Teachers Strikes
#21
(01-18-2023, 08:15 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You might all bleat your high social status opinions on here but there are two FaCTs that need to be taken into account. 1) Public sector pay rises feed into inflation. There is no debate about that. 2) The only way public sector pay rises can be funded is by higher taxes, at a time when the tax burden is already at a 70 year high.

Inflation is the greatest hidden “tax” on us all - particularly the poor saps on fixed incomes. The longer inflation prevails the poorer we all become. You won’t defeat inflation by creating a wage / price spiral, you’ll just make it worse.

So to clarify, you support uprating welfare and pensions but not pay?

Interesting
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#22
Me posting a cheque to the Treasury is going to ensure teachers don't strike over pay and address the chronic shortages in subjects like maths and physics, aye? I really hate this dumb argument, and if I really wanted I could become self-employed instead of PAYE and utilise my savings more efficiently if I wanted to pay less tax.

You have a choice here, either except tax receipts need to go up or face more strikes, educational disruption, teacher shortages, school place shortages, lack of provision for new school buildings etc. Unfortunately the Tories have dropped the ball economically so increased tax receipts through growth hasn't happened and isn't going to happen with predicted stagflation, so you're either stuck with higher taxes or borrowing and any self-respecting economic liberal would always choose tax over borrowing.
Reply
#23
(01-18-2023, 08:15 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You might all bleat your high social status opinions on here but there are two FaCTs that need to be taken into account. 1) Public sector pay rises feed into inflation. There is no debate about that. 2) The only way public sector pay rises can be funded is by higher taxes, at a time when the tax burden is already at a 70 year high.

Inflation is the greatest hidden “tax” on us all - particularly the poor saps on fixed incomes. The longer inflation prevails the poorer we all become. You won’t defeat inflation by creating a wage / price spiral, you’ll just make it worse.

Says man who got a Brexit bonus stiffy that builders and lorry drivers wages were rising at a ludicrous level only a year or so ago. 

What you’re arguing is the public sector workers should be happy to take a significant and unaffordable in some cases hit to their wages and conditions and meekly accept that. Meanwhile this government are hell bent on deregulating bankers income so they can earn more obscene income. Similarly shareholders and the top 1% continue to see huge rises in their income. Ironic given the reason / excuse for austerity of public services was because of the same people crashing the economy and yet you make an exception for them.
Reply
#24
BB - tax receipts ARE going up. Fiscal drag will see to that - more low paid workers will be drawn into tax, more moderately paid workers will be drawn into Higher Tax and those that aren’t in control of their own affairs (largely salaried senior public sector workers) will be drawn into the top rate of tax. Corporation Tax is also being increased by a quarter. How much more do YOU want to pay?

(01-18-2023, 09:15 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote:
(01-18-2023, 08:15 AM)Protheroe Wrote: You might all bleat your high social status opinions on here but there are two FaCTs that need to be taken into account. 1) Public sector pay rises feed into inflation. There is no debate about that. 2) The only way public sector pay rises can be funded is by higher taxes, at a time when the tax burden is already at a 70 year high.

Inflation is the greatest hidden “tax” on us all - particularly the poor saps on fixed incomes. The longer inflation prevails the poorer we all become. You won’t defeat inflation by creating a wage / price spiral, you’ll just make it worse.

So to clarify, you support uprating welfare and pensions but not pay?

Interesting

See my note re: Fixed Incomes. Those of us in employment can move jobs in what remains a tight labour market, those who are pensioners or long term sick cannot.

I'm not against pay increases, just against pay increases that are self defeating when the only enemy we ought to be concentrating on is the one that robs us all - inflation.
Reply
#25
(01-18-2023, 10:14 AM)Protheroe Wrote: BB - tax receipts ARE going up. Fiscal drag will see to that - more low paid workers will be drawn into tax, more moderately paid workers will be drawn into Higher Tax and those that aren’t in control of their own affairs (largely salaried senior public sector workers) will be drawn into the top rate of tax. Corporation Tax is also being increased by a quarter. How much more do YOU want to pay?

And they NEED to go up to cover expenditure, you can't have functioning public services with chronic shortages. If taxes need to go up to alleviate chronic shortages then they need to go up.

Quite frankly there are more economically liberal countries than the UK with higher tax burdens (Netherlands, Sweden) and if that's what's necessary then sobeit. The experiment to increase tax receipts via growth has failed due to a lack of growth over 15 years and projections are flat for the next 5, something needs to give.

Either accept that income tax needs to go up or don't complain about teachers going on strike. You can't have your cake and eat it. Nominal teacher salaries have been flat for 13 years and inflation is at 10%, no fucking shit they're striking. I'm astonished it took them this long.
Reply
#26
Can’t Proth show some ‘agency’ and pop his kids into private education? Or are those teachers on strike as well?
Reply
#27
(01-18-2023, 10:34 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-18-2023, 10:14 AM)Protheroe Wrote: BB - tax receipts ARE going up. Fiscal drag will see to that - more low paid workers will be drawn into tax, more moderately paid workers will be drawn into Higher Tax and those that aren’t in control of their own affairs (largely salaried senior public sector workers) will be drawn into the top rate of tax. Corporation Tax is also being increased by a quarter. How much more do YOU want to pay?

And they NEED to go up to cover expenditure, you can't have functioning public services with chronic shortages. If taxes need to go up to alleviate chronic shortages then they need to go up.

Quite frankly there are more economically liberal countries than the UK with higher tax burdens (Netherlands, Sweden) and if that's what's necessary then sobeit. The experiment to increase tax receipts via growth has failed due to a lack of growth over 15 years and projections are flat for the next 5, something needs to give.

Either accept that income tax needs to go up or don't complain about teachers going on strike. You can't have your cake and eat it. Nominal teacher salaries have been flat for 13 years and inflation is at 10%, no fucking shit they're striking. I'm astonished it took them this long.

How much more do YOU want to pay? Put a figure on it. Come on.
Reply
#28
(01-18-2023, 10:34 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-18-2023, 10:14 AM)Protheroe Wrote: BB - tax receipts ARE going up. Fiscal drag will see to that - more low paid workers will be drawn into tax, more moderately paid workers will be drawn into Higher Tax and those that aren’t in control of their own affairs (largely salaried senior public sector workers) will be drawn into the top rate of tax. Corporation Tax is also being increased by a quarter. How much more do YOU want to pay?

And they NEED to go up to cover expenditure, you can't have functioning public services with chronic shortages. If taxes need to go up to alleviate chronic shortages then they need to go up.

Quite frankly there are more economically liberal countries than the UK with higher tax burdens (Netherlands, Sweden) and if that's what's necessary then sobeit. The experiment to increase tax receipts via growth has failed due to a lack of growth over 15 years and projections are flat for the next 5, something needs to give.

Either accept that income tax needs to go up or don't complain about teachers going on strike. You can't have your cake and eat it. Nominal teacher salaries have been flat for 13 years and inflation is at 10%, no fucking shit they're striking. I'm astonished it took them this long.

Agreed. But ive not seen this much anger and unity in the sector in my lifetime. Gonna be a turbulent few months this.
Someone could have been killed
Reply
#29
When you go from ‘We’re all in this together’ to ‘grab what you can lads’ in a decade the workers will get a tad pissed off
Reply
#30
(01-18-2023, 10:43 AM)CaptainFantastico Wrote: Agreed. But ive not seen this much anger and unity in the sector in my lifetime. Gonna be a turbulent few months this.

Imagine their disappointment when they realise the  next Labour government can't give them what they want either.

(01-18-2023, 10:50 AM)baggy1 Wrote: When you go from ‘We’re all in this together’ to ‘grab what you can lads’ in a decade the workers will get a tad pissed off

Surely no one ever believed the "we're all in this together" bollocks? "Strong & Stable"? "Build Back Better"? "Levelling Up"?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: