It's working in London. 40% rise in the number of cyclists in 3 years from 2019 to 2022. Also working in Paris. You can't handwave away those two examples like you tried with Copenhagen and Amsterdam.

And you're extrapolating things that should be disincentivised with bans. I've reduced my red meat consumption, primarily for carbon reasons (I work in the energy industry, climate change is the huge problem) through personal choice. Not just me either, despite a larger population meat consumption is down over the last decade. We've also seen the success of Lumo as an open access rail operator competing with low cost airlines, also the Italian high speed rail network has killed the market for flights in Italy. If you offer people workable, low carbon solutions as a genuine choice they will take them.

This is a fine thread as far as debates on this dump go.

Some are being overly-simplistic, with a get back to the caves mindset, whilst some on the other scale seem stubborn and slightly ambivalent.

It is an enormously complex debate, but one that needs a long-tern approach. A focus on keeping stuff longer, and transportation solutions appear the crux of it.

I believe as a country we can only succeed tackling this with a cross party long-term approach to matters such as transportation.

However, as has been said it's the likes of China and India polluting so much that's the biggest problem.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 01:50 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 01:35 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 01:27 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I understand traffic filtering - and I'm just saying I don't think it will create more than a negligible uptake in cycling.

And as for carbon credits, did you actually read my post?!! It wasn't me suggesting limiting the public in this respect! I literally said I've never taken it seriously. Its others on here suggesting people will "have to" limit red meat consumption, and suggesting restrictions on flying could be a thing. I was asking were people seriously suggesting this could be a thing?

It's working in London. 40% rise in the number of cyclists in 3 years from 2019 to 2022. Also working in Paris. You can't handwave away those two examples like you tried with Copenhagen and Amsterdam.

And you're extrapolating things that should be disincentivised with bans. I've reduced my red meat consumption, primarily for carbon reasons (I work in the energy industry, climate change is the huge problem) through personal choice. Not just me either, despite a larger population meat consumption is down over the last decade. We've also seen the success of Lumo as an open access rail operator competing with low cost airlines, also the Italian high speed rail network has killed the market for flights in Italy. If you offer people workable, low carbon solutions as a genuine choice they will take them.

London is so different to other places. And a 40% rise still hardly equates to that many does it really?


40% over 3 years is huge.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 01:14 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:49 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:46 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:38 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: What do we do then?  We managed as a species to survive before the jet engine was developed.  We shouldn't be flying products round the world just because we want strawberries at Xmas or the flowers that smell nicer than the one we've grown here.  There has to be an acceptance that this type of commercialism isn't really needed. 

Why do we import Lamb from NZ or Beef from Argentina?  We should be able to produce enough food products here.  Accept that we have to eat less beef if the methane is a problem.  Most people really can't tell the difference in taste.

We've globally over-populated to such an extent that we just need more and more resources all the time and we're creeping further and further into the green lands, forests etc along side needing more food, more animals for us to eat.  If this doesn't change it will end mankind as we know it.

You asked me what type of restrictions or adaptations - I've no idea if air mile restrictions would work, it was just an example.  It would have to be applied globally and to rich/poor alike.  Maybe our co-vid vaccine chips can track us  Big Grin

I think you're totally going against human nature. We managed as a species in medieval times, but that doesn't mean quality of life was as good as now. People want to enjoy life!

"Accept that we have to eat less red meat". I'd wager there's a huge proportion of the population that won't accept that. Its not North Korea (I know this phrase gets overused, but my point is people like to have choice).

Plus, if we get to air mile restrictions and red meat restrictions on the public, that's effectively 'carbon credits' for the population isn't it?

I agree regarding producing our own things and not flying stuff round needlessly BTW. But all these things have impacts on jobs etc. Its complex.

Attitudes like this have brought us to the cliff-edge with the climate and it's the same attitudes that will drive us over it like lemmings.

Attitudes like people want to enjoy life? That's hardly unusual!

People like to have choice? Again, hardly unusual!

What sort of society do you want to live in, where people don't want to enjoy life or have choice?

Since we first came onto the scene, mankind has selfishly plundered, pillaged and exploited the planet (and it's flora and fauna) in the name of "enjoying life" in one respect or another. The irony that the end result is going to be that planet will become unliveable on for humans if we carry on the same is obviously lost on you.

And this is the flaw with a lot of "Green" movements. They are run by individuals who fundamentally despise the human race. Hence they almost seem to be drooling about mass suffering. Look at the video I posted earlier. The head of Extinction Rebellion is almost fantasising about the wave of sexual violence in the grim future. 

People like that do not have mass appeal and their movements will only ever have fringe appeal. I am very wary of any movement built on disdain for the general population. Particularly when many people are spending their lives working for a more environmentally friendly world in terms of technological advances and policy change.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 01:53 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 01:50 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 01:35 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 01:27 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I understand traffic filtering - and I'm just saying I don't think it will create more than a negligible uptake in cycling.

And as for carbon credits, did you actually read my post?!! It wasn't me suggesting limiting the public in this respect! I literally said I've never taken it seriously. Its others on here suggesting people will "have to" limit red meat consumption, and suggesting restrictions on flying could be a thing. I was asking were people seriously suggesting this could be a thing?

It's working in London. 40% rise in the number of cyclists in 3 years from 2019 to 2022. Also working in Paris. You can't handwave away those two examples like you tried with Copenhagen and Amsterdam.

And you're extrapolating things that should be disincentivised with bans. I've reduced my red meat consumption, primarily for carbon reasons (I work in the energy industry, climate change is the huge problem) through personal choice. Not just me either, despite a larger population meat consumption is down over the last decade. We've also seen the success of Lumo as an open access rail operator competing with low cost airlines, also the Italian high speed rail network has killed the market for flights in Italy. If you offer people workable, low carbon solutions as a genuine choice they will take them.

London is so different to other places. And a 40% rise still hardly equates to that many does it really?


40% over 3 years is huge.

Was that to do with ULEZ starting in 2019? (which IMO hammers the poor and 'forces' them out of cars at least to a degree, as they're likely to have the older non-complaint ones).

Plus, 40% increase is sweet FA if we're on the road to extinction.

There's a few on here suggesting we're literally on the brink (or past it). If that's the case, do you think a 40% rise in cyclists over 3 years is really going to help save us?

And what do you think of other's suggestions (not mine) that we require restrictions far in excess of this? Limiting red meat? Flying etc?

Given the fact we're apparently on the brink, doesn't that mean severe changes immediately are required? Or not?
Reply
(07-20-2023, 01:39 PM)boingingjim Wrote: Can we also have a debate that a certain amount of temperature rise may be beneficial for many regions on earth?  Nope... Okay back to impending doom.

And this reasoning is why we'll never get anywhere without enforcement.

To the other parts of the thread, I'm not advocating Air Mile restrictions I was just answering the question as to what sort of adaptions did I think we could face.  That's one idea from my own mind.

Ultimately we need to be more self-sufficient as a nation and accept seasonal fruit and veg as a basic example of transporting fruit all round the world.  Farming needs to be radically changed.

And yes, an acceptance that red meat may well be restricted. Not so much as rationing, just fewer produce available which will no doubt increase the price and make it a rich persons meat, but we accept not eating caviar and truffles.

I'd also attack the car manufacturers and engineers.  Hydrogen vehicles can be made and are more likely to be a better option than electric, so force them to develop or remove there ability to trade.  EVERYONE takes the path of least resistance and if they can get away with doing nothing they will do so.  It's why we drive because public transport isn't convenient enough.  It's why we buy new things instead of repairing.  Don't darn your socks, go to Primark and buy 3 for £1 (or whatever they charge) without a thought for the fact they've probably been imported from half a world away.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
(07-20-2023, 01:14 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 01:14 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:49 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Attitudes like people want to enjoy life? That's hardly unusual!

People like to have choice? Again, hardly unusual!

What sort of society do you want to live in, where people don't want to enjoy life or have choice?

Since we first came onto the scene, mankind has selfishly plundered, pillaged and exploited the planet (and it's flora and fauna) in the name of "enjoying life" in one respect or another. The irony that the end result is going to be that planet will become unliveable on for humans if we carry on the same is obviously lost on you.

Its not lost on me! I understand we're working towards net zero by 2050. I have nothing against that at all, as long as it doesn't affect the poor and working classes. Nothing wrong with my view there.

So tell me, what's your vision for society on how you want to get people to stop having choices and enjoying life? Banning air travel? Severe restrictions? As I said in my earlier post, people want to know detail on how it actually affects life. By criticising enjoyment and choices, you're not being very persuasive.

So what's your vision on how we should save the planet? Restrictions? Limiting carbon use per person?

I see you've moved the goalposts from being astonished at the prospect of everyone not being able to do whatever they want to enjoy life to it only being an issue for the poor and working classes. Climate change doesn't distinguish between social classes of course, but it will be the poorest countries that will suffer more quickly and won't be able to mitigate for it.

I don't have a vision for the planet/society, I'll leave that to experts who know far more about such things than me. What I do know is that no vision will be implemented whilst the government on the day think it'll cause them to lose a general election. That's why they'll talk a lot about the importance of the climate crisis and set goals without explaining how they'll be achieved, but they'll keep kicking the can down the road when it comes to taking the required steps whilst hoping for a technological miracle to occur.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 12:40 PM)Loanee Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:31 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:27 PM)Loanee Wrote: Assume those complaining don’t walk in the middle of the brummie road after a match blocking cars ?  Lots appear to do this…

I bet they're the very same people that get all aggy with car drivers beeping at them to walk on the pavement or behind the cones.

The culture know is "all about me".

Of course they are, as mentioned by someone else earlier they’ll also be the ones advocating disruptive protest against Lai.

That was me and they will. Cuz that ay woke!
Reply
(07-20-2023, 01:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 01:14 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: Since we first came onto the scene, mankind has selfishly plundered, pillaged and exploited the planet (and it's flora and fauna) in the name of "enjoying life" in one respect or another. The irony that the end result is going to be that planet will become unliveable on for humans if we carry on the same is obviously lost on you.

I don't think there's a consensus that the planet will become uninhabitable for humans. It's this level of hyperbole which is so dangerous and divisive.

I don't give a shit what a lifelong "I'm alright Jack" Tory like yourself thinks about anything.
Reply
(07-20-2023, 02:06 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 01:14 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 01:14 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 12:49 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Attitudes like people want to enjoy life? That's hardly unusual!

People like to have choice? Again, hardly unusual!

What sort of society do you want to live in, where people don't want to enjoy life or have choice?

Since we first came onto the scene, mankind has selfishly plundered, pillaged and exploited the planet (and it's flora and fauna) in the name of "enjoying life" in one respect or another. The irony that the end result is going to be that planet will become unliveable on for humans if we carry on the same is obviously lost on you.

Its not lost on me! I understand we're working towards net zero by 2050. I have nothing against that at all, as long as it doesn't affect the poor and working classes. Nothing wrong with my view there.

So tell me, what's your vision for society on how you want to get people to stop having choices and enjoying life? Banning air travel? Severe restrictions? As I said in my earlier post, people want to know detail on how it actually affects life. By criticising enjoyment and choices, you're not being very persuasive.

So what's your vision on how we should save the planet? Restrictions? Limiting carbon use per person?

I see you've moved the goalposts from being astonished at the prospect of everyone not being able to do whatever they want to enjoy life to it only being an issue for the poor and working classes. Climate change doesn't distinguish between social classes of course, but it will be the poorest countries that will suffer more quickly and won't be able to mitigate for it.

I don't have a vision for the planet/society, I'll leave that to experts who know far more about such things than me. What I do know is that no vision will be implemented whilst the government on the day think it'll cause them to lose a general election. That's why they'll talk a lot about the importance of the climate crisis and set goals without explaining how they'll be achieved, but they'll keep kicking the can down the road when it comes to taking the required steps whilst hoping for a technological miracle to occur.

Nope, I've not moved any goalposts. I've simply said people wanting to enjoy life is normal. And working towards net zero is fine as long as its not at the expense of the working classes/vulnerable.

You don't have a vision, but you seem to dislike the fact people want to enjoy life. You criticise people making choices, you say this is what's ending the world as we know it, yet you can't come up with any answers or suggestions?

I hope you enjoy life more than you let on!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)