Motd
#41
(03-13-2023, 10:18 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Just tweeted that he restarts on Saturday but managed to slide in a few comments re refugees and tolerant country in a 4 tweet chain.  Suspect there will be a fair amount of right wing piss boilt over the coming days.

Not really bothered as I don't watch MotD, due to the fact I don't really have an interest in the Prem, but I also stopped watching as the punditry is laughably poor, to the point it ruins the product. 

If Lineker isn't the presenter, some other smug, overpaid and overrated presenter will get the gig. I've no issue with what he said, but how he said it. I still believe bringing the Nazi regime into matters is disgraceful, but he's well within his right to be critical of this government. 

I think he'd be more of a bell end if he backed the government (generally). They're a shambles.
Reply
#42
To be fair the BBC have been impartial - they've pissed off the the Left by suspending him and the Right by having him back.
Reply
#43
(03-13-2023, 10:39 AM)Duffers Wrote: To be fair the BBC have been impartial - they've pissed off the the Left by suspending him and the Right by having him back.

Have an Arf  Big Grin
Reply
#44
(03-13-2023, 10:29 AM)hudds Wrote:
(03-13-2023, 07:21 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-12-2023, 05:36 PM)KRO Wrote:
(03-12-2023, 03:53 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(03-11-2023, 11:47 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: Enjoyed it more tonight. No crap commentary from likes of Jonathan Pearce. And didn't have to fast forward the likes of Danny Murphy talking drivel

Same here. It’s highlighted how much of the show is padded out with the inane drivel of the pundits when it could be a much more condensed package which shows ultimately what the average football fan has tuned in for.

I thought it was way worse than normal. Absolute shite in fact

x 2.

I do think sometimes the analysis can go on too long, but really don't see much wrong with it and often the experts show us things we would have missed. After all, whilst many try to think they are experts virtually none of us are.

There's some miserable gitts on this site, piling into a likeable, humorous and knowledgable expert like Lineker and those who just love BBC bashing.

It just shows to me how despite being an Albion fan there's lots of our fans that only my football team I share in common and I probably wouldn't get on with them.

We are extremely fortunate to have the BeeB, the most highly thought of broadcasting corporation in the world.
I support the Beeb as an instution and would side with Lineker on the controversy.  The "expert analysis" on MoTD if I catch it is cliched, risible and vapid. The two things aren't mutually exclusive Spandex.  I never have the commentary on any channel and avoid the usual platitudes spouted although sometimes unavoidable.

I'd love to see a programme of just football and minimal wasteful tripe.
Agree. There seems to be a view that if you would rather have MOTD without Lineker and his dullard cronies then you're some kind right wing monster. Personally my politics are very left leaning and I think recent events have shown the BBC in a very poor light. Politics and how I like to view football highlights are completely separate issues.
Reply
#45
(03-13-2023, 10:33 AM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(03-13-2023, 10:18 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Just tweeted that he restarts on Saturday but managed to slide in a few comments re refugees and tolerant country in a 4 tweet chain.  Suspect there will be a fair amount of right wing piss boilt over the coming days.

Not really bothered as I don't watch MotD, due to the fact I don't really have an interest in the Prem, but I also stopped watching as the punditry is laughably poor, to the point it ruins the product. 

If Lineker isn't the presenter, some other smug, overpaid and overrated presenter will get the gig. I've no issue with what he said, but how he said it. I still believe bringing the Nazi regime into matters is disgraceful, but he's well within his right to be critical of this government. 

I think he'd be more of a bell end if he backed the government (generally). They're a shambles.

All he said was the truth.

The government's messaging about refugees is exactly the same as 1930's about Jews and other people they didn't like. He never said the Tories are Nazis, they inferred it, guilty conscience?
Reply
#46
Birdman1811 Wrote:
SuperBob2002 Wrote:
CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:Just tweeted that he restarts on Saturday but managed to slide in a few comments re refugees and tolerant country in a 4 tweet chain.  Suspect there will be a fair amount of right wing piss boilt over the coming days.

Not really bothered as I don't watch MotD, due to the fact I don't really have an interest in the Prem, but I also stopped watching as the punditry is laughably poor, to the point it ruins the product. 

If Lineker isn't the presenter, some other smug, overpaid and overrated presenter will get the gig. I've no issue with what he said, but how he said it. I still believe bringing the Nazi regime into matters is disgraceful, but he's well within his right to be critical of this government. 

I think he'd be more of a bell end if he backed the government (generally). They're a shambles.

All he said was the truth.

The government's messaging about refugees is exactly the same as 1930's about Jews and other people they didn't like. He never said the Tories are Nazis, they inferred it, guilty conscience?
….and then took him off the airwaves Nazi style!
 As someone said above, just because you don't like Lineker doesn't mean you agree with the action taken or the government, although many see it that way. Just to put the cat among the pigeons, I can't stand goody two shoes Jamie Oliver either. Has he paid his creditors yet, the big round face fraud?
Reply
#47
(03-13-2023, 11:11 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Birdman1811 Wrote:
SuperBob2002 Wrote:
CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:Just tweeted that he restarts on Saturday but managed to slide in a few comments re refugees and tolerant country in a 4 tweet chain.  Suspect there will be a fair amount of right wing piss boilt over the coming days.

Not really bothered as I don't watch MotD, due to the fact I don't really have an interest in the Prem, but I also stopped watching as the punditry is laughably poor, to the point it ruins the product. 

If Lineker isn't the presenter, some other smug, overpaid and overrated presenter will get the gig. I've no issue with what he said, but how he said it. I still believe bringing the Nazi regime into matters is disgraceful, but he's well within his right to be critical of this government. 

I think he'd be more of a bell end if he backed the government (generally). They're a shambles.

All he said was the truth.

The government's messaging about refugees is exactly the same as 1930's about Jews and other people they didn't like. He never said the Tories are Nazis, they inferred it, guilty conscience?
….and then took him off the airwaves Nazi style!
 As someone said above, just because you don't like Lineker doesn't mean you agree with the action taken or the government, although many see it that way. Just to put the cat among the pigeons, I can't stand goody two shoes Jamie Oliver either. Has he paid his creditors yet, the big round face fraud?

There's heaps of celebs I dislike, but I respect their right to say what they want. Can't stomach Clarkson, but if he wants to have a pop at Harry and Meghan then fair dos. 

It's all onions who you like and don't like.
Reply
#48
(03-13-2023, 12:39 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-13-2023, 11:11 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Birdman1811 Wrote:
SuperBob2002 Wrote:
CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:Just tweeted that he restarts on Saturday but managed to slide in a few comments re refugees and tolerant country in a 4 tweet chain.  Suspect there will be a fair amount of right wing piss boilt over the coming days.

Not really bothered as I don't watch MotD, due to the fact I don't really have an interest in the Prem, but I also stopped watching as the punditry is laughably poor, to the point it ruins the product. 

If Lineker isn't the presenter, some other smug, overpaid and overrated presenter will get the gig. I've no issue with what he said, but how he said it. I still believe bringing the Nazi regime into matters is disgraceful, but he's well within his right to be critical of this government. 

I think he'd be more of a bell end if he backed the government (generally). They're a shambles.

All he said was the truth.

The government's messaging about refugees is exactly the same as 1930's about Jews and other people they didn't like. He never said the Tories are Nazis, they inferred it, guilty conscience?
….and then took him off the airwaves Nazi style!
 As someone said above, just because you don't like Lineker doesn't mean you agree with the action taken or the government, although many see it that way. Just to put the cat among the pigeons, I can't stand goody two shoes Jamie Oliver either. Has he paid his creditors yet, the big round face fraud?

There's heaps of celebs I dislike, but I respect their right to say what they want. Can't stomach Clarkson, but if he wants to have a pop at Harry and Meghan then fair dos. 

It's all onions who you like and don't like.

I've seen a few people try to equate the Lineker thing with Clarkson, despite them not being the same at all. Lineker posted a Tweet, on his personal account, criticising the language and rhetoric used by this government. Clarkson wrote, and presumably was paid for, an article that was published by a major newspaper in which he said "I hate Meghan Markel, I would like to see her whipped naked through the streets" (or words very much to that effect, can't recall precisely what he said).

You would have to be pretty thick to think they were similar.

Free speech is not the freedom to just say what you want, and it never has been. You can't deny the Holocaust happened, or say "I hate blacks/Jews/women/gays/trans people/etc" or incite hatred towards any individual or individuals. There is a thick line between free speech and hate speech that you should never cross, Lineker was nowhere near that line. Clarkson, if we're being generous, was at the very least bumping against it.
Reply
#49
(03-13-2023, 10:28 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Does appear to be a fair amount of back peddling by Tim Davie, from what I've read.

If the leaked contract was right the BBC had no leg to stand on over it.
Reply
#50
(03-13-2023, 01:20 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(03-13-2023, 12:39 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(03-13-2023, 11:11 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Birdman1811 Wrote:
SuperBob2002 Wrote:Not really bothered as I don't watch MotD, due to the fact I don't really have an interest in the Prem, but I also stopped watching as the punditry is laughably poor, to the point it ruins the product. 

If Lineker isn't the presenter, some other smug, overpaid and overrated presenter will get the gig. I've no issue with what he said, but how he said it. I still believe bringing the Nazi regime into matters is disgraceful, but he's well within his right to be critical of this government. 

I think he'd be more of a bell end if he backed the government (generally). They're a shambles.

All he said was the truth.

The government's messaging about refugees is exactly the same as 1930's about Jews and other people they didn't like. He never said the Tories are Nazis, they inferred it, guilty conscience?
….and then took him off the airwaves Nazi style!
 As someone said above, just because you don't like Lineker doesn't mean you agree with the action taken or the government, although many see it that way. Just to put the cat among the pigeons, I can't stand goody two shoes Jamie Oliver either. Has he paid his creditors yet, the big round face fraud?

There's heaps of celebs I dislike, but I respect their right to say what they want. Can't stomach Clarkson, but if he wants to have a pop at Harry and Meghan then fair dos. 

It's all onions who you like and don't like.

I've seen a few people try to equate the Lineker thing with Clarkson, despite them not being the same at all. Lineker posted a Tweet, on his personal account, criticising the language and rhetoric used by this government. Clarkson wrote, and presumably was paid for, an article that was published by a major newspaper in which he said "I hate Meghan Markel, I would like to see her whipped naked through the streets" (or words very much to that effect, can't recall precisely what he said).

You would have to be pretty thick to think they were similar.

Free speech is not the freedom to just say what you want, and it never has been. You can't deny the Holocaust happened, or say "I hate blacks/Jews/women/gays/trans people/etc" or incite hatred towards any individual or individuals. There is a thick line between free speech and hate speech that you should never cross, Lineker was nowhere near that line. Clarkson, if we're being generous, was at the very least bumping against it.

There absolutely is not, otherwise, you wouldn't have people sending JK Rowling death threats and claiming she is inciting genocide for writing this:

https://www.jkrowling.com/opinions/j-k-r...er-issues/
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)