Capital Gains Tax
#11
All tax is theft (or at the very least extortion). You can make that exact argument for income tax, corporation tax, national insurance etc etc etc. That's the price citizens pay to participate in society.

It's theft with a utilitarian benefit, as is the logic behind stealing bread to feed the hungry or why Robin Hood was the good guy. Capital gains are a type of income, therefore they are taxed as is the case with all income. Not equalising that with average rates results in the state stealing more as a proportion from the poor than the rich, which goes right back to the issue of income taken as capital gains tax resulting in a lower average rate than income taken from producing labour - which is bullshit.
Reply
#12
Capital Gains are the return on risk, I don't agree with your contention that they're a type of income.
Reply
#13
Do you realise those capital gains at the point of extraction (profit) in some form other than a monetary one?

If not, it's a form of income. As are dividends.
Reply
#14
I do not consider the realisation of a capital gain to be income in the same way as salary - which is what I believe you were getting at in the OP and the "unfairness" of the tax treatment.

In my situation I have PGs all over the place that put me and my family at personal financial risk should any of our businesses fail. The state will bear none of the downside, but wants a fifth of the upside for no risk. Equalise that with my marginal rate of tax and the state gets at least two-fifths of the upside for no risk.

We won't agree on this point.

If the State recognises the benefit of CGT free risk taking in ISAs and (certain) Gold coins, then why not the businesses that I've spent 14 years building?
Reply
#15
I don't really care about your consideration because it's wrong, if you realise capital gains in a monetary means then that is income. As in, it is literally covered quite bluntly by the dictionary definition of the word income in both British English and American English.

The unfairness relates to the discrepancy between the average rates between labour and capital gains resulting in something that is, objectively, a regressive distribution. As a utilitarian (a foundational tenet of being a liberal, in the Classical sense) that is very bad. As someone who recognises the need for the state to be fiscally responsible and is very opposed to borrowing to cover general expenditure (as opposed to infrastructure investment), I am aware of the lack of capacity for the state to enable income tax cuts. Therefore, to deal with that discrepancy in a utilitarian manner, that average rate gap should be bridged.


The state doesn't care about the risk you put up, much as it doesn't care about the time and effort I put in to produce my labour. All it cares about is the output. As is the case with every single tax. The only consideration the state takes in is that capital gains needs to be incentivised more than passive dividends which is why CGT has both a higher allowance and a lower rate than income tax on dividends. Which is why I pointed to a small bump at the higher rate instead of equalising it.
Reply
#16
I said we wouldn't agree.

And the CGT allowance is now barely above the Dividend Tax allowance and the initial rate is higher than Dividend Tax too.
Reply
#17
You can disagree with evolution for all I care, I'm just calling you out for contradicting the established and accepted definition of income.

And I've already said I want the personal allowance for CGT and IT equalised, as for the rates for dividends there is no excuse there not to equalise that with IT across the board.
Reply
#18
Do that and watch most small businesses pack up.

I'd just a get a non-job at the Council. Bugger all effort, great hours and conditions, no stress, guaranteed pension, sick pay, paid holidays etc

You're just another red in yellow clothing.
Reply
#19
Ah yes, aligning myself with Margaret Thatcher's/Nigel Lawson's tax policy makes me a socialist. Really "nuanced" analysis that.

You're just a mercantile high Tory with the "low tax for me, high tax for thee" attitude.
Reply
#20
FWIW, I've paid capital gains tax on more than one occasion. It is purely on profit and had certain allowable expenses including a quite favourable 'length of time owned' tapir adjustment. It was an additional income as far as I could see. Or, a price we pay for being in a society. How the taxed money is distributed is the only argument I see, otherwise it is simply income. As I say, it wasn't so punitive, IMO.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: