Teachers Strikes
#41
(01-18-2023, 04:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Under a Labour government which expanded the Public Sector by 50% productivity actually fell by 2% between 1997-2009.

Under the Tories 2010-2019 the public sector expanded by 8% and productivity edged up to 3.7% compared with 1997 levels. All this increase was lost during the Covid pandemic despite an expansion of the public sector by 10% in that period. To reiterate - All of that increase wiped out since 1997.

So with all the technology and automation available to the public sector in the UK, public sector productivity has not increased at all in 26 years - and actually fell when Labour was spunking money (largely in wages and additional hires) between 1997-2009.

Who produced these stats, how were they determined? If we take the NHS as an example, I seem to recall record satisfaction statistics. Minutes, days / weeks turnaround in care, not months, years for treatment / consultations. I remember targeted local public health that was having a real impact on peoples health. Labour at the time was working and a damn site better than the clown car we have now running things.

Can you explain how the productivity in youth provision has gone up? In care? Mental health? The courts? Education? I’m not saying you’re talking absolute oss poo but I suspect you are using weasel words and skewed statistics to argue that funding cuts haven’t made a difference.
Reply
#42
Fill your boots Dekka: https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/economico...vices/2019

Figure 1 is a good start.
Reply
#43
(01-18-2023, 05:10 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Fill your boots Dekka: https://www.ons.gov.uk/economy/economico...vices/2019

Figure 1 is a good start.

They prove feck all, other than statistics don’t tell anywhere near the truth. 

The NHS is far worse now than it was 13 years ago
Ambulance Service, much worse 
Care is no better if not worse 
Mental health no better if not worse 
Public Health no better, much worse in reality 
Court system worse
Social Care provision worse 
Prison service worse 

No one who has any direct contact with those services over the past decade without a vested interest will argue services are better, more efficient or have better outcomes. For proof, and using the NHS again waiting times up in AE, diagnostics, treatment, operations, GP appointments, ambulance waits, life expectancy down, excess deaths, NHS dentistry, mental health support etc etc. I don’t really think at this stage of Tory governance that there is any real belief that things have got better in pretty much any public service over the last 14yrs no matter what this report argues.
Reply
#44
They prove that productivity has not increased at all in public services for a quarter of a century. That is not up for debate.
Reply
#45
(01-18-2023, 05:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote: They prove that productivity has not increased at all in public services for a quarter of a century. That is not up for debate.

They also don’t prove that austerity has delivered a better service quite the contrary. The lack of joined up thinking about what those cuts would do over the medium to long term to services is why we are where we are. No matter how you dress it, most if not all public services were better under Labour. 

Before tearing things down as your party seems hell bent on from austerity to Brexit perhaps have a credible, plan for a better future for all, good public services and at the centre of all policies what’s best for the nation, not best for a small cabal of rich, Tufton Street, hard right, ideologically driven loons and useful idiots / enablers (who might they be?) who want to cling to power even when they know they are making other peoples lives worse.
Reply
#46
I think you're having a different argument with yourself again Dekka.

I don't believe, as a taxpayer, that it is too much to ask for public sector productivity to increase in twenty-five years of growing state expenditure and a massive expansion of technology & automation. If outcomes are declining and productivity hasn't grown at all isn't that a damning indictment of how our money is being spent?

Would anyone actually disagree with that?

Which brings me back to the point really. It's madness to spend even more of our money with no guarantees that productivity and outcomes will improve. Increasing wages must go hand in hand with reform and measurable incremental improvement.
Reply
#47
(01-18-2023, 06:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I think you're having a different argument with yourself again Dekka.

I don't believe, as a taxpayer, that it is too much to ask for public sector productivity to increase in twenty-five years of growing state expenditure and a massive expansion of technology & automation. If outcomes are declining and productivity hasn't grown at all isn't that a damning indictment of how our money is being spent?

Would anyone actually disagree with that?

Which brings me back to the point really. It's madness to spend even more of our money with no guarantees that productivity and outcomes will improve. Increasing wages must go hand in hand with reform and measurable incremental improvement.

You continue to ignore the fact the NHS was functioning well before your party strolled into power and ‘improved’ it’s ‘productivity’ and made it erm a lot worse and not function properly. 

I get the feeling you when you say productivity you mean people treated like robotic drones to serve, not complain and accept anything the government says they should.
Reply
#48
(01-18-2023, 05:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote: They prove that productivity has not increased at all in public services for a quarter of a century. That is not up for debate.

All such statistics are up for debate.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#49
(01-18-2023, 07:44 PM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(01-18-2023, 05:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote: They prove that productivity has not increased at all in public services for a quarter of a century. That is not up for debate.

All such statistics are up for debate.

There doesn't appear to be much debate about them. They're generally accepted in Parliament.

But give it your best shot nevertheless.

(01-18-2023, 07:16 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-18-2023, 06:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I think you're having a different argument with yourself again Dekka.

I don't believe, as a taxpayer, that it is too much to ask for public sector productivity to increase in twenty-five years of growing state expenditure and a massive expansion of technology & automation. If outcomes are declining and productivity hasn't grown at all isn't that a damning indictment of how our money is being spent?

Would anyone actually disagree with that?

Which brings me back to the point really. It's madness to spend even more of our money with no guarantees that productivity and outcomes will improve. Increasing wages must go hand in hand with reform and measurable incremental improvement.

You continue to ignore the fact the NHS was functioning well before your party strolled into power and ‘improved’ it’s ‘productivity’ and made it erm a lot worse and not function properly. 

I get the feeling you when you say productivity you mean people treated like robotic drones to serve, not complain and accept anything the government says they should.

I'm not ignoring anything, and please don't misunderstand me - I don't believe the NHS has got better since 2010 - it's as dreadful if not worse than before in terms of outcomes.

You may "get the feeling" about my motivation, but as usual you're wrong.

You never seem able to answer a direct question so I'll pose it again "If outcomes are declining and productivity hasn't grown at all isn't that a damning indictment of how our money is being spent?"
Reply
#50
[Image: Fmx6Y3UXEAESfUY?format=jpg&name=900x900]

Oh for 2008’s lack of productivity!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: