Can interest rises work?
#81
After 13yrs of abject failure on nearly every area of governance Proth only resigned due to what almost every western country did to protect its people during a pandemic.
Reply
#82
(07-19-2023, 06:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: After 13yrs of abject failure on nearly every area of governance Proth only resigned due to what almost every western country did to protect its people during a pandemic.

The chilling effects of keeping kids off school are being felt in every country Dekka. I don't regard what happened here as "protecting" children, quite the opposite.
Reply
#83
(07-19-2023, 06:30 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-19-2023, 05:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: So? A one off £15bn cost could be spread out with various tax reforms, and I'd argue that there's plenty of potential for return for addressing the fallout of the disrupted education system from COVID through tax benefits from a better educated populace with better skills (especially when the skills in question are as basic as numeracy and literacy). Hardly a drastic amount that it's unable to be costed, the government have just put aside £20bn for SMRs for an experimental deployment after 2030 for Christ's sakes.

I don't agree it would end up as a one-off. I don't agree that it would be targeted well enough so that it wouldn't end up benefitting those who don't need the resource (same as Sure Start). I don't agree that £15bn is a sum that can be raised from tax when the pips were already squeaking and net receipts from increased rates are not keeping up with inflation. 

£15bn "hardly a drastic amount"? That's simply an opinion I don't share.

(07-19-2023, 05:46 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-19-2023, 05:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Rather it was spend shoring up paymasters through the VIP lane BB obvs

Well he opposes equalising income tax rates for pensioners with workers, even though that is costed to raise £11bn per annum and also has the moral benefit of the most protected group during COVID repaying society to cover that to mitigate the effect on children.

https://www.ft.com/content/22e4336e-2c3e...4536188f49

The FT again saying taxes need to go up to cover government expenditure. Those pesky big statists at the FT, Times and Bloomberg! How dare they state the obvious!

Who does? 

I've been calling for Pensioners to pay NI for a very long time. I just don't agree with your idea of folding NI into PAYE. Two very different things.

Absolute nonsense.

Kevan's plan was spelled out. There was no way it wouldn't have been a one off. 200,000 kids starting Year 7 with substandard literacy skills shouldn't need to be addressed every year. You don't need to make up 115 lost days of education every single year.

Any comparison with schemes like Sure Start is a disingenuous false equivalence because Sure Start a) didn't have a fixed, 3-year end date and b) didn't have a fixed, time-based objective that can be broken down with extra teaching hours.

£15bn is chump change for investment into addressing lost educational outcomes and reducing the economic fallout of a cohort of adults lacking basic skills. To say otherwise is to sing from the same stupid hymn sheet as George Osborne. Spread the cost over 3 years as proposed is £5bn per year, that's 4.3% of the education budget and the estimated education outcome shortfalls that you don't think are worth addressing are estimated to cost £100bn. I don't know how your maths skills are but spending £15bn to avoid £100bn of damage sounds like being fiscally sensible, to the tune of £85bn. Need I also bring up that on a per-capita basis it's merely in-line with what the US and Dutch governments have spent to catch up? And the Dutch and Americans had shorter school closures than we did during COVID, with educational outcomes impacted less as a result.

And I called for NI to be folded into income tax bands to enable pensioners and landlords to pay equivalent rates to workers, primarily so we can move away from a system that focuses the burden of tax on middle class workers because National Insurance is a regressive and illiberal tax compared with income tax. Do you want to know which Think Tank also backs abolishing NI and folding the rates into income tax? The Adam Smith Institute, that bastion of big state and high tax outlook.
Reply
#84
Your faith in the State and the population's ability to resist the temptation to demand more despite the cost is touching. As Milton Freidman once said "There's nothing more permanent than a temporary government program". And the problems in education go far beyond substandard literacy in Year 7. They're far more fundamental than that - like turning up to school in the first place.

And like I said, I have no problem with pensioners paying NI - at the very least if they're working. I have every problem with folding NI into Income Tax where it effects the return on long term, often debt funded investments into businesses or property - when the tax system has already eroded returns to the point of them being marginal. You do realise you'd kill the remaining individual BTL market at a stroke, don't you? And who'd benefit from that? Not tenants for a start.

As for channeling the ASI, I doubt you'd agree with their thoughts on NHS funding.
Reply
#85
Talking of NHS funding did Proth ever get the memo that the ‘largest ever’ funding funding figures included the PPE VIP lane payments?
Reply
#86
(07-19-2023, 07:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Your faith in the State and the population's ability to resist the temptation to demand more despite the cost is touching. As Milton Freidman once said "There's nothing more permanent than a temporary government program". And the problems in education go far beyond substandard literacy in Year 7. They're far more fundamental than that - like turning up to school in the first place.

And like I said, I have no problem with pensioners paying NI - at the very least if they're working. I have every problem with folding NI into Income Tax where it effects the return on long term, often debt funded investments into businesses or property  - when the tax system has already eroded returns to the point of them being marginal. You do realise you'd kill the remaining individual BTL market at a stroke, don't you? And who'd benefit from that? Not tenants for a start. 

As for channeling the ASI, I doubt you'd agree with their thoughts on NHS funding.

This has the square root of fuck all to do with or with not trusting the state. This is about a rational assessment of the long term economic and developmental impacts of children missing out on 115 days of education and wanting to address that. The plan was spelled out over a three year period to cover for that. The very principle of it is empirically sound, and the fiscal impact was projected (a conservative estimate) to save £85bn net. You are singing from the same hymn sheet as George Osborne and those under the effects of the disease known as Treasury Brain and look where that's landed us,

I will play my tiny violin for the landlords and being taxed on their economic rent. Tenants are getting fucked over with or without amateur landlords so I consider the impact to be between zero to negligible on that front, far greater issues namely forcing more people than necessary to be tenants and driving up the costs of rent. Frankly I consider that line of argument as stupid anyway as houses don't disappear, the capital asset value of the house doesn't erode, the incentive to pay income tax on lettings was already eroded by George Osborne's tax changes and amateur landlords aren't the only type of landlord.

As for NHS funding, good distraction. Considering my position on NHS funding is primarily due to the fact that there are bigger constraints on NHS resources than the funding model such as it being used as a social care outlet to cover the gaps in the system that is supposed to fix that, I consider all discussion of what you, the ASI and David Laws (who I agree with on all other things) to be entirely redundant to actually improving the current situation and not empirical. But I am open to looking into it when what's the actual problems with the healthcare system that are resulting in stagnated/worsened outcomes are fixed first, because ultimately the assessments the ASI for a mixed financing system and David Laws did on social insurance were made when the NHS wasn't a complete shitshow and the social care responsibilities weren't anywhere near as much a dragged anchor on the NHS as is the case today (also stuff like obesity and shifting from a reactive to preventative system to maximise efficiency of outcomes like Japan does, reform you see). Meanwhile, folding NI into income tax is empirical, as is reforming business rates and council tax to an LVT, reducing transactional taxes, broadening the VAT base to cover more items (ideally with a goal to reduce the VAT rate to ~13%), a negative-income tax to replace welfare provisions, upping tax thresholds in-line with inflation which are all ASI tax endorsements. There's other things I agree with them as well, like abolishing the green belt, introducing a Dutch-style planning system, NTB abolition through mutual recognition of standards to the maximum extent etc etc so your shitty gotcha on the NHS is kind of pointless.
Reply
#87
Good for you.

There is a bit of a liberal lurking in there after all. Though your faith in the state is still touching. Bless
Reply
#88
You are such a patronising twat
Reply
#89
Patronising? No  Wink Big Grin
Reply
#90
(07-19-2023, 09:33 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: You are such a patronising twat

You deserve it tbh. 

I was idealistic once too. I'm rational now.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 6 Guest(s)