Action4Albion
#61
(03-26-2023, 06:08 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-26-2023, 06:03 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: New Auditors? I missed that. Have the last ones resigned? That's a story

Yes PwC resigned last year after the audit.  New auditors are Azets.

Christ. I sacked Azets because of their lack of attention to detail  Big Grin
Reply
#62
(03-26-2023, 06:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-26-2023, 06:08 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-26-2023, 06:03 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: New Auditors? I missed that. Have the last ones resigned? That's a story

Yes PwC resigned last year after the audit.  New auditors are Azets.

Christ. I sacked Azets because of their lack of attention to detail  Big Grin


I take considerable comfort from knowing that MSD will have done extensive due diligence bevies agreeing to lend to Group
Reply
#63
(03-26-2023, 06:56 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-26-2023, 06:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-26-2023, 06:08 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-26-2023, 06:03 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: New Auditors? I missed that. Have the last ones resigned? That's a story

Yes PwC resigned last year after the audit.  New auditors are Azets.

Christ. I sacked Azets because of their lack of attention to detail  Big Grin


I take considerable comfort from knowing that MSD will have done extensive due diligence bevies agreeing to lend to Group

I wouldn't go that far, Prag. I could tell you horror stories where bank's have lost a lot more than £20M!

I don't know a  banker who would put their name to this. The only clear exit is by taking control of the club via Administration and selling to the highest bidder.

Yes we may get promoted, we may have assets to sell, but there are no guarantees. My personal view is that MSD have an agenda for lending to football clubs. I'm not rightly sure what that agenda is, though!
Reply
#64
(03-26-2023, 06:12 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: Fuck Lai and how 'legal' it is. It is fucking Immoral, that's all. Fuck him and keep going until him and his like have fucked off for good.

(03-24-2023, 12:20 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: He’s done a fantastic job of drumming up support and media interest. It’s great Albion supporters have the time in their lives to do this and devote it to Albion.

All of that said, we are a privately owned company, with shareholders across China. They simply do not care and it will have limited effect on them or the future of the club. It is that simple.

Unless someone wants to buy is at a price they want to accept nothing will change. They’re hardly going to feel any pressure from thousands of miles away.

For all the hard work and dedication, since this campaign started the situation has got worse not better. Not only do we not have the loans repaid we have a new loan charge over the assets of the club.

If you sit and take this approach, then don't moan if we miss out on the play-offs. It is this approach which saw us a striker short this season. And a RB short.

What are you in about?

A4A aren’t going to affect our promotion or what we spend. It’s a noble pursuit but it has zero levers. 

As I said it’s got worse not better. The £20m loan came after the protests started. 

I applaud what they’re doing but it has no levers, no incentives and no ability to influence.
Reply
#65
(03-26-2023, 07:52 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-26-2023, 06:56 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-26-2023, 06:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-26-2023, 06:08 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-26-2023, 06:03 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: New Auditors? I missed that. Have the last ones resigned? That's a story

Yes PwC resigned last year after the audit.  New auditors are Azets.

Christ. I sacked Azets because of their lack of attention to detail  Big Grin


I take considerable comfort from knowing that MSD will have done extensive due diligence bevies agreeing to lend to Group

I wouldn't go that far, Prag. I could tell you horror stories where bank's have lost a lot more than £20M!

I don't know a  banker who would put their name to this. The only clear exit is by taking control of the club via Administration and selling to the highest bidder.

Yes we may get promoted, we may have assets to sell, but there are no guarantees. My personal view is that MSD have an agenda for lending to football clubs. I'm not rightly sure what that agenda is, though!

I know MSD and I know how they operate.  They won’t be losing any money on this loan, primarily because there is no other debt.  And I believe  they can take control via their debenture in the event of default without the group actually going into formal administration. 

In fact, MSD should be already banging the table over the non-repayment of the Wisdom Smart loan as it materially affects cash flow.  One to keep an eye on.
Reply
#66
The approach to lending money has evolved during my career. The provision of security, whilst highly important, is not the number 1 priority. Lenders don't "porn broke' any more.

You are right, they will be in control, and shouldn't lose money, but an exit could take time, and you have the ongoing costs of running the club whilst this happens.

I remember using your (valid) reasoning to a ratings agency and investment bank just before the 2008 crash. I was working on a Securitisation at the time. They disagreed with me, saying in the event of Default, just get out as quickly as you can and move on. That is the difference in approach.

Lending money profitably these days is measured by how little intervention is needed to collect the interest and have the capital repaid. I'm not scare-mongering, but if it did go wrong, it could take as long as Derby to resolve. I guess the club is worth £50M in its present state. If it takes 12 months to sell, with professional costs and rolling interst on the loan, the costs to exit might be £30M+ (all fag packet figures).

So they are in at 60%+ of the NAV of the club. That would be too much for many in a very volatile sector.
Reply
#67
(03-26-2023, 09:01 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The approach to lending money has evolved during my career. The provision of security, whilst highly important, is not the number 1 priority. Lenders don't "porn broke' any more.

You are right, they will be in control, and shouldn't lose money, but an exit could take time, and you have the ongoing costs of running the club whilst this happens.

I remember using your (valid) reasoning to a ratings agency and investment bank just before the 2008 crash. I was working on a Securitisation at the time. They disagreed with me, saying in the event of Default, just get out as quickly as you can and move on. That is the difference in approach.

Lending money profitably these days is measured by how little intervention is needed to collect the interest and have the capital repaid. I'm not scare-mongering, but if it did go wrong, it could take as long as Derby to resolve. I guess the club is worth £50M in its present state. If it takes 12 months to sell, with professional costs and rolling interst on the loan, the costs to exit might be £30M+ (all fag packet figures).

So they are in at 60%+ of the NAV of the club. That would be too much for many in a very volatile sector.

There’s no comparison at all with Derby.  Derby owed just under £200m to Mel Morris and had already sold the ground to a company owned by him.  They were an absolute basket case long before MSD came into the scene when Morris stopped funding them. 

The reality is that banks no longer lend to football clubs.  As you say, it doesn’t fit their model.  It’s all Macquarie and MSD these days - specialist lenders with an appetite to earn double-digit interest on a secured loan.
Reply
#68
I'm not comparing to Derby from a risk perspective, Prag. I'm comparing from a Banker's recovery prospective.

You only earn double digits if you actually get your capital back. And you are only secured here if West Brom still have a Golden Share and league membership. 

The 90 day Vacant Possession value (which many of these lenders use in high risk scenarios) of the properties will be a fraction of going concern value. The decent players will already have been sold to reduce costs and keep the ship afloat.

This is absolute armageddon, but that's what A4A want us to be worried about.

Regarding Administration, I haven't read the Debenture on Companies House. I'm guessing the only way this could work would be with a charge over the shares of the controlling party. You would want this to be a Legal Charge rather than an Equitable Charge, and I can't see this on the Companies House register? Would welcome your thoughts.
Reply
#69
So, by Lai referring to Wisdom Smart as his "related party", he means it is owned by his missus/mom/sister/aunt?

If the business isn't trading and had funds after the £24m in shares was paid back, then why did it need a loan in the first place?

Is Lai recouping the money that he paid for the club by "doing a Peace"?

These are rhetorical questions, by the way. I wouldn't expect anybody other than those directly involved to know the answers.
Reply
#70
(03-27-2023, 08:55 AM)baggie_ray Wrote: So, by Lai referring to Wisdom Smart as his "related party", he means it is owned by his missus/mom/sister/aunt?

If the business isn't trading and had funds after the £24m in shares was paid back, then why did it need a loan in the first place?

Is Lai recouping the money that he paid for the club by "doing a Peace"?

These are rhetorical questions, by the way. I wouldn't expect anybody other than those directly involved to know the answers.

It doesn’t appear to be owned by anybody (obviously) connected with him, but it could indeed be a relative (or mistress).

It’s not certain that Wisdom Smart had funds to cover its creditors after the £24m was paid back. Wisdom Smart signed a Solvency Statement but was it true?  There are lots of questions to be asked there and it’s Ken as director of Group (as lender) who needs to be asking them - as well as the auditors.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: