Teachers Strikes
#51
If you’re using what’s accepted in parliament as the cornerstone of certainty I think we have a conclusion to this one.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#52
(01-18-2023, 08:15 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You might all bleat your high social status opinions on here but there are two FaCTs that need to be taken into account. 1) Public sector pay rises feed into inflation. There is no debate about that. 2) The only way public sector pay rises can be funded is by higher taxes, at a time when the tax burden is already at a 70 year high.

Inflation is the greatest hidden “tax” on us all - particularly the poor saps on fixed incomes. The longer inflation prevails the poorer we all become. You won’t defeat inflation by creating a wage / price spiral, you’ll just make it worse.

You are wrong. Public sector pay rises don't feed inflation if taxes rise to pay for them. That is basic economics.

Here is an explainer from Milton Friedman:

https://www.cato.org/commentary/wage-pri...erous-myth

Had we not had austerity and QE (and Brexit) we wouldn't be in such fucking mess. A mess that will take a long time to get out of.

Nevertheless, all workers need to accept that real wages have to fall due to that bastard in Russia invading Ukraine. Only when our economy has adjusted to the energy price shock will things get better.
Reply
#53
Thank you for your opinion, but in a labour market as tight as our own rising wages in one sector will only bid up wage demands (and salaries offered to attract workers) in other sectors - why do you think private sector wage growth is at 7%? That will only embed inflation, even if it doesn’t constitute a real increase.

You’re right about the fact that we’ll all have to get used to being a little poorer to get inflation under control.

(01-18-2023, 08:14 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: If you’re using what’s accepted in parliament as the cornerstone of certainty I think we have a conclusion to this one.

More than happy to hear what you take issue with in the ONS numbers. Be my guest. I
Reply
#54
(01-18-2023, 09:54 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Thank you for your opinion, but in a labour market as tight as our own rising wages in one sector will only bid  up wage demands (and salaries offered to attract workers) in other sectors - why do you think private sector wage growth is at 7%? That will only embed inflation, even if it doesn’t constitute a real increase.

You’re right about the fact that we’ll all have to get used to being a little poorer to get inflation under control.


Just so as I’m clear in what you are saying here, are you seriously saying that if nurses or teachers get 10% then the private sector workers will demand the same? I think in there you admitted that public sector pay rises themselves wouldn’t impact inflation, glad we got there in the end. I’m keen to understand your logic behind paying public sector workers more would cause private sector wage demands to increase as well. Do you think that private sector workers will down tools and threaten to become nurses or ambulance drivers instead leaving the private sector employers no choice.

And forgive me if I’ve remembered this incorrectly but wasn’t the point you made months ago about truck drivers getting paid more because brexit had restricted the labour market a good thing?
Reply
#55
Excuse my ignorance but how much are newly qualified primary and a secondary school teacher picking up?
Reply
#56
(01-19-2023, 06:33 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(01-18-2023, 09:54 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Thank you for your opinion, but in a labour market as tight as our own rising wages in one sector will only bid  up wage demands (and salaries offered to attract workers) in other sectors - why do you think private sector wage growth is at 7%? That will only embed inflation, even if it doesn’t constitute a real increase.

You’re right about the fact that we’ll all have to get used to being a little poorer to get inflation under control.


Just so as I’m clear in what you are saying here, are you seriously saying that if nurses or teachers get 10% then the private sector workers will demand the same? I think in there you admitted that public sector pay rises themselves wouldn’t impact inflation, glad we got there in the end. I’m keen to understand your logic behind paying public sector workers more would cause private sector wage demands to increase as well. Do you think that private sector workers will down tools and threaten to become nurses or ambulance drivers instead leaving the private sector employers no choice.

And forgive me if I’ve remembered this incorrectly but wasn’t the point you made months ago about truck drivers getting paid more because brexit had restricted the labour market a good thing?

I have pointed this hypocrisy / contradiction out a number of times. It was also a Brexit benefit for builders as well. Proth’s politics are a moving target, so he can never be wrong.
Reply
#57
(01-19-2023, 08:17 AM)Jimmy_Moz Wrote: Excuse my ignorance but how much are newly qualified primary and a secondary school teacher picking up?

28k.

I wouldnt teach Primary for 56k, never mind 28.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#58
(01-19-2023, 06:33 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(01-18-2023, 09:54 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Thank you for your opinion, but in a labour market as tight as our own rising wages in one sector will only bid  up wage demands (and salaries offered to attract workers) in other sectors - why do you think private sector wage growth is at 7%? That will only embed inflation, even if it doesn’t constitute a real increase.

You’re right about the fact that we’ll all have to get used to being a little poorer to get inflation under control.


Just so as I’m clear in what you are saying here, are you seriously saying that if nurses or teachers get 10% then the private sector workers will demand the same? I think in there you admitted that public sector pay rises themselves wouldn’t impact inflation, glad we got there in the end. I’m keen to understand your logic behind paying public sector workers more would cause private sector wage demands to increase as well. Do you think that private sector workers will down tools and threaten to become nurses or ambulance drivers instead leaving the private sector employers no choice.

And forgive me if I’ve remembered this incorrectly but wasn’t the point you made months ago about truck drivers getting paid more because brexit had restricted the labour market a good thing?

No, I didn't admit that. Quite the opposite.

If public sector workers bid up wages (and pension contributions) they have to be paid for. If all workers face more taxation (which they already do) to pay for public sector wages rises then they will naturally bid up wages to protect net pay - particularly in a tight labour market. Core inflation will become embedded, interest rates will stay higher for longer and we'll all be even poorer. I don't think a that's too complex a concept to grasp.

I have no problem with the Independent Pay Review bodies revisiting their evidence and recommendations, but part of that evidence will be from the OBR which lays bare the problem:
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk...LISHED.pdf
Reply
#59
Yeah the ‘independent’ pay bodies that have their parameters put in place by the government based on what is available, not a measure of what we need to attract and retain key workers.

And stop talking bollocks about tax pushing up inflation when we’ve had next to zero inflation for years whilst, as you have pointed out, the highest tax burden ever.

It must be so complicated having such diametrically opposed opinions to keep tripping up over.
Reply
#60
(01-19-2023, 11:38 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And stop talking bollocks about tax pushing up inflation when we’ve had next to zero inflation for years whilst, as you have pointed out, the highest tax burden ever.

Hmm. 

Sunak's post-Covid "Fiscal Drag forever" has coincided with the greatest inflationary problem since the late 1970s / early 1980s. If your net pay is visibly reducing year on year, you're being dragged into tax for the first time or into a higher band, or are in danger of tapering Child Benefit these are the kind of things you notice, and the kind of things that feed into wage demands.  

It's also coincided with the "Great Resignation" which has further tightened labour markets.

I'm not convinced that it makes any sense to compare today with, say 2019, prior to Rishi's main tax grabs, the inflationary crisis and the further tightening of the labour market. The past, in this respect - is a different country.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: