Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
I only meant technically, people reading what they like again. In every way I'd pick Olsson and GMac over any of these, but technical ability not much in it, just as you say, consistency, leadership, determination, aggression... All miles ahead.
Posts: 588
Threads: 8
Joined: Feb 2023
Reputation:
12
03-04-2023, 11:53 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-04-2023, 11:59 AM by Mr Nimbus.)
Real leaders are people who make you feel like you'd crawl over broken glass for them. They find the trigger to motivate people to give that bit more. It's a character trait that can be built on, but I don't think created. You cant just "lead by example" or lead by being the best player on the park. You arnt a leader because you wear the captains armband, but a leader with the armband has real authority.
Megson's team was full of leaders, but it was no coincidence. He made multiple signings over a period of time who were already club captains or vice captains. That side wasnt technically brilliant but it had strong characters that could boss every area on the pitch. They were well organised and had real mental fortitude
Saying that, when we talk about quality of players, i can only think of Yakuslu and Wallace as players who would be challenging for starters in the Megson team. Hoult, Clem, Lyttle, Balis, Siggy, Moore and Gichirst all start ahead of the current back division.. McInnes, Appleton and Johnsons get in ahead of Molomby and Swift. Robert's would play ahead of both Dike and BTA on current form and I always had a soft spot for Dichio who was a fierce competitor in both boxes. Let's not forget the returning SuperBob Taylor scoring important goals. Does put the perceived quality of this squad into perspective!! You could feel quite confident that team would nick one early and hold this team very easily at arms length for a very comfortable 1-0 Meggo special.
I do see a little bit of SGM in CC. Totally different time, and different characters, but little things they and their teams do are familiar.
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
McInnes
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 13,258
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(03-04-2023, 11:43 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I only meant technically, people reading what they like again. In every way I'd pick Olsson and GMac over any of these, but technical ability not much in it, just as you say, consistency, leadership, determination, aggression... All miles ahead.
Evans, Dawson, Lescott, even Hegazi would massively improve the CB pairing in terms of leadership.
I don't think we realised how many leaders we had in the team back then.
Steven Reid at right back was a leader too
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
(03-04-2023, 08:53 AM)Mr Nimbus Wrote: An odd game. We dominated possession but lacked that cutting edge. They had one half chance and scored two goals, one of which was a belter, he wont hit it better all season.
We on the other hand created numerous half chances, as many after we went behind as before. Was it gutless? No. Did they give up? No. Did we lack quality in both boxes? Yes.
Up front Dike looks like he's labouring, he's lost the explosive power that made him such an exciting prospect. Is it the body, or just in the head? He is the potential difference maker. BTA is also a real miss, he can change the feeling of a game with his hard running and has a goal in him (although not yet looking prolific).
Dara is a decent footballing CH and one of our own but is no beast. Pieters is a LB lately come CH doing a fantastic job for us to provide balance. Together they make a decent pairing but can be bullied by a powerful striker on his game. More than that, neither provide any threat at set pieces, which is an important source of goals for a team that play with control as we do.
Those were the key differences last night. Other factors? Love him to bits but Jed a shocker, yes he can whip in a good cross but his decision making and finishing last night were poor. Albrighton offered a couple of nice touches but nothing really offensively. Changes were needed but, no disrespect to the kids, the subs we now have offer nothing really. Reach!!
Yes we miss some real leaders with McInnes, Fletcher, Olson, Gmac offered, to which I'd add Moore but they would grace most Albion teams I've seen. At this point I'd take a Clement, Siggy, Gilchrist even.
As has been noted the loss of the much maligned Phillip's and Barts to THIS team has been massive. If nothing else when confident and fit they offer real physicality in their positions and a goal threat.Also insane that after having an overabundance of average left sided players queuing up to play for the last few years we now have zero.
Dont think there is much more to get out of this team, we are no Burnley and rely on small margins. The striker hits the stand as per usual rather than top corner. That free kick hits the post and bounces in. Unless we have a run of those moments going our way again the play offs look unlikely. Good post this. I'd add there is a massive lack of pace throughout the team.
Totally agree on small margins: pre-bad run we were getting the rub of the green but now everything goes against us.
Posts: 293
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(03-03-2023, 10:54 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (03-03-2023, 10:53 PM)TartanRug Wrote: (03-03-2023, 10:49 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (03-03-2023, 10:48 PM)Peachy Wrote: Oh for Gmac and Olsson at centre half tonight. Proper fucking leaders. Tbf I really like Dara but he just wasn't at it tonight.
He's doing too much, Pieters just isn't that good, and being Captain and one of the few with the right mentality it's forcing him into mistakes.
Yet these same players have looked rock solid in certain games like Boro last week, just can't do it consistently At home, solid, away, not.
Suggest a mentality problem to me.
This is the most desperate attempt to prove a point ever. Show me a team anywhere, ever, who are better away than at home, in the history of football. Now show me 10. There are mentality and costistancy problems, thats why they play for the Albion. If they were always on top of their game, they would be higher up the chain
Posts: 3,903
Threads: 18
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(03-04-2023, 11:43 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I only meant technically, people reading what they like again. In every way I'd pick Olsson and GMac over any of these, but technical ability not much in it, just as you say, consistency, leadership, determination, aggression... All miles ahead.
I'm with you on this Birdy ,for me a defenders priority first and foremost is the be able to bloody defend not hit 30yrd passes or play at being wingers, keep the ball out of our net first then build from that. Give me an Ally Rob ,John Wile , Olson, Gmac, etc anytime.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
03-04-2023, 12:53 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-04-2023, 12:54 PM by Tom Joad.)
Well I see it differently, FWIW. Last night we were not undone by a good Hull side, nor despite the repetition, some great tactics by Rosenior. A worldy from a bloke who until the 30th minute had trapped a ball further than most of us can kick it and hadn't scored in months and a 2nd from a ball in the danger area (Credit due for that), that could have gone anywhere.
A good performance wouldn't have presented us with the numerous chances we had and missed.
We lost because of very poor performances from a couple of players. Our full backs were absolutely shocking. Both need dropping as I can't imagine for a moment it could make us worse. Then, just a slight criticism, Dike has promise but is raw. makes poor decisions and lacks composure. For me, he needs to play with someone closer to him on the pitch. Albrighton was inconsistent but don't get me started on Chalobah, he needs a rocket behind him. The rest did enough to win 2 games.
CC was right when he said we lost the game in both boxes. I'm as much his fan as anyone on here but if he can't see TGH should be 1st midfield sub and on occasions, starting, then he won't go as far in the game as he is intending.
Oh and re the OP, yes we desperately need a few leaders on the pitch.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(03-04-2023, 11:43 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I only meant technically, people reading what they like again. In every way I'd pick Olsson and GMac over any of these, but technical ability not much in it, just as you say, consistency, leadership, determination, aggression... All miles ahead.
If by technically you mean the art of defending then Olsson and GMac are a mile ahead of Pieters and O'Shea. Didn't lose players off their shoulders, knew which side of the play to be, knew when to let someone run in behind and not follow, knew how to move across as a back 4 not individually, knew when to foul, knew when to put a foot in and when not to, rarely got caught under the ball due to their positional sense AND THEN they had the consistency, leadership, determination and aggression. All round much, much better defenders.
Better "technical" skills in controlling and passing? A bit of that too. Olsson reguarly played a great ball to Fortune's (in particular) feet, a drilled pass through midfield, but given Pieters is a full back he would be expected to be good on the ball, then I'd agree they're not much better on that side.
They were PL\International level defenders and we're comparing them to a left back and a relative youngster learning the game and is currently playing to his level, mid-table Champo.
Trump is a Cunt
|