Posts: 1,139
Threads: 11
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
Playing the ball on the deck and being confident in possession at the back rather than aimlessly punting the ball forward and losing the ball is a positive; playing little triangles and hospital passes a la Livermore at Bristol is another entirely. We don’t have the players to do that and I have seen teams regularly come unstuck doing similar this season other than Man City.
Posts: 986
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
This may be controversial.
The rigidity was an issue. One or two players struggled with it. However, the refusal of the home support to accept it was just as much of a problem.
The ‘support’ turned it into a self fulfulling prophecy. I heard the following over and over again
The fucking about at the back is costing us goals every week
We make the same mistakes over and over again
This became an accepted ‘fact’ even though the reality was that it didn’t cost us goals in the first half of the season. I repeatedly asked people to name the goals it had cost us. Nobody could. I don’t accept JRod v Derby as that was a striker doing what they do every so often. Just a huge bollock which happens regardless of formation.
The home fans have some responsibility to bear for the outcome of this season, for turning The Hawthorns into a place wher a significant chunk of the squad just did not want to play. This is fact and was part of the reason for our poor run at home.
Hammering Johnstone every time he waited, as instructed was the most damaging thing. It was interesting that despite not fucking about at the back any more, he still got hammered on Monday for correctly choosing to hold the ball rather than throw it to Holgate just before half time. Hammering the players and constantly getting on their backs at every missed pass affects them. The away form was superb and part of the reason for this was the player’s attitude to away games due to the support.
Then came Boro. The it was like manna from heaven for the detractors because they finally had concrete evidence to back up their default settings.
There was a total refusal to admit that playing at the back had a major positive impact in our strong second half performances and numerous late goals as the opposition were knackered. This is a fundamental component of the tactic.
It was also vitally important in releasing Barnes and giving him the space to wreak havoc.
Of course, being banned from clearing your lines is ridiculous and being totally rigid is a problem, but not going up because we faffed about at the back is bollocks IMHO.
We have many accepted ‘facts’, such as Johnstone, Bertley and Mears all being shit, J-Rod doing fuck all but pens and tap ins, Brunt should never put a shirt on etc etc.
Losing Barnes, Phillips, questionable or non subs, playing players out of position, and the poor run of home form not helped one bit by the support are all bigger reasons for us not being promoted automatically than faffing about at the back.
We want exciting football. We want goals. We don’t care if we concede or lose a few as long as we are trying to win games. We’d rather be in the championship than defending and hoping for a set piece. This was the mantra for three years under Pulis, during relegation and in the summer.
The reality of thiis season has proved all of those statements to be a steaming pile of horse shit.
We want open attacking football, with no risk and a clean sheet every week. It doesn’t exist.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(04-27-2019, 10:59 AM)Statto Wrote: This may be controversial.
The rigidity was an issue. One or two players struggled with it. However, the refusal of the home support to accept it was just as much of a problem.
The ‘support’ turned it into a self fulfulling prophecy. I heard the following over and over again
The fucking about at the back is costing us goals every week
We make the same mistakes over and over again
This became an accepted ‘fact’ even though the reality was that it didn’t cost us goals in the first half of the season. I repeatedly asked people to name the goals it had cost us. Nobody could. I don’t accept JRod v Derby as that was a striker doing what they do every so often. Just a huge bollock which happens regardless of formation.
The home fans have some responsibility to bear for the outcome of this season, for turning The Hawthorns into a place wher a significant chunk of the squad just did not want to play. This is fact and was part of the reason for our poor run at home.
Hammering Johnstone every time he waited, as instructed was the most damaging thing. It was interesting that despite not fucking about at the back any more, he still got hammered on Monday for correctly choosing to hold the ball rather than throw it to Holgate just before half time. Hammering the players and constantly getting on their backs at every missed pass affects them. The away form was superb and part of the reason for this was the player’s attitude to away games due to the support.
Then came Boro. The it was like manna from heaven for the detractors because they finally had concrete evidence to back up their default settings.
There was a total refusal to admit that playing at the back had a major positive impact in our strong second half performances and numerous late goals as the opposition were knackered. This is a fundamental component of the tactic.
It was also vitally important in releasing Barnes and giving him the space to wreak havoc.
Of course, being banned from clearing your lines is ridiculous and being totally rigid is a problem, but not going up because we faffed about at the back is bollocks IMHO.
We have many accepted ‘facts’, such as Johnstone, Bertley and Mears all being shit, J-Rod doing fuck all but pens and tap ins, Brunt should never put a shirt on etc etc.
Losing Barnes, Phillips, questionable or non subs, playing players out of position, and the poor run of home form not helped one bit by the support are all bigger reasons for us not being promoted automatically than faffing about at the back.
We want exciting football. We want goals. We don’t care if we concede or lose a few as long as we are trying to win games. We’d rather be in the championship than defending and hoping for a set piece. This was the mantra for three years under Pulis, during relegation and in the summer.
The reality of thiis season has proved all of those statements to be a steaming pile of horse shit.
We want open attacking football, with no risk and a clean sheet every week. It doesn’t exist.
Can't really disagree with any of that Statto.
First half of the season, Derby excepted, we lost games in which we failed to attack well. I think there have been occasions where we conceded goals because we have been careless in the way we have passed the ball in our half of the field, but by and large these have not cost us points and we don't know how many points we may not have gained by taking a more direct and defensive approach to our play.
Clem posted earlier in the thread that you won't concede goals if the ball is in row z, true, but by the same token you won't score goals if the ball is in row z.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
Open, exciting attacking football doesn't come from having 1000 passes in your own half.
I agree the fans didn't take to the style and didn't help, but I couldn't name you a West Brom team that has ever played in the style that Jones tried to impose on us.
I don't think the fans want Pulisball, or tippy-tappy for that matter. What I think we want is pragmatic football with a bit of style.
Posts: 27,981
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(04-27-2019, 11:16 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Open, exciting attacking football doesn't come from having 1000 passes in your own half.
I agree the fans didn't take to the style and didn't help, but I couldn't name you a West Brom team that has ever played in the style that Jones tried to impose on us.
Mowbray’s PL season wants a word.
Posts: 1,187
Threads: 52
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
(04-27-2019, 11:16 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Open, exciting attacking football doesn't come from having 1000 passes in your own half.
I agree the fans didn't take to the style and didn't help, but I couldn't name you a West Brom team that has ever played in the style that Jones tried to impose on us.
I don't think the fans want Pulisball, or tippy-tappy for that matter. What I think we want is pragmatic football with a bit of style.
Pulisball wasn't just about a long ball game v tippy tappy. It was the restrictive nature of Pulisball that wears people down over time.
Games where we won, could have long periods where there just wasn't much happening and little happening from open play as a goal threat.
I've got nothing against a long ball game as such, as long as there is some kind method behind it and goal threat.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(04-27-2019, 11:23 AM)Duffers Wrote: (04-27-2019, 11:16 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Open, exciting attacking football doesn't come from having 1000 passes in your own half.
I agree the fans didn't take to the style and didn't help, but I couldn't name you a West Brom team that has ever played in the style that Jones tried to impose on us.
Mowbray’s PL season wants a word.
Fair play - and look how it ended up.
I remember on this forum calling it "the emperors new clothes", because Mowbray kept telling us how good it was, but we all knew how it would end up.
Each to their own, but I certainly don't want to watch "considered" football. I want to see the ball moved quickly and not over-elaborated. That doesn't mean I want to see route one pulisball though.
I was bought up on the late 70's team. They were exciting, but they were direct when they had to be as well. You wouldn't have seen Wile & Robertson playing triangles in their own half.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
I personally love watching good football of all types, possession based, counter attacking, even effective defensive football if its done well. Only thing I struggle with is pure Pulis ball, it's not so much defensive as just not even playing the game anymore.
Posts: 1,139
Threads: 11
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
Forget Pulis and Mowbray / Moore. The best football we have played in the last 20 years was the first half of Clarke’s first season - well-organised, hard to beat AND decent football and goals. That should be the blueprint whatever level we are at.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
04-27-2019, 12:03 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-27-2019, 12:04 PM by Kit Kat Chunky.)
(04-27-2019, 11:57 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I personally love watching good football of all types, possession based, counter attacking, even effective defensive football if its done well. Only thing I struggle with is pure Pulis ball, it's not so much defensive as just not even playing the game anymore.
It's a method of achieving an result. I wouldn't call it football.
(04-27-2019, 12:02 PM)clem4england Wrote: Forget Pulis and Mowbray / Moore. The best football we have played in the last 20 years was the first half of Clarke’s first season - well-organised, hard to beat AND decent football and goals. That should be the blueprint whatever level we are at.
I think that was Hodgson's organisation with a bit of flair - exactly what I'm talking about.
|