Grant
#61
(05-10-2023, 04:58 PM)Huggybear Wrote:
(05-10-2023, 03:08 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(05-10-2023, 03:02 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I’ve never had a problem with players who come to our club either on a free or a small fee and are low risk.What I do have a problem with are players like Grant who have come on astronomical fees and wages and have given nothing to the club but have taken a lot from the club.
    Grant would probably be in my top five hated players and on reflection one of the worst value for money players we have ever had.No speed,no energy and a poor touch with a I don’t care body language.

What relevance has money got to do with it? Ultimately he has no influence on the transfer fee he has commanded. That was between us and Huddersfield. Yes, he may have a bigger wage than some of our players, but I'm pretty sure he'd play the same if he was on £10k a week or £100k a week.

I agree he can’t control his transfer fee but when I see supporters having a go at players who have contributed to previous promotions and also contributed in the Premier League then I don’t get it.What has Grant contributed to our club?

24 goals in 98 games, so roughly a goal every four games.

Not earth shattering, but hardly "worst thing to ever happen to the club" material either.

When the dust settles and we come back to look on this period, the decisions made and the individuals who have led us to ruin Karlan Grant will be petty low down the list of people to blame.
Reply
#62
(05-10-2023, 05:16 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(05-10-2023, 04:58 PM)Huggybear Wrote:
(05-10-2023, 03:08 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(05-10-2023, 03:02 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I’ve never had a problem with players who come to our club either on a free or a small fee and are low risk.What I do have a problem with are players like Grant who have come on astronomical fees and wages and have given nothing to the club but have taken a lot from the club.
    Grant would probably be in my top five hated players and on reflection one of the worst value for money players we have ever had.No speed,no energy and a poor touch with a I don’t care body language.

What relevance has money got to do with it? Ultimately he has no influence on the transfer fee he has commanded. That was between us and Huddersfield. Yes, he may have a bigger wage than some of our players, but I'm pretty sure he'd play the same if he was on £10k a week or £100k a week.

I agree he can’t control his transfer fee but when I see supporters having a go at players who have contributed to previous promotions and also contributed in the Premier League then I don’t get it.What has Grant contributed to our club?

24 goals in 98 games, so roughly a goal every four games.

Not earth shattering, but hardly "worst thing to ever happen to the club" material either.

When the dust settles and we come back to look on this period, the decisions made and the individuals who have led us to ruin Karlan Grant will be petty low down the list of people to blame.

And those figures are skewed by this season. As per above last year he got 18 goals when playing out of position (arguably). I think that's a more than reasonable contribution for a side pushing for promotion.
Reply
#63
(05-10-2023, 02:09 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(05-10-2023, 11:30 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote: Another player who has been made a scapegoat, and when he plays well (as he has done since being reintroduced) he still gets called a cunt and useless.

I'm not saying he's the answer, but he's no where near as bad as some of you lot are making out.

If we can't move him on (I do think it's time) then if he gets a run on the wide left, then he could be an important player next season.

You and me both see a good player there.
But so many "fans" hate him, he has to go, I guess.
If he gets another championship club he'll score plenty, likely against us.
Then we'll get "why didn't he do that for us"".
He scored about 1 in 3 appearances apparently.

He's such a strange player. I personally don't get the hate towards him but then I rarely do with any player. I don't see a player that hides necessarily but he could certainly up his effort at times I feel. He's 100% not a number 9 and I think the lad would be the first to admit that. When he plays on the left he's more dangerous but he's not a brave player. Both in the physical and footballing sense. I'd love to see him go at players more and commit them and for me he is guilty of taking the easy option too often.

Onto the conundrum. Hes scored 45 goals in 149 Championship games for Huddersfield and Us. That ain't bad.

I think if we can cover our remaining costs by flogging him and freeing up wages then I think it's time we shipped him out. It feels as though most fans have written him off now. We need to find a number 9 from Europe or wherever (Piroe only cost swans £1m!) and then it takes the pressure off BTA who I personally feel has the work rate, attitude and courage to play yhat wide left role that Grant will vacate.
Reply
#64
Any chance we could sign Morgan Rogers from Man City? He has 12m remaining deal on his city deal
Reply
#65
(05-10-2023, 08:00 PM)Super-Okay Wrote: Any chance we could sign Morgan Rogers from Man City? He has 12m remaining deal on his city deal

Blackpool were relegated, that might be our level!
Reply
#66
I've nothing against Grant but he's a player we could afford to lose and receive a reasonable fee for, while getting a high wage off the books. If someone like Rangers were to come in and offer £2m with potential add-ons then it has to happen.
Reply
#67
(05-10-2023, 08:05 PM)BradleyFromTheHalfWayLine Wrote: I've nothing against Grant but he's a player we could afford to lose and receive a reasonable fee for, while getting a high wage off the books. If someone like Rangers were to come in and offer £2m with potential add-ons then it has to happen.

I think in that scenario we might be obliged to settle the remaining fee to Hudds. Not sure if we have to pay off Grant's contract either?
Reply
#68
If he goes the only saving will be his salary. I assume any fee will be paid in installments. Certainly no funds will go into our transfer kitty. I think I'd rather keep him. Are we going to be able to sign a free or loan player who scored more goals then Grant over the last few seasons. That's a nope.
If he does go surely we must let Clearly have a run.
Reply
#69
(05-10-2023, 08:20 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: If he goes the only saving will be his salary. I assume any fee will be paid in installments. Certainly no funds will go into our transfer kitty. I think I'd rather keep him. Are we going to be able to sign a free or loan player who scored more goals then Grant over the last few seasons. That's a nope.
If he does go surely we must let Clearly have a run.

I disagree. We absolutely could sign a free who will contribute far more than this absolute waster.

We still owe £7.5m for him despite signing him 3 years ago. He's the worst player relative to a transfer fee that this club has ever bought.
Reply
#70
(05-11-2023, 11:50 AM)Moore Than Wrote:
(05-10-2023, 08:20 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: If he goes the only saving will be his salary. I assume any fee will be paid in installments. Certainly no funds will go into our transfer kitty. I think I'd rather keep him. Are we going to be able to sign a free or loan player who scored more goals then Grant over the last few seasons. That's a nope.
If he does go surely we must let Clearly have a run.

I disagree. We absolutely could sign a free who will contribute far more than this absolute waster.

We still owe £7.5m for him despite signing him 3 years ago. He's the worst player relative to a transfer fee that this club has ever bought.

Oli Burke wants a word.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: