Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(02-24-2023, 08:57 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Borin' Baggie Wrote:Tom Joad Wrote:Borin' Baggie Wrote:Tom Joad Wrote:Much as Brexit has complicated trade, it is not to blame here. This is due to supermarkets and their price fixing. Put simply, our supermarkets dictate the price they will pay for these items. France, and the other countries stocked with tomatoes and peppers are paying the true cost which is high due to the short supply - and charging customers accordingly. If you want out of season veg after varying spells of inclement weather, then you can still get it. You just have to pay a realistic price. In much of Britain, cheap is always preferable to quality. Much as I don't agree with much of Ms Coffey's politics, as environment secretary she is right when she says we ought to eat more seasonal veg.
The issue with that is there is no means for the UK to be self sufficient on home-grown produce without utilisation of green houses and polytunnels as are used in The Netherlands, and if you're using green houses and polytunnels you might as well start growing popular stuff e.g. tomatoes and cucumbers instead of turnips. We weren't even self-sufficient in WWII with expanded agricultural land usage, growing incentives and 2/3rds of the current population.
Food seasonality in the UK is a middle class luxury and unfortunately seasonal veg isn't cheap because of limited agricultural potential.
I'd also dispute the issue with regards to Brexit, it's certainly at least a minor factor owing to wholesale suppliers not being bloc-wide anymore and couriers being subject to red tape introducing extra cost on imports from the EU. I didn't state anything like that? The point of the experts interviewed today (Radio 4), was that our supermarkets telling their suppliers what they will pay has allowed the suppliers to sell the limited produce to those that will pay the most. BTW, Many of the tomatoes imported are from Morocco, not the EU, the Spanish exporters have been badly hit by bad weather and the fuel situation. I see no argument for not eating a MORE seasonal diet. That doesn't mean we need to live on turnips or we don't need to import. Just that we need to be real about the true cost in both financial terms and global warming. Lamb from New Zealand being cheaper than Welsh lamb as an example. I should add, veg in season tastes far better too, it's win-win!
But that doesn't negate the issue about capacity of UK seasonal produce and methods required to increase capacity negate seasonality. If you start implementing polytunnels and green houses to expand British agricultural capacity then you can grow all sorts year round which negates seasonal produce. If more people eat seasonally the prices will also shoot up. The ability to eat seasonally in this country is unfortunately very much a middle class thing.
Moroccan exports also enter the UK market via EU ports, namely Algeciras and the Dutch ports. It's extra paperwork now to forward that on.
I also mentioned supermarkets screwing over UK suppliers above, I'm just pointing out that Brexit absolutely has an impact compounding on other factors. First, British agriculture does make much use of greenhouses and polytunnels. Also UK agriculture is not due to gain any financial support re the energy crisis so our greenhouses are currently holding back on early tomato seeds. Further, as I said last post, how on Earth can it make any sense that New Zealand lamb is cheaper than Welsh lamb? I'm just putting forward a point that it must make every sense to eat more locally and more seasonally. A middle class thing, if you'd like an example, is importing beans from Kenya because they are cheaper than home grown. Another one is expecting salads in February when a good stew is what the doctor ordered.
Have a good weekend BB, I'm opening my Merlot now and your next post will be asking if it is from Halfpenny Green. 
There’s one extra point here that isn’t being made, it’s only half the reason that the supermarkets dictate the price therefore the growers can’t make any money. The other reason they can’t make any money is because there isn’t a price cap for businesses for the heating required to grow the food, so they simply just stop growing and shut everything.
However it is a big factor that growers in southern Europe and Northern Africa will find it easier selling into one big block that serves 20 odd markets rather than one with more red tape for 1 market.
Brexit is again a factor that is making it worse and whether that is by 1% or 99% it doesn’t align with the ‘everything will be better’ mantra that won the votes.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
02-24-2023, 09:58 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-24-2023, 09:58 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
(02-24-2023, 08:57 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: Borin' Baggie Wrote:Tom Joad Wrote:Borin' Baggie Wrote:Tom Joad Wrote:Much as Brexit has complicated trade, it is not to blame here. This is due to supermarkets and their price fixing. Put simply, our supermarkets dictate the price they will pay for these items. France, and the other countries stocked with tomatoes and peppers are paying the true cost which is high due to the short supply - and charging customers accordingly. If you want out of season veg after varying spells of inclement weather, then you can still get it. You just have to pay a realistic price. In much of Britain, cheap is always preferable to quality. Much as I don't agree with much of Ms Coffey's politics, as environment secretary she is right when she says we ought to eat more seasonal veg.
The issue with that is there is no means for the UK to be self sufficient on home-grown produce without utilisation of green houses and polytunnels as are used in The Netherlands, and if you're using green houses and polytunnels you might as well start growing popular stuff e.g. tomatoes and cucumbers instead of turnips. We weren't even self-sufficient in WWII with expanded agricultural land usage, growing incentives and 2/3rds of the current population.
Food seasonality in the UK is a middle class luxury and unfortunately seasonal veg isn't cheap because of limited agricultural potential.
I'd also dispute the issue with regards to Brexit, it's certainly at least a minor factor owing to wholesale suppliers not being bloc-wide anymore and couriers being subject to red tape introducing extra cost on imports from the EU. I didn't state anything like that? The point of the experts interviewed today (Radio 4), was that our supermarkets telling their suppliers what they will pay has allowed the suppliers to sell the limited produce to those that will pay the most. BTW, Many of the tomatoes imported are from Morocco, not the EU, the Spanish exporters have been badly hit by bad weather and the fuel situation. I see no argument for not eating a MORE seasonal diet. That doesn't mean we need to live on turnips or we don't need to import. Just that we need to be real about the true cost in both financial terms and global warming. Lamb from New Zealand being cheaper than Welsh lamb as an example. I should add, veg in season tastes far better too, it's win-win!
But that doesn't negate the issue about capacity of UK seasonal produce and methods required to increase capacity negate seasonality. If you start implementing polytunnels and green houses to expand British agricultural capacity then you can grow all sorts year round which negates seasonal produce. If more people eat seasonally the prices will also shoot up. The ability to eat seasonally in this country is unfortunately very much a middle class thing.
Moroccan exports also enter the UK market via EU ports, namely Algeciras and the Dutch ports. It's extra paperwork now to forward that on.
I also mentioned supermarkets screwing over UK suppliers above, I'm just pointing out that Brexit absolutely has an impact compounding on other factors. First, British agriculture does make much use of greenhouses and polytunnels. Also UK agriculture is not due to gain any financial support re the energy crisis so our greenhouses are currently holding back on early tomato seeds. Further, as I said last post, how on Earth can it make any sense that New Zealand lamb is cheaper than Welsh lamb? I'm just putting forward a point that it must make every sense to eat more locally and more seasonally. A middle class thing, if you'd like an example, is importing beans from Kenya because they are cheaper than home grown. Another one is expecting salads in February when a good stew is what the doctor ordered.
Have a good weekend BB, I'm opening my Merlot now and your next post will be asking if it is from Halfpenny Green. 
I literally mentioned above in this very thread about UK green houses shutting off for financial reasons owing to financial constraints. I am not ignorant to that, otherwise I would not have raised it. All I'm doing is pointing out that friction between the UK and EU is affecting Moroccan imports into the UK by virtue of being processed in the EU as it is a larger market adjacent to them with bigger ports (Dutch and Belgian ports) or adjacent ports (Algeciras).
The UK has polytunnels and green houses in agriculture but it seriously underutilises them. The Dutch utilisation of climate controlled agriculture is the reason they are one of the biggest tomato exporters in the world, at a greater volume than Spain and Morocco combined in 2021.
New Zealand lamb is cheaper to produce than Welsh lamb because New Zealand is a lot bigger, has more grazing area so there can be larger farms with better yields than Welsh farms and because New Zealand's lamb season is 6 months off from us their produce is more developed and therefore bigger when we tend to want to eat it in the spring. One of the reasons New Zealand is known for lamb production is because Britain wanted a cheaper place to produce lamb than Great Britain. The cost of shipping and processing is a fraction of that.
And I'm sorry but eating seasonally in the UK is absolutely a middle class luxury, it's been such for centuries with the lower classes getting better access to produce through free trade driving down costs. That's one of the reasons the lower classes benefited from free trade policies vs protectionist policies like the corn laws. Look at Japan as an extreme modern example, all of their fresh seasonal fruit and vegetables are stupidly expensive compared with imports owing to land utilisation restrictions. If you want to justify eating seasonally as a means to reduce climate impact, quality justifications, freshness and supporting local producers then that's perfectly valid but unfortunately it isn't cheap compared to shipping in from places that make food cheaper than we can or want to.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
Quote:Turnip farmer on Radio 4 now, grew most of UK’s turnips, stopped 6 months ago. One major factor was loss of labour, otherwise known as Brexit. Got another vegetable you’d like to suggest?
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
Jay Rayner
Explanation on food production in the U.K. and the shortages we face. Yes the B word is used and it’s not beetroot.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
Derek Hardballs Wrote:Jay Rayner
Explanation on food production in the U.K. and the shortages we face. Yes the B word is used and it’s not beetroot.
Great article and the point I was trying make put far more articulately than I could manage. Yes, Brexit doesn't help but there are a series of mistakes, all of which we ought to have been working towards from JR's initial warning in 2014. Until we get some rational thinking and politicians with a long term policy, then we are doomed to repeat the same short term mistakes. A Keystones Cops type own goal.
Posts: 1,058
Threads: 51
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
3
(02-22-2023, 08:21 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I await the rest of the Europe posting pictures of their empty shelves…
Quote:Save British Farming group blamed Brexit and the “disastrous” Tory government for the shortages – describing the idea of only the weather in Spain being to blame as “absolute nonsense”.
“The reason that we have food shortages in Britain and that we don’t have food shortages in Spain – or anywhere else in the EU – is because of Brexit, and also because of this disastrous Conservative government that has no interest in food production, farming or even food supply,” said chair Liz Webster.
The alternative opinion
From some other industry sites, you know, the ones you love as long a g back your bias but become “obscure sites” when they don’t.
“Unusual weather is primarily to be blamed for the short supply, according to Andrew Opie, director of the British Retail Consortium”
“However, Jack Ward, CEO of the British Growers Association, told us that the shortage has its roots in increased energy costs. “
“The situation was aggravated by diminished tomato production in greenhouses of big producer countries like the Netherlands, primarily due to high energy costs”
“Contrary to some of the reaction on social media, Brexit has a minimal role to play in the immediate shortage, according to experts.
For example, the British Growers Association says one of the big issues arising from Brexit for the fresh produce sector - attracting workers from EU countries - has been mitigated by the Seasonal Workers Permit Scheme.”
Irish supermarkets have also reported depleted stocks of tomatoes and fresh produce, just like in the UK - but while geography (and related costs) will be a factor there, Brexit won't be.
From your beloved Brexit bashing BBC;
In the winter months the UK imports around 95% of its tomatoes and 90% of its lettuces, most of them from Spain and north Africa, according to trade group the British Retail Consortium (BRC).
But southern Spain has been suffering unusually cold weather and in Morocco crop yields have been affected by floods, while storms have caused ferries to be delayed or cancelled.” “ Wholesalers, importers and retailers the BBC has spoken to suggested the UK may be suffering because of lower domestic production and more complex supply chains, as well as a price-sensitive market.
But they said Brexit was unlikely to be a factor. “ Are the BBC telling porkies then?
From one of those Industry sites you like to swear by when they agree with you;
“Producers in southern Spain are struggling to fulfil their supermarket programmes due to supply shortages caused by unseasonal weather.
Almería is Europe’s main supplier of winter-grown vegetables
The high temperatures recorded this winter, followed by a prolonged cold snap, have resulted in a sharp drop in production, especially in Almería.”
From another of those wonderful Industry pages “A combination of striking Spanish hauliers and a series of other supply chain disruptions has contributed to shortages of some key fruit & veg lines in the mults.
Analysis of Associate data by The Grocer has shown a number of fresh fruit & veg SKUs – including salads and soft fruits – have been out of stock for more than two days across the mults this week.
Spain – a key supplier of fresh produce to the UK in winter – has been rocked by industrial action from lorry drivers over the past two weeks due to rising fuel costs, leading to big delays to the transportation of produce.
The impact of the strikes has been exacerbated by poor weather in Spain and north Africa, issues with paperwork and the impact of global container shortages, industry insiders have suggested.”
From a German newspaper ;
“The extreme weather conditions which affected Europe last month have also had an impact on the harvest in Spain and Italy, two of the continent’s main exporters of vegetables.”
One of the nay sayers! Justin King, former CEO of Sainsbury’s, says “The sector has been horribly hurt by Brexit” but does not explain how and of course, he is a Remainer zealot.
Still, you do want to eat ‘out of season’ produce, ruining the planet to get it here and pay next to nothing for it!
Posts: 6,416
Threads: 305
Joined: Aug 2022
Reputation:
28
This the cheaper food you were telling us all about in 2019?
Someone could have been killed
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(03-02-2023, 07:32 AM)JOK Wrote: (02-22-2023, 08:21 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I await the rest of the Europe posting pictures of their empty shelves…
Quote:Save British Farming group blamed Brexit and the “disastrous” Tory government for the shortages – describing the idea of only the weather in Spain being to blame as “absolute nonsense”.
“The reason that we have food shortages in Britain and that we don’t have food shortages in Spain – or anywhere else in the EU – is because of Brexit, and also because of this disastrous Conservative government that has no interest in food production, farming or even food supply,” said chair Liz Webster.
The alternative opinion
From some other industry sites, you know, the ones you love as long a g back your bias but become “obscure sites” when they don’t.
“Unusual weather is primarily to be blamed for the short supply, according to Andrew Opie, director of the British Retail Consortium”
“However, Jack Ward, CEO of the British Growers Association, told us that the shortage has its roots in increased energy costs. “
“The situation was aggravated by diminished tomato production in greenhouses of big producer countries like the Netherlands, primarily due to high energy costs”
“Contrary to some of the reaction on social media, Brexit has a minimal role to play in the immediate shortage, according to experts.
For example, the British Growers Association says one of the big issues arising from Brexit for the fresh produce sector - attracting workers from EU countries - has been mitigated by the Seasonal Workers Permit Scheme.”
Irish supermarkets have also reported depleted stocks of tomatoes and fresh produce, just like in the UK - but while geography (and related costs) will be a factor there, Brexit won't be.
From your beloved Brexit bashing BBC;
In the winter months the UK imports around 95% of its tomatoes and 90% of its lettuces, most of them from Spain and north Africa, according to trade group the British Retail Consortium (BRC).
But southern Spain has been suffering unusually cold weather and in Morocco crop yields have been affected by floods, while storms have caused ferries to be delayed or cancelled.” “ Wholesalers, importers and retailers the BBC has spoken to suggested the UK may be suffering because of lower domestic production and more complex supply chains, as well as a price-sensitive market.
But they said Brexit was unlikely to be a factor. “ Are the BBC telling porkies then?
From one of those Industry sites you like to swear by when they agree with you;
“Producers in southern Spain are struggling to fulfil their supermarket programmes due to supply shortages caused by unseasonal weather.
Almería is Europe’s main supplier of winter-grown vegetables
The high temperatures recorded this winter, followed by a prolonged cold snap, have resulted in a sharp drop in production, especially in Almería.”
From another of those wonderful Industry pages “A combination of striking Spanish hauliers and a series of other supply chain disruptions has contributed to shortages of some key fruit & veg lines in the mults.
Analysis of Associate data by The Grocer has shown a number of fresh fruit & veg SKUs – including salads and soft fruits – have been out of stock for more than two days across the mults this week.
Spain – a key supplier of fresh produce to the UK in winter – has been rocked by industrial action from lorry drivers over the past two weeks due to rising fuel costs, leading to big delays to the transportation of produce.
The impact of the strikes has been exacerbated by poor weather in Spain and north Africa, issues with paperwork and the impact of global container shortages, industry insiders have suggested.”
From a German newspaper ;
“The extreme weather conditions which affected Europe last month have also had an impact on the harvest in Spain and Italy, two of the continent’s main exporters of vegetables.”
One of the nay sayers! Justin King, former CEO of Sainsbury’s, says “The sector has been horribly hurt by Brexit” but does not explain how and of course, he is a Remainer zealot.
Still, you do want to eat ‘out of season’ produce, ruining the planet to get it here and pay next to nothing for it!
2
|