Coventry
#21
(05-17-2023, 09:39 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-17-2023, 09:34 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote:
(05-17-2023, 09:01 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Coventry Vs Luton is the best this league can do. Fuck me what a state.

Fair play to both clubs but that these two teams have made the final illustrates how weak the division has become.

Look at the sides in the play-offs in 2019. A very strong Leeds with Bielsa in charge, Villa with Grealish, McGinn, Abraham, Mings et al and Albion with Gayle, J-Rod, Dawson, Hegazi, Murphy, Brunt, Morrison, Philips, Gibbs.

This year Sunderland and Boro were both poor in the play-offs, the second legs in particular. If you didn't know how much was at stake tonight you could be mistaken for thinking Boro were playing a pre-season friendly.

I'd counter this with the fact that over the last few years, good coaching has overtaken player ability a lot, see Brighton as an example, most of those players wouldn't get into a squad trying for Europe. Their 'Keeper was a laughing stock at a Championship club a few years ago.

Get players in who can do what the coach needs them to, and you can do well. We do still have a decent squad for our level, FFS, we have Wallace and Swift, two of the players generally accepted as the best at this level, Carlos has shown how much more important coaching them well is.

There was a great comment on the City v Madrid Comms tonight saying just this. Whilst Real can rely on a team of eleven brilliant players to produce moments of world class quality, they can't handle it when faced with a team performance of the quality that City put in. Granted both sides have all the resources in the world but the point stands. Becomes even more important when you've not got a pot to piss in, get the most out of what you've got. Something we've not done for the best part of a decade.
Reply
#22
(05-17-2023, 09:39 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(05-17-2023, 09:34 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote:
(05-17-2023, 09:01 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Coventry Vs Luton is the best this league can do. Fuck me what a state.

Fair play to both clubs but that these two teams have made the final illustrates how weak the division has become.

Look at the sides in the play-offs in 2019. A very strong Leeds with Bielsa in charge, Villa with Grealish, McGinn, Abraham, Mings et al and Albion with Gayle, J-Rod, Dawson, Hegazi, Murphy, Brunt, Morrison, Philips, Gibbs.

This year Sunderland and Boro were both poor in the play-offs, the second legs in particular. If you didn't know how much was at stake tonight you could be mistaken for thinking Boro were playing a pre-season friendly.

I'd counter this with the fact that over the last few years, good coaching has overtaken player ability a lot, see Brighton as an example, most of those players wouldn't get into a squad trying for Europe. Their 'Keeper was a laughing stock at a Championship club a few years ago.

Get players in who can do what the coach needs them to, and you can do well. We do still have a decent squad for our level, FFS, we have Wallace and Swift, two of the players generally accepted as the best at this level, Carlos has shown how much more important coaching them well is.

I'm not saying different

The fact the league is weaker of course works in our favour. We've got a handful of quality players for this level (where there is generally a death of quality), a quality manager and contrary to the doom-mongers on here we will do well next season.

Good coaching is seeing better results in large part because this division is weaker. Regardless of how well Coventry and Luton are set-up, neither would have been near the play-offs 3-4 seasons ago.
Reply
#23
I don't buy the league being weaker argument at all.

Mostly because it's a metric that can't be physically measured, every, single, season, we've been in this league has been the weakest Championship yet. However the numbers don't bear this out, promoted teams do better when promoted than ever before (Premier League era) so I really don't agree. What has changed is clubs down at this level don't want to spend vast sums of dead money in transfer fees, instead preferring to develop their own with a few good free transfers and loans from top clubs.

I certainly don't see it as weaker at all, the football is immeasurably better than when we were first promoted, and let's be honest, we were damn lucky the last time we were promoted, literally relying on Brentford bottling it, I'd say it was weaker that season truth be told.
Reply
#24
To just add another touch to this.

I, as I have said a few times, know people in the game professionally. The general prevalent attitude is that ALL levels of English football are actually improving, League 1, is considered similar in player ability and development scale to the Champ a few seasons ago, why seeing Plymouth, Ipswich and Sheffield Wednesday dominate so much this season is so impressive. Teams generally defend far better than ever before, and in the professional game, that's how they judge the team's ability, far more than its goal-scoring ability over the course of a season. We've seen defences this season far better than we've seen in the past, not helped that we've become so blunt in attack as injuries hit us.

Coaching is more important than ever as players have got better, because academies and youth coaching is so much better, as one of my pro friends said to me, any player in a Cat 1 academy has the raw ability to make it as a pro, they are not there otherwise, all these players filter down the leagues depending on attitude and luck. If anything, now is the time to start trying to find young, developing players in the lower leagues, with good coaching, a lot can make it to very high levels.
Reply
#25
Middlesbrough only won 2 of their last 10 games. The wheels well and truly fell off at the wrong time for them.
Reply
#26
(05-17-2023, 10:30 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I don't buy the league being weaker argument at all.

Mostly because it's a metric that can't be physically measured, every, single, season, we've been in this league has been the weakest Championship yet. However the numbers don't bear this out, promoted teams do better when promoted than ever before (Premier League era) so I really don't agree. What has changed is clubs down at this level don't want to spend vast sums of dead money in transfer fees, instead preferring to develop their own with a few good free transfers and loans from top clubs.

I certainly don't see it as weaker at all, the football is immeasurably better than when we were first promoted, and let's be honest, we were damn lucky the last time we were promoted, literally relying on Brentford bottling it, I'd say it was weaker that season truth be told.

I think it's weaker Birdy but what has happened is the gap has closed throughout the division

Over the years there have been some real stand out sides who you knew would go up and make an impression, then you had the bottom half of the championship who were considerably weaker. I don't see that this season, anybody beats anybody in this division and personally I don't think Burnley were "all that" and certainly Sheff Utd were pretty average really, I think the top 6 are weaker than ever but 7th - 20th have improved massively over recent seasons, just look at us to see that, with all our shortfalls we've managed to take the play offs to the final day

I agree we'll be "OK" next season, CC will wheel and deal, some loans, some free's maybe a few to move on we've just got to hope those Chinese fuckers don't interefere anymore than they already have and CC gets the little bit of backing he needs

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#27
(05-17-2023, 11:26 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(05-17-2023, 10:30 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I don't buy the league being weaker argument at all.

Mostly because it's a metric that can't be physically measured, every, single, season, we've been in this league has been the weakest Championship yet. However the numbers don't bear this out, promoted teams do better when promoted than ever before (Premier League era) so I really don't agree. What has changed is clubs down at this level don't want to spend vast sums of dead money in transfer fees, instead preferring to develop their own with a few good free transfers and loans from top clubs.

I certainly don't see it as weaker at all, the football is immeasurably better than when we were first promoted, and let's be honest, we were damn lucky the last time we were promoted, literally relying on Brentford bottling it, I'd say it was weaker that season truth be told.

I think it's weaker Birdy but what has happened is the gap has closed throughout the division

Over the years there have been some real stand out sides who you knew would go up and make an impression, then you had the bottom half of the championship who were considerably weaker. I don't see that this season, anybody beats anybody in this division and personally I don't think Burnley were "all that" and certainly Sheff Utd were pretty average really, I think the top 6 are weaker than ever but 7th - 20th have improved massively over recent seasons, just look at us to see that, with all our shortfalls we've managed to take the play offs to the final day

I agree we'll be "OK" next season, CC will wheel and deal, some loans, some free's maybe a few to move on we've just got to hope those Chinese fuckers don't interefere anymore than they already have and CC gets the little bit of backing he needs

Cuzer

I’m not sure I agree 7th-20th have improved Cuzer, I think the division has suffered hugely through Covid and squads have significantly weakened. Whilst there are still some very talented players at this level, most teams in this division are now padding their squad out with youth players which has acted as a real leveller.

You also can’t deny the impact of the winter World Cup this season. Squads have been stretched with 2 games a week pretty much every week since September which has led to more injuries than is normal. Every team seems to be riddled with injuries and this has meant most sides have struggled with consistency. It’s no real shock for me that Cov and Luton, two of the younger, fitter and dare I say “hungrier” squads have come through this season so well.

There have also been a couple of Kamikazi relegation sides thrown into the mix. Many of the sides relegated over the last couple of years have made some bizarre decisions, and squandered their parachute cash. When teams have come down with a plan and investment - Burnley, Fulham etc - they have absolutely pissed the division in a way fewer sides have recently.

The last 2 years have been massive missed opportunities for us IMO. We’ve had arguably the 2 weakest overall championship campaigns since the ITV digital crash and we’ve had a massive financial advantage which we’ve squandered with little to show for it.

(05-17-2023, 10:40 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Middlesbrough only won 2 of their last 10 games. The wheels well and truly fell off at the wrong time for them.

Playoffs are an absolute bastard, you really do want to approach them in form.

Boro took their foot off the gas and made too many changes in the final 3-4 games knowing their playoff spot was confirmed and lost all momentum.
Reply
#28
(05-18-2023, 06:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-17-2023, 11:26 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(05-17-2023, 10:30 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I don't buy the league being weaker argument at all.

Mostly because it's a metric that can't be physically measured, every, single, season, we've been in this league has been the weakest Championship yet. However the numbers don't bear this out, promoted teams do better when promoted than ever before (Premier League era) so I really don't agree. What has changed is clubs down at this level don't want to spend vast sums of dead money in transfer fees, instead preferring to develop their own with a few good free transfers and loans from top clubs.

I certainly don't see it as weaker at all, the football is immeasurably better than when we were first promoted, and let's be honest, we were damn lucky the last time we were promoted, literally relying on Brentford bottling it, I'd say it was weaker that season truth be told.

I think it's weaker Birdy but what has happened is the gap has closed throughout the division

Over the years there have been some real stand out sides who you knew would go up and make an impression, then you had the bottom half of the championship who were considerably weaker. I don't see that this season, anybody beats anybody in this division and personally I don't think Burnley were "all that" and certainly Sheff Utd were pretty average really, I think the top 6 are weaker than ever but 7th - 20th have improved massively over recent seasons, just look at us to see that, with all our shortfalls we've managed to take the play offs to the final day

I agree we'll be "OK" next season, CC will wheel and deal, some loans, some free's maybe a few to move on we've just got to hope those Chinese fuckers don't interefere anymore than they already have and CC gets the little bit of backing he needs

Cuzer

I’m not sure I agree 7th-20th have improved Cuzer, I think the division has suffered hugely through Covid and squads have significantly weakened. Whilst there are still some very talented players at this level, most teams in this division are now padding their squad out with youth players which has acted as a real leveller.

You also can’t deny the impact of the winter World Cup this season. Squads have been stretched with 2 games a week pretty much every week since September which has led to more injuries than is normal. Every team seems to be riddled with injuries and this has meant most sides have struggled with consistency. It’s no real shock for me that Cov and Luton, two of the younger, fitter and dare I say “hungrier” squads have come through this season so well.

There have also been a couple of Kamikazi relegation sides thrown into the mix. Many of the sides relegated over the last couple of years have made some bizarre decisions, and squandered their parachute cash. When teams have come down with a plan and investment - Burnley, Fulham etc - they have absolutely pissed the division in a way fewer sides have recently.

The last 2 years have been massive missed opportunities for us IMO. We’ve had arguably the 2 weakest overall championship campaigns since the ITV digital crash and we’ve had a massive financial advantage which we’ve squandered with little to show for it.

(05-17-2023, 10:40 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Middlesbrough only won 2 of their last 10 games. The wheels well and truly fell off at the wrong time for them.

Playoffs are an absolute bastard, you really do want to approach them in form.

Boro took their foot off the gas and made too many changes in the final 3-4 games knowing their playoff spot was confirmed and lost all momentum.

Yep.  It tends to be the teams that out a run together and just make the playoffs that get promoted.  I guess the pressure isn’t as great on these teams than those who just missed out on automatic promotion.
Reply
#29
After the Man city game I switched over to the Cov game.
They could be in the same league next year....
Tough one to call, that!
Reply
#30
It'll be massive for either club to get their hands on all that dosh.

It will build Luton's new stadium and fund their sqaud for the next 3 seasons.

Cov might be able to get their stadium back too.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: