Just stop oil protests
#71
(07-20-2023, 11:17 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I find the whole “debate” with JSO, and other climate issues, incredibly oversimplified tbh.

What most people want to know, IMO, is if society needs to change to “save us from extinction”, what does this actually mean? Actual real world changes. Is stopping new oil going to increase our costs? Are there genuine viable alternatives? Is switching to electric cars going to price the poor out of driving? Are we going to have travel restricted in any way? People want to know real world impacts IMO. How it’ll actually affect their quality of life.

These are an example of the things that don’t get discussed much. It all seems to be you’re either for or against with no detail or cost benefit analysis.

And of course, there’s a high percentage of people who say “i support the cause” but they’re just paying lip service and don’t give it a second thought in reality, or certainly don’t take any steps to change anything. I mean neither do I, I love driving and holidays, but I don’t say “I support the cause” either. I want to know detail of actual effects to people’s lives before I claim to support stopping oil etc.

And I think there’s plenty of people like me. What’s the actual real world result of getting to net zero by 2040, 2050 etc etc? This is the key.

Another good post. 

What is obvious is, that this issue transcends all of us individually. As a species we are destroying the planet. Our reliance on personal transport, our urge to consume, our impatience and our familiarity with a life governed by convenience and comfort is going to be very hard to shake off, and its only been the case since the 50/60s in reality. 

I am trying my best personally. I have made big changes to my life style. I fly no more than once or twice a year now rather than every month. I have though brought a (modern) diesel van which is my camper which enables me to have more local holiday. We have changed our second vehicle for an electric. Which is what we use daily. I only buy locally sourced meat from a local butcher. I try and avoid using my heating until the missus is close to tears and I very rarely but clothes/tech/other items as I have really taken to the simple life.

But I know that these changes are so insignificant, especially when you consider that the huge developing economies like China, India & Brazil are increasing their consumption and emission much faster than the rest of us are reducing them.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#72
(07-20-2023, 11:17 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I find the whole “debate” with JSO, and other climate issues, incredibly oversimplified tbh.

What most people want to know, IMO, is if society needs to change to “save us from extinction”, what does this actually mean? Actual real world changes. Is stopping new oil going to increase our costs? Are there genuine viable alternatives? Is switching to electric cars going to price the poor out of driving? Are we going to have travel restricted in any way? People want to know real world impacts IMO. How it’ll actually affect their quality of life.

These are an example of the things that don’t get discussed much. It all seems to be you’re either for or against with no detail or cost benefit analysis.

And of course, there’s a high percentage of people who say “i support the cause” but they’re just paying lip service and don’t give it a second thought in reality, or certainly don’t take any steps to change anything. I mean neither do I, I love driving and holidays, but I don’t say “I support the cause” either. I want to know detail of actual effects to people’s lives before I claim to support stopping oil etc.

And I think there’s plenty of people like me. What’s the actual real world result of getting to net zero by 2040, 2050 etc etc? This is the key.

The biggest impact on climate is people.  How many would support a ban on having more than 1 child?
Reply
#73
(07-20-2023, 11:17 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I find the whole “debate” with JSO, and other climate issues, incredibly oversimplified tbh.

What most people want to know, IMO, is if society needs to change to “save us from extinction”, what does this actually mean? Actual real world changes. Is stopping new oil going to increase our costs? Are there genuine viable alternatives? Is switching to electric cars going to price the poor out of driving? Are we going to have travel restricted in any way? People want to know real world impacts IMO. How it’ll actually affect their quality of life.

These are an example of the things that don’t get discussed much. It all seems to be you’re either for or against with no detail or cost benefit analysis.

And of course, there’s a high percentage of people who say “i support the cause” but they’re just paying lip service and don’t give it a second thought in reality, or certainly don’t take any steps to change anything. I mean neither do I, I love driving and holidays, but I don’t say “I support the cause” either. I want to know detail of actual effects to people’s lives before I claim to support stopping oil etc.

And I think there’s plenty of people like me. What’s the actual real world result of getting to net zero by 2040, 2050 etc etc? This is the key.

I agree we need far more information, I also agree that this subject makes hypocrites of us all. I can’t and won’t be giving up my car and for my families needs I can’t afford an electric vehicle. The problem is we won’t like the answers. There aren’t going to be for the immediate futures cheaper or better alternatives than what we have. Humans are selfish, stubborn and short term creatures and it will take something absolutely catastrophic to make us change our habits by then I suspect it’ll be way too late. The Leonardo DiCaprio film Don’t Look Up is a perfect example of where we are as a species.
Reply
#74
(07-20-2023, 11:36 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 11:17 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I find the whole “debate” with JSO, and other climate issues, incredibly oversimplified tbh.

What most people want to know, IMO, is if society needs to change to “save us from extinction”, what does this actually mean? Actual real world changes. Is stopping new oil going to increase our costs? Are there genuine viable alternatives? Is switching to electric cars going to price the poor out of driving? Are we going to have travel restricted in any way? People want to know real world impacts IMO. How it’ll actually affect their quality of life.

These are an example of the things that don’t get discussed much. It all seems to be you’re either for or against with no detail or cost benefit analysis.

And of course, there’s a high percentage of people who say “i support the cause” but they’re just paying lip service and don’t give it a second thought in reality, or certainly don’t take any steps to change anything. I mean neither do I, I love driving and holidays, but I don’t say “I support the cause” either. I want to know detail of actual effects to people’s lives before I claim to support stopping oil etc.

And I think there’s plenty of people like me. What’s the actual real world result of getting to net zero by 2040, 2050 etc etc? This is the key.

I agree we need far more information, I also agree that this subject makes hypocrites of us all. I can’t and won’t be giving up my car and for my families needs I can’t afford an electric vehicle. The problem is we won’t like the answers. There aren’t going to be for the immediate futures cheaper or better alternatives than what we have. Humans are selfish, stubborn and short term creatures and it will take something absolutely catastrophic to make us change our habits by then I suspect it’ll be way too late. The Leonardo DiCaprio film Don’t Look Up is a perfect example of where we are as a species.

TBF it doesn’t make hypocrites of everyone. Only those who preach but don’t practice are the hypocrites. If you say you don’t give a shit and act like you don’t give a shit you’re hardly a hypocrite.

But the key is we need detail. I refuse to say I support a cause of stopping oil, for example, when I genuinely don’t know if this would increase our costs, and I’ll never support anything that hammers the working classes.

Likewise with electric cars etc. I don’t support this transition if it prices ordinary people out of driving while the rich can carry on.
Reply
#75
Education of the general public needs to improve drastically, not just by national and local government but also by the media, particularly newspapers. It's also beholden on us to seek answers to questions that we have relating to climate change and not just wait for info to be fed to us.

Meteorologists and weather presenters have a part to play too, for example by stopping calling temperatures a degree or two below average "disappointing" and not refer to temperatures between 16-20C as "chilly" (as I have heard said several times). They seem to feel they have a duty to reflect unnecessary and unhelpful expectations that it needs to be 30C in the shade for weeks before it can be properly regarded as summer.

The job of meteorologists is to report scientific facts using proper terminology and not dress up forecasts with subjective and/or emotive terms.
Reply
#76
I do my recycling bits etc but I also use my car and fly on holidays. I "support" the point JSO are making that things need to change but are happily hypocritical when it suits.

I'd suggest most people will change as the government implements changes and restrictions, they don't appear to be taking it seriously enough. This is where JSO should be the publics conscience and be targeting that ideally.

Calling them cunts etc is quite frankly, pathetic. There has to be some disruption for anyone to listen, I do though agree they shouldn't be stopping people getting to hospitals etc. and need to consider who and how they create the disruption required. Give it a couple of days and Josh will be agreeing with JSO and calling the aggressive wanker a cunt if the Huw Edwards thread is anything to go by.

The term "cunt" should be applied to the man who punched the protester to the floor and then kicked him/her in the head whilst on the ground. The bloke was going in the other direction and not even being held up by the protestors. He needs to be up in front of the beak pronto. I have to shake my head and look to the sky at the amount of people who are justifying these actions.

When you find yourself agreeing with GB News and the likes of Julia Hartley-Brewster then you need to reassess and change your opinion.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#77
(07-20-2023, 11:42 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: Education of the general public needs to improve drastically, not just by national and local government but also by the media, particularly newspapers. It's also beholden on us to seek answers to questions that we have relating to climate change and not just wait for info to be fed to us.

Meteorologists and weather presenters have a part to play too, for example by stopping calling temperatures a degree or two below average "disappointing" and not refer to temperatures between 16-20C as "chilly" (as I have heard said several times). They seem to feel they have a duty to reflect unnecessary and unhelpful expectations that it needs to be 30C in the shade for weeks before it can be properly regarded as summer.

The job of meteorologists is to report scientific facts using proper terminology and not dress up forecasts with subjective and/or emotive terms.

The weather forecasters are incredibly annoying for stating what they think is ‘good and bad’ weather.  Rain is now treated like a plague by some of the more populist news outlets.
Reply
#78
CA baggie… What do you mean by the government implementing restrictions? I think this is the detail people want to know. Actual impacts on their lives. What sort of restrictions?
Reply
#79
(07-20-2023, 11:42 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 11:36 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 11:17 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I find the whole “debate” with JSO, and other climate issues, incredibly oversimplified tbh.

What most people want to know, IMO, is if society needs to change to “save us from extinction”, what does this actually mean? Actual real world changes. Is stopping new oil going to increase our costs? Are there genuine viable alternatives? Is switching to electric cars going to price the poor out of driving? Are we going to have travel restricted in any way? People want to know real world impacts IMO. How it’ll actually affect their quality of life.

These are an example of the things that don’t get discussed much. It all seems to be you’re either for or against with no detail or cost benefit analysis.

And of course, there’s a high percentage of people who say “i support the cause” but they’re just paying lip service and don’t give it a second thought in reality, or certainly don’t take any steps to change anything. I mean neither do I, I love driving and holidays, but I don’t say “I support the cause” either. I want to know detail of actual effects to people’s lives before I claim to support stopping oil etc.

And I think there’s plenty of people like me. What’s the actual real world result of getting to net zero by 2040, 2050 etc etc? This is the key.

I agree we need far more information, I also agree that this subject makes hypocrites of us all. I can’t and won’t be giving up my car and for my families needs I can’t afford an electric vehicle. The problem is we won’t like the answers. There aren’t going to be for the immediate futures cheaper or better alternatives than what we have. Humans are selfish, stubborn and short term creatures and it will take something absolutely catastrophic to make us change our habits by then I suspect it’ll be way too late. The Leonardo DiCaprio film Don’t Look Up is a perfect example of where we are as a species.

TBF it doesn’t make hypocrites of everyone. Only those who preach but don’t practice are the hypocrites. If you say you don’t give a shit and act like you don’t give a shit you’re hardly a hypocrite.

But the key is we need detail. I refuse to say I support a cause of stopping oil, for example, when I genuinely don’t know if this would increase our costs, and I’ll never support anything that hammers the working classes.

Likewise with electric cars etc. I don’t support this transition if it prices ordinary people out of driving while the rich can carry on.

I was sent this a few weeks ago. It will certainly make everyone realise electric cars are certainly not the eco-friendly solution. Well worth the watch. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yiga3atlTRs
Reply
#80
(07-20-2023, 11:50 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: CA baggie… What do you mean by the government implementing restrictions? I think this is the detail people want to know. Actual impacts on their lives. What sort of restrictions?

I don't know, I'm happy to state I don't know enough about what's truly required.  But clearly some changes or restrictions to the way we currently live will have to be implemented as we can't continue as we are.

It may be something as simple as accepting that we can't have strawberries all year round as they grow in the summer!  Why are we importing them?  Why are we importing flowers from around the world?   We may have travel restrictions placed on us, such as air-miles per annum in order to cut air traffic.  

We will have to adapt.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 4 Guest(s)