Action4Albion
#51
(03-26-2023, 02:23 PM)baggie_ray Wrote:
(03-23-2023, 04:56 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Maybe this is something that everyone else knows and I was asleep when it was discussed/revealed.


Did Lai personally take the loan or was it made to another company that Lai has an interest in. 

Would be surprised if the loan was made to Lai. 

Makes the issue of a dividend to re pay the loan unlikely if it was made to another company .

Surprised nobody has answered this as it is the pivotal point in everything.

The loan went to another of Lai's companies. That company needed the loan in order for it to be able to continue trading (I presume it wasnt just a means to take money out of the Albion). That company needed the money because it was (again presumably) losing money. 

If so, there is no way that company would now be making such a profit in such a short period of time that it could afford to repay the loan in full. If it can't repay the loan at this point, we won't be getting our money back anytime soon.

Lai or his consortium would appear not to have the funds themselves, else they could have just funded the other company themselves, rather than having to take it from another of their companies. As such, Lai and his consortium won't be paying the Albion back anytime soon.

Whether Lai is losing face or not, if he, and/or his consortium, or the other company do not have the money to repay the loan, it won't be repaid.

I believe it was a CoVid cash flow problem, well that’s how it was portrayed.  It’s common to just move money around companies that are of common ownership.  Albion had it sitting there and the company needed it.

If the other company can no longer afford to repay it then it could become a bad debt and we may never see the money.  That will depend if any security was taken or if someone gave a personal guarantee. 

I suspect we’ll never see the money. All we can be grateful for at the moment is they don’t appear to be blatantly asset stripping the club, which looked ominous when they were trying to get the Pereira money back to China.  I suspect other deals across other owned companies had some benefit of that sale…

I’d say say keep up the good work, we all know we can’t force them to sell etc. but if it gives him any embarrassment at all then it’s doing it’s job, may just make them act quicker into getting rid of the hassle.  

And then we start all over again…
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#52
When you say Covid problem, was it a lab in Wuhan?

Joking aside, this could very well become a bad debt, and a write off (which goes against our FFP loses). I presume the Articles of Association allow the Limited Company to make the loan. Whether the company officers have breached the Companies Act, I wouldn’t know, but I'm guessing not. It would seem that whilst all of us are pissed off about this, I suspect practically there is little that can be done.

It will be interesting to see how this is classified in the accounts (i.e Creditor within 12 mths, Creditor due after 12 mths, or written off as a Bad Debt) but we won't know that until next March when the accounts are distributed to the minority shareholders.
Reply
#53
If the loan was due to cash-flow issues at the other company I'd have more hope of seeing the money returned. Although that would be dependent on if and when those cash-flow issues are resolved. I doubt that will happen soon, in the current financial climate.
Reply
#54
A lot of inaccuracies being stated here.

Lai is neither a director nor a shareholder of Wisdom Smart. He is neither a director nor a shareholder of the Chinese company which owns 49% of Wisdom Smart. Is is not obvious therefore that he even has any connection to Wisdom Smart.

From public source info in Hong Kong, in May 2022 was worth at least HK$240m (around £24m). We know that because in May 2022 the sole director of Wisdom Smart signed a Solvency Statement confirming that the company would be solvent - ie after repaying all of its debts ! - immediately after repaying HK$239,990,000 to its shareholders. So how come it was solvent in May 2022 (and so could repay us), but hasn’t done so?

There is no evidence whatsoever that Wisdom Smart is a “trading” company at all. We simply don’t know.

The sole director of West Bromwich Albion Group Limited did not “breach the law” when making the loan to Wisdom Smart. However, he acted in breach of his fiduciary duty owed to the Company by making a loan which could not possibly have been made in the best interests of the Company. The only remedy for that can be for the 12% minority shareholders to bring an action against the sole director personally for that breach of fiduciary duty, but that can only happen if the minority shareholders have actually suffered a loss as a result of that breach of fiduciary duty. Right now, there is no such loss to the minority shareholders. That might change when the latest audited accounts are published this week, because the new auditors will have had to assess the recoverability of that unpaid loan. There is no need to wait until next year to find that out - the auditors have to form a view now re the recoverability of that debt when signing off the June 2022 audited accounts.

This week could be interesting.
Reply
#55
With regard to the June 22 accounts, Prag, they may be filed this week but that doesn't mean they were signed off this week. I wouldn't be surprised to see they were signed prior to 31st December 2022 which was the last agreed repayment date. By doing this they wouldn't have been concerned by a payment that hadn't been missed.

Even if the accounts were finalised and signed recently, would the minority shareholders as a group want to incur the costs of legal action, which wouldn't be cheap.

It keeps coming back to my main point that everyone is toothless in this, unless the minority shareholders fancy an expensive legal battle.
Reply
#56
(03-26-2023, 05:51 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: With regard to the June 22 accounts, Prag, they may be filed this week but that doesn't mean they were signed off this week. I wouldn't be surprised to see they were signed prior to 31st December 2022 which was the last agreed repayment date. By doing this they wouldn't have been concerned by a payment that hadn't been missed.

Even if the accounts were finalised and signed recently, would the minority shareholders as a group want to incur the costs of legal action, which wouldn't be cheap.

It keeps coming back to my main point that everyone is toothless in this, unless the minority shareholders fancy an expensive legal battle.

I’m certain that they won’t have been signed off until very recently, but regardless of that, the new auditors are still required to investigate the the recoverability of the loan.  It’s a material sum and with it already being in default they will not be glossing over it.
Reply
#57
New Auditors? I missed that. Have the last ones resigned? That's a story
Reply
#58
(03-26-2023, 06:03 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: New Auditors? I missed that. Have the last ones resigned? That's a story

Yes PwC resigned last year after the audit.  New auditors are Azets.
Reply
#59
Fuck Lai and how 'legal' it is. It is fucking Immoral, that's all. Fuck him and keep going until him and his like have fucked off for good.

(03-24-2023, 12:20 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: He’s done a fantastic job of drumming up support and media interest. It’s great Albion supporters have the time in their lives to do this and devote it to Albion.

All of that said, we are a privately owned company, with shareholders across China. They simply do not care and it will have limited effect on them or the future of the club. It is that simple.

Unless someone wants to buy is at a price they want to accept nothing will change. They’re hardly going to feel any pressure from thousands of miles away.

For all the hard work and dedication, since this campaign started the situation has got worse not better. Not only do we not have the loans repaid we have a new loan charge over the assets of the club.

If you sit and take this approach, then don't moan if we miss out on the play-offs. It is this approach which saw us a striker short this season. And a RB short.
Reply
#60
(03-26-2023, 06:08 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-26-2023, 06:03 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: New Auditors? I missed that. Have the last ones resigned? That's a story

Yes PwC resigned last year after the audit.  New auditors are Azets.

As a lender I was always taught to question a change in Auditors, because it was possible that the Auditors weren't happy with certain aspects of financial conduct. 

This isn't always the case, but it is unusual for a firm to lose business. Given the international ownership, you would want to see a top tier firm on the ticket.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: