New FM
#11
(03-27-2023, 02:04 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Support for Scottish independence has been consistently polled between 45% to 52% yes over the last 9 years, where is the evidence it's waining? Westminster is still the boogeyman, as it has been with Sturgeon and Salmond using it as a convenient scapegoat to cover their failings in Holyrood

All the polls since Sturgeon. announced she was leaving, with the exception of one that I never heard of have been below 45%, with last 2 40% and 39%

Fair amount of undecided
Reply
#12
(03-27-2023, 02:18 PM)strawman Wrote:
(03-27-2023, 02:04 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Support for Scottish independence has been consistently polled between 45% to 52% yes over the last 9 years, where is the evidence it's waining? Westminster is still the boogeyman, as it has been with Sturgeon and Salmond using it as a convenient scapegoat to cover their failings in Holyrood

All the polls since Sturgeon. announced she was leaving, with the exception of one that I never heard of have been below 45%, with last 2 40% and 39%

Fair amount of undecided

I'm excluding don't knows

(03-27-2023, 02:14 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-27-2023, 02:04 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Westminster is still the boogeyman, as it has been with Sturgeon and Salmond using it as a convenient scapegoat to cover their failings in Holyrood

I don't consider the Scots to be daft. You can only fool people for so long.

Going well for Northern Ireland that is.
Reply
#13
(03-27-2023, 01:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote: If Labour can't beat this guy on his lamentable record in government and questionable voting record then they simply don't deserve to gain a foothold in Scotland again.

Particularly as he won by the thick end of fuck all and will be weakened because of it.

Did you describe the Brexit victory in such terms.

You are right it causes an issue, but I'm not certain that in the long term support foe independence will wane. 

Can Labour benefit in Scotland, maybe in a Westminster election, but even then I'm not sure.
Reply
#14
(03-27-2023, 03:19 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(03-27-2023, 01:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote: If Labour can't beat this guy on his lamentable record in government and questionable voting record then they simply don't deserve to gain a foothold in Scotland again.

Particularly as he won by the thick end of fuck all and will be weakened because of it.

Did you describe the Brexit victory in such terms.

You are right it causes an issue, but I'm not certain that in the long term support foe independence will wane. 

Can Labour benefit in Scotland, maybe in a Westminster election, but even then I'm not sure.

Brexit didn't need 2nd preference votes to scrape home, and let's be honest it's hardly the same thing is it?
Reply
#15
(03-27-2023, 04:28 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-27-2023, 03:19 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(03-27-2023, 01:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote: If Labour can't beat this guy on his lamentable record in government and questionable voting record then they simply don't deserve to gain a foothold in Scotland again.

Particularly as he won by the thick end of fuck all and will be weakened because of it.

Did you describe the Brexit victory in such terms.

You are right it causes an issue, but I'm not certain that in the long term support foe independence will wane. 

Can Labour benefit in Scotland, maybe in a Westminster election, but even then I'm not sure.

Brexit didn't need 2nd preference votes to scrape home, and let's be honest it's hardly the same thing is it?

No it's more important.

I'm not a fan of referendum. Close results leave divided nations.

And this close result leaves a potentially divided party.

If I was a SNP strategist I wouldn't  worry about the next decade too much. Given that younger Scots are more likely to be in favour of independence than older Scots, I think waiting before pushing for another independence referendum.

In the meantime, a Starmer govt will probably have extinguished any hope of good governance for Scotland by Westminster.
Reply
#16
Quite right about referendums. Asking a question of in or out always leaves the side that will bring change likely to turn out disproportionately more strongly than turning up to say let’s just carry on
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#17
(03-27-2023, 05:42 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Quite right about referendums. Asking a question of in or out always leaves the side that will bring change likely to turn out disproportionately more strongly than turning up to say let’s just carry on

Except in Scotland, clearly.

And except in most Mayoral referendums where change was enforced anyway.

And except on the vote to remain in the Common Market.

Oh yes, and the AV referendum. How could I forget the Lib Dems selling their collective souls for that one.
Reply
#18
Because one side wins doesn’t mean the vote was proportional to the wider population ya dummy
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#19
(03-27-2023, 05:58 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Because one side wins doesn’t mean the vote was proportional to the wider population ya dummy

You said the side that "will bring change [is] likely to turn out disproportionately more strongly than turning up to say let’s just carry on".

The results I cited suggest that's bollocks.
Reply
#20
They do nothing of the sort. They suggest there was enough of a buffer in the proportion that didn’t want change for the outcome to still reflect that view. I can fetch the puppets if needed?
Someone could have been killed
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: