Lai - loan - report - stuff
#11
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 07:47 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-30-2023, 10:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-30-2023, 09:18 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The guarantee is worth fuck all. How are you going to enforce it? The beneficial owner is guaranteeing itself.

No - if and when the club gets sold that’s where 88% of the sale proceeds go.  That’s when we’d get paid back - if not prior to that.  It’s far better than Wisdom Smart having no guarantor.  At least we know that Holdings has an asset worth probably £60m+.  Wisdom Smart clearly has nothing

There is no security with it, and even if it is governed by English Law, what actual assets does Holdings have? Its all Balance Sheet

I agree it is most likely to be repaid when the club is sold, but this could be another situation similar to the Peace loan.

Why do we have the Guarantee now? Has the EOD been remedied? If so what are the terms? Has this loan been amended to no fixed repayment date? Can we Determine the Guarantee now, default the loan and call in the Guarantee?

This Guarantee probably has no Commercial Benefit in any case. We have more chance of enforcing a parking fine.

I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

It hasn’t been written off.  It’s been impaired - which means the value of the loan as an asset has been written down in our books, but it still exists and is still repayable.  Standard accounting practice applies by the auditors to write down the loan on grounds of prudence, because of the risk of the asset not being recovered.

So many people are getting confused by the difference between writing off the debt and writing down the value of the asset.

(03-31-2023, 11:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 07:47 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-30-2023, 10:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-30-2023, 09:18 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The guarantee is worth fuck all. How are you going to enforce it? The beneficial owner is guaranteeing itself.

No - if and when the club gets sold that’s where 88% of the sale proceeds go.  That’s when we’d get paid back - if not prior to that.  It’s far better than Wisdom Smart having no guarantor.  At least we know that Holdings has an asset worth probably £60m+.  Wisdom Smart clearly has nothing

There is no security with it, and even if it is governed by English Law, what actual assets does Holdings have? Its all Balance Sheet

I agree it is most likely to be repaid when the club is sold, but this could be another situation similar to the Peace loan.

Why do we have the Guarantee now? Has the EOD been remedied? If so what are the terms? Has this loan been amended to no fixed repayment date? Can we Determine the Guarantee now, default the loan and call in the Guarantee?

This Guarantee probably has no Commercial Benefit in any case. We have more chance of enforcing a parking fine.

I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

The guarantee will have been negotiated after the loan went into default, FF, or as the new repayment date was agreed. 

If you look at the accounts for Holdings as at June 2021, these are presented as Consolidated. If you dig a bit deeper into the accounts it shows you the Balance Sheet of Holdings at company level. The only assets it has are it's shares in the subsidiary trading companies. The guarantee is worthless.

I disagree.  The asset of Holdings (via the Jersey company) is the capital value of the 88% holding in Group.  Whether consolidated or not, if Holdings sells then 88% of the sale proceeds go to Holdings, and that’s when we would get repaid (if not already repaid by then).  It’s not true to say that the guarantee is worthless.
Reply
#12
(03-31-2023, 02:13 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 07:47 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-30-2023, 10:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-30-2023, 09:18 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The guarantee is worth fuck all. How are you going to enforce it? The beneficial owner is guaranteeing itself.

No - if and when the club gets sold that’s where 88% of the sale proceeds go.  That’s when we’d get paid back - if not prior to that.  It’s far better than Wisdom Smart having no guarantor.  At least we know that Holdings has an asset worth probably £60m+.  Wisdom Smart clearly has nothing

There is no security with it, and even if it is governed by English Law, what actual assets does Holdings have? Its all Balance Sheet

I agree it is most likely to be repaid when the club is sold, but this could be another situation similar to the Peace loan.

Why do we have the Guarantee now? Has the EOD been remedied? If so what are the terms? Has this loan been amended to no fixed repayment date? Can we Determine the Guarantee now, default the loan and call in the Guarantee?

This Guarantee probably has no Commercial Benefit in any case. We have more chance of enforcing a parking fine.

I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

It hasn’t been written off.  It’s been impaired - which means the value of the loan as an asset has been written down in our books, but it still exists and is still repayable.  Standard accounting practice applies by the auditors to write down the loan on grounds of prudence, because of the risk of the asset not being recovered.

So many people are getting confused by the difference between writing off the debt and writing down the value of the asset.

(03-31-2023, 11:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 07:47 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-30-2023, 10:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: No - if and when the club gets sold that’s where 88% of the sale proceeds go.  That’s when we’d get paid back - if not prior to that.  It’s far better than Wisdom Smart having no guarantor.  At least we know that Holdings has an asset worth probably £60m+.  Wisdom Smart clearly has nothing

There is no security with it, and even if it is governed by English Law, what actual assets does Holdings have? Its all Balance Sheet

I agree it is most likely to be repaid when the club is sold, but this could be another situation similar to the Peace loan.

Why do we have the Guarantee now? Has the EOD been remedied? If so what are the terms? Has this loan been amended to no fixed repayment date? Can we Determine the Guarantee now, default the loan and call in the Guarantee?

This Guarantee probably has no Commercial Benefit in any case. We have more chance of enforcing a parking fine.

I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

The guarantee will have been negotiated after the loan went into default, FF, or as the new repayment date was agreed. 

If you look at the accounts for Holdings as at June 2021, these are presented as Consolidated. If you dig a bit deeper into the accounts it shows you the Balance Sheet of Holdings at company level. The only assets it has are it's shares in the subsidiary trading companies. The guarantee is worthless.

I disagree.  The asset of Holdings (via the Jersey company) is the capital value of the 88% holding in Group.  Whether consolidated or not, if Holdings sells then 88% of the sale proceeds go to Holdings, and that’s when we would get repaid (if not already repaid by then).  It’s not true to say that the guarantee is worthless.

Prag…

With reduced the debt to zero and charged the p&l account with the full value of the debt.  In my view, as far as the accounts go, we’ve written the whole lot off. 

Seems odd the auditors have insisted on writing it down to zero as at june 2022
Reply
#13
(03-31-2023, 02:21 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:13 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 07:47 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-30-2023, 10:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: No - if and when the club gets sold that’s where 88% of the sale proceeds go.  That’s when we’d get paid back - if not prior to that.  It’s far better than Wisdom Smart having no guarantor.  At least we know that Holdings has an asset worth probably £60m+.  Wisdom Smart clearly has nothing

There is no security with it, and even if it is governed by English Law, what actual assets does Holdings have? Its all Balance Sheet

I agree it is most likely to be repaid when the club is sold, but this could be another situation similar to the Peace loan.

Why do we have the Guarantee now? Has the EOD been remedied? If so what are the terms? Has this loan been amended to no fixed repayment date? Can we Determine the Guarantee now, default the loan and call in the Guarantee?

This Guarantee probably has no Commercial Benefit in any case. We have more chance of enforcing a parking fine.

I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

It hasn’t been written off.  It’s been impaired - which means the value of the loan as an asset has been written down in our books, but it still exists and is still repayable.  Standard accounting practice applies by the auditors to write down the loan on grounds of prudence, because of the risk of the asset not being recovered.

So many people are getting confused by the difference between writing off the debt and writing down the value of the asset.

(03-31-2023, 11:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 07:47 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: There is no security with it, and even if it is governed by English Law, what actual assets does Holdings have? Its all Balance Sheet

I agree it is most likely to be repaid when the club is sold, but this could be another situation similar to the Peace loan.

Why do we have the Guarantee now? Has the EOD been remedied? If so what are the terms? Has this loan been amended to no fixed repayment date? Can we Determine the Guarantee now, default the loan and call in the Guarantee?

This Guarantee probably has no Commercial Benefit in any case. We have more chance of enforcing a parking fine.

I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

The guarantee will have been negotiated after the loan went into default, FF, or as the new repayment date was agreed. 

If you look at the accounts for Holdings as at June 2021, these are presented as Consolidated. If you dig a bit deeper into the accounts it shows you the Balance Sheet of Holdings at company level. The only assets it has are it's shares in the subsidiary trading companies. The guarantee is worthless.

I disagree.  The asset of Holdings (via the Jersey company) is the capital value of the 88% holding in Group.  Whether consolidated or not, if Holdings sells then 88% of the sale proceeds go to Holdings, and that’s when we would get repaid (if not already repaid by then).  It’s not true to say that the guarantee is worthless.

Prag…

With reduced the debt to zero and charged the p&l account with the full value of the debt.  In my view, as far as the accounts go, we’ve written the whole lot off. 

Seems odd the auditors have insisted on writing it down to zero as at june 2022

Yes that’s a prudent accounting provision in accordance with accounting policies. But that is 100% not the same as writing off the debt. It remains fully recoverable. 

The auditors take into account what is known at the date of signing the accounts. What is known is that the revised promised repayment date of 31 December was missed, as was the promise to repay it early in the New Year.  The auditors had no alternative.
Reply
#14
(03-31-2023, 02:13 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 07:47 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-30-2023, 10:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-30-2023, 09:18 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The guarantee is worth fuck all. How are you going to enforce it? The beneficial owner is guaranteeing itself.

No - if and when the club gets sold that’s where 88% of the sale proceeds go.  That’s when we’d get paid back - if not prior to that.  It’s far better than Wisdom Smart having no guarantor.  At least we know that Holdings has an asset worth probably £60m+.  Wisdom Smart clearly has nothing

There is no security with it, and even if it is governed by English Law, what actual assets does Holdings have? Its all Balance Sheet

I agree it is most likely to be repaid when the club is sold, but this could be another situation similar to the Peace loan.

Why do we have the Guarantee now? Has the EOD been remedied? If so what are the terms? Has this loan been amended to no fixed repayment date? Can we Determine the Guarantee now, default the loan and call in the Guarantee?

This Guarantee probably has no Commercial Benefit in any case. We have more chance of enforcing a parking fine.

I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

It hasn’t been written off.  It’s been impaired - which means the value of the loan as an asset has been written down in our books, but it still exists and is still repayable.  Standard accounting practice applies by the auditors to write down the loan on grounds of prudence, because of the risk of the asset not being recovered.

So many people are getting confused by the difference between writing off the debt and writing down the value of the asset.

(03-31-2023, 11:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 07:47 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-30-2023, 10:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: No - if and when the club gets sold that’s where 88% of the sale proceeds go.  That’s when we’d get paid back - if not prior to that.  It’s far better than Wisdom Smart having no guarantor.  At least we know that Holdings has an asset worth probably £60m+.  Wisdom Smart clearly has nothing

There is no security with it, and even if it is governed by English Law, what actual assets does Holdings have? Its all Balance Sheet

I agree it is most likely to be repaid when the club is sold, but this could be another situation similar to the Peace loan.

Why do we have the Guarantee now? Has the EOD been remedied? If so what are the terms? Has this loan been amended to no fixed repayment date? Can we Determine the Guarantee now, default the loan and call in the Guarantee?

This Guarantee probably has no Commercial Benefit in any case. We have more chance of enforcing a parking fine.

I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

The guarantee will have been negotiated after the loan went into default, FF, or as the new repayment date was agreed. 

If you look at the accounts for Holdings as at June 2021, these are presented as Consolidated. If you dig a bit deeper into the accounts it shows you the Balance Sheet of Holdings at company level. The only assets it has are it's shares in the subsidiary trading companies. The guarantee is worthless.

I disagree.  The asset of Holdings (via the Jersey company) is the capital value of the 88% holding in Group.  Whether consolidated or not, if Holdings sells then 88% of the sale proceeds go to Holdings, and that’s when we would get repaid (if not already repaid by then).  It’s not true to say that the guarantee is worthless.

The only assets that Holdings has is the share capital of the subsidiaries. There isn't £5M of cash (or any other assets) that can be liquidated to repay this. If the club is sold, then this is another situation similar to the Peace loan (though legally different) in that the club will be ultimately liable for the repayment of the debt. Whilst this means that any negotiated sale may take this into effect, this loan has gone B&D, and many of us could be forgiven for thinking that whilst the guarantee liability exists, this will be the last we see of the cash.

I think the guarantee is worthless, because if Holdings pays this back, it is effectively coming from either up-streamed dividends (S4A will get excited) or the sale of the shares. The only thing this may do is suppress the sale value by c£5M, but the cash has left anyway.
Reply
#15
(03-31-2023, 02:50 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:13 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 07:47 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-30-2023, 10:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: No - if and when the club gets sold that’s where 88% of the sale proceeds go.  That’s when we’d get paid back - if not prior to that.  It’s far better than Wisdom Smart having no guarantor.  At least we know that Holdings has an asset worth probably £60m+.  Wisdom Smart clearly has nothing

There is no security with it, and even if it is governed by English Law, what actual assets does Holdings have? Its all Balance Sheet

I agree it is most likely to be repaid when the club is sold, but this could be another situation similar to the Peace loan.

Why do we have the Guarantee now? Has the EOD been remedied? If so what are the terms? Has this loan been amended to no fixed repayment date? Can we Determine the Guarantee now, default the loan and call in the Guarantee?

This Guarantee probably has no Commercial Benefit in any case. We have more chance of enforcing a parking fine.

I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

It hasn’t been written off.  It’s been impaired - which means the value of the loan as an asset has been written down in our books, but it still exists and is still repayable.  Standard accounting practice applies by the auditors to write down the loan on grounds of prudence, because of the risk of the asset not being recovered.

So many people are getting confused by the difference between writing off the debt and writing down the value of the asset.

(03-31-2023, 11:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 07:47 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: There is no security with it, and even if it is governed by English Law, what actual assets does Holdings have? Its all Balance Sheet

I agree it is most likely to be repaid when the club is sold, but this could be another situation similar to the Peace loan.

Why do we have the Guarantee now? Has the EOD been remedied? If so what are the terms? Has this loan been amended to no fixed repayment date? Can we Determine the Guarantee now, default the loan and call in the Guarantee?

This Guarantee probably has no Commercial Benefit in any case. We have more chance of enforcing a parking fine.

I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

The guarantee will have been negotiated after the loan went into default, FF, or as the new repayment date was agreed. 

If you look at the accounts for Holdings as at June 2021, these are presented as Consolidated. If you dig a bit deeper into the accounts it shows you the Balance Sheet of Holdings at company level. The only assets it has are it's shares in the subsidiary trading companies. The guarantee is worthless.

I disagree.  The asset of Holdings (via the Jersey company) is the capital value of the 88% holding in Group.  Whether consolidated or not, if Holdings sells then 88% of the sale proceeds go to Holdings, and that’s when we would get repaid (if not already repaid by then).  It’s not true to say that the guarantee is worthless.

The only assets that Holdings has is the share capital of the subsidiaries. There isn't £5M of cash (or any other assets) that can be liquidated to repay this. If the club is sold, then this is another situation similar to the Peace loan (though legally different) in that the club will be ultimately liable for the repayment of the debt. Whilst this means that any negotiated sale may take this into effect, this loan has gone B&D, and many of us could be forgiven for thinking that whilst the guarantee liability exists, this will be the last we see of the cash.

I think the guarantee is worthless, because if Holdings pays this back, it is effectively coming from either up-streamed dividends (S4A will get excited) or the sale of the shares. The only thing this may do is suppress the sale value by c£5M, but the cash has left anyway.

But the loan wasn’t made to Wba holdings. It went out the door to an unrelated company, other than Lai has his fingers in the noodles of wisdom.  This is where the directors should questioned as to why they allowed cash to go to an external 3rd party other than doing so because the controlling shareholder (Lai & Co) told them to.
Reply
#16
(03-31-2023, 02:50 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:13 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 07:47 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-30-2023, 10:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: No - if and when the club gets sold that’s where 88% of the sale proceeds go.  That’s when we’d get paid back - if not prior to that.  It’s far better than Wisdom Smart having no guarantor.  At least we know that Holdings has an asset worth probably £60m+.  Wisdom Smart clearly has nothing

There is no security with it, and even if it is governed by English Law, what actual assets does Holdings have? Its all Balance Sheet

I agree it is most likely to be repaid when the club is sold, but this could be another situation similar to the Peace loan.

Why do we have the Guarantee now? Has the EOD been remedied? If so what are the terms? Has this loan been amended to no fixed repayment date? Can we Determine the Guarantee now, default the loan and call in the Guarantee?

This Guarantee probably has no Commercial Benefit in any case. We have more chance of enforcing a parking fine.

I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

It hasn’t been written off.  It’s been impaired - which means the value of the loan as an asset has been written down in our books, but it still exists and is still repayable.  Standard accounting practice applies by the auditors to write down the loan on grounds of prudence, because of the risk of the asset not being recovered.

So many people are getting confused by the difference between writing off the debt and writing down the value of the asset.

(03-31-2023, 11:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 07:47 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: There is no security with it, and even if it is governed by English Law, what actual assets does Holdings have? Its all Balance Sheet

I agree it is most likely to be repaid when the club is sold, but this could be another situation similar to the Peace loan.

Why do we have the Guarantee now? Has the EOD been remedied? If so what are the terms? Has this loan been amended to no fixed repayment date? Can we Determine the Guarantee now, default the loan and call in the Guarantee?

This Guarantee probably has no Commercial Benefit in any case. We have more chance of enforcing a parking fine.

I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

The guarantee will have been negotiated after the loan went into default, FF, or as the new repayment date was agreed. 

If you look at the accounts for Holdings as at June 2021, these are presented as Consolidated. If you dig a bit deeper into the accounts it shows you the Balance Sheet of Holdings at company level. The only assets it has are it's shares in the subsidiary trading companies. The guarantee is worthless.

I disagree.  The asset of Holdings (via the Jersey company) is the capital value of the 88% holding in Group.  Whether consolidated or not, if Holdings sells then 88% of the sale proceeds go to Holdings, and that’s when we would get repaid (if not already repaid by then).  It’s not true to say that the guarantee is worthless.

The only assets that Holdings has is the share capital of the subsidiaries. There isn't £5M of cash (or any other assets) that can be liquidated to repay this. If the club is sold, then this is another situation similar to the Peace loan (though legally different) in that the club will be ultimately liable for the repayment of the debt. Whilst this means that any negotiated sale may take this into effect, this loan has gone B&D, and many of us could be forgiven for thinking that whilst the guarantee liability exists, this will be the last we see of the cash.

I think the guarantee is worthless, because if Holdings pays this back, it is effectively coming from either up-streamed dividends (S4A will get excited) or the sale of the shares. The only thing this may do is suppress the sale value by c£5M, but the cash has left anyway.

No that’s not correct.  Holdings is Yunyai.  If the club is sold, Holdings receives the proceeds and the guarantee is enforced.   It doesn’t suppress the sale value to anybody other than Yunyai.  It doesn’t affect anybody else.
Reply
#17
Prag.

Why didn’t we simply create a specific provision for a bad debt against the loan? Even a 99% or 100% provision and still show the total loan outstanding in the balance sheet as a debtor if they believe it has some chance, of being repaid. That would have made more sense.
Reply
#18
(03-31-2023, 02:59 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:50 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:13 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 07:47 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: There is no security with it, and even if it is governed by English Law, what actual assets does Holdings have? Its all Balance Sheet

I agree it is most likely to be repaid when the club is sold, but this could be another situation similar to the Peace loan.

Why do we have the Guarantee now? Has the EOD been remedied? If so what are the terms? Has this loan been amended to no fixed repayment date? Can we Determine the Guarantee now, default the loan and call in the Guarantee?

This Guarantee probably has no Commercial Benefit in any case. We have more chance of enforcing a parking fine.

I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

It hasn’t been written off.  It’s been impaired - which means the value of the loan as an asset has been written down in our books, but it still exists and is still repayable.  Standard accounting practice applies by the auditors to write down the loan on grounds of prudence, because of the risk of the asset not being recovered.

So many people are getting confused by the difference between writing off the debt and writing down the value of the asset.

(03-31-2023, 11:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

The guarantee will have been negotiated after the loan went into default, FF, or as the new repayment date was agreed. 

If you look at the accounts for Holdings as at June 2021, these are presented as Consolidated. If you dig a bit deeper into the accounts it shows you the Balance Sheet of Holdings at company level. The only assets it has are it's shares in the subsidiary trading companies. The guarantee is worthless.

I disagree.  The asset of Holdings (via the Jersey company) is the capital value of the 88% holding in Group.  Whether consolidated or not, if Holdings sells then 88% of the sale proceeds go to Holdings, and that’s when we would get repaid (if not already repaid by then).  It’s not true to say that the guarantee is worthless.

The only assets that Holdings has is the share capital of the subsidiaries. There isn't £5M of cash (or any other assets) that can be liquidated to repay this. If the club is sold, then this is another situation similar to the Peace loan (though legally different) in that the club will be ultimately liable for the repayment of the debt. Whilst this means that any negotiated sale may take this into effect, this loan has gone B&D, and many of us could be forgiven for thinking that whilst the guarantee liability exists, this will be the last we see of the cash.

I think the guarantee is worthless, because if Holdings pays this back, it is effectively coming from either up-streamed dividends (S4A will get excited) or the sale of the shares. The only thing this may do is suppress the sale value by c£5M, but the cash has left anyway.

No that’s not correct.  Holdings is Yunyai.  If the club is sold, Holdings receives the proceeds and the guarantee is enforced.   It doesn’t suppress the sale value to anybody other than Yunyai.  It doesn’t affect anybody else.

Yunwai is the shareholder, not the guarantor, Prag. The liability with Shareholder rests with the equity invested, no more than this. Yunwai won't be paying anyyhing. Anybody buying Holdings will have a Guarantee liability as a Contingent Obligation to consider, and this will be factored into the sale price negotiations.
Reply
#19
Confucius say, "when Lai has his fingers in the noodles of wisdom...."  

Very profound, Prag   Wink
Reply
#20
(03-31-2023, 03:12 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:59 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:50 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 02:13 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-31-2023, 08:03 AM)Fulham Fallout Wrote: I’d like to know why we decided to write off the loan when we had re-scheduled the repayment date to Dec 22.   And during this period we’ve been told the loan will be repaid and yet not once was it mentioned it’s been written off in the books. 

Also, amazingly…… the very same time the accounts are released, we’re advised the loan will be repaid and has a guarantor. Did we suddenly receive notification yesterday about the guarantee and it’s all a co-incidence re the timing?  It all fucking stinks.

It hasn’t been written off.  It’s been impaired - which means the value of the loan as an asset has been written down in our books, but it still exists and is still repayable.  Standard accounting practice applies by the auditors to write down the loan on grounds of prudence, because of the risk of the asset not being recovered.

So many people are getting confused by the difference between writing off the debt and writing down the value of the asset.

(03-31-2023, 11:32 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The guarantee will have been negotiated after the loan went into default, FF, or as the new repayment date was agreed. 

If you look at the accounts for Holdings as at June 2021, these are presented as Consolidated. If you dig a bit deeper into the accounts it shows you the Balance Sheet of Holdings at company level. The only assets it has are it's shares in the subsidiary trading companies. The guarantee is worthless.

I disagree.  The asset of Holdings (via the Jersey company) is the capital value of the 88% holding in Group.  Whether consolidated or not, if Holdings sells then 88% of the sale proceeds go to Holdings, and that’s when we would get repaid (if not already repaid by then).  It’s not true to say that the guarantee is worthless.

The only assets that Holdings has is the share capital of the subsidiaries. There isn't £5M of cash (or any other assets) that can be liquidated to repay this. If the club is sold, then this is another situation similar to the Peace loan (though legally different) in that the club will be ultimately liable for the repayment of the debt. Whilst this means that any negotiated sale may take this into effect, this loan has gone B&D, and many of us could be forgiven for thinking that whilst the guarantee liability exists, this will be the last we see of the cash.

I think the guarantee is worthless, because if Holdings pays this back, it is effectively coming from either up-streamed dividends (S4A will get excited) or the sale of the shares. The only thing this may do is suppress the sale value by c£5M, but the cash has left anyway.

No that’s not correct.  Holdings is Yunyai.  If the club is sold, Holdings receives the proceeds and the guarantee is enforced.   It doesn’t suppress the sale value to anybody other than Yunyai.  It doesn’t affect anybody else.

Yunwai is the shareholder, not the guarantor, Prag. The liability with Shareholder rests with the equity invested, no more than this. Yunwai won't be paying anyyhing. Anybody buying Holdings will have a Guarantee liability as a Contingent Obligation to consider, and this will be factored into the sale price negotiations.

Holdings has entered into a specific guarantee to pay the debt.  I know that Yunyai is not the guarantor.  Holdings will not be able to pay away the net sale proceeds without settling the guarantee obligation.  

Nobody will be buying Holdings!   They will be buying the new clean Jersey company in between.  That’s specifically why it was put there to make it a lot cleaner for the purchaser in a sale without having to buy any murkiness and history re Holdings.   Holdings will sell
JerseyCo to a new owner, and Holdings will receive the sale proceeds.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: