Posts: 8,000
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(05-09-2023, 12:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (05-09-2023, 11:16 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (05-09-2023, 10:30 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Football fans are brilliant.
Criticising one of the most creative players in this league over the last few seasons for not 'running about enough' and not 'standing in space' without any understanding of a - how difficult it is and b - the tactical nuances of the role he's being asked to play by the best coach we've had for about five seasons.
It's going to be a really long summer if this shit continues.
You saying he is beyond criticism Ted?
Not many that are not recognising his contribution, just think he could / should contribute more. Surely, in any walk of life, improving ones shortcomings is a positive?
Factoring in all tactical nuances, there are 2 truly "shit" ways of viewing him IMO.
1) He is rubbish
2) He gives everything and could not do more.
That's because neither are true and I imagine pre-season will see one of the best coaches we have had for 5 seasons challenging him to improve certain aspects of his game. Which I'm sure Swift will relish.
"Run more" and "stand in space" are not valid critiques of any professional footballer. When you simplify it, then maybe, but in reality both are valid.
Running with intent would probably be more appropriate when levelled at Swift, especially when balls come in from the right, He doesn't gamble enough IMO. Same with tracking back, which he does, so it's not about maintaining his position, he just does it a bit half-heartedly, with no real effort to regain possession. This criticism could be levelled at most forward players to be fair.
As for standing in space, well I agree that is ridiculous, but finding space and gambling on making a run, he could certainly improve. He's almost like a quarterback, whereby, he stops to admire his work rather than looking to get involved in the next phase.
As I said before I'm sure Swift is aware of these things and am absolutely certain that Carlos is, so would hope to see improvement in both areas after a full pre-season. If so we will have a very good player on our hands.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
I think everything has to be put in context. Swift isn't Pereira, but if we got rid of him surely no one believes that we'd likely replace him with better
Posts: 8,000
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(05-09-2023, 02:04 PM)Sliced Wrote: I think everything has to be put in context. Swift isn't Pereira, but if we got rid of him surely no one believes that we'd likely replace him with better
That's exactly the point though. Don't want him to be replaced, just want him to be better.
Stats wise he has had a decent season but no-one can tell me he has fulfilled his potential. With a full Carlos pre-season, and the right application, he could smash this league.
Posts: 527
Threads: 0
Joined: Dec 2020
Reputation:
4
(05-09-2023, 11:38 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (05-09-2023, 10:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-09-2023, 10:26 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (05-09-2023, 10:06 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Swift has quality about him. It's easy to become a spacegoat, you can easily see the evidence to prove your prejudice if that's what you're looking for.
Pereira was not known for his work-rate, he disappeared for long periods, sometimes several games. But with the rosy glow of hindsight, we see how he was the thing that made the Bilic team of strollers function properly on their good days.
I think Swift suffers from the lack of industry elsewhere in our midfield. Molumby gets criticised for being a "headless chicken", but Okay is extremely static, especially since being kicked up in the air against Millwall. To me he looks much older than his alleged 29 years- and don't forget how little he played since leaving us 2 years ago. Imagine Bryan Robson, Len Cantello, Andy Johnson or Youssouf Mulumbu in our midfield rushing around and crashing into tackles. Swift wouldn't look such a luxury then. And I can't imagine any of those four thinking a back-pass from the centre circle to the goalie was the best option.
Swift should only go if it's a financial necessity IMO.
Swift also suffers from our lack of strikers getting into the sort of positions that he can exploit with his incisive passing. Imagine a Phillips or Taylor-type striker and their positioning. Even Charlie Austin (who even now I suspect would have put away a decent number of the gilt-edged chances that we missed this season).
He couldn't do that 3 years ago for us 
He wasn’t being fed by the same level of golden chances we’ve missed this year. Even Andy Carroll might have bagged 15 for us this year!
We don’t create nearly as many chances for our strikers as people think we do and Charlie Austin wouldn’t have been on the end of any of them either because he can barely move anymore, which is why he’s playing in League Two.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(05-09-2023, 03:20 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (05-09-2023, 02:04 PM)Sliced Wrote: I think everything has to be put in context. Swift isn't Pereira, but if we got rid of him surely no one believes that we'd likely replace him with better
That's exactly the point though. Don't want him to be replaced, just want him to be better.
Stats wise he has had a decent season but no-one can tell me he has fulfilled his potential. With a full Carlos pre-season, and the right application, he could smash this league.
The pisser yesterday was he had a very rare foray into the box when we attacked down the right wing and guffed an easy side foot from 6 yards out.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(05-09-2023, 03:54 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: (05-09-2023, 11:38 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (05-09-2023, 10:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-09-2023, 10:26 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (05-09-2023, 10:06 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Swift has quality about him. It's easy to become a spacegoat, you can easily see the evidence to prove your prejudice if that's what you're looking for.
Pereira was not known for his work-rate, he disappeared for long periods, sometimes several games. But with the rosy glow of hindsight, we see how he was the thing that made the Bilic team of strollers function properly on their good days.
I think Swift suffers from the lack of industry elsewhere in our midfield. Molumby gets criticised for being a "headless chicken", but Okay is extremely static, especially since being kicked up in the air against Millwall. To me he looks much older than his alleged 29 years- and don't forget how little he played since leaving us 2 years ago. Imagine Bryan Robson, Len Cantello, Andy Johnson or Youssouf Mulumbu in our midfield rushing around and crashing into tackles. Swift wouldn't look such a luxury then. And I can't imagine any of those four thinking a back-pass from the centre circle to the goalie was the best option.
Swift should only go if it's a financial necessity IMO.
Swift also suffers from our lack of strikers getting into the sort of positions that he can exploit with his incisive passing. Imagine a Phillips or Taylor-type striker and their positioning. Even Charlie Austin (who even now I suspect would have put away a decent number of the gilt-edged chances that we missed this season).
He couldn't do that 3 years ago for us 
He wasn’t being fed by the same level of golden chances we’ve missed this year. Even Andy Carroll might have bagged 15 for us this year!
We don’t create nearly as many chances for our strikers as people think we do and Charlie Austin wouldn’t have been on the end of any of them either because he can barely move anymore, which is why he’s playing in League Two.
Agree - we've created better quality chances than we did under Val, but that's down to having some actual quality in the final third as oppose to Adam Reach, however to think this side is creating better chances than we did with Diangana, Pereira, Krov and a much fitter Phillips? Nah
Posts: 3,390
Threads: 218
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(05-09-2023, 01:17 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: (05-08-2023, 11:17 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Just doesn’t work hard enough, why he never made it at Chelsea and why he’s now here
Yes, I’d cash in too if possible, plenty better out there
Cuzer
Plenty better? Such as?
Odegaard. Way above anything Swift does.
You asked for better, I gave you better
Posts: 7,972
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Swift has been adequate overall. His overall stats are decent but he still has exactly the same issues he had last July
Fitness is poor and he hasn’t shed the weight he had on day 1 here
Doesn’t work enough out of possession
Doesn’t get on the ball enough in open play
Doesn’t attack the penalty spot enough - given we play 1 striker and 2 wingers
/ the attributes of Wallace
He’s a good player in a poor Champo team - just as he showed at Reading. If he did a few of the above - he would be a good player in a top 6 Champo side.
Posts: 289
Threads: 27
Joined: Apr 2023
Reputation:
0
(05-09-2023, 05:57 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Swift has been adequate overall. His overall stats are decent but he still has exactly the same issues he had last July
Fitness is poor and he hasn’t shed the weight he had on day 1 here
Doesn’t work enough out of possession
Doesn’t get on the ball enough in open play
Doesn’t attack the penalty spot enough - given we play 1 striker and 2 wingers
/ the attributes of Wallace
He’s a good player in a poor Champo team - just as he showed at Reading. If he did a few of the above - he would be a good player in a top 6 Champo side.
I just wonder if CC continues to play with a 4-2-3-1 whether he see Swift in a deeper role with a more dynamic No.10
Posts: 7,972
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(05-09-2023, 06:04 PM)Super-Okay Wrote: (05-09-2023, 05:57 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Swift has been adequate overall. His overall stats are decent but he still has exactly the same issues he had last July
Fitness is poor and he hasn’t shed the weight he had on day 1 here
Doesn’t work enough out of possession
Doesn’t get on the ball enough in open play
Doesn’t attack the penalty spot enough - given we play 1 striker and 2 wingers
/ the attributes of Wallace
He’s a good player in a poor Champo team - just as he showed at Reading. If he did a few of the above - he would be a good player in a top 6 Champo side.
I just wonder if CC continues to play with a 4-2-3-1 whether he see Swift in a deeper role with a more dynamic No.10
I would be surprised. He doesn’t do enough out of possession for a number 4 or 8.
We need to find another inexpensive Dorrans - just like we did 15 years back
|