Posts: 12,682
Threads: 1,158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
15
(04-10-2023, 09:08 PM)KRO Wrote: (04-10-2023, 09:02 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-10-2023, 08:55 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (04-10-2023, 08:43 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Barnsley were Millwall and Luton then they quickly went to shit as did Huddersfield you can get lucky / ride a wave of good form for a while with no money but it soon finds you out. I like the optimism of some about ‘you just need a good manager in this division’ but that’s not really the case.
Barnsley and Hudds were one season wonders Dekka, to compare them to Millwall and Luton a little disrespectful.
Millwall have been steadily improving year on year under Rowett and have finally added that bit of quality in Flemming that’s seen them compete for a top 6 spot. Similarly Luton have improved every season for the best part of a decade under their current board and have been punching significantly above their weight and spending power for a vast number of those years.
Don’t think it’s true to say you can’t overachieve through being run in a manner that maximises every ounce of your ability and resources and through having a good coach. It’s a constant uphill battle, and there’s no guarantee of success but with the number of basket case clubs there’s always the opportunity for a well run club getting more right than wrong to sneak into the top 6 without deep pockets.
We don’t have an interested owner, our scouting system is crap, we have no long term plan and I’m not in the CC is a genius camp, decent maybe. This added to the lack of cash has reset my ambition / expectation for the club at Blues levels of achievement at best.
Bloody cheek! If you smash open you're piggy bank you've probably got more money than us. Furthermore, you have interested parties willing to take you on as the club and invest. We have a diminutive Chinese bloke, who's a front for a consortium, mortgaging us to the hilt to pay for several failing Chinese businesses, I wish I was at Blues level that someone might be interested in buying or investing in us.
Posts: 3,884
Threads: 161
Joined: Mar 2022
We are in the shit .....some still dont get what's going to happen to us .
Many of you work in office jobs who are lretty clever with numbers etc ....look at wba balance sheet you should be shaking in your boots and having sleepless nights whats going to happen to us in 18 months.
Head in the sand most on here no club nothing to support .
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(04-11-2023, 01:50 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: We are in the shit .....some still dont get what's going to happen to us .
Many of you work in office jobs who are lretty clever with numbers etc ....look at wba balance sheet you should be shaking in your boots and having sleepless nights whats going to happen to us in 18 months.
Head in the sand most on here no club nothing to support .
I can read a balance sheet perfectly well after 35 years as a director of regulated financial services companies.
My reading is that we have a healthy balance sheet, one of the healthiest in the Championship. We have no discernible debt. Even the £20m that we borrowed from MSD has barely been touched yet.
Our immediate solvency risk is cash flow. and the £20m loan from MSD bought time where that’s concerned. Without it, we would probably have run out of cash flow before next season is over.
As was made clear in the auditors report, there is an expectation that we will need to sell players to balance the books. We already know that about £7m is going to drop off the wage bill. Depending on who we manage to sell, and how many players we sell, we may also be able to “pay off” several other players to leave (those on big wages who we are unlikely to be able to easily offload). We simply don’t know how successful that process will be. As the auditors point out, there is uncertainty that we will be able to offload enough, hence the going concern qualification.
My personal belief is that Yunyai will look to sell as soon as it’s clear that we will not be getting promoted this season. That is not mathematically certain yet. Indeed, had we taken the expected 6 points from the Rotherham and QPR games we would now be 5th with a game in hand. Easy to see why Yunyai haven’t pushed the sale button yet, but I think it will be imminent, and I think the MSD loan was taken solely to buy time.
Even if we are sold this summer, it seems probably that any sensible buyer will also insist on cutting the wage bill, unless it’s a buyer with very deep pockets. I just don’t see Yunyai letting this run any longer, but of course they can’t control which or how many buyers are out there, so the longer it drags on, the bigger the potential problem.
But we remain a very attractive buy to the right sort of buyer - because we have no debt. We won’t be cheap - because of that lack of debt. I could see a deal at around the £50-£60m mark, maybe £40m in a years time. I am pretty certain that we are close to D-Day with Yunyai in terms of crystallising their large loss. Getting £60m now has to be better than £40m in a years time, and the odds against promotion without a big cash injection - which won’t come from Yunyai - are very high.
For that reason I don’t think administration is at all likely, but if no sake of the club has happened this time next year then we have had to jettison a lot of the players that we really need to keep.
Events of the next two months I think could be very interesting indeed.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(04-11-2023, 02:49 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (04-11-2023, 01:50 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: We are in the shit .....some still dont get what's going to happen to us .
Many of you work in office jobs who are lretty clever with numbers etc ....look at wba balance sheet you should be shaking in your boots and having sleepless nights whats going to happen to us in 18 months.
Head in the sand most on here no club nothing to support .
I can read a balance sheet perfectly well after 35 years as a director of regulated financial services companies.
My reading is that we have a healthy balance sheet, one of the healthiest in the Championship. We have no discernible debt. Even the £20m that we borrowed from MSD has barely been touched yet.
Our immediate solvency risk is cash flow. and the £20m loan from MSD bought time where that’s concerned. Without it, we would probably have run out of cash flow before next season is over.
As was made clear in the auditors report, there is an expectation that we will need to sell players to balance the books. We already know that about £7m is going to drop off the wage bill. Depending on who we manage to sell, and how many players we sell, we may also be able to “pay off” several other players to leave (those on big wages who we are unlikely to be able to easily offload). We simply don’t know how successful that process will be. As the auditors point out, there is uncertainty that we will be able to offload enough, hence the going concern qualification.
My personal belief is that Yunyai will look to sell as soon as it’s clear that we will not be getting promoted this season. That is not mathematically certain yet. Indeed, had we taken the expected 6 points from the Rotherham and QPR games we would now be 5th with a game in hand. Easy to see why Yunyai haven’t pushed the sale button yet, but I think it will be imminent, and I think the MSD loan was taken solely to buy time.
Even if we are sold this summer, it seems probably that any sensible buyer will also insist on cutting the wage bill, unless it’s a buyer with very deep pockets. I just don’t see Yunyai letting this run any longer, but of course they can’t control which or how many buyers are out there, so the longer it drags on, the bigger the potential problem.
But we remain a very attractive buy to the right sort of buyer - because we have no debt. We won’t be cheap - because of that lack of debt. I could see a deal at around the £50-£60m mark, maybe £40m in a years time. I am pretty certain that we are close to D-Day with Yunyai in terms of crystallising their large loss. Getting £60m now has to be better than £40m in a years time, and the odds against promotion without a big cash injection - which won’t come from Yunyai - are very high.
For that reason I don’t think administration is at all likely, but if no sake of the club has happened this time next year then we have had to jettison a lot of the players that we really need to keep.
Events of the next two months I think could be very interesting indeed.
+1 - well said Prag.
The whole lack of a sale thus far has been down to a balance of Yunyai not wanting to lose face with investors or the business community, and through a belief we were still well positioned to win promotion. Next season is the first time we will not be odds on to finish in the top 6 going into a season and there has to be acceptance upstairs that cutting their losses now is the the “easiest” exit.
Our owners have tried to take what cash they can from the club, and have succeeded in small amounts but the A4A campaign has brought sufficient scrutiny for them to be unable to do it much further, especially with the duties of care and responsibility to act within a business’s best interest rules that you’ve rightly highlighted before.
The longer Yunyai stay, the messier it gets for all parties, and with very few of our current players likely to generate big fees there’s only so many ways Yunyai can exploit the club. There won’t be any big profits next season or the year after to generate dividends/further external loans.
Taking out a deal with MSD at the likely rate of interest is kicking the can further down the road and hoping they can exit before shit gets real. The big threat is that if they’re desperate to exit we could end i with any manner of nut jobs next, and for all their fault our balance sheet has remained healthy and the club has remained relatively stable and sustainable, who knows what comes next.
Not sure what the current sanctions are between China and the US, as given the strong dollar and the view from many US investors that the PL is hugely undervalued vs US sports (an MLS club costs more than an average PL club) I imagine any likely buyer will be from there, but unsure how easy a deal will be to do in current conditions.
Posts: 3,488
Threads: 101
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(04-10-2023, 08:43 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Barnsley were Millwall and Luton then they quickly went to shit as did Huddersfield you can get lucky / ride a wave of good form for a while with no money but it soon finds you out. I like the optimism of some about ‘you just need a good manager in this division’ but that’s not really the case.
Agreed, we are in much more trouble than a decent coach can fix esp. as we won't be given much in the way of tools to do a good job here.
Posts: 1,674
Threads: 93
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(04-11-2023, 02:49 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (04-11-2023, 01:50 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: We are in the shit .....some still dont get what's going to happen to us .
Many of you work in office jobs who are lretty clever with numbers etc ....look at wba balance sheet you should be shaking in your boots and having sleepless nights whats going to happen to us in 18 months.
Head in the sand most on here no club nothing to support .
I can read a balance sheet perfectly well after 35 years as a director of regulated financial services companies.
My reading is that we have a healthy balance sheet, one of the healthiest in the Championship. We have no discernible debt. Even the £20m that we borrowed from MSD has barely been touched yet.
Our immediate solvency risk is cash flow. and the £20m loan from MSD bought time where that’s concerned. Without it, we would probably have run out of cash flow before next season is over.
As was made clear in the auditors report, there is an expectation that we will need to sell players to balance the books. We already know that about £7m is going to drop off the wage bill. Depending on who we manage to sell, and how many players we sell, we may also be able to “pay off” several other players to leave (those on big wages who we are unlikely to be able to easily offload). We simply don’t know how successful that process will be. As the auditors point out, there is uncertainty that we will be able to offload enough, hence the going concern qualification.
My personal belief is that Yunyai will look to sell as soon as it’s clear that we will not be getting promoted this season. That is not mathematically certain yet. Indeed, had we taken the expected 6 points from the Rotherham and QPR games we would now be 5th with a game in hand. Easy to see why Yunyai haven’t pushed the sale button yet, but I think it will be imminent, and I think the MSD loan was taken solely to buy time.
Even if we are sold this summer, it seems probably that any sensible buyer will also insist on cutting the wage bill, unless it’s a buyer with very deep pockets. I just don’t see Yunyai letting this run any longer, but of course they can’t control which or how many buyers are out there, so the longer it drags on, the bigger the potential problem.
But we remain a very attractive buy to the right sort of buyer - because we have no debt. We won’t be cheap - because of that lack of debt. I could see a deal at around the £50-£60m mark, maybe £40m in a years time. I am pretty certain that we are close to D-Day with Yunyai in terms of crystallising their large loss. Getting £60m now has to be better than £40m in a years time, and the odds against promotion without a big cash injection - which won’t come from Yunyai - are very high.
For that reason I don’t think administration is at all likely, but if no sake of the club has happened this time next year then we have had to jettison a lot of the players that we really need to keep.
Events of the next two months I think could be very interesting indeed.
Thanks for that it makes sense to me
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(04-11-2023, 07:36 AM)Cornflake Wrote: (04-11-2023, 02:49 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (04-11-2023, 01:50 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: We are in the shit .....some still dont get what's going to happen to us .
Many of you work in office jobs who are lretty clever with numbers etc ....look at wba balance sheet you should be shaking in your boots and having sleepless nights whats going to happen to us in 18 months.
Head in the sand most on here no club nothing to support .
I can read a balance sheet perfectly well after 35 years as a director of regulated financial services companies.
My reading is that we have a healthy balance sheet, one of the healthiest in the Championship. We have no discernible debt. Even the £20m that we borrowed from MSD has barely been touched yet.
Our immediate solvency risk is cash flow. and the £20m loan from MSD bought time where that’s concerned. Without it, we would probably have run out of cash flow before next season is over.
As was made clear in the auditors report, there is an expectation that we will need to sell players to balance the books. We already know that about £7m is going to drop off the wage bill. Depending on who we manage to sell, and how many players we sell, we may also be able to “pay off” several other players to leave (those on big wages who we are unlikely to be able to easily offload). We simply don’t know how successful that process will be. As the auditors point out, there is uncertainty that we will be able to offload enough, hence the going concern qualification.
My personal belief is that Yunyai will look to sell as soon as it’s clear that we will not be getting promoted this season. That is not mathematically certain yet. Indeed, had we taken the expected 6 points from the Rotherham and QPR games we would now be 5th with a game in hand. Easy to see why Yunyai haven’t pushed the sale button yet, but I think it will be imminent, and I think the MSD loan was taken solely to buy time.
Even if we are sold this summer, it seems probably that any sensible buyer will also insist on cutting the wage bill, unless it’s a buyer with very deep pockets. I just don’t see Yunyai letting this run any longer, but of course they can’t control which or how many buyers are out there, so the longer it drags on, the bigger the potential problem.
But we remain a very attractive buy to the right sort of buyer - because we have no debt. We won’t be cheap - because of that lack of debt. I could see a deal at around the £50-£60m mark, maybe £40m in a years time. I am pretty certain that we are close to D-Day with Yunyai in terms of crystallising their large loss. Getting £60m now has to be better than £40m in a years time, and the odds against promotion without a big cash injection - which won’t come from Yunyai - are very high.
For that reason I don’t think administration is at all likely, but if no sake of the club has happened this time next year then we have had to jettison a lot of the players that we really need to keep.
Events of the next two months I think could be very interesting indeed.
Thanks for that it makes sense to me Thanks Prag a post which I can understand, not big into finances and the overall accounts so I can relate to your post Prag.
We all know the next few months will be critical to our club but thank you a sensible post. Which a lot of posters can relate to.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
04-11-2023, 09:02 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-11-2023, 09:09 AM by Spandaubaggie.)
(04-11-2023, 02:49 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: (04-11-2023, 01:50 AM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote: We are in the shit .....some still dont get what's going to happen to us .
Many of you work in office jobs who are lretty clever with numbers etc ....look at wba balance sheet you should be shaking in your boots and having sleepless nights whats going to happen to us in 18 months.
Head in the sand most on here no club nothing to support .
I can read a balance sheet perfectly well after 35 years as a director of regulated financial services companies.
My reading is that we have a healthy balance sheet, one of the healthiest in the Championship. We have no discernible debt. Even the £20m that we borrowed from MSD has barely been touched yet.
Our immediate solvency risk is cash flow. and the £20m loan from MSD bought time where that’s concerned. Without it, we would probably have run out of cash flow before next season is over.
As was made clear in the auditors report, there is an expectation that we will need to sell players to balance the books. We already know that about £7m is going to drop off the wage bill. Depending on who we manage to sell, and how many players we sell, we may also be able to “pay off” several other players to leave (those on big wages who we are unlikely to be able to easily offload). We simply don’t know how successful that process will be. As the auditors point out, there is uncertainty that we will be able to offload enough, hence the going concern qualification.
My personal belief is that Yunyai will look to sell as soon as it’s clear that we will not be getting promoted this season. That is not mathematically certain yet. Indeed, had we taken the expected 6 points from the Rotherham and QPR games we would now be 5th with a game in hand. Easy to see why Yunyai haven’t pushed the sale button yet, but I think it will be imminent, and I think the MSD loan was taken solely to buy time.
Even if we are sold this summer, it seems probably that any sensible buyer will also insist on cutting the wage bill, unless it’s a buyer with very deep pockets. I just don’t see Yunyai letting this run any longer, but of course they can’t control which or how many buyers are out there, so the longer it drags on, the bigger the potential problem.
But we remain a very attractive buy to the right sort of buyer - because we have no debt. We won’t be cheap - because of that lack of debt. I could see a deal at around the £50-£60m mark, maybe £40m in a years time. I am pretty certain that we are close to D-Day with Yunyai in terms of crystallising their large loss. Getting £60m now has to be better than £40m in a years time, and the odds against promotion without a big cash injection - which won’t come from Yunyai - are very high.
For that reason I don’t think administration is at all likely, but if no sake of the club has happened this time next year then we have had to jettison a lot of the players that we really need to keep.
Events of the next two months I think could be very interesting indeed.
Despite running my own business, spending many an hour on my excel spreadsheet etc, I admit to having a very limited knowledge of accounts, but I am humble enough to listen to those who have financial knowledge on here and only them, rather than rampant doom-mongers.
Prag seems to be the go to guy and I hope he is right.
Aside of this, I would hope Action For Albion soon start finding fan-based consortiums expressing an interest.
I worked out in the wee small hours it would take 25,000 fans a few thousand each to buy the club in the dream scenario. It's not viable, but we do have some very wealthy and intelligent fans and a very wide fanbase, better than 80 per cent of clubs, so I'm hopeful the long time future is good, even if it's so rocky now.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
A well written piece, but I worry if we are relying on raising money from the sale of players as I think there will be very little interest in them
Posts: 7,973
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
I really hope you are right Prag. What you have said is perfectly correct in respect of pretty much any balance sheet in any sector. My only qualifier to it is the various quirks of the football industry
|