Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(04-08-2023, 02:35 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: (04-08-2023, 02:27 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote: (04-08-2023, 02:17 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (04-08-2023, 02:02 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote: (04-08-2023, 01:56 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: My hope is Corberan gets in players he has a say with.
However, I’m not denying the recruitment has been shot to bits since Dashworth left.
Somehow the template that had made us one of the most successful midsize self sustaining clubs of a decade ago has been put in the shredder.
What Ashworth did had to have been a logical process. It's not mystical or magical he must have followed a process. So why did no one learn from this and follow the process that was obviously working? Instead we employed egotistical Bell ends whi just weren't very good at their job. The recruitment at all levels stinks.
Correct, the most costly decision we've made as a club was to believe Garlick was an appropriate replacement for Ashworth, and then to believe McDonut was the right stopgap. Garlick was an excellent administrator, and sage counsel hence his progress since leaving us, but he was not, nor had he ever been a leader or an innovator.
Look at our subsequent disastrous appointments of McDonut (Benitez-loving Hispanophile and hater of Ashworth), Terry Burton (a walking black book and throwback to the 90s), Nicky Hammond (a chocolate fireguard who managed to make Celtic finish 2nd in a 1 horse race), Giuliano Terraneo (still dining out on discovering Baggio in the 90s) and Luke Dowling (Genuinely think he started our OK, but just go lost into the mess we've become) and it's clear to see why we have fallen so far. The most crucial position at a club of our size and resource is the DoF, and we've shown zero pattern, logic or plan since losing Ashworth and subsequently that chaos has become endemic in the whole club.
We are now sitting with a squad that's lacked balance for 5 seasons and is on its 6th coach in the same time frame and our most successful signings of late have been the result of one being an ex boss's neighbour and another playing alongside his son in law!!!!!
Spot on.
The situation the club is in now hasn't happened overnight. It's absolutely no surprise at all to me. Perhaps I'm more surprised it hasn't happened sooner. It's a catalogue of errors at all levels which has been happening for years. Even when we had funds we were cheap fucks trying to cut corners and penny pinch. The real start of the rot was Peace, who couldn't care less about Albion selling out to the highest bidder. But you only have to look back and know that we were only a handful of errors from a disaster.
Plus side is that there'll still be an Albion. But it'll be awful and we'll very much be in the shadow of our more illustrious neighbours.
Is what it is. It's been coming and now it's here.
At no point in our history have we been even remotely good at spending big money on players. We broke the British transfer record to sign David fucking Mills! Yet you keep going on about the money we should be spending when all of our best signings have been the cheap ones you wrote off because they didn't cost very much.
That's very true. I remember working out the Hodgson side which was one of our best first for a long time cost something like 11 million in total
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
Absolutely right that we have been appalling with big money signings. It just doesn’t work for us. All of our successes have been in the bargain basement. Long may that continue!
Posts: 3,316
Threads: 58
Joined: Sep 2022
(04-08-2023, 06:18 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: Absolutely right that we have been appalling with big money signings. It just doesn’t work for us. All of our successes have been in the bargain basement. Long may that continue!
Well we'll have no choice. We won't even be shopping at Aldi we'll be having what's left from food banks.
In all seriousness I'm used to us doing stuff on the cheap but what they requires is very good decision making. I'm hopeful that Gourlay and Pearce get the sack and we can try someone else in this department.
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(04-08-2023, 06:28 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote: (04-08-2023, 06:18 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: Absolutely right that we have been appalling with big money signings. It just doesn’t work for us. All of our successes have been in the bargain basement. Long may that continue!
Well we'll have no choice. We won't even be shopping at Aldi we'll be having what's left from food banks.
In all seriousness I'm used to us doing stuff on the cheap but what they requires is very good decision making. I'm hopeful that Gourlay and Pearce get the sack and we can try someone else in this department.
I’m very happy with Gourlay staying on. Pearce must go though
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-08-2023, 06:41 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: (04-08-2023, 06:28 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote: (04-08-2023, 06:18 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: Absolutely right that we have been appalling with big money signings. It just doesn’t work for us. All of our successes have been in the bargain basement. Long may that continue!
Well we'll have no choice. We won't even be shopping at Aldi we'll be having what's left from food banks.
In all seriousness I'm used to us doing stuff on the cheap but what they requires is very good decision making. I'm hopeful that Gourlay and Pearce get the sack and we can try someone else in this department.
I’m very happy with Gourlay staying on. Pearce must go though
You speak such sense Prag and it’s refreshing when I see intelligent posters like you.
The less able posters just always seek a ground zero approach of utter destruction and then a miraculous rebuild. It’s the ‘all the players are cheating a living’ posts mindset.
We have many able players in the squad and equally there’s expertise in the general running of the club. The skill is weeding out those who aren’t contributing to a better club.
I still believe if Corberan stays and works with a better footballing department then we can be very competitive next season.
Posts: 78
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation:
0
Our whole business model is to be self-sufficient which we achieved through good off-field management with Ashworth, everything from world wide search to flexible player contracts and good value transfer fees. No surprise he went on to work at Brighton and now Newcastle. He’s a talented bloke. No Chief Exec has recruited effectively a replacement DOF since he left, we haven’t valued the role. The best value player in recent times, Perreira, came via Bilic and as we know we even managed to get poor value on his sale.
It is clear that since his departure it’s been very poor both in terms of players joining and being sold at the right time, we have also struggled to promote academy players at times. It’s definitely the most important off field job in football. I appreciate Pulis didn’t want a DOF and so we changed the model but with Carlos as head coach it’s needed to support him, in my view. The problem now is Gourlay will argue we can’t afford such a role but it’s vital if we are to continue our business model, it probably overlaps with his own role also so another reason he won’t support it.
Pearce was a scout at Brighton for 4 years before he became our head of recruitment in 2018, ironically Ashworth started at Brighton a few months after he left. We need a DOF, not head of recruitment, which sounds like a scapegoat job description, but incredibly he’s still here FFS.
Sheffield United bought Rhian Brewster for 23.5 million and McBurnie for £20m and also took Ollie Burke off us so not all good but they have some stalwarts who costs virtually nothing and are still playing, a nucleus of the old Wilder squad. It’s not just us that spends big purchases badly, they are high risk. However we don’t seem to have their knack of uncovering lower league gems or bringing in good loan players. McAtee and Doyle have been superb for them this season, our loans have not.
Pearce definitely needs to go asap. Goulay we seem to be stuck with but I am concerned about his ability to do DOF roles such as player negotiations, both contracts and transfer fees.
I think we can rise again but the off field football management need to compliment Carlos, not work against him.
Posts: 3,316
Threads: 58
Joined: Sep 2022
(04-08-2023, 07:54 PM)TLMS Wrote: Our whole business model is to be self-sufficient which we achieved through good off-field management with Ashworth, everything from world wide search to flexible player contracts and good value transfer fees. No surprise he went on to work at Brighton and now Newcastle. He’s a talented bloke. No Chief Exec has recruited effectively a replacement DOF since he left, we haven’t valued the role. The best value player in recent times, Perreira, came via Bilic and as we know we even managed to get poor value on his sale.
It is clear that since his departure it’s been very poor both in terms of players joining and being sold at the right time, we have also struggled to promote academy players at times. It’s definitely the most important off field job in football. I appreciate Pulis didn’t want a DOF and so we changed the model but with Carlos as head coach it’s needed to support him, in my view. The problem now is Gourlay will argue we can’t afford such a role but it’s vital if we are to continue our business model, it probably overlaps with his own role also so another reason he won’t support it.
Pearce was a scout at Brighton for 4 years before he became our head of recruitment in 2018, ironically Ashworth started at Brighton a few months after he left. We need a DOF, not head of recruitment, which sounds like a scapegoat job description, but incredibly he’s still here FFS.
Sheffield United bought Rhian Brewster for 23.5 million and McBurnie for £20m and also took Ollie Burke off us so not all good but they have some stalwarts who costs virtually nothing and are still playing, a nucleus of the old Wilder squad. It’s not just us that spends big purchases badly, they are high risk. However we don’t seem to have their knack of uncovering lower league gems or bringing in good loan players. McAtee and Doyle have been superb for them this season, our loans have not.
Pearce definitely needs to go asap. Goulay we seem to be stuck with but I am concerned about his ability to do DOF roles such as player negotiations, both contracts and transfer fees.
I think we can rise again but the off field football management need to compliment Carlos, not work against him.
Given the fact that Gourlay's appointment of his mate Bruce was a huge flop and he hadn't got the bollocks to sack him sooner, thus effectively wasting 3/4 months of this season and effectively destroying any slim hopes of promotion. Add to that your concerns raised above the question is: why the fuck is he still here?
Posts: 78
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation:
0
I agree and would love to see the back of Gourlay. Unfortunately he seems to be in prime position as the link to the Lai regime so I’m assuming he will only leave when the regime changes, they don’t seem to have any other football knowledge in the set up. Best thing, as we all know, would be for Lai et al to go and then a new regime appoints a tip top DOF. This would be the best option all round but seems unlikely currently.
Posts: 3,316
Threads: 58
Joined: Sep 2022
(04-08-2023, 09:02 PM)TLMS Wrote: I agree and would love to see the back of Gourlay. Unfortunately he seems to be in prime position as the link to the Lai regime so I’m assuming he will only leave when the regime changes, they don’t seem to have any other football knowledge in the set up. Best thing, as we all know, would be for Lai et al to go and then a new regime appoints a tip top DOF. This would be the best option all round but seems unlikely currently.
Very much agree.
Cannot for the life of me see the support for Gourlay given his contribution to our demise.
Posts: 10,860
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(04-08-2023, 12:29 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: We should keep Griffith's, Palmer, O'Shea, Okay, Molumby and Wallace.
The rest can all go.
Those are the only ones that could generate some quick cash!
We will be left with the shit ones and the kids....
|