We're Fucked
#21
(06-15-2023, 09:40 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Quite clearly, you just don't get it.

The Eurozone is already in recession. The UK needs to go into recession to defeat core inflation.

If you believe that Brexit, rather than suppressed interest rates for far too long and tens of £billions of QE is to blame for the UK's core inflation problem then you're in a minority of about one right now. Over regulation? A lack of supply side measures (planning constraints in particular which again you appear to love)? The great resignation during and post Covid? Millions pretending to work from home? The crazy Stamp Duty Holiday?

None of this feeds into core inflation. Just Brexit.

Jesus fucking Christ.

Comprehension isn’t your thing then. I never said it was just Brexit, why do you Brexity types struggle with the idea that the decision to leave has exasperated and amplified our problems as a country, rather than say those critical of the decision to leave are blaming everything on it? You love a bit of nuance when it suits though Wink You were getting rather excited along with a few others a couple of years ago that spiralling wages in transport notably lorry drivers was a clear Brexit benefit 

I get the argument about creating a recession to tackle inflation however I have yet to see any large company, their management team, or those in the banking sector reduce their profits to help combat inflation. I have seen however Libertarian twats excuse them, argue for tax cuts and argue that a nurse, teacher, the disabled, soldier, doctor etc should stfu and take yet more of a hit to their real terms income

You say this is inevitable, it’s not it’s a decision by both the government and those business’s to disproportionately burden the less well off. For example one of the water monopolies sorry companies bosses has just been paid over £3m and for what? Dumping shite in the seas and rivers and failing to invest properly in infrastructure to reduce this for decades? Inflation is just something to bother the little people with, it seems.
Reply
#22
(06-15-2023, 11:19 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-15-2023, 09:40 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Quite clearly, you just don't get it.

The Eurozone is already in recession. The UK needs to go into recession to defeat core inflation.

If you believe that Brexit, rather than suppressed interest rates for far too long and tens of £billions of QE is to blame for the UK's core inflation problem then you're in a minority of about one right now. Over regulation? A lack of supply side measures (planning constraints in particular which again you appear to love)? The great resignation during and post Covid? Millions pretending to work from home? The crazy Stamp Duty Holiday?

None of this feeds into core inflation. Just Brexit.

Jesus fucking Christ.

Comprehension isn’t your thing then. I never said it was just Brexit, why do you Brexity types struggle with the idea that the decision to leave has exasperated and amplified our problems as a country, rather than say those critical of the decision to leave are blaming everything on it? You love a bit of nuance when it suits though Wink You were getting rather excited along with a few others a couple of years ago that spiralling wages in transport notably lorry drivers was a clear Brexit benefit 

Brexit is a contributory factor to inflation, I've never denied that. However the forces of 15 years of the loosest monetary policy in history is the prime cause (in the UK / EU & US) - as it always would be.

Average wages have been flat since 2008, I don't have any issue with anyone demanding more money now, but maybe doctors asking for 35% ought to reflect that most people's post tax income hasn't increased at all in 15 years. And they're asking those people to increase their pay by over a third.

Corporate pay at the upper level doesn't matter. It has zero effect on broader inflation. Other than the fact that you don't like some people being paid a lot of money I don't know why you keep bringing it up. However inflation creates union power and always does. The BoE & government ought to be bearing this in mind too.
Reply
#23
(06-15-2023, 11:49 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-15-2023, 11:19 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-15-2023, 09:40 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Quite clearly, you just don't get it.

The Eurozone is already in recession. The UK needs to go into recession to defeat core inflation.

If you believe that Brexit, rather than suppressed interest rates for far too long and tens of £billions of QE is to blame for the UK's core inflation problem then you're in a minority of about one right now. Over regulation? A lack of supply side measures (planning constraints in particular which again you appear to love)? The great resignation during and post Covid? Millions pretending to work from home? The crazy Stamp Duty Holiday?

None of this feeds into core inflation. Just Brexit.

Jesus fucking Christ.

Comprehension isn’t your thing then. I never said it was just Brexit, why do you Brexity types struggle with the idea that the decision to leave has exasperated and amplified our problems as a country, rather than say those critical of the decision to leave are blaming everything on it? You love a bit of nuance when it suits though Wink You were getting rather excited along with a few others a couple of years ago that spiralling wages in transport notably lorry drivers was a clear Brexit benefit 

Brexit is a contributory factor to inflation, I've never denied that. However the forces of 15 years of the loosest monetary policy in history is the prime cause (in the UK / EU & US) - as it always would be.

Average wages have been flat since 2008, I don't have any issue with anyone demanding more money now, but maybe doctors asking for 35% ought to reflect that most people's post tax income hasn't increased at all in 15 years. And they're asking those people to increase their pay by over a third.

Corporate pay at the upper level doesn't matter. It has zero effect on broader inflation. Other than the fact that you don't like some people being paid a lot of money I don't know why you keep bringing it up.

Real wages for junior doctors are down over 25% on 2008.

Basic maths. 100 * 0.74 = 74. 74 * 1.35 = 99.9. The 35% increase would put them on par with the wage stagnation experienced by the average UK citizen.
Reply
#24
(06-15-2023, 11:56 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Real wages for junior doctors are down over 25% on 2008.

Basic maths. 100 * 0.74 = 74. 74 * 1.35 = 99.9. The 35% increase would put them on par with the wage stagnation experienced by the average UK citizen.

Real wages for *everyone* are down on 2008.

The doctors are asking everyone to pay for their wage increase when they haven't had one themselves. That's my point.
Reply
#25
(06-15-2023, 11:57 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-15-2023, 11:56 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Real wages for junior doctors are down over 25% on 2008.

Basic maths. 100 * 0.74 = 74. 74 * 1.35 = 99.9. The 35% increase would put them on par with the wage stagnation experienced by the average UK citizen.

Real wages for *everyone* are down on 2008.

The doctors are asking everyone to pay for their wage increase when they haven't had one themselves. That's my point.

Your point is misleading, as demonstrated by the maths.

The "pay increase" junior doctors want is to put them to the real terms level experienced by the average UK worker, not above them.
Reply
#26
(06-15-2023, 11:49 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-15-2023, 11:19 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(06-15-2023, 09:40 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Quite clearly, you just don't get it.

The Eurozone is already in recession. The UK needs to go into recession to defeat core inflation.

If you believe that Brexit, rather than suppressed interest rates for far too long and tens of £billions of QE is to blame for the UK's core inflation problem then you're in a minority of about one right now. Over regulation? A lack of supply side measures (planning constraints in particular which again you appear to love)? The great resignation during and post Covid? Millions pretending to work from home? The crazy Stamp Duty Holiday?

None of this feeds into core inflation. Just Brexit.

Jesus fucking Christ.

Comprehension isn’t your thing then. I never said it was just Brexit, why do you Brexity types struggle with the idea that the decision to leave has exasperated and amplified our problems as a country, rather than say those critical of the decision to leave are blaming everything on it? You love a bit of nuance when it suits though Wink You were getting rather excited along with a few others a couple of years ago that spiralling wages in transport notably lorry drivers was a clear Brexit benefit 

Brexit is a contributory factor to inflation, I've never denied that. However the forces of 15 years of the loosest monetary policy in history is the prime cause (in the UK / EU & US) - as it always would be.

Average wages have been flat since 2008, I don't have any issue with anyone demanding more money now, but maybe doctors asking for 35% ought to reflect that most people's post tax income hasn't increased at all in 15 years. And they're asking those people to increase their pay by over a third.

Corporate pay at the upper level doesn't matter. It has zero effect on broader inflation. Other than the fact that you don't like some people being paid a lot of money I don't know why you keep bringing it up. However inflation creates union power and always does. The BoE & government ought to be bearing this in mind too.

You write union power as if it is abad thing.

I think there would be a lot of workers, particularly in the private sector, who would be enjoying a better standard of living if the unions had had more power in the last 20 to 30 years.

Wages for most people have stagnated over the last 20 years. But no matter they are the ones who will continue to make sacrifices to correct Govt economic incompetence.

Meanwhile in other news, businesses involved in the production and retail of luxury goods and services continue to do very well.
Reply
#27
(06-15-2023, 12:01 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The "pay increase" junior doctors want is to put them to the real terms level experienced by the average UK worker, not above them.

I don't think that's their argument at all. They're simply using the rise in the cost of living, and RPI at that.

(06-15-2023, 12:27 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: You write union power as if it is abad thing.

I think there would be a lot of workers, particularly in the private sector, who would be enjoying a better standard of living if the unions had had more power in the last 20 to 30 years.

Wages for most people have stagnated over the last 20 years. But no matter they are the ones who will continue to make sacrifices to correct Govt economic incompetence.

Meanwhile in other news, businesses involved in the production and retail of luxury goods and services continue to do very well.

Union power in itself isn't intrinsically a bad thing - union power is simply reflective of a very bad thing - inflation.

In times of low and stable inflation where have the unions been? Exactly.

It's the lower and middle classes who have continually paid the price for government incompetence forever. That's just a given I'm afraid.
Reply
#28
(06-15-2023, 02:40 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-15-2023, 12:01 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The "pay increase" junior doctors want is to put them to the real terms level experienced by the average UK worker, not above them.

I don't think that's their argument at all. They're simply using the rise in the cost of living, and RPI at that.

You would think wrong then, because that is literally how they got to the 35.3%. It wasn't plucked out of thin air. The BMA's literature spells it out:

"Pay awards for doctors have been below inflation since 2008. Our calculations show that pay awards for junior doctors in England from 2008/09 to 2021/22 have delivered a real terms (RPI) pay cut of 26.1% . To achieve pay restoration by reversing this cut, would require a 35.3% pay uplift."

RPI is the fairest means to examine the cut as this is relative to internally within the UK which is what RPI tracks. CPI is used to track relative trends external to the UK, predominantly other European countries. To not use RPI would be bad data practice purely from a statistical point of view.

Final point, reaching parity is the top end of the BMA's demands during negotiations. If the government were to offer 30% that would probably be accepted even though it leaves junior doctors worse off compared to the average UK worker over the same period (therefore accounting for the real term wage declines since January 2021).
Reply
#29
Haven’t you just confirmed what I posted?

They want a rise equivalent to cumulative RPI, I have no idea where you get this “average worker” bollocks from. The “average worker” has also seen a real terms cut in pay. And if you want to give junior doctors - some who’re already exceptionally well paid - another 30% where on Earth will that come from? Borrowing at 6%? Yet more taxation?

https://www.theguardian.com/business/202...-thinktank
Reply
#30
What I find interesting is this.

When the idea of tax increases on the wealthy or on corporations are mooted. The argument against is that these individuals/organisations will leave the country or cease the enterprise they are involved in.

The same principle can be applied, and is far more likely to be true of professionals such as doctors.

They have transferable, sought after skillsets. I heard that Australian health employers were recruiting junior doctors. at the picket line .

And if you were a junior doctor why wouldn't you, higher wages, plus I suspect (I don't know the rules on this exactly) by working abroad you would avoid repaying your student loan.

It would be interesting to see how many graduates have emigrated since the introduction of tuition fees.

And what impact this loss of intellectual infrastructure has on our economy.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: