Can interest rises work?
#11
Only is being used as an adjective to denote it as a singular instance (as in only child), there is no capacity for it to be used in any other context unless you decide to completely ignore the context of the subsequent section of the sentence - "and not in nominal terms". Yet again you've read what you have wanted to read instead of what was written.

As for your point about tax avoidance, so your objection is that some people who don't pay employee NICs currently will avoid an additional charge on income tax resulting in a net impact of zero, and ignoring that NIC exemptions from income are wider than the narrow purview you're implying (pensions, rent etc). Not really an argument against folding employee NICs into income tax, is it?
Reply
#12
All I read is you want ever more tax on ever more people despite the evidence suggesting that the tipping point on receipts has been breached. You're no fucking liberal, you're just a nasty little moneygrabbing statist.
Reply
#13
That tends to happen when instead of reading what has been put you instead opt to read what you want to read as a convenient means to build up a strawman to attack instead.

Do you genuinely believe your cakeism, or is it a coping mechanism to avoid admitting that being rigidly ideological is irrational? We have a deficit, fact. We need to eliminate that deficit. We do not have natural resources to cover spending gaps as we did in the 1980s and 1990s. Wage growth is stagnant and declining in real terms so the capacity to raise taxes from that is out the question. Economic growth is stagnant so increasing receipts via that isn't happening. We have an aging population with more people becoming economically inactive as well as burdening state spending on pensions and healthcare. The practicalities of cutting tax are out of the question as there's zero capacity to cost them into the budget. The scope for public sector cuts is zero owing to budgets being frozen outside of the NHS and the state pension and it being politically impossible to cut those two. What is more liberal, raising taxes to cover the operational government deficit as a means to tighten fiscal conditions or borrowing to cover it? I've mentioned abolishing employees NI and folding that income tax rates to ensure that income outside of that scope (like pensions) is included as means to close the gap but you had a tantrum over that. Do you want us to turn into Spain or something? Or do you want the government to dream up another millennial labour tax instead to cover it if we're on about who's a "moneygrabbing statist"?

As for the "tipping point": fuel duty cut, business rates relief, income tax rates (not thresholds, rates). Are you factoring in those changes to your hypothesis?
Reply
#14
You’re pissing in the wind. No one serious is calling for further tax increases, it’s both politically and economically unsustainable. We’re reaping the whirlwind for all those things you never complained about - all those bailouts and all those indiscriminate hand outs you called for. Good grief, you were even calling for hugely counter productive mortgage support recently - paid for by who, exactly?

15 years I’ve been harping on about this. Here we are, final destination. The short term pain we should have taken then has been compounded by Covid and war and leaves us with an unsustainable state. There are plenty of us who are saying no, no more. Cut your cloth like we have to cut ours.
Reply
#15
1. I don't really care about who is or isn't calling for further tax increases. Nobody "serious" is calling for the ending of the triple lock either. Fact is that you are advocating fiscal cakeism, you can't have tight fiscal conditions and simultaneously not want to address the operational deficit.

2. What things didn't I complain about? Low interest rates? I complained about them. The distorted tax burden? I complained about that. Lack of housebuilding? Definitely complained about that. Covid? Seem to recall complaining about the inept response to that. How we've dealt with the energy price rises? Oh have I complained about that.

3. What indiscriminate handouts did I support?

4. The mortgage support I supported wasn't indiscriminate, it was costed for and targeted to a narrow domain within the exceptional circumstances of the moron premium applied to the UK economy accelerating interest rate rises beyond the domain of economic correction. I also accept that now it wouldn't work because rates are too high to apply practical costings to and what was an additional premium has now been appli.

5. You can point to to Covid and the Ukrainian war but the fact is that other countries have been affected by those things yet as they don't have the longstanding economic frailties, poor management, a dismissive attitude to planning and an unwillingness to deal with inherent problems coupled with exacerbating those problems (like the economic effects of Brexit, or prioritising planning for leaving without a deal over the pandemic we were experiencing).

6. You are aware that I also live in this country, right? That I am also suffering under the consequences of a high tax burden, low productivity zombie government with zero imagination, right? You can, quite frankly, shove your hoity-toity exceptionalist attitude up your arse. The absolute gall of someone to support the political party that has ignored dealing with problems and act as though the consequences don't apply to other people is astounding.

The fact that you're blaming me for this mess really does sum this up.
Reply
#16
1. Sunday Papers suggest no one at all is calling for tax rises at all. All we need now is for them to start considering all that government does and to start reducing it. Wes Streeting is on the right lines.

2/3 I don't recall you complaining about the indiscriminate bank bailouts, nor endless QE, nor the Western World's most expensive exercise in paying people to stay at home, nor the ruinous Lockdowns.

4. Any entirely counter productive mortgage support to anyone is brainless beyond belief when it's generally accepted the institutions will do everything to avoid repossessions.

5. I largely agree.

6. In case it escaped your attention, I've not been a member nor voted for any political party for several years. However when I was a member I did help save you all from something much worse (several times) and no ever seems to want to thank me for that. You're welcome though, I forgive you. Though you're all on your own now.
Reply
#17
1. FT publishing interview with one of the UK's most respected economists calling for tax rises to both balance inflation alongside interest rate rises and balance government spending - today.

And quite frankly the Sunday papers a complete mess. The "most respected" Sunday Broadsheet is comparing Sunak and Starmer to animals and saying Starmer is losing the youth vote. They haven't the foggiest.

Balancing the deficit goes two ways, and the trope of "cutting spending" is dead in the water as the politically difficult choices will never be made and as a result they start cutting stupid shit like social care budgets or mental health budgets or council budgets or holding down public sector pay in spite of massive labour burdens and labour shortages in critical public sector roles. Tax rises need to be factored in, and the first means to do that is to flatten out the burden across age.

2. The banks bailout was 15 years ago, I was in school 15 years ago. What was I supposed to do? My economic exposure was working in my granddad's shop and helping him do his accounting. In hindsight bailing out RBS was stupid but that's balanced against what happened with Lloyds (probably over invested by about £6bn instead of encouraging to make that windfall up from the markets as Barclays did, and sold too quickly to maximise returns, ideally you do what Ireland did or what Sweden did in the early 1990s) and looking back I'd have preferred the BoE to operate as the "lender of last resort" which it is supposed to be to facilitate that but unfortunately Mervyn King opted to block that route.

QE is as a result of low interest rates as you have no fiscal headroom unless you start dipping into negative rates. Me criticising not raising interest rates sooner kind of already deals with that.

As for COVID, I was critical of political decisions that extended the necessary scope - namely a lack of planning in schools over the summer term to enable hybridisation as well as doing everything last minute instead of heading things off letting issues balloon, I am critical of the dereliction of duty for adequate auditing in key areas (PPE) considering they managed to audit other areas perfectly fine in spite of being subject the same challenges (energy), I was critical on wasting money on Covid Passports, I opposed the renewal of the Covid act for the third time and supported the Lib Dems in also opposing it, I was vehemently pro-vaccine as I wanted lockdowns to be over and that was the golden bullet to ensure that and  I was also critical of people making stupid personal choices like opting not to wear masks in spite of the empirical evidence showing that FPP2 masks lower the chance of exposure in-turn reducing the spread and reducing the risk of another lockdown being enforced. Do you honestly think that I, someone who would be paying taxes to cover the debt and wasn't statistically at risk of dying due to my age and lack of underlying health problems wanted lockdown?

4. And applying a political moron premium on the UK economy is generally accepted to be brainless yet it happened, though as I've said you can't cost that so I don't support it anymore.

6. Oh I'm so glad that you so vehemently upheld political decisions that have contributed to the floundering mess. How lucky we are as a country to be staring down the barrel of stagflation.
Reply
#18
It explains a lot if you were in school 15 years ago. In that case you haven't lived through a period where tough choices by households and governments had to be made, and actually were made without recourse to printing money or screaming for a bailout whenever any minor personal finance crisis reared its head.

The whole nation has been infantilised over the last 15 years. However P-Major & P-Minor are being brought up to understand that life is not fair.

I love that you're an idealist BB, but you're going to have a rude awakening over the next few years - the last 15 are probably about the best you'll have had in terms of earning and investing potential for some time.
Reply
#19
Patronising gump.

I was in school 15 years ago, I wasn't just born 15 years ago.

Also what earning potential? What investing potential? I can't even buy a house despite earning more than my parents did adjusted for inflation at the same age, and my savings to do that have been declining in real terms my entire adult life except for my pension which I can't invest as much as I want to in because I have bills to pay and need to save for a house that it looks like I might be able to afford when I'm 40. I've been perfectly sanguine as to the fact that my generation and the generation will be paying for the collective mistakes of your generation and the generation above yours unless we leave the country because there's fuck all we can do. Now excuse me while I pay a greater average tax rate than our esteemed Prime Minister to cover the mistakes of successive Tory governments.
Reply
#20
I repeat. If you were in school 15 years ago you have only been alive in an era government and households ducked serious issues.

You won't find me disagreeing about the mistakes of a political generation or three since 1990. I'm sorry you believe I'm patting you on the head when all I'm doing is stating a fact. Politically driven stagnation is not the same as the employment recessions and industrial restructuring I lived through as a child and a young adult. There has been nothing like the fallout over the last 30 years from any economic crisis including the GFC.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: