Erling Haaland
#51
Haaland is a bit special football wise to say the least, however he does come across as an entitled cunt.

It's impossible to compare players from different generations, and nowadays does just feel like most money wins and so does detract from a player's achievements, rightly or wrongly.
Reply
#52
(05-04-2023, 11:54 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Haaland is a bit special football wise to say the least, however he does come across as an entitled cunt.

It's impossible to compare players from different generations, and nowadays does just feel like most money wins and so does detract from a player's achievements, rightly or wrongly.

Really? Well, I guess to an extent most mega rich young footballers do. Haaland always seems like a good laugh to me.
Reply
#53
(05-04-2023, 09:34 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:12 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 09:06 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:53 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 08:42 AM)Duffers Wrote: As I've said further up though City have had elite players before and the environment you mention has existed for a while. Yet nobody in that environment has achieved what Haaland has this season.

It's not "fawning" to acknowledge that he's simply a different class to what has come before him.

And I have. Look at the very start of the thread- I think he is going to be one of the greatest of all time. He is phenomenal, but he is also in a team that has world stars galore around him. 
His record though surely isn't as impressive as Dixie Dean's on for want of a better term was in a time when those muddy pitches saw teams on a level playing field.
It's not just the quality of his co-stars either, it's the quality of the opposition.
Frank Bruno would have been the greatest champion of all time if he'd only fought lightweiights. That's the equivalent for me, it's such an uneven playing field that it's a bit embarrassing to laud any record attained by these clubs.

Thank the lord for you on this Bob.

It's like lauding Westlife as one of the greatest modern bands of all time.

By my calculations they must be nearly twice as good as Oasis as they had 14 number ones and Oasis only 8.

Surely you can't argue with the facts!

You know selecting circumstantial opinions from people who agree with you isn’t facts?

Haaland has scored 35 goals in 31 games in a City team with 87 goals 
Dean scored 60 in 42 in an Everton side that scored 102

Based on the above, one could argue that Everton’s style, or perhaps the tactics of football over 100 years ago better suited Dean given he was responsible for almost 60% of their goals, vs Haaland being about 40%

A quick look at the 1927/28 season’s top goal scorers shows TWENTY players in that division managed 20  or more goals. Dean scored almost double the next highest scorer with 35, suggesting that individual players scored more goals back then, but looking at 3-4 seasons either side of Dean’s record breaking season, generally the top scorers hit between 35-40 suggesting his season really was an emphatic performance.

Whilst Dean did consistently score goals for Everton for nearly 10 years, he didn’t get anywhere near 60 again, and his number reverted to the 30-40 amounts the top strikers in the league tended to hit. Suggesting 1927/28 was a purple patch.

Looking at other PL strikers this season, there’s a similar gap of about 30% between Haaland’s numbers and the next ranked striker to what Dean managed suggesting Haaland and he were about level for this season vs the 1927/28 one.

Moving forward, I expect Haaland will get better as the years go by, and will end the comparisons, but both were clearly very good strikers and it’s not really worth trying to say who is better as it’s ultimately impossible.

And let’s drop the “could he do it in a team like Burnley” nonsense, he could.

Bravo statistical shizzle SW4Baggie, SausEgg likes this.
Reply
#54
Who is he?
Reply
#55
(05-04-2023, 12:39 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 11:54 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Haaland is a bit special football wise to say the least, however he does come across as an entitled cunt.

It's impossible to compare players from different generations, and nowadays does just feel like most money wins and so does detract from a player's achievements, rightly or wrongly.

Really? Well, I guess to an extent most mega rich young footballers do. Haaland always seems like a good laugh to me.

Same. I guess at worst you could say he's a bit eccentric? Definitely doesn't come across entitled though.
Reply
#56
(05-04-2023, 01:05 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 12:39 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 11:54 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Haaland is a bit special football wise to say the least, however he does come across as an entitled cunt.

It's impossible to compare players from different generations, and nowadays does just feel like most money wins and so does detract from a player's achievements, rightly or wrongly.

Really? Well, I guess to an extent most mega rich young footballers do. Haaland always seems like a good laugh to me.

Same. I guess at worst you could say he's a bit eccentric? Definitely doesn't come across entitled though.
 Haaland the entitled cunt! Don't think so.

 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NlyMOd08gEE
Reply
#57
(05-04-2023, 01:11 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 01:05 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 12:39 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 11:54 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Haaland is a bit special football wise to say the least, however he does come across as an entitled cunt.

It's impossible to compare players from different generations, and nowadays does just feel like most money wins and so does detract from a player's achievements, rightly or wrongly.

Really? Well, I guess to an extent most mega rich young footballers do. Haaland always seems like a good laugh to me.

Same. I guess at worst you could say he's a bit eccentric? Definitely doesn't come across entitled though.
 Haaland the entitled cunt! Don't think so.

 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NlyMOd08gEE

Nice. Kinda confirms what I thought about the lad. An almost nothing interaction, but in comparison to his team mates, it was a point of difference. And you can see the kitman appreciates it.
Reply
#58
(05-04-2023, 10:36 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Simply Haaland has been acknowledged by all on this thread as an incredible talent. However, it has morphed slightly into a dig at modern day football where the modern day game allows the stronger teams to have more of the money, which leads to better players, which leads to domination of the ball, which leads to more of the chances, which leads to more goals, which has all lead to a chasm.

It is a chasm that means Haaland looks even better than he is and adds to the cult of celebrity surrounding the game now.

For those of us old enough to recall per prem days of course the game wasn't as advanced due to poorer pitches, players not knowing about how to maximise their strengths through training and diet. However, it was great when Albion, Ipswich, Forest, Watford could actually have a fair contest v other teams. I think we all still enjoyed the competitiveness rather than the procession where we know who will win.

I’m not going to get all tit for tat with you, but I think you need to read the thread Big Grin 

My argument is with what I’ve highlighted here. I disagree entirely that the fact Haaland playing for Man City makes him look better than he is. Haaland has had to adapt his game massively this season, and if he just wanted to be a bag merchant, he could have gone to a different side that would have built their entire side around creating chances for him. Yes, Man City create a lot of chances and score a lot of goals, but he makes up a relatively low percentage of them. I’d imagine if you look at the likes of Shearer at Newcastle, the whole side was built on him scoring their goals, as was similar players like Yorke, van Nistlerooy when they posted 30 goal seasons. The closest I would say to Haaland right now was that one season Suarez had under Rodgers hitting 30-something in a team that scored over a hundred.

I’d also add that going back to a time when football was more even, the tactics suited strikers far more. Yes I agree resourced were spread more evenly, but that doesn’t mean top players didn’t face top players still, it just meant that they played for different clubs. The quality of player hasn’t massively changed relatively, just how much they’re paid and their freedom to move to clubs other than those with the deepest pockets.
Reply
#59
Not going to believe he’s any good until he’s scored a hat trick on a cold wet winter Wednesday night in Stoke
Reply
#60
(05-04-2023, 04:54 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(05-04-2023, 10:36 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Simply Haaland has been acknowledged by all on this thread as an incredible talent. However, it has morphed slightly into a dig at modern day football where the modern day game allows the stronger teams to have more of the money, which leads to better players, which leads to domination of the ball, which leads to more of the chances, which leads to more goals, which has all lead to a chasm.

It is a chasm that means Haaland looks even better than he is and adds to the cult of celebrity surrounding the game now.

For those of us old enough to recall per prem days of course the game wasn't as advanced due to poorer pitches, players not knowing about how to maximise their strengths through training and diet. However, it was great when Albion, Ipswich, Forest, Watford could actually have a fair contest v other teams. I think we all still enjoyed the competitiveness rather than the procession where we know who will win.

I’m not going to get all tit for tat with you, but I think you need to read the thread Big Grin 

My argument is with what I’ve highlighted here. I disagree entirely that the fact Haaland playing for Man City makes him look better than he is. Haaland has had to adapt his game massively this season, and if he just wanted to be a bag merchant, he could have gone to a different side that would have built their entire side around creating chances for him. Yes, Man City create a lot of chances and score a lot of goals, but he makes up a relatively low percentage of them. I’d imagine if you look at the likes of Shearer at Newcastle, the whole side was built on him scoring their goals, as was similar players like Yorke, van Nistlerooy when they posted 30 goal seasons. The closest I would say to Haaland right now was that one season Suarez had under Rodgers hitting 30-something in a team that scored over a hundred.

I’d also add that going back to a time when football was more even, the tactics suited strikers far more. Yes I agree resourced were spread more evenly, but that doesn’t mean top players didn’t face top players still, it just meant that they played for different clubs. The quality of player hasn’t massively changed relatively, just how much they’re paid and their freedom to move to clubs other than those with the deepest pockets.

Still can’t find anything anywhere about him not doing it for Burnley.
Jokes apart SW4 you can’t beat a well reasoned argument and you’ve presented some good facts.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)