So, how long does Moore have?
#21
(02-07-2019, 11:36 AM)ferencpuskas Wrote: Before BD's appointment, I posted, should anyone care to check up, that he had done a great job, galvinising the players, bringing some pride back to the Club, and was imo a strong dressing room personality, and probably great for geeing the lads up etc, and getting the best out of 'em, but at that time not yet managerial material. I believe that he needs this season at least, to hone those necessary skills, we are currently in a comfortable position, and any thoughts of his removal should be put aside. I also wonder whether he really benefits from having Jones around . Just saying like !.

I thought Jones influence was clear too see at full time going into extra time. He did the bulk of the on-pitch team talk last night with DM stood just behind acting like a nodding dog. I like DM, but I think tactically ( in-game management specifically ) Jones is the one pulling the strings.
Reply
#22
Moore is massively in credit with me.

I didn't really want him to get the job, but felt it was justified based on the job he did as caretaker manager.

Overall he has exceeded my expectations. I think the criticism he has received has been ridiculous at times and taken nitpicking to a whole new art form. Nothing irritates me more at the moment than the suggestion his in game management is poor. Really we have won more games than we have lost and gained more points from losing positions than we have lost points from winning positions. Or put it another way when we win games it's never down to Moore's skill as a manager, but if we drop points it's down to him being naïve or a novice,

I take on board that this season represents the best opportunity to get promotion, and we do have a squad with depth and some very good players. I think though in one crucial area we have had a problem and that's midfield. We are between and betwixt there, we have midfield players who are reaching the end of their careers who will inevitably struggle with the relentless physical demands of the championship and we have a couple of very promising young midfield players, who are probably too young to have the experience and consistency necessity to be the basis of a promotion midfield. Livermore is the one player who we can play consistently and yet he has had to miss 5 games through suspension.

In short I would like to see Moore manage beyond this season and see where we go from there. He deserves a summer window with the new management structure put together by the club in the autumn.
Reply
#23
This season we go up all good. If we don't until Christmas next if we are struggling. If the club wants promotion there is no excuse for not achieving that with our squad and sentiment doesn't come into it. The one thing that is assured in football management is you get the sack eventually.

I'd love to know what a manager can build over ten years without promotion, with every dwindling resources given to him as finances get tighter and tighter. It takes a fucking huge leap of faith to believe that DM gaining experience in say two or three seasons will negate the drop in quality we would see in our team.
Reply
#24
(02-07-2019, 12:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: This season we go up all good. If we don't until Christmas next if we are struggling. If the club wants promotion there is no excuse for not achieving that with our squad and sentiment doesn't come into it. The one thing that is assured in football management is you get the sack eventually.

I'd love to know what a manager can build over ten years without promotion, with every dwindling resources given to him as finances get tighter and tighter. It takes a fucking huge leap of faith to believe that DM gaining experience in say two or three seasons will negate the drop in quality we would see in our team.

What i would say he has a great crop of youngsters to fall back on and they will be the future of the club even if we go up eventually .
Reply
#25
Mooro could be our Fergie.
Reply
#26
(02-07-2019, 12:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: This season we go up all good. If we don't until Christmas next if we are struggling. If the club wants promotion there is no excuse for not achieving that with our squad and sentiment doesn't come into it. The one thing that is assured in football management is you get the sack eventually.

I'd love to know what a manager can build over ten years without promotion, with every dwindling resources given to him as finances get tighter and tighter. It takes a fucking huge leap of faith to believe that DM gaining experience in say two or three seasons will negate the drop in quality we would see in our team.

Alan Pardew's 8 year contract is the longest I can remember Wink


(Actually, think Bolton gave Big Sam a 10 year deal at one point - but that's not as convenient!)
Reply
#27
Norwich finished 14th last year. We need to be patient.

We cannot keep chopping and changing our managers.

Short of something utterly disastrous happening, DM keeps his job for another season.
Reply
#28
(02-07-2019, 11:08 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Not advocating sacking him, more just gauging opinion.

On the positive side, I think he's brought unity and pride back after the mess of last season, and when I look at how Swansea and Stoke are doing, it's far too easy to forget we were as much of a state - if not more in Stoke's case - as both of these clubs, yet we look the most likely to return of all 3. Further, he picked up an unbalanced squad that needed to combine both a change in mentality and style with picking up results, which for the most part he's managed. 

The negative is that we're under-achieving. When I look at the sides above and around us, we have far more in the tank. Yes our squad lacked balance, but I still feel we're too reliant on individual moments to win games and that I can count on one hand the number of genuinely quality performances we've put in this season and as the games progress we don't seem to be evolving or progressing any discernible way of playing. 

I didn't expect promotion this season, and still don't if I'm honest, so to sack him for not taking us up would be incredibly harsh, but having looked at the standard of sides around us, if we do drop out of the top 6 in the next few weeks, I'd be asking questions.

Interesting question and perfectly valid.

When the poll was put on the site at the start of the season I had top 2 as a finish. Keeping JRod, Hegazi, Gibbs, Livermore etc and adding Johnstone in early (came with a great reputation) and Barnes meant the squad was really strong for the division. To factor in stalwarts such as Brunt and Morrison and later signings including Sako (ok it never worked out) the summer window finished with us, in my opinion, having a squad even more capable of finishing top 2. It was now down to the management to get the best out of the squad at their disposal..

I don't buy into the comments about it being Moore's first job and his inexperience. He is paid to do a job, has a great squad and hand picked his coaches. Promotion in any form would be success. Play off failure and I would have no hesitation in keeping Moore as, whilst my expectation is top 2, just missing out and failing in the lottery of the play offs is excusable, just. Finishing outside the top 6 and his future really has to be questioned.

The crux for me is how we would move forward from failure to get promoted. With less and less money available I just have a good feeling about Moore and how he would move the club forward with the current crop of youngsters. There's no guarantee in anything but the thought of the managerial merry-go-round again is the last thing I would want. 


If we don't get promoted then keep him for next season with a review towards Christmas time if outside the top 6.
Reply
#29
(02-07-2019, 01:19 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote:
(02-07-2019, 11:08 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Not advocating sacking him, more just gauging opinion.

On the positive side, I think he's brought unity and pride back after the mess of last season, and when I look at how Swansea and Stoke are doing, it's far too easy to forget we were as much of a state - if not more in Stoke's case - as both of these clubs, yet we look the most likely to return of all 3. Further, he picked up an unbalanced squad that needed to combine both a change in mentality and style with picking up results, which for the most part he's managed. 

The negative is that we're under-achieving. When I look at the sides above and around us, we have far more in the tank. Yes our squad lacked balance, but I still feel we're too reliant on individual moments to win games and that I can count on one hand the number of genuinely quality performances we've put in this season and as the games progress we don't seem to be evolving or progressing any discernible way of playing. 

I didn't expect promotion this season, and still don't if I'm honest, so to sack him for not taking us up would be incredibly harsh, but having looked at the standard of sides around us, if we do drop out of the top 6 in the next few weeks, I'd be asking questions.

Interesting question and perfectly valid.

When the poll was put on the site at the start of the season I had top 2 as a finish. Keeping JRod, Hegazi, Gibbs, Livermore etc and adding Johnstone in early (came with a great reputation) and Barnes meant the squad was really strong for the division. To factor in stalwarts such as Brunt and Morrison and later signings including Sako (ok it never worked out) the summer window finished with us, in my opinion, having a squad even more capable of finishing top 2. It was now down to the management to get the best out of the squad at their disposal..

I don't buy into the comments about it being Moore's first job and his inexperience. He is paid to do a job, has a great squad and hand picked his coaches. Promotion in any form would be success. Play off failure and I would have no hesitation in keeping Moore as, whilst my expectation is top 2, just missing out and failing in the lottery of the play offs is excusable, just. Finishing outside the top 6 and his future really has to be questioned.

The crux for me is how we would move forward from failure to get promoted. With less and less money available I just have a good feeling about Moore and how he would move the club forward with the current crop of youngsters. There's no guarantee in anything but the thought of the managerial merry-go-round again is the last thing I would want. 


If we don't get promoted then keep him for next season with a review towards Christmas time if outside the top 6.
We have a great crop of youngsters who will come through also who the manager believes in by the look of it .
Reply
#30
(02-07-2019, 11:14 AM)Duffers Wrote: He’s still well in credit for me, given the state we were in when he first took over we could easily have done a awolves and crashed down through the Championship too. That he has picked up a squad destroyed by Pulis and Pardew, rebuilt their belief and got us challenging is a remarkable job.

Is he perfect, of course not. He’s shown himself to be too inflexible tactically when he finds something that works, and less said about his subs the better, but he’s still a young coach and will improve over time.

Ultimately I’m enjoying Albion again for the first time in years and that is all down to the work DM has done. Long may it continue.

(Oh and we won’t drop out of the top 6)
Not for the first time in the last 24 hours, me and Duffers think alike. Last season was a disaster to have us challenging is no mean feat when you look at what Swansea and Stoke have done. In other words I'm saying the same as Duffers only in less words Smile
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)