Can interest rises work?
#71
(07-19-2023, 12:44 PM)baggy1 Wrote: And what about Furlough whilst a quick look at the BBL legislation shows me it was brought in April 2020 (wasn’t that before you resigned?)

Spare me the ‘you don’t care about the kids’ bullshit. The Tory party and your vision of a small state depleted the resources available for schools to operate in a safe environment for over a decade. The ignoring the reports about global pandemics and not preparing put us in a no win situation. The schools would have closed through lockdown or lack of teaching staff available through illness, either way we would find ourselves in the same position now. 

And pack in your revisionist view of Covid - it was a fucker and it killed thousands, there were very little options available because of Tory policy that you promoted in the decade and a half prior to it. Where was the care for the kids at that point?

What about furlough? Apart from it being the most egregious untargeted use of public funds for people to sit on their arses - many of whom continued to work anyway (or most in the case of SEISS). The schools being closed was the final straw.

The contract between parents and educational institutions was broken by Covid. In many areas school is now seen as a voluntary pursuit by kids and their parents. Losses to school rolls are in excess of 100,000. Kids were stabbed to death in the street during Lockdown when they should've been in school.

You can engage in whataboutery if you like, but the effects of excluding kids from school for months on end will be with us for generations. If you think it's fair game to attack me for highlighting that then fill your boots Dear.
Reply
#72
(07-19-2023, 12:28 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-19-2023, 09:59 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Furlough and BBLs were prior to you resigning so you did have the chance. You threw your toys out the pram when Proth juniors couldn’t get to school IIRC.

BBLs were not prior to me resigning.

What happened to education during Covid, and what has transpired since in attendance, attainment, behaviour and parental attitudes to education is nothing short of disastrous. If you consider that's "throwing my dollies out" then I suspect you don't have the same level of concern for the nations' kids as I have.

Then why were you opposed to a proposed initiative Sir Kevan Collins to bridge the education gap caused by COVID?
Reply
#73
@ Proth following 72: You miss my point - you said you resigned from the party because of Proth juniors not being able to attend school, i pointed out that both furlough and BBL happened before that and you carried on regardless paying your dues. You had plenty of opportunity to resign before.

I quote “ You have some very odd interpretations of my beliefs. I resigned from the Tory Party over its completely illiberal approach to lockdown. I wish I could have resigned again over the appalling spunking of cash in Furlough, BBLs, indiscriminate energy price support, its completely incompetent handling of fiscal policy and its meek acceptance or whatever crap Andrew Bailey spouts on any particular day.”

It’s the ‘I wish I could have resigned again…’ dramatics i refer to - BBL and furlough were prior to you resigning but you chose not to at the time.

And good use of the word “Dear’ , it’s always a sign that you are getting desparate
Reply
#74
What is it you fail to grasp about the term "the final straw"?

As for your semantics over dates - BBL's weren't launched for applications until May 2020, furlough was extended. The complete lack of integrity of both polices didn't become clear until much later. Given Sunak had already cancelled the Corporation Tax cut given as part recompense for cutting the Dividend Tax allowance I was already on the way out, not that I really owe you or anyone else much of an explanation. Dear.

(07-19-2023, 01:52 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Then why were you opposed to a proposed initiative Sir Kevan Collins to bridge the education gap caused by COVID?

£15bn
Reply
#75
Semantics over dates, surely that is words and not dates dear.

It must have come as a shock in 2020 that the Tory party were full of shit and would say anything to get your vote. If only there had been people warning of you of that for at least half a decade before. I am old enough to remember your joshing about Boris only being there to get a job done and how the Tory party would just realign and roll out the next front person. That seems such a long time ago.
Reply
#76
So? A one off £15bn cost could be spread out with various tax reforms, and I'd argue that there's plenty of potential for return for addressing the fallout of the disrupted education system from COVID through tax benefits from a better educated populace with better skills (especially when the skills in question are as basic as numeracy and literacy). Hardly a drastic amount that it's unable to be costed, the government have just put aside £20bn for SMRs for an experimental deployment after 2030 for Christ's sakes.
Reply
#77
Rather it was spend shoring up paymasters through the VIP lane BB obvs
Reply
#78
(07-19-2023, 05:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Rather it was spend shoring up paymasters through the VIP lane BB obvs

Well he opposes equalising income tax rates for pensioners with workers, even though that is costed to raise £11bn per annum and also has the moral benefit of the most protected group during COVID repaying society to cover that to mitigate the effect on children.

https://www.ft.com/content/22e4336e-2c3e...4536188f49

The FT again saying taxes need to go up to cover government expenditure. Those pesky big statists at the FT, Times and Bloomberg! How dare they state the obvious!
Reply
#79
Whilst you’re at it I’m not certain why after a decade of underfunding education and its ancillary services that it’s become impossible to get kids into schools.
Reply
#80
(07-19-2023, 05:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: So? A one off £15bn cost could be spread out with various tax reforms, and I'd argue that there's plenty of potential for return for addressing the fallout of the disrupted education system from COVID through tax benefits from a better educated populace with better skills (especially when the skills in question are as basic as numeracy and literacy). Hardly a drastic amount that it's unable to be costed, the government have just put aside £20bn for SMRs for an experimental deployment after 2030 for Christ's sakes.

I don't agree it would end up as a one-off. I don't agree that it would be targeted well enough so that it wouldn't end up benefitting those who don't need the resource (same as Sure Start). I don't agree that £15bn is a sum that can be raised from tax when the pips were already squeaking and net receipts from increased rates are not keeping up with inflation. 

£15bn "hardly a drastic amount"? That's simply an opinion I don't share.

(07-19-2023, 05:46 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(07-19-2023, 05:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Rather it was spend shoring up paymasters through the VIP lane BB obvs

Well he opposes equalising income tax rates for pensioners with workers, even though that is costed to raise £11bn per annum and also has the moral benefit of the most protected group during COVID repaying society to cover that to mitigate the effect on children.

https://www.ft.com/content/22e4336e-2c3e...4536188f49

The FT again saying taxes need to go up to cover government expenditure. Those pesky big statists at the FT, Times and Bloomberg! How dare they state the obvious!

Who does? 

I've been calling for Pensioners to pay NI for a very long time. I just don't agree with your idea of folding NI into PAYE. Two very different things.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 6 Guest(s)