USP
#1
What is the USP for the Lib Dems?

Or rather, what makes them materially different these days from Labour under the likes of Starmer, Reeves and Streeting?
Reply
#2
LVT-based business rate reform instead of wanting to just cut it.

Wanting proportional representation.

Community land auctions through 1961 Land Compensation Act reform.

Wanting income tax and national insurance bands to rise with inflation.

Wanting to use a stabilised trade relationship with the EU and EFTA as a means to join the single market instead of having the stabilised relationship be the new norm as Labour want.

A digital bill of rights and actually opposing legislation that erodes civil liberties as shown in the Covert Human Intelligence Sources (Criminal Conduct) Bill vote.
Reply
#3
Thank you BB.

Is there anything in there the majority of Labour MPs after the next election would fundamentally disagree with do you think?

The reason I ask, is that #LeastWorst is well and truly up for grabs right now. I don't think Labour is going to get over the line on their own - so what leverage do the Lib Dems have? I expect that after last time there ought to be some actual red lines for a coalition. I expect it's a commitment on PR rather than a referendum?
Reply
#4
Oo, oo I know this one, it gives the less swivel eyed Tory inclined voter the opportunity to vote for an alternative and feel better about themselves given the state of the country.

I always thought it would be a hung Parliament because we have a sizeable degree of whoppers who would vote Tory no matter what but given the hardening of the polls over the last couple of weeks, the mess the economy will likely still be in and tactical voting I think Labour will just about do it.
Reply
#5
PR is the big one, though the Labour membership back it Labour's position as the de-factor party of the left makes it unattractive to MPs. There's probably some leeway in that, the Lib Dems support STV and the pro-PR Labour like mixed-member systems like MMP in Scotland or AV+ but the Lib Dems will be a lot harder on it after fucking up massively on that in 2010, also Johnson's own goal of setting the recent precedent for changing the voting system without a referendum for his mayoral vote change.

There will probably be some resistance to joining the EFTA and civil liberties protections from the Labour frontbench but don't think the majority of Labour MPs will oppose it and people like Chris Bryant will likely agree with it.

There will probably be pushback on EFTA by Labour but I doubt that will be a priority for the Lib Dems to push in the next parliament, likely a platform for 2029 and beyond, as the immediate priority is stabilising the relationship with the EU and EFTA through addressing the stupid red tape between the UK and single market members from the Brexit fall out.

Nothing I'm seeing or hearing is saying anything other than a Labour majority though. FPTP merged with the fact that the Lib Dems and Labour are competing for like 5 seats nationally against one another benefits that outcome. Unless you think the Greens are going to screw things up?
Reply
#6
Labour will get over the line. Rishis failure to hit even the meekest of self imposed “targets” will be the last straw for many waiverers. What substantial demographic other than relatively wealthy pensioners are realistically left on side?
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#7
(05-12-2023, 03:15 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: PR is the big one, though the Labour membership back it Labour's position as the de-factor party of the left makes it unattractive to MPs. There's probably some leeway in that, the Lib Dems support STV and the pro-PR Labour like mixed-member systems like MMP in Scotland or AV+ but the Lib Dems will be a lot harder on it after fucking up massively on that in 2010, also Johnson's own goal of setting the recent precedent for changing the voting system without a referendum for his mayoral vote change.

There will probably be some resistance to joining the EFTA and civil liberties protections from the Labour frontbench but don't think the majority of Labour MPs will oppose it and people like Chris Bryant will likely agree with it.

There will probably be pushback on EFTA by Labour but I doubt that will be a priority for the Lib Dems to push in the next parliament, likely a platform for 2029 and beyond, as the immediate priority is stabilising the relationship with the EU and EFTA through addressing the stupid red tape between the UK and single market members from the Brexit fall out.

Nothing I'm seeing or hearing is saying anything other than a Labour majority though. FPTP merged with the fact that the Lib Dems and Labour are competing for like 5 seats nationally against one another benefits that outcome. Unless you think the Greens are going to screw things up?

Starmer won't get an overall majority based on the local election results, and although the polls show a wider lead I'd expect it to narrow barring another Tory cataclysm.
Reply
#8
Even the relatively wealthy pensioners will have lost faith after Boris promised them a lifetime care cap that was quietly withdrawn and the prospect that the age of retirement will be moved to 68 for anyone born after 1970 as soon as any election takes place.

Having said that Labour are not jumping into any of the bear traps that the Tories are planting everywhere which is a sensible approach but they will have to come out fighting after the next conference with a set of policies to stand on. All the Tories are doing is trying to bait them - Greg Hands; daily post of the letter saying there is no money left, 30p Lee playing the tough maverick fighting for the people role, Braverman doing everything apart from wearing the blackshirt that comes with her talk and whichever loon is sent out to repeat the promise of reducing inflation without explaining all that means is that things will be even more expensive.

It's shocking we have got here at all but if the Tories get even 25% of the vote next year will mean that the games gone Tom.

(05-12-2023, 05:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Starmer won't get an overall majority based on the local election results, and although the polls show a wider lead I'd expect it to narrow barring another Tory cataclysm.

Local election results that didn't include the inner cities, give me a break.
Reply
#9
(05-12-2023, 05:11 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Even the relatively wealthy pensioners will have lost faith after Boris promised them a lifetime care cap that was quietly withdrawn and the prospect that the age of retirement will be moved to 68 for anyone born after 1970 as soon as any election takes place.

Having said that Labour are not jumping into any of the bear traps that the Tories are planting everywhere which is a sensible approach but they will have to come out fighting after the next conference with a set of policies to stand on. All the Tories are doing is trying to bait them - Greg Hands; daily post of the letter saying there is no money left, 30p Lee playing the tough maverick fighting for the people role, Braverman doing everything apart from wearing the blackshirt that comes with her talk and whichever loon is sent out to repeat the promise of reducing inflation without explaining all that means is that things will be even more expensive.

It's shocking we have got here at all but if the Tories get even 25% of the vote next year will mean that the games gone Tom.

(05-12-2023, 05:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Starmer won't get an overall majority based on the local election results, and although the polls show a wider lead I'd expect it to narrow barring another Tory cataclysm.

Local election results that didn't include the inner cities, give me a break.

Labour doesn't need to pile up any more vote in the inner cities though.
Reply
#10
Be a massive surprise if the Conservatives get less than 30% of the vote at the next GE.

I don't believe there is a precedence for them getting below that  in any GE since the war (and possibly before it)

Fully expect Labour to be the biggest party at the next GE, but it will be touch and go if they win a majority. 

The opinion polls suggest they will, the council election results suggest they won't. 

If there is a hung parliament, then I fervently hope that the Lib Dems will insist that fptp is ditched and a or system is introduced, before they join any coalition.

Knowing the Lib dems they will finda way to screw this opportunity up.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)