15-Minute Cities
#1
https://www.itv.com/news/2023-02-20/what...troversial

Can anyone shed any light on why this would be in any way, shape or form a bad move? I see the 'fash' were out in force in Oxford this weekend protesting against it - which surely only adds more weight behind this being a good idea.

Would you like better amenities, public transport, cycling provision, access to education and healthcare within fifteen minutes of your home? I dunno, sounds a bit Communist, that.

Answers on an undelivered post card.
Reply
#2
Weirdo conspiracy nuts thinking that prioritising pedestrians = confining people to districts like they're going to introduce something modelled in the Hunger Games.
Reply
#3
I hadn't heard of them until a week ago so I'll be interested to hear views on these. They sound a good idea to me. I did read claims of personal freedoms being restricted e.g. Only allowed outside your FMT so many times a year but that just sounds paranoid nonsense to me.
Reply
#4
The general principle of major amenities being within a 15 min walk of your house seems like a massive positive to me.

We need to incentivise walking and cycling over driving for the majority of out local journeys, which will only happen if people can access the things they need, by walking.
Reply
#5
Public transport outside of London is crap for all
Public transport for the disabled outside of London is absolutely awful
Taxi’s for the disabled in places like Brum are an embarrassment
The clean air nonsense in Brum has just pushed traffic onto the ring road and suburbs where people actually live
There are very few decent amenities in peoples doorsteps in most areas

Address the problems above first then make changes. Not the other way around because all you do is piss people off, ram ever more people onto woeful public transport and make many people job’s impossible financially and practically.
Reply
#6
(02-21-2023, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Public transport outside of London is crap for all
Public transport for the disabled outside of London is absolutely awful
Taxi’s for the disabled in places like Brum are an embarrassment
The clean air nonsense in Brum has just pushed traffic onto the ring road and suburbs where people actually live
There are very few decent amenities in peoples doorsteps in most areas

Address the problems above first then make changes. Not the other way around because all you do is piss people off, ram ever more people onto woeful public transport and make many people job’s impossible financially and practically.

Ah yes. Because addressing air quality problems (that disabled people breath and particularly affects those with respiratory problems), improving pedestrian access (including reducing interfacing with dangerous motor traffic and giving more space for wheelchair users and guide dogs) and attempting to increase local amenities and services (so disabled people don't need to travel so far) really screws over the disabled instead of helping them immensely.
Reply
#7
(02-21-2023, 11:18 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-21-2023, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Public transport outside of London is crap for all
Public transport for the disabled outside of London is absolutely awful
Taxi’s for the disabled in places like Brum are an embarrassment
The clean air nonsense in Brum has just pushed traffic onto the ring road and suburbs where people actually live
There are very few decent amenities in peoples doorsteps in most areas

Address the problems above first then make changes. Not the other way around because all you do is piss people off, ram ever more people onto woeful public transport and make many people job’s impossible financially and practically.

Ah yes. Because addressing air quality problems (that disabled people breath and particularly affects those with respiratory problems), improving pedestrian access (including reducing interfacing with dangerous motor traffic and giving more space for wheelchair users and guide dogs) and attempting to increase local amenities and services (so disabled people don't need to travel so far) really screws over the disabled instead of helping them immensely.

Erm those things aren’t in place so until they are, private vehicles for many disabled people are the only way they can access city centres and other amenities. Address the infrastructure first don’t punish the individuals for having the audacity to have a car and wish to drive to places outside of they’re local area.

All those problems you note are important but there is very little put in place to address them n terms of facilities, law enforcement etc. 

Dare I say it but this argument is far more ‘nuanced’ than beat the motorist over the head with yet more charges.
Reply
#8
(02-21-2023, 11:30 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-21-2023, 11:18 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-21-2023, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Public transport outside of London is crap for all
Public transport for the disabled outside of London is absolutely awful
Taxi’s for the disabled in places like Brum are an embarrassment
The clean air nonsense in Brum has just pushed traffic onto the ring road and suburbs where people actually live
There are very few decent amenities in peoples doorsteps in most areas

Address the problems above first then make changes. Not the other way around because all you do is piss people off, ram ever more people onto woeful public transport and make many people job’s impossible financially and practically.

Ah yes. Because addressing air quality problems (that disabled people breath and particularly affects those with respiratory problems), improving pedestrian access (including reducing interfacing with dangerous motor traffic and giving more space for wheelchair users and guide dogs) and attempting to increase local amenities and services (so disabled people don't need to travel so far) really screws over the disabled instead of helping them immensely.

Erm those things aren’t in place so until they are, private vehicles for many disabled people are the only way they can access city centres and other amenities. Address the infrastructure first don’t punish the individuals for having the audacity to have a car and wish to drive to places outside of they’re local area.

All those problems you note are important but there is very little put in place to address them n terms of facilities, law enforcement etc. 

Dare I say it but this argument is far more ‘nuanced’ than beat the motorist over the head with yet more charges.

Do you think that you can build everything at once? The LTN in Kings Heath is being supplemented by the reopening of the Camp Hill Line and development of the Bordesley Chords. There's a tram extension being built. The pavement on Digbeth High Street is being widened. Colmore Row is being pedestrianised. They're using HS2 to increase capacity at New Street making new stations in the Black Country viable. They're building segregated bus infrastructure with bus gates in from Walsall to Solihull to reduce bus travel times and improve frequency.

You're just using a cop out excuse against building any infrastructure, because ultimately unless you incentivise said new infrastructure you can't build a business case around it so it won't be built. Much the same as your opposition to building more houses your position makes absolutely no sense.
Reply
#9
I think that is the general idea behind the 15 minute city...to improve things so that it is possible  to access all the amenities they need without having to use their car.

All of this will take time, that's why Oxford, for example, are not expecting to have implemented a 15 min city there, before 2040.

But if we continue to naysay new ideas and strangle them at birth, then we will be perpetually in the same boat.

Where people are suffering with their health through exposure to poor air quality, lack of exercise. The economically vulnerable who do not have access to private transport will become increasingly isolated.
Reply
#10
(02-21-2023, 11:42 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-21-2023, 11:30 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-21-2023, 11:18 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-21-2023, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Public transport outside of London is crap for all
Public transport for the disabled outside of London is absolutely awful
Taxi’s for the disabled in places like Brum are an embarrassment
The clean air nonsense in Brum has just pushed traffic onto the ring road and suburbs where people actually live
There are very few decent amenities in peoples doorsteps in most areas

Address the problems above first then make changes. Not the other way around because all you do is piss people off, ram ever more people onto woeful public transport and make many people job’s impossible financially and practically.

Ah yes. Because addressing air quality problems (that disabled people breath and particularly affects those with respiratory problems), improving pedestrian access (including reducing interfacing with dangerous motor traffic and giving more space for wheelchair users and guide dogs) and attempting to increase local amenities and services (so disabled people don't need to travel so far) really screws over the disabled instead of helping them immensely.

Erm those things aren’t in place so until they are, private vehicles for many disabled people are the only way they can access city centres and other amenities. Address the infrastructure first don’t punish the individuals for having the audacity to have a car and wish to drive to places outside of they’re local area.

All those problems you note are important but there is very little put in place to address them n terms of facilities, law enforcement etc. 

Dare I say it but this argument is far more ‘nuanced’ than beat the motorist over the head with yet more charges.

Do you think that you can build everything at once? The LTN in Kings Heath is being supplemented by the reopening of the Camp Hill Line and development of the Bordesley Chords. There's a tram extension being built. The pavement on Digbeth High Street is being widened. Colmore Row is being pedestrianised. They're using HS2 to increase capacity at New Street making new stations in the Black Country viable. They're building segregated bus infrastructure with bus gates in from Walsall to Solihull to reduce bus travel times and improve frequency.

You're just using a cop out excuse against building any infrastructure, because ultimately unless you incentivise said new infrastructure you can't build a business case around it so it won't be built. Much the same as your opposition to building more houses your position makes absolutely no sense.

Until they are built you penalise those with access and mobility difficulties, those who have to use a car for work and those who can’t afford the ever growing costs to access towns and cities with their cars. 

Trying to bully people out of their cars has done feck all for the environment. Birmingham is now strangled by a carpark of a ring road pushing out fuel to those who live in the most deprived areas of the city. 

No I don’t want to live in a concrete carbuncle, not be able to my job whilst those who can afford to live in leafy areas, can afford / physically able to take trains everywhere, or pay to enter the city centre with their electric cars and have access to all Thanks to the size of their wallet. 

This is not a fair or equitable solution until they build the infrastructure first. All you do is punish the less well off for wanting to just go about their lives.,
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)