Lower League Armageddon Awaits
#51
(04-08-2023, 02:13 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 01:58 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 01:47 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 01:00 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 11:47 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Relax.  As has been pointed out several times on this board, since the MSD loan was taken out with the related Debenture, not a penny can leave the Club without the consent of MSD, other than for the day to day running of the club.  Any breach of that is an event of default, which enables MSD to call in their loan immediately, which would almost certainly trigger administration.   Do you really think Yunyai will do that? I certainly don’t.

Proth with all due respect I sometimes wonder if you're on the the same planet. Our owners do exactly as they want. They answer to no one. They could easily pay the loan off and tell MSD to take a hike.
This is real business they bend, break and make the rules. 
I said a long time ago they were taking money out of the club and it was noooo they simply can't take money out of the club when they want. Well they did. And mark my words they have not finished yet.
They don't work within the same moral code as we do. Our rules and regulations do not mean anything to them. Lai could have simply paid himself a £5m dividend and paid the loan off. He couldn't even be bothered to do that. He just crossed it out and wrote it on another balance sheet. That's the type of people our owners are. No matter what we are not getting a penny back. They probably charged us a large fee for moving it.

Past tense.  They USED TO do what they wanted until their actions came under the microscope once it was clear what was going on.  The owners can’t “easily pay the loan off” if the owners can’t or won’t find the money to do so. They are an investment consortium and the investment was made on the clear basis that the investment would be self-financing. 

The FACT is that for the past 3 months a debenture is in place re the MSD loan. It’s on public record at Companies House on public record.  Well worth a read. So it’s impossible for them to take anything more out without being in breach, which would trigger MSD demanding repayment of their debt in full.  So your “mark my words” is without foundation.  The rules have changed with MSD in place.  That’s actually a good thing. 

Lai couldn’t do that with the £5m loan. Wisdom Smart owes the money. Wisdom Smart is not a shareholder. The shareholder (ultimately) is Yunyai and its 1032 (approx) investors, not Lai.   Any dividends belong to all of the shareholders,  so the money would not easily find its way to Wisdom Smart to enable Wisdom Smart to repay its debt.  And remember that a dividend can only be paid out of available cash flow - which we don’t have.  And also remember that any dividend also has to be paid to the 12% shareholders. The cash outlay is simply not an option currently to pay the dividend. 

You are overlooking the reality that Lai is merely a front for the 1032 investors. He is one of them.  It is NOT, and never was his money.  He is answerable to a lot of people in China.  He cannot just do as he pleases - although I think that’s exactly what he WAS doing until he was rumbled.  He will be facing enormous heat in China as a result.  That’s why I think a sale will come soon - once promotion is impossible this season.

I'm nowhere neat to being anywhere near your understanding of this but one thing I think folk seem to miss is that Lai is a front for a consortium so what difference will yelling g at him make?

If I'd invested I'd at least want back what I put in regardless of a bunch of ageing English blokes yelling obscenities at a glass door.

The media exposure will have reached China and made Lai accountable for what he was up to

So will he be able to convince his investors to bail out?
Reply
#52
(04-08-2023, 02:00 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 01:47 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 01:00 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 11:47 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 08:31 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The owners obviously haven't finished draining the club of funds, they know more money is available. With player sales and contracts ending it's another perfect way of syphoning off several million. I don't expect our owners to go anywhere until the purse is well and truly 


Relax.  As has been pointed out several times on this board, since the MSD loan was taken out with the related Debenture, not a penny can leave the Club without the consent of MSD, other than for the day to day running of the club.  Any breach of that is an event of default, which enables MSD to call in their loan immediately, which would almost certainly trigger administration.   Do you really think Yunyai will do that? I certainly don’t.

Proth with all due respect I sometimes wonder if you're on the the same planet. Our owners do exactly as they want. They answer to no one. They could easily pay the loan off and tell MSD to take a hike.
This is real business they bend, break and make the rules. 
I said a long time ago they were taking money out of the club and it was noooo they simply can't take money out of the club when they want. Well they did. And mark my words they have not finished yet.
They don't work within the same moral code as we do. Our rules and regulations do not mean anything to them. Lai could have simply paid himself a £5m dividend and paid the loan off. He couldn't even be bothered to do that. He just crossed it out and wrote it on another balance sheet. That's the type of people our owners are. No matter what we are not getting a penny back. They probably charged us a large fee for moving it.

Past tense.  They USED TO do what they wanted until their actions came under the microscope once it was clear what was going on.  The owners can’t “easily pay the loan off” if the owners can’t or won’t find the money to do so. They are an investment consortium and the investment was made on the clear basis that the investment would be self-financing. 

The FACT is that for the past 3 months a debenture is in place re the MSD loan. It’s on public record at Companies House on public record.  Well worth a read. So it’s impossible for them to take anything more out without being in breach, which would trigger MSD demanding repayment of their debt in full.  So your “mark my words” is without foundation.  The rules have changed with MSD in place.  That’s actually a good thing. 

Lai couldn’t do that with the £5m loan. Wisdom Smart owes the money. Wisdom Smart is not a shareholder. The shareholder (ultimately) is Yunyai and its 1032 (approx) investors, not Lai.   Any dividends belong to all of the shareholders,  so the money would not easily find its way to Wisdom Smart to enable Wisdom Smart to repay its debt.  And remember that a dividend can only be paid out of available cash flow - which we don’t have.  And also remember that any dividend also has to be paid to the 12% shareholders. The cash outlay is simply not an option currently to pay the dividend. 

You are overlooking the reality that Lai is merely a front for the 1032 investors. He is one of them.  It is NOT, and never was his money.  He is answerable to a lot of people in China.  He cannot just do as he pleases - although I think that’s exactly what he WAS doing until he was rumbled.  He will be facing enormous heat in China as a result.  That’s why I think a sale will come soon - once promotion is impossible this season.

I can't believe Lai would be beholding to MSD.
We can but hope, but we all know it's the hope that kills you.

He is totally beholden, as is Ken. Read the Debenture on the Companies House website!
Reply
#53
Lai is beholden, but unless a breach is reported, MSD would only likely find out when they read the accounts. He does of course have to comply with the loan covenants but we don't know what they are, or how often they are tested. I'm amazed MSD entertained this loan. Yes they are unlikely to lose money, but you don't lend if it is going to cost time and money to recover. It costs you money, even if your rate of interest is 9.75% above Sonia.

What will be interesting is the shareholder agreement between the 1032 investors. I'm guessing any decision to sell requires 2/3 approval? As I have said before I believe this is a part of an Investment Visa scheme and the individuals behind it will be wealthy, with their £2M each to qualify for the Visa invested in a number of assets.
Reply
#54
(04-08-2023, 02:14 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 02:13 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 01:58 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 01:47 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 01:00 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Proth with all due respect I sometimes wonder if you're on the the same planet. Our owners do exactly as they want. They answer to no one. They could easily pay the loan off and tell MSD to take a hike.
This is real business they bend, break and make the rules. 
I said a long time ago they were taking money out of the club and it was noooo they simply can't take money out of the club when they want. Well they did. And mark my words they have not finished yet.
They don't work within the same moral code as we do. Our rules and regulations do not mean anything to them. Lai could have simply paid himself a £5m dividend and paid the loan off. He couldn't even be bothered to do that. He just crossed it out and wrote it on another balance sheet. That's the type of people our owners are. No matter what we are not getting a penny back. They probably charged us a large fee for moving it.

Past tense.  They USED TO do what they wanted until their actions came under the microscope once it was clear what was going on.  The owners can’t “easily pay the loan off” if the owners can’t or won’t find the money to do so. They are an investment consortium and the investment was made on the clear basis that the investment would be self-financing. 

The FACT is that for the past 3 months a debenture is in place re the MSD loan. It’s on public record at Companies House on public record.  Well worth a read. So it’s impossible for them to take anything more out without being in breach, which would trigger MSD demanding repayment of their debt in full.  So your “mark my words” is without foundation.  The rules have changed with MSD in place.  That’s actually a good thing. 

Lai couldn’t do that with the £5m loan. Wisdom Smart owes the money. Wisdom Smart is not a shareholder. The shareholder (ultimately) is Yunyai and its 1032 (approx) investors, not Lai.   Any dividends belong to all of the shareholders,  so the money would not easily find its way to Wisdom Smart to enable Wisdom Smart to repay its debt.  And remember that a dividend can only be paid out of available cash flow - which we don’t have.  And also remember that any dividend also has to be paid to the 12% shareholders. The cash outlay is simply not an option currently to pay the dividend. 

You are overlooking the reality that Lai is merely a front for the 1032 investors. He is one of them.  It is NOT, and never was his money.  He is answerable to a lot of people in China.  He cannot just do as he pleases - although I think that’s exactly what he WAS doing until he was rumbled.  He will be facing enormous heat in China as a result.  That’s why I think a sale will come soon - once promotion is impossible this season.

I'm nowhere neat to being anywhere near your understanding of this but one thing I think folk seem to miss is that Lai is a front for a consortium so what difference will yelling g at him make?

If I'd invested I'd at least want back what I put in regardless of a bunch of ageing English blokes yelling obscenities at a glass door.

The media exposure will have reached China and made Lai accountable for what he was up to

So will he be able to convince his investors to bail out?
No, but he may need to start explaining that investments can go down as well as up.
Reply
#55
But if this is an investment scheme, other investments may have performed well, and the underlying objective is to achieve the Visas.

They won't be happy that the West Brom investment has failed, but there may be other factors at play, here.
Reply
#56
(04-08-2023, 01:58 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 01:47 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 01:00 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 11:47 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 08:31 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The owners obviously haven't finished draining the club of funds, they know more money is available. With player sales and contracts ending it's another perfect way of syphoning off several million. I don't expect our owners to go anywhere until the purse is well and truly 


Relax.  As has been pointed out several times on this board, since the MSD loan was taken out with the related Debenture, not a penny can leave the Club without the consent of MSD, other than for the day to day running of the club.  Any breach of that is an event of default, which enables MSD to call in their loan immediately, which would almost certainly trigger administration.   Do you really think Yunyai will do that? I certainly don’t.

Proth with all due respect I sometimes wonder if you're on the the same planet. Our owners do exactly as they want. They answer to no one. They could easily pay the loan off and tell MSD to take a hike.
This is real business they bend, break and make the rules. 
I said a long time ago they were taking money out of the club and it was noooo they simply can't take money out of the club when they want. Well they did. And mark my words they have not finished yet.
They don't work within the same moral code as we do. Our rules and regulations do not mean anything to them. Lai could have simply paid himself a £5m dividend and paid the loan off. He couldn't even be bothered to do that. He just crossed it out and wrote it on another balance sheet. That's the type of people our owners are. No matter what we are not getting a penny back. They probably charged us a large fee for moving it.

Past tense.  They USED TO do what they wanted until their actions came under the microscope once it was clear what was going on.  The owners can’t “easily pay the loan off” if the owners can’t or won’t find the money to do so. They are an investment consortium and the investment was made on the clear basis that the investment would be self-financing. 

The FACT is that for the past 3 months a debenture is in place re the MSD loan. It’s on public record at Companies House on public record.  Well worth a read. So it’s impossible for them to take anything more out without being in breach, which would trigger MSD demanding repayment of their debt in full.  So your “mark my words” is without foundation.  The rules have changed with MSD in place.  That’s actually a good thing. 

Lai couldn’t do that with the £5m loan. Wisdom Smart owes the money. Wisdom Smart is not a shareholder. The shareholder (ultimately) is Yunyai and its 1032 (approx) investors, not Lai.   Any dividends belong to all of the shareholders,  so the money would not easily find its way to Wisdom Smart to enable Wisdom Smart to repay its debt.  And remember that a dividend can only be paid out of available cash flow - which we don’t have.  And also remember that any dividend also has to be paid to the 12% shareholders. The cash outlay is simply not an option currently to pay the dividend. 

You are overlooking the reality that Lai is merely a front for the 1032 investors. He is one of them.  It is NOT, and never was his money.  He is answerable to a lot of people in China.  He cannot just do as he pleases - although I think that’s exactly what he WAS doing until he was rumbled.  He will be facing enormous heat in China as a result.  That’s why I think a sale will come soon - once promotion is impossible this season.

I'm nowhere neat to being anywhere near your understanding of this but one thing I think folk seem to miss is that Lai is a front for a consortium so what difference will yelling g at him make?

If I'd invested I'd at least want back what I put in regardless of a bunch of ageing English blokes yelling obscenities at a glass door.

I too would want at least what I'd invested back but if I realised that had little to no chance of ever happening then I might be tempted to get what I can rather than waiting forever for something that will never arrive
Reply
#57
(04-08-2023, 04:54 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Lai is beholden, but unless a breach is reported, MSD would only likely find out when they read the accounts. He does of course have to comply with the loan covenants but we don't know what they are, or how often they are tested. I'm amazed MSD entertained this loan. Yes they are unlikely to lose money, but you don't lend if it is going to cost time and money to recover. It costs you money, even if your rate of interest is 9.75% above Sonia.

What will be interesting is the shareholder agreement between the 1032 investors. I'm guessing any decision to sell requires 2/3 approval? As I have said before I believe this is a part of an Investment Visa scheme and the individuals behind it will be wealthy, with their £2M each to qualify for the Visa invested in a number of assets.

No.  There will be strict regular management accounting submissions to MSD.  Each Director of each relevant board (of each company) have an immediate obligation to report any breech. Any breech means the loan is in default and MSD can call in their security.  They’d be insane to try anything stupid and not expect to see the loan get called in. 

There’s plenty of margin in it for MSD to recover their loan. No worries on that front. 

The structure is a limited company with 3 limited partnerships as the shareholders.  Lai is the general partner of the largest limited partnership (which holds around 55%) and so he’s the controlling party. Seems that he has all the decision-making power on behalf of the investors. 

No it’s certainly not an investment visa scheme. There are multiple Chinese state and regional banks, insurance companies, pension funds etc amongst the 1032 limited partners in the 3 limited partnerships.

(04-08-2023, 05:17 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: But if this is an investment scheme, other investments may have performed well, and the underlying objective is to achieve the Visas.

They won't be happy that the West Brom investment has failed, but there may be other factors at play, here.

No. This is a single standalone investment.
Reply
#58
Well Prag, we will just have to differ

In my 35 years of Corporate Banking I've never seen an SME come running to a Bank to report a breach. The only times it happens is in Insolvency, or if they are required to do so due to be the members of an Exchange. This is the reason Peace took West Brom of AIM, so he didn't have to disclose so much h information. Most SME lending requires quarterly Management Information at best, and that tends to be focused around Profitability covenants. There is a more detailed annual covenant check when accounts are received

My understanding is this is a Visa scheme. I worked with a similar group of Chinese trying to buy an EFL club around the same time. Mass events were held to encourage investment. It was just like selling time share.
Reply
#59
(04-08-2023, 05:30 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 01:58 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 01:47 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 01:00 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(04-08-2023, 11:47 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Relax.  As has been pointed out several times on this board, since the MSD loan was taken out with the related Debenture, not a penny can leave the Club without the consent of MSD, other than for the day to day running of the club.  Any breach of that is an event of default, which enables MSD to call in their loan immediately, which would almost certainly trigger administration.   Do you really think Yunyai will do that? I certainly don’t.

Proth with all due respect I sometimes wonder if you're on the the same planet. Our owners do exactly as they want. They answer to no one. They could easily pay the loan off and tell MSD to take a hike.
This is real business they bend, break and make the rules. 
I said a long time ago they were taking money out of the club and it was noooo they simply can't take money out of the club when they want. Well they did. And mark my words they have not finished yet.
They don't work within the same moral code as we do. Our rules and regulations do not mean anything to them. Lai could have simply paid himself a £5m dividend and paid the loan off. He couldn't even be bothered to do that. He just crossed it out and wrote it on another balance sheet. That's the type of people our owners are. No matter what we are not getting a penny back. They probably charged us a large fee for moving it.

Past tense.  They USED TO do what they wanted until their actions came under the microscope once it was clear what was going on.  The owners can’t “easily pay the loan off” if the owners can’t or won’t find the money to do so. They are an investment consortium and the investment was made on the clear basis that the investment would be self-financing. 

The FACT is that for the past 3 months a debenture is in place re the MSD loan. It’s on public record at Companies House on public record.  Well worth a read. So it’s impossible for them to take anything more out without being in breach, which would trigger MSD demanding repayment of their debt in full.  So your “mark my words” is without foundation.  The rules have changed with MSD in place.  That’s actually a good thing. 

Lai couldn’t do that with the £5m loan. Wisdom Smart owes the money. Wisdom Smart is not a shareholder. The shareholder (ultimately) is Yunyai and its 1032 (approx) investors, not Lai.   Any dividends belong to all of the shareholders,  so the money would not easily find its way to Wisdom Smart to enable Wisdom Smart to repay its debt.  And remember that a dividend can only be paid out of available cash flow - which we don’t have.  And also remember that any dividend also has to be paid to the 12% shareholders. The cash outlay is simply not an option currently to pay the dividend. 

You are overlooking the reality that Lai is merely a front for the 1032 investors. He is one of them.  It is NOT, and never was his money.  He is answerable to a lot of people in China.  He cannot just do as he pleases - although I think that’s exactly what he WAS doing until he was rumbled.  He will be facing enormous heat in China as a result.  That’s why I think a sale will come soon - once promotion is impossible this season.

I'm nowhere neat to being anywhere near your understanding of this but one thing I think folk seem to miss is that Lai is a front for a consortium so what difference will yelling g at him make?

If I'd invested I'd at least want back what I put in regardless of a bunch of ageing English blokes yelling obscenities at a glass door.

I too would want at least what I'd invested back but if I realised that had little to no chance of ever happening then I might be tempted to get what I can rather than waiting forever for something that will never arrive

All this I want back what I put in is clearly taken from people who don’t take risk’s and realise how the world works. 
You invest in something and you’ve no guarantee. I have shares that have gone up and down. I thankfully got out of the dot.com fiasco before it went arseways in 2001 or so. I’ve made some investments though that were rubbish. 
The 1000 odd investors will never get their money back. That’s life.
Reply
#60
(04-08-2023, 05:46 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Well Prag, we will just have to differ

In my 35 years of Corporate  Banking I've never seen an SME come running to a Bank to report a breach. The only times it happens is in Insolvency, or if they are required to do so due to be the members of an Exchange. This is the reason Peace took West Brom of AIM, so he didn't have to disclose so much h information. Most SME lending requires quarterly Management Information at best, and that tends to be focused around Profitability covenants. There is a more detailed annual covenant check when accounts are  received

My understanding is this is a Visa scheme. I worked with a similar group of Chinese trying to buy an EFL club around the same time. Mass events were held to encourage investment. It was just like selling time share.

Yes we’ll have to agree to disagree. 

Normal rules of bank lending don’t apply to hedge fund lenders in a narrow market who set their own rules.  I also categorically know 100% how MSD operate in relation to football clubs. 

This absolutely is not an investment visa scheme.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: