HS waste of money
#11
I have no opinion on this topic. We'll all be under water by the time it's done ay it.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#12
(03-09-2023, 03:41 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-09-2023, 03:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-09-2023, 02:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Imagine being opposed to HS2.

Imagine thinking it offered any real value

It does, improving railway capacity is a huge value. The Shinkansen got the exact same criticisms in the 60s, now the people criticising it look like idiots. The TGV got the same criticisms, now the people criticising it look like idiots. So did the direttissima, the ICE, HS1, AVE, KTX, HSL etc etc etc. All the people criticising those initiatives now look like idiots.

Maybe if NIMBYs like you accepted the overwhelming pile of evidence instead of obstructing it at every point then it would have been built by now at a much lower cost? But oh no, can't improve the UK's infrastructure.

Do you know what the most congested railway line in Europe is? The Rugby-Wolverhampton spur on the WCML. Most overcrowded not in the UK but all of Europe. That is the value of HS2.

I get it you think whatever the cost in its broadest sense is justified and criticism by environmentalists, wildlife experts, residents affected by project  and others is met with disdain, dismissal and name calling.
Reply
#13
I am ridiculing those which deserve ridiculing, and seeing as the line runs very closely past my house I know full well that they're full of shit.
Reply
#14
A complete white elephant.

The lockdown proved that meetings can now be done remotely, via Zoom etc. Nobody needs to get from London to Manchester 20 minutes quicker. The money could be much better spent elsewhere.
Reply
#15
(03-09-2023, 09:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I get it you think whatever the cost in its broadest sense is justified and criticism by environmentalists, wildlife experts, residents affected by project  and others is met with disdain, dismissal and name calling.

Let's be honest Dekka, it's hard enough building anything anywhere ever in this country these days - let alone infrastructure projects of national importance. It's about time we met these selfish voices of conservatism, like your own - with the disdain it deserves.
Reply
#16
Is it worth it to get to (nearly) London slightly quicker? Probably not.

Is another train line needed to alleviate some of the strain on the WCML? Absolutely.

Is the money being spent on HS2 justifiable in terms of it's only benefit being "reducing capacity on the WCML"? Nope.

Whole thing is a total fuck up and considering the money poured in and the work already done we might as well finish it to Birmingham at least.
Reply
#17
(03-10-2023, 01:45 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Is it worth it to get to (nearly) London slightly quicker? Probably not.

Is another train line needed to alleviate some of the strain on the WCML? Absolutely.

Is the money being spent on HS2 justifiable in terms of it's only benefit being "reducing capacity on the WCML"? Nope.

Whole thing is a total fuck up and considering the money poured in and the work already done we might as well finish it to Birmingham at least.

Most of the cost in Phase 1 is down to tunnelling and design, it's still within the original budget inc. contingency.

Obviously there's not much you can do about tunnelling in London but the government retrospectively changing the design scope for Euston wasted a lot of money, as has adding in tunnels (like the one near me, pandering to a fucking golf course that isn't even that good).

The issue with the costs ballooning has largely been down to redesign and inflation, if the government dug their feet in and brought forward parts of Phase 2 and didn't change the designs where it wasn't reasonable for them to be changed then it would look a lot more reasonable as you negate the extra costs associated with design changes, use less costly construction e.g. viaducts instead of tunnels and you hedge against inflation.

Hilariously the section into Birmingham from the airport interchange is actually going to be quite cheap as it uses the old Curzon Street railway alignment.
Reply
#18
(03-10-2023, 02:11 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-10-2023, 01:45 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Is it worth it to get to (nearly) London slightly quicker? Probably not.

Is another train line needed to alleviate some of the strain on the WCML? Absolutely.

Is the money being spent on HS2 justifiable in terms of it's only benefit being "reducing capacity on the WCML"? Nope.

Whole thing is a total fuck up and considering the money poured in and the work already done we might as well finish it to Birmingham at least.

Most of the cost in Phase 1 is down to tunnelling and design, it's still within the original budget inc. contingency.

Obviously there's not much you can do about tunnelling in London but the government retrospectively changing the design scope for Euston wasted a lot of money, as has adding in tunnels (like the one near me, pandering to a fucking golf course that isn't even that good).

The issue with the costs ballooning has largely been down to redesign and inflation, if the government dug their feet in and brought forward parts of Phase 2 and didn't change the designs where it wasn't reasonable for them to be changed then it would look a lot more reasonable as you negate the extra costs associated with design changes, use less costly construction e.g. viaducts instead of tunnels and you hedge against inflation.

Hilariously the section into Birmingham from the airport interchange is actually going to be quite cheap as it uses the old Curzon Street railway alignment.

It's a lot of money for something that doesn't get you into central London any quicker than the rail infrastructure that already exists. 

I fully agree with pretty much everything else you've said r.e capacity.
Reply
#19
(03-10-2023, 04:09 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(03-10-2023, 02:11 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-10-2023, 01:45 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Is it worth it to get to (nearly) London slightly quicker? Probably not.

Is another train line needed to alleviate some of the strain on the WCML? Absolutely.

Is the money being spent on HS2 justifiable in terms of it's only benefit being "reducing capacity on the WCML"? Nope.

Whole thing is a total fuck up and considering the money poured in and the work already done we might as well finish it to Birmingham at least.

Most of the cost in Phase 1 is down to tunnelling and design, it's still within the original budget inc. contingency.

Obviously there's not much you can do about tunnelling in London but the government retrospectively changing the design scope for Euston wasted a lot of money, as has adding in tunnels (like the one near me, pandering to a fucking golf course that isn't even that good).

The issue with the costs ballooning has largely been down to redesign and inflation, if the government dug their feet in and brought forward parts of Phase 2 and didn't change the designs where it wasn't reasonable for them to be changed then it would look a lot more reasonable as you negate the extra costs associated with design changes, use less costly construction e.g. viaducts instead of tunnels and you hedge against inflation.

Hilariously the section into Birmingham from the airport interchange is actually going to be quite cheap as it uses the old Curzon Street railway alignment.

It's a lot of money for something that doesn't get you into central London any quicker than the rail infrastructure that already exists. 

I fully agree with pretty much everything else you've said r.e capacity.
We need more spent on the network, but it feels because we spend/invest so little over decades, when a big project comes along it stands out like a sore thumb for criticism. As a country we seem to have little faith in our ability to complete projects on time and on budget - why is that? When was the last major govt investment in a project that finished on budget and on time?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)