Carlos Corberan's thinking
#21
Lets not forget we decided to bring Griffiths back from his Pompey loan where he had played every game. This was before Palmers injury. 

Why bring the kid back unless you had serious doubts about your number 2? I firmly believe Griffiths was bought back to put pressure on Button and so Carlos could see him in the flesh.

He apparently chucked one in in the stiffs a few weeks back. Big deal. Buttons dropped some clangers for the stiffs too don't forget. 

Griffiths has had 2 and a half seasons of first team football where he's won rave reviews. Over 100 games. Thats amazing for a 21 year old keeper. I bet theres not a keeper in Europe that has done that other than that Donaruma who started for Milan at 16. You send youngsters out on loan to give them experience and he has plenty. He is also an England U21 International and supposedly every top club is keeping an eye on him.

Yes he's still very young for a keeper but given our situation I don't see that we can afford for Button to stay in goal. If Griffiths isn't going to get his shot then we need to look at freebies and all I can see is Ben Foster and the useless Lee Camp!!
Reply
#22
Bloody hell,  talk about doom and gloom.   Cheer up Chaps.  They say a week in politics is long....... 

Last night was very disappointing made worse by Button's howlers but it's one game, we won ten of the last 13.  

Time for another winning streak,  starting on Wednesday.
Reply
#23
(02-11-2023, 08:59 PM)Hopalong Wrote: Bloody hell,  talk about doom and gloom.   Cheer up Chaps.  They say a week in politics is long....... 

Last night was very disappointing made worse by Button's howlers but it's one game, we won ten of the last 13.  

Time for another winning streak,  starting on Wednesday.

We won 10 of the previous 13, yes, but Button wasn't in goal for 9 of them.
The concerns are justified.
Reply
#24
(02-11-2023, 08:03 PM)Peachy Wrote: Lets not forget we decided to bring Griffiths back from his Pompey loan where he had played every game. This was before Palmers injury. 

Why bring the kid back unless you had serious doubts about your number 2? I firmly believe Griffiths was bought back to put pressure on Button and so Carlos could see him in the flesh.

He apparently chucked one in in the stiffs a few weeks back. Big deal. Buttons dropped some clangers for the stiffs too don't forget. 

Griffiths has had 2 and a half seasons of first team football where he's won rave reviews. Over 100 games. Thats amazing for a 21 year old keeper. I bet theres not a keeper in Europe that has done that other than that Donaruma who started for Milan at 16. You send youngsters out on loan to give them experience and he has plenty. He is also an England U21 International and supposedly every top club is keeping an eye on him.

Yes he's still very young for a keeper but given our situation I don't see that we can afford for Button to stay in goal. If Griffiths isn't going to get his shot then we need to look at freebies and all I can see is Ben Foster and the useless Lee Camp!!

Button clearly fell below his own poor standards last night.  I would expect Carlos to have sat him down today and made it absolutely clear he can't make those kind of mistakes again - as if he needs to spell that out.  Depending on the results on Tuesday there could be enormous pressure on Wednesday's game,   Griffiths may thrive on that pressure but he could also fall apart if he cocks up.  Despite Button's performance it's still a big call to throw Griffiths in (and is it fair to him to make his debut under those circumstances)  but that decision is what Carlos is paid for.  In fairness he took as much responsibilty for the defeat as the team,  so will be doing a lot of analysis to put things right.  

If you analyse the goals, what exactly were Diang and Wallace doing with the first?  Why weren't they in a two man wall covering Button's left hand post area which would have meant Hannibal would have probably crossed it instead?  Whose responsibility was that - you could argue Button's but you could also argue that Dara should have taken some responsibility too?  

The second - yes,  Button misjudged the flight of the ball and missed his punch (in what was a very crowded 6 yd box)  however we had 4/5 bodies in there but Bielek still had a free header - so who was assigned to mark Bielek?    

I'm in no way defending Button but last night wasn't all down to him, we were poor all over the pitch including our organisation and defending.
Reply
#25
If Griffiths falls apart, would he be any worse than Button's usual performances? IMO probably not
Reply
#26
(02-11-2023, 09:27 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-11-2023, 08:03 PM)Peachy Wrote: Lets not forget we decided to bring Griffiths back from his Pompey loan where he had played every game. This was before Palmers injury. 

Why bring the kid back unless you had serious doubts about your number 2? I firmly believe Griffiths was bought back to put pressure on Button and so Carlos could see him in the flesh.

He apparently chucked one in in the stiffs a few weeks back. Big deal. Buttons dropped some clangers for the stiffs too don't forget. 

Griffiths has had 2 and a half seasons of first team football where he's won rave reviews. Over 100 games. Thats amazing for a 21 year old keeper. I bet theres not a keeper in Europe that has done that other than that Donaruma who started for Milan at 16. You send youngsters out on loan to give them experience and he has plenty. He is also an England U21 International and supposedly every top club is keeping an eye on him.

Yes he's still very young for a keeper but given our situation I don't see that we can afford for Button to stay in goal. If Griffiths isn't going to get his shot then we need to look at freebies and all I can see is Ben Foster and the useless Lee Camp!!

Button clearly fell below his own poor standards last night.  I would expect Carlos to have sat him down today and made it absolutely clear he can't make those kind of mistakes again - as if he needs to spell that out.  Depending on the results on Tuesday there could be enormous pressure on Wednesday's game,   Griffiths may thrive on that pressure but he could also fall apart if he cocks up.  Despite Button's performance it's still a big call to throw Griffiths in (and is it fair to him to make his debut under those circumstances)  but that decision is what Carlos is paid for.  In fairness he took as much responsibilty for the defeat as the team,  so will be doing a lot of analysis to put things right.  

If you analyse the goals, what exactly were Diang and Wallace doing with the first?  Why weren't they in a two man wall covering Button's left hand post area which would have meant Hannibal would have probably crossed it instead?  Whose responsibility was that - you could argue Button's but you could also argue that Dara should have taken some responsibility too?  

The second - yes,  Button misjudged the flight of the ball and missed his punch (in what was a very crowded 6 yd box)  however we had 4/5 bodies in there but Bielek still had a free header - so who was assigned to mark Bielek?    

I'm in no way defending Button but last night wasn't all down to him, we were poor all over the pitch including our organisation and defending.

Because Button set the wall wrong. The goalkeeper is supposed to decide the number of people in the wall and the position of it so you can position yourself relative to the ball and the exposed area of the goal.

I would also like to point out that Button nearly conceded two other goals, Blues had another free kick in the first half that Hannibal smashed at him, he fumbled it and very nearly spilled it to a Blues player. He also came to punch a cross, didn't connect and it almost found a Blues player.
Reply
#27
Another insightful OP. Thanks.
Reply
#28
(02-11-2023, 09:07 PM)GMBaggie Wrote:
(02-11-2023, 08:59 PM)Hopalong Wrote: Bloody hell,  talk about doom and gloom.   Cheer up Chaps.  They say a week in politics is long....... 

Last night was very disappointing made worse by Button's howlers but it's one game, we won ten of the last 13.  

Time for another winning streak,  starting on Wednesday.

We won 10 of the previous 13, yes, but Button wasn't in goal for 9 of them.
The concerns are justified.

I didn't say they weren't justified.

(02-11-2023, 09:36 PM)Sliced Wrote: If Griffiths falls apart, would he be any worse than Button's usual performances? IMO probably not

I agree on that point but we're talking about a young player with hopefully a promising career ahead - we just have to trust Carlos's judgement and the coaches.

(02-11-2023, 09:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-11-2023, 09:27 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(02-11-2023, 08:03 PM)Peachy Wrote: Lets not forget we decided to bring Griffiths back from his Pompey loan where he had played every game. This was before Palmers injury. 

Why bring the kid back unless you had serious doubts about your number 2? I firmly believe Griffiths was bought back to put pressure on Button and so Carlos could see him in the flesh.

He apparently chucked one in in the stiffs a few weeks back. Big deal. Buttons dropped some clangers for the stiffs too don't forget. 

Griffiths has had 2 and a half seasons of first team football where he's won rave reviews. Over 100 games. Thats amazing for a 21 year old keeper. I bet theres not a keeper in Europe that has done that other than that Donaruma who started for Milan at 16. You send youngsters out on loan to give them experience and he has plenty. He is also an England U21 International and supposedly every top club is keeping an eye on him.

Yes he's still very young for a keeper but given our situation I don't see that we can afford for Button to stay in goal. If Griffiths isn't going to get his shot then we need to look at freebies and all I can see is Ben Foster and the useless Lee Camp!!

Button clearly fell below his own poor standards last night.  I would expect Carlos to have sat him down today and made it absolutely clear he can't make those kind of mistakes again - as if he needs to spell that out.  Depending on the results on Tuesday there could be enormous pressure on Wednesday's game,   Griffiths may thrive on that pressure but he could also fall apart if he cocks up.  Despite Button's performance it's still a big call to throw Griffiths in (and is it fair to him to make his debut under those circumstances)  but that decision is what Carlos is paid for.  In fairness he took as much responsibilty for the defeat as the team,  so will be doing a lot of analysis to put things right.  

If you analyse the goals, what exactly were Diang and Wallace doing with the first?  Why weren't they in a two man wall covering Button's left hand post area which would have meant Hannibal would have probably crossed it instead?  Whose responsibility was that - you could argue Button's but you could also argue that Dara should have taken some responsibility too?  

The second - yes,  Button misjudged the flight of the ball and missed his punch (in what was a very crowded 6 yd box)  however we had 4/5 bodies in there but Bielek still had a free header - so who was assigned to mark Bielek?    

I'm in no way defending Button but last night wasn't all down to him, we were poor all over the pitch including our organisation and defending.

Because Button set the wall wrong. The goalkeeper is supposed to decide the number of people in the wall and the position of it so you can position yourself relative to the ball and the exposed area of the goal.

I would also like to point out that Button nearly conceded two other goals, Blues had another free kick in the first half that Hannibal smashed at him, he fumbled it and very nearly spilled it to a Blues player. He also came to punch a cross, didn't connect and it almost found a Blues player.

There wasn't a wall was there? But as I said previously is that Button's sole responsibility or do others need to take responsibility too (including Carlos) for organising these rather than just standing around meaninglessly?

You don't need to point anything out to me I saw it with my own eyes and as I've said I'm not defending him, most keepers have a hairy moment or two - Palmer hasn't been perfect and neither was Johnstone - far from it.

His confidence was shot after the first goal and he got away with those you mention.  It's a shame his team-mates didn't put his opposite number under the same pressure and to use your phrase 'smash' a few at him.  

He did make a good save from Chong in the first half that was going in the top corner (where was Furlong?) and the one he fumbled from Hannibal was a good save albeit he fumbled it.  

At least we have a new super spacegoat  Big Grin and it deflects the heat off of the other 15 who didn't turn up.
Reply
#29
Button is RUBBISH
Reply
#30
(02-12-2023, 12:50 AM)BaggieBaggieBromBrom Wrote: Button is RUBBISH

Yes we know, what's your point?  
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: