Capital Gains Tax
#41
Then why the hell have you been defending the diverging rates based on source of income?
Reply
#42
(03-28-2023, 02:26 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Then why the hell have you been defending the diverging rates based on source of income?

Because I don't consider capital gains to be "income" in the way you do.

However I do believe that the outcome of tax simplification / harmonisation via Flat Tax is acceptable - because it would be far lower than the rate you suggest. Pragmatism, that's all.
Reply
#43
It's not me though, you're disagreeing with the universally established definition of what constitutes income for some bizarre reason.

The rate I would suggest for a hypothetical flat tax would be the rate required to cover operational public liabilities. Otherwise you don't have a sustainable economy. The very fact this thread was made in the first place is because I was pointing out the divergence in average rates which points out the difference in average rates applied to different types of income (the widely accepted definition of income, not the one that only you apply), especially considering that the median pre-tax income has a higher rate of income tax + NIC than Sunak's average rate of tax on his personal income - implying that any flat tax levied would result in Sunak's average rate increasing.
Reply
#44
(03-22-2023, 05:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Sunak's tax receipts are out.

He paid 36.6% of his earnings income as income tax.

He also paid 19.8% of his capital gains as capital gains tax.

Capital gains covered 73.2% of his taxable balance. Yet he paid significantly less as a proportion in CGT than IT. He paid less as a proportion of CGT than I paid in IT for fucks sakes.

How is that fair?

It's important to note that the UK tax system is complex and includes various allowances, exemptions, and rates that can affect the amount of tax an individual pays. Without knowing the specifics of Sunak's income sources and the deductions he was able to claim, it's difficult to assess whether his tax payments were fair or not.

However, in general, the UK tax system is designed to be progressive, meaning that individuals with higher incomes are expected to pay a higher proportion of their earnings in taxes. It's possible that Sunak's income sources or deductions allowed him to pay a lower proportion of his capital gains in tax compared to his income tax.

It's also worth noting that the tax system aims to strike a balance between raising revenue for the government and providing incentives for economic growth and investment. Capital gains tax rates may be set lower than income tax rates to encourage investment and entrepreneurship, which can benefit the economy as a whole.

Ultimately, whether Sunak's tax payments were fair or not is a matter of personal opinion and depends on a range of factors. However, it's important to consider the wider context of the UK tax system when evaluating individual tax payments.
Reply
#45
(04-21-2023, 08:35 AM)ErickBerry Wrote:
(03-22-2023, 05:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Sunak's tax receipts are out.

He paid 36.6% of his earnings income as income tax.

He also paid 19.8% of his capital gains as capital gains tax.

Capital gains covered 73.2% of his taxable balance. Yet he paid significantly less as a proportion in CGT than IT. He paid less as a proportion of CGT than I paid in IT for fucks sakes.

How is that fair?

It's important to note that the UK tax system is complex and includes various allowances, exemptions, and rates that can affect the amount of tax an individual pays. Without knowing the specifics of Sunak's income sources and the deductions he was able to claim, it's difficult to assess whether his tax payments were fair or not.

However, in general, the UK tax system is designed to be progressive, meaning that individuals with higher incomes are expected to pay a higher proportion of their earnings in taxes. It's possible that Sunak's income sources or deductions allowed him to pay a lower proportion of his capital gains in tax compared to his income tax.

It's also worth noting that the tax system aims to strike a balance between raising revenue for the government and providing incentives for economic growth and investment. Capital gains tax rates may be set lower than income tax rates to encourage investment and entrepreneurship, which can benefit the economy as a whole.

Ultimately, whether Sunak's tax payments were fair or not is a matter of personal opinion and depends on a range of factors. However, it's important to consider the wider context of the UK tax system when evaluating individual tax payments.

Looking at the link bottom left does that mean that Eric is a chatGPT creation by someone on here?
Reply
#46
(04-21-2023, 09:15 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(04-21-2023, 08:35 AM)ErickBerry Wrote:
(03-22-2023, 05:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Sunak's tax receipts are out.

He paid 36.6% of his earnings income as income tax.

He also paid 19.8% of his capital gains as capital gains tax.

Capital gains covered 73.2% of his taxable balance. Yet he paid significantly less as a proportion in CGT than IT. He paid less as a proportion of CGT than I paid in IT for fucks sakes.

How is that fair?

It's important to note that the UK tax system is complex and includes various allowances, exemptions, and rates that can affect the amount of tax an individual pays. Without knowing the specifics of Sunak's income sources and the deductions he was able to claim, it's difficult to assess whether his tax payments were fair or not.

However, in general, the UK tax system is designed to be progressive, meaning that individuals with higher incomes are expected to pay a higher proportion of their earnings in taxes. It's possible that Sunak's income sources or deductions allowed him to pay a lower proportion of his capital gains in tax compared to his income tax.

It's also worth noting that the tax system aims to strike a balance between raising revenue for the government and providing incentives for economic growth and investment. Capital gains tax rates may be set lower than income tax rates to encourage investment and entrepreneurship, which can benefit the economy as a whole.

Ultimately, whether Sunak's tax payments were fair or not is a matter of personal opinion and depends on a range of factors. However, it's important to consider the wider context of the UK tax system when evaluating individual tax payments.

Looking at the link bottom left does that mean that Eric is a chatGPT creation by someone on here?

Reads like something ChatGPT would output.

Seeing as it missed the point about CGT rates resulting in a regressive tax.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)