Jimmy Shanbles
#11
He picked Bartley then made him captain. That's all I need to know. If that's not absolutely fucking clueless then somebody show me something that is.
Reply
#12
Playing 3/5 at the back is daft. To sacrifice a more mobile perhaps more creative midfielder to play Bartley will be the best thing Villa could hope for. Its the kind of managerial decision making that you know is just plain wrong. 442 fucking please
Reply
#13
Why is it clear they are never going to invest? More spent in summer 17 and Jan 18 than Peace ever spent, more recruitments in Jan 19 than Peace ever brought in for a Jan window.
Reply
#14
(05-06-2019, 06:57 AM)Stratfordbaggie Wrote: I know Shan has stumbled into the role and is trying his best but we currently look a shambles, forget results, those that have attended know we have looked poor, lack motivation, lack creativity and pace, now we look defensively frail and disorganised.

The 5 or 3 at the back make us weaker, we have little attacking flair out wide, Harper looks like a spoilt kid, Bartley a liability and our tactics look non existent.

The board or owner have cocked up big time here and not only left us with another year if not years out of the PL, it has also meant a potential mauling by Villa.

I really hope I am wrong, but the longer Shan has, the worse we are look8ng.

Sam J
Holgate
Hegazi
Dawson
Gibbs

Phillips
Brunt
Johanson
Livermore

JRod
Gayle

I can't believe someone who watches us is proposing we play 4 in midfield.
Reply
#15
(05-06-2019, 03:53 PM)Pontificator Wrote: Playing 3/5 at the back is daft. To sacrifice a more mobile perhaps more creative midfielder to play Bartley will be the best thing Villa could hope for. Its the kind of managerial decision making that you know is just plain wrong. 442 fucking please

Why 442, we don't have the midfielders for 442,or the wide players, if we do that can guarantee JRod and Gayle will barely see the ball.
Reply
#16
So the 5 at the back is working, let us wait and see.

Bartley looks awful, we get overrun in midfield too. Villa’s youthful midfield must be licking their lips.
Reply
#17
(05-06-2019, 08:35 AM)billybassett Wrote: You can't blame Shan at all. He has been put in a position that anyone of us would have accepted and not done badly. The players are culpable for a lot many like yesterday strolling round with minimal effort and I hope hrk never puts on a baggies shirt again.
The problem is there's only one way out of the whole mess and that's promotion. My feeling is it is unlikely not because of the talent we have but because of the lack of desire and mental fortitude.

And this is the problem we have players here who go missing for large parts on the season at crucial times and others who really couldn't be bothered and put the bare min of effort in hence the reason we got relegated in the first place and then we expect the same said players to get us out of the mess of their making we should have got rid of all of the Old school(except Brunt as even with his faults he seems the only one who genuinely gives a toss) and started again, but would have taken money and patience neither of which Lai seems blessed with. We are now possibly going to suffer long term for the boards incompetence and also the unthinkable and horrifying prospect of being dumped out of the play offs by Vile and have to hear those fisheatingarrogantdeludedsealclaret&blue wankers gloating forever more, I just hope Brunt & Mozza let the rest of them know exactly what these next 2 games mean to us fans and get them wound up enough to put 2 proper performances in the next 2 or 3 games as I'm convinced if we perform close to our best we will have to much for Vile and whoever in the final COYB
Reply
#18
(05-06-2019, 03:56 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-06-2019, 03:53 PM)Pontificator Wrote: Playing 3/5 at the back is daft. To sacrifice a more mobile perhaps more creative midfielder to play Bartley will be the best thing Villa could hope for. Its the kind of managerial decision making that you know is just plain wrong. 442 fucking please

Why 442, we don't have the midfielders for 442,or the wide players, if we do that can guarantee JRod and Gayle will barely see the ball.
But we have the same midfielders playing with 3 in the middle. All season we've been lightweight in midfield, all season we've been outnumbered there.  Put 4 in there with Holgate and Gibbs pushing/overlapping. Who needs 3 fucking centre backs? Most teams only have one striker, get some bodies bossing the halfway line and Gayle and JRod will do the rest.
Reply
#19
We've had good/terrible performances with both formations. We've played three at the back recently so may as well go for that.
Reply
#20
(05-06-2019, 06:57 AM)Stratfordbaggie Wrote: I know Shan has stumbled into the role and is trying his best but we currently look a shambles, forget results, those that have attended know we have looked poor, lack motivation, lack creativity and pace, now we look defensively frail and disorganised.

The 5 or 3 at the back make us weaker, we have little attacking flair out wide, Harper looks like a spoilt kid, Bartley a liability and our tactics look non existent.

The board or owner have cocked up big time here and not only left us with another year if not years out of the PL, it has also meant a potential mauling by Villa.

I really hope I am wrong, but the longer Shan has, the worse we are look8ng.

Sam J
Holgate
Hegazi
Dawson
Gibbs

Phillips
Brunt
Johanson
Livermore

JRod
Gayle

(05-06-2019, 04:24 PM)Artist Wrote: We've had good/terrible performances with both formations. We've played three at the back recently so may as well go for that.

I think there is no doubt, Shan cannot change his formation now, the only question appears to be which midfield 3?

Johanson, Brunt ........then either Harper, Phillips or Livermore
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: