Players conduct towards referees
#11
(03-06-2023, 03:41 PM)Bromley Baggie 2 Wrote: It's been going on for years. I remember one game at Old Trafford (I think United were playing Middlesbrough) and the ref dared to award Boro a penalty. The usual suspects at the time, Keane, Gary Neville, Ferdinand, Scholes et al, surrounded the ref and he was practically pushed back from the 18 yard box to the centre line, with the United players screaming at him.

I can't recall who the ref was, but if he'd had anything about it, he'd have started flashing the cards. First yellow, then red if they didn't shut up and get on with the game.

The refs are perfectly within their rights to show cards to players who surround and scream at them, if he makes a decision they don't like. They're all frightened to, though. Especially if they are running a game with one of the "big clubs" involved.
Reply
#12
Simple solution is to treat it like rugby, as many have suggested. (Although I thought that rugby was vilified on here?)

I played schoolboy and grass roots rugby, and there was never any dissent or shouting at the refs whatsoever, even if he was being shite/a prick. And that all comes from watching how the pros play, and the general behaviour of "captain only, otherwise you get penalised".

A similar story to Tom, I'd once been stamped on in a ruck and was seething. We'd won a penalty in the ruck though, but I moaned at the ref and he reversed the penalty to the other team. It was early in the game, so we had other chances, but we lost by 2 points. I never moaned again after that. That's how easy it would be to deal with.
Reply
#13
(03-06-2023, 02:59 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: One of my absolute pet peeves is player behaviour towards referees. A complete failure to punish dissent at the top level filtering down towards the non-leagues. Kids getting abused by parents at youth level being normal, kids giving it to referees because they see it weekly on the TV. Puts more people off from being referees in turn reducing the quality of referees due to the smaller pool to pick from at the top.


Would not be surprised if Fernandes isn't punished, even though it should be a straight red for touching the referee in the way he did.
Compare this lot, to the way Rugby players treat officials. Its night and day, the egg chasers have total respect for official.
Reply
#14
(03-06-2023, 02:59 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: One of my absolute pet peeves is player behaviour towards referees. A complete failure to punish dissent at the top level filtering down towards the non-leagues. Kids getting abused by parents at youth level being normal, kids giving it to referees because they see it weekly on the TV. Puts more people off from being referees in turn reducing the quality of referees due to the smaller pool to pick from at the top.


Would not be surprised if Fernandes isn't punished, even though it should be a straight red for touching the referee in the way he did.
It was actually the linesman and if you watch the incident the linesman touches Fernandes first nothing in it so get on with game which they did. 
I’m all for the booking for players running at the the ref and if they do touch push any official then a straight red and a big ban, but the Fernandes incident was a nothing incident.
Reply
#15
I coach a u14 team, low level & quality junior football, but watching conduct towards refs get worse and worse. I’m convinced it’s down to what kids see on the, along with parents / coaches allowing their teams to do it (general societal problem). If anyone on my team complains to the ref they immediately get pulled up by myself and I’m very clear with parents on this.

I had to pull an opposition player off one of mine a couple of weeks ago & the opposition coach just stood on the sidelines laughing and said it was the refs job to deal with the situation (the ref being a 16 year old kid).
Reply
#16
Do you pull anyone off or just opposition players?

Asking for a friend  Angel ?
Reply
#17
(03-07-2023, 11:48 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(03-06-2023, 02:59 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: One of my absolute pet peeves is player behaviour towards referees. A complete failure to punish dissent at the top level filtering down towards the non-leagues. Kids getting abused by parents at youth level being normal, kids giving it to referees because they see it weekly on the TV. Puts more people off from being referees in turn reducing the quality of referees due to the smaller pool to pick from at the top.


Would not be surprised if Fernandes isn't punished, even though it should be a straight red for touching the referee in the way he did.
It was actually the linesman and if you watch the incident the linesman touches Fernandes first nothing in it so get on with game which they did. 
I’m all for the booking for players running at the the ref and if they do touch push any official then a straight red and a big ban, but the Fernandes incident was a nothing incident.

Are you serious?
Reply
#18
(03-06-2023, 03:41 PM)Bromley Baggie 2 Wrote: It's been going on for years. I remember one game at Old Trafford (I think United were playing Middlesbrough) and the ref dared to award Boro a penalty. The usual suspects at the time, Keane, Gary Neville, Ferdinand, Scholes et al, surrounded the ref and he was practically pushed back from the 18 yard box to the centre line, with the United players screaming at him.

I can't recall who the ref was, but if he'd had anything about it, he'd have started flashing the cards. First yellow, then red if they didn't shut up and get on with the game. 

The refs are perfectly within their rights to show cards to players who surround and scream at them, if he makes a decision they don't like. They're all frightened to, though. Especially if they are running a game with one of the "big clubs" involved.

Stam, Keane, Beckham were the worst in the one I think you're thinking of.
Reply
#19
I agree with what’s been said above, FA, professional referees who have the tools to deal with it, Howard Webb, players, managers, absolute shambles. Other sports like rugby and tennis seem to handle these so called societal problems so much better. I’m not sure Women’s football has quite the same problem. 
I hope the young guys who are learning the game are not too disheartened as they are needed to be the officials of tomorrow, they shouldn’t have to put up with it.
I met Uriah Rennie a few months ago and asked him who the worst players to refer were. He said Wayne Rooney and Robbie Savage as they never shut up, they were constantly in your ear complaining. So it’s been going on for too long.
Reply
#20
(03-07-2023, 01:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-07-2023, 11:48 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(03-06-2023, 02:59 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: One of my absolute pet peeves is player behaviour towards referees. A complete failure to punish dissent at the top level filtering down towards the non-leagues. Kids getting abused by parents at youth level being normal, kids giving it to referees because they see it weekly on the TV. Puts more people off from being referees in turn reducing the quality of referees due to the smaller pool to pick from at the top.


Would not be surprised if Fernandes isn't punished, even though it should be a straight red for touching the referee in the way he did.
It was actually the linesman and if you watch the incident the linesman touches Fernandes first nothing in it so get on with game which they did. 
I’m all for the booking for players running at the the ref and if they do touch push any official then a straight red and a big ban, but the Fernandes incident was a nothing incident.

Are you serious?

Yes ask the premier league nothing being done, ask Dermot Gallagher on sky linesman touched first. I think some of you want players banned for nothing .
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: