New FM
#1
Well the SNP have given Labour an open goal then.
Reply
#2
No they haven't. Labour are targeting the central belt, the open goal was Forbes. Tartan Toryism isn't popular in Glasgow.

Yousuf is incompetent but at he's the lesser of two evils around the metro areas of Clyde and Lothian for SNP members.
Reply
#3
If Labour can't beat this guy on his lamentable record in government and questionable voting record then they simply don't deserve to gain a foothold in Scotland again.

Particularly as he won by the thick end of fuck all and will be weakened because of it.
Reply
#4
Thought this was going to be about the latest instalment of the popular football management sim.
Reply
#5
(03-27-2023, 01:25 PM)Protheroe Wrote: If Labour can't beat this guy on his lamentable record in government and questionable voting record then they simply don't deserve to gain a foothold in Scotland again.

Particularly as he won by the thick end of fuck all and will be weakened because of it.

When has nationalism ever followed reason? Sturgeon and Salmond had a terrible record in government yet they were kept on.

Labour's best chance was for Forbes to get in and the Scottish nationalist vote to be split between the SNP and Scottish Greens.
Reply
#6
(03-27-2023, 01:30 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: When has nationalism ever followed reason? Sturgeon and Salmond had a terrible record in government yet they were kept on.

When the Scots were presented with Miliband and Corbyn at General Elections, yes. 

And Humza is not Sturgeon or Salmond. Like them or loathe them they had a certain charisma, and keeping the momentum up for Independence is going to be a tough job.
Reply
#7
It's quite simple really Proth.

FPTP is undemocratic and favours the Scottish nationalists, the vast majority of nationalists have their opinion settled on the issue (hence the lack of movement on the issue of a referendum over the last decade) and Labour don't support an independence referendum so that nationalists won't vote for them.

Has fuck all to do with who's the Labour leader and everything to do with the spoiler effect as part of FPTP. The best chance for Labour is to amplify the spoiler effect on the nationalists side a.k.a. split the vote between the Scottish Greens and SNP which Forbes and Regan were more likely to do. As it is Labour can only really hope for Scottish unionists holding their nose and voting for them instead of staying at home/voting Tory or Scottish Lib Dem which didn't happen in 2019 or 2015 or 2010. And I highly doubt that the young people in the central belt give a shit about Corbyn's economic or foreign policy given they vote SNP.
Reply
#8
Like I said, as enthusiasm for Independence wanes (which it is and I expect it to further) then Labour ought to step into the breach.
Reply
#9
Support for Scottish independence has been consistently polled between 45% to 52% yes over the last 9 years, where is the evidence it's waining? Westminster is still the boogeyman, as it has been with Sturgeon and Salmond using it as a convenient scapegoat to cover their failings in Holyrood
Reply
#10
(03-27-2023, 02:04 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Westminster is still the boogeyman, as it has been with Sturgeon and Salmond using it as a convenient scapegoat to cover their failings in Holyrood

I don't consider the Scots to be daft. You can only fool people for so long.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: