Livermore
#11
(04-26-2019, 09:59 AM)Dumbo Wrote: --Phillips--Johansen--Brunt--

Overrun.

Field--Johansen--Brunt

Phillips as a wingback
Reply
#12
(04-26-2019, 12:43 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-26-2019, 09:59 AM)Dumbo Wrote: --Phillips--Johansen--Brunt--

Overrun.

Field--Johansen--Brunt

Phillips as a wingback

Phillips is totally wasted at wing back IMO. Plus he doesn't, and never has, follow runners.
Holgate a much better bet there. Get Phillips in the middle
Reply
#13
(04-26-2019, 12:48 PM)boingingbaggie Wrote:
(04-26-2019, 12:43 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-26-2019, 09:59 AM)Dumbo Wrote: --Phillips--Johansen--Brunt--

Overrun.

Field--Johansen--Brunt

Phillips as a wingback

Phillips is totally wasted at wing back IMO. Plus he doesn't, and never has, follow runners.
Holgate a much better bet there. Get Phillips in the middle

If he doesn’t follow runners, he can’t be trusted in the middle  with only Brunt and Johansen!!

Phillips was at his best this season when played as a wingback, and the legacy of Pulis is he tracks back  in a wide position - TP even trusted him at RB on occasion.

Phillips has performed in the middle once.

Holgate offers nothing going forward, and in our system games are won/lost in those positions. Phillips as a wingback with Holgate on the right of a back 3 alongside Dawson and Hegazi for me.
Reply
#14
Holgate has 1 goal and 3 assists this season, which is the same goals + assists per game as Gibbs. He definitely offers something going forward. Arguably he's better going forward than defending.
Reply
#15
(04-26-2019, 01:06 PM)Sliced Wrote: Holgate has 1 goal and 3 assists this season, which is the same goals + assists per game as Gibbs. He definitely offers something going forward. Arguably he's better going forward than defending.

None of those have come in a 3-5-2 formation, they've all come from him playing at fullback and the goal was from a corner from memory. 

Phillips has 5 goals and 7 assists, with the majority of his goals coming from when he featured out wide in a 4-4-2 and 3-5-2.

I don't get the clamour for Phillips in the middle, he needs space to attack and he gets far more of that when he can cut in from wide positions and when he can get behind the opposing fullback.
Reply
#16
We've only played that formation for about 3 games though, and the fact that he's got 1 goal and 3 assists in a more defensive position than he would be in that formation only further shows that he offers us something going forwards. I think either are reasonable options but intuitively I would go for Phillips in the centre because of the combination of lack of mobility in our CM positions and the fact that Holgate undoubtedly does more defensively than Phillips. The other option of course is Holgate at CB, however the Bartley and Dawson have looked more solid recently. I'd be worried seeing Holgate in the centre to be honest.
Reply
#17
Hit the Gym to much for me, far to big up top now, very slow. Can't believe he got in the England squad.
Reply
#18
I'd go Field for Jake. Did enough for me at Reading to get another go.

(04-26-2019, 01:06 PM)Sliced Wrote: Holgate has 1 goal and 3 assists this season, which is the same goals + assists per game as Gibbs. He definitely offers something going forward. Arguably he's better going forward than defending.

Gibbs has scored more than 1 Slice. Sheff Utd away and then last week against Hull spring to mind. Sure he's scored more too.
Reply
#19
(04-26-2019, 02:18 PM)Peachy Wrote: I'd go Field for Jake. Did enough for me at Reading to get another go.

(04-26-2019, 01:06 PM)Sliced Wrote: Holgate has 1 goal and 3 assists this season, which is the same goals + assists per game as Gibbs. He definitely offers something going forward. Arguably he's better going forward than defending.

Gibbs has scored more than 1 Slice. Sheff Utd away and then last week against Hull spring to mind. Sure he's scored more too.

Per game Peach and goals + assists. He's scored 4 and 4 assists (8) in 34 games
Holgate has 1 and 3 (so 4) in 17 games

I'm not suggesting that Holgate is as good as Gibbs btw. IMO he isn't
Reply
#20
Another week?

that’s another stone
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: