FFP Points deductions
#71
(04-24-2019, 04:33 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-24-2019, 04:26 PM)Juan Quidonqui Wrote:
(04-24-2019, 04:13 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-24-2019, 03:40 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-24-2019, 02:55 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: Not one poster has a clue though. Gew used to write the equivalent to War and Peace about it but neither he, Prag or Minstrel can tell us anything that isn't pretty much in the public domain. We will all here more about the (non) story at about the same time as each other.

i think that is unfair, Worcs.

It is fair to say that we do not have the inside track on the internal workings of any EFL Club, or are privy to the EFL meetings. 

We do understand the P&S rules though, which inter-alia our professional experience does give the ability to comment on the rules and their interpretation. None of us have ever pretended to be ITK, and indeed the information is in the public domain. Not too many people can either be bothered by it, or fully understand it, though.

Spot on KKC.  Apart from the very occasional comment from somebody connected to a club, anything I post is based on my interpretation of info which is in the public domain, including the EFL’s own regulations which remarkably few have bothered to read (including journalists!).

I’m not surprised by the clubs’ vote at today’s meeting of EFL clubs (to be clear, it wasn’t an EFL meeting and I believe that’s going on separately. I couldn’t see that clubs would open their books to other clubs.  It has to be down to the EFL itself as “regulator”.  Does Gibson believe that 3 clubs are telling the EFL the truth about their finances?  Clearly not.

The big problem is that the 3 clubs can string the EFL along, mislead them, lie to them, get promoted by cheating. Next March’s audited accounts will then prove them to have lied, but too late - the horse has bolted and those clubs will take their chances.

What we can’t have is some clubs cheating (without being sanctioned) and prospering as a result, while other clubs abide by the rules.  Either the EFL must enforce their own rules or they must scrap them. One or the other.

If (as I believe) any punishment of the EFL can now be effectively carried over and enforced by the Premier League I suppose the only thing that might make clubs think twice about scamming their way around the rules would be a massive points deduction imposed by the Premier League if it’s found that they had lied to the EFL about their finances when the fully audited accounts come out. And by massive I mean enough to almost certainly relegate them straight back down after one year.

It would have to be a points deduction, rather than a fine. The fine is an irrelevance to the obscenely wealthy that this applies to.

They should also forfeit the parachute, and the enhanced losses that a relegated club enjoys under P&S from the Prem. So you send them back to the division they came from, with no financial advantage, and make them play by the rules moving forward.

All the PL care about is their brand, and the subsequent marketability and financial rewards this brings, so I doubt they’ll take any action to water down the competitiveness of their brand by deducting a team so many points as to make relegation a dead cert, or impose a transfer ban which will weaken a side so much they become an embarrassment to the league. The PL is in favour of relaxing FFFP rules, and hasn’t signed up to the P&S rules Villa would be breaching, so whilst they may well agree to honour any punishment they’ll be pushing for one which doesn’t harm the inherent value of the PL by watering down the quality, and the EFL constantly badgering the PL for trickle down cash will hardly put up a fight IMO. 

The PL wants foreign owners with massive wallets creating interest in home countries and Villa have American, Chinese and Saudi-Egyptian owners, all areas of expansion for the PL Brand... If any punishment is going to seriously harm Villa it has to happen this season as if they do manage to get through the playoffs I genuinely think they’ll get away with their over spending. 

I realise the EFL need to be seen to be taking action against clubs that overspend and break the rules, but I just can’t see them getting their act in gear before it’s too late. If they get up it’ll be a relatively soft embargo with plenty of loopholes and a poxy 6-8 point deduction.
Reply
#72
I know QPR had a massive fine a few years ago but what laws did they break ? Was it completely different to what we are discussing about FFP ?
Reply
#73
So let me get this right, after all the hype, expectation and hope absolutely fugg all that matters is going to happen to those cheatingobnoxiousarrogantdeludedfisheatingsealcunts this season ,, well no change there then as if anyone really thought it would!!!!!
Reply
#74
FFP. It's the hope that kills you
Reply
#75
(04-24-2019, 05:34 PM)Three Degrees Wrote: I know QPR had a massive fine a few years ago but what laws did they break ? Was it completely different to what we are discussing about FFP ?

Have QPR actually paid anything yet though ?

(04-24-2019, 06:16 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: FFP. It's the hope that kills you

Really don’t see anything major happening regardless what rich owners do to break the rules and make a farce of fair competition.
Reply
#76
(04-24-2019, 04:13 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-24-2019, 03:40 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(04-24-2019, 02:55 PM)WorcBaggie Wrote: Not one poster has a clue though. Gew used to write the equivalent to War and Peace about it but neither he, Prag or Minstrel can tell us anything that isn't pretty much in the public domain. We will all here more about the (non) story at about the same time as each other.

i think that is unfair, Worcs.

It is fair to say that we do not have the inside track on the internal workings of any EFL Club, or are privy to the EFL meetings. 

We do understand the P&S rules though, which inter-alia our professional experience does give the ability to comment on the rules and their interpretation. None of us have ever pretended to be ITK, and indeed the information is in the public domain. Not too many people can either be bothered by it, or fully understand it, though.

Spot on KKC.  Apart from the very occasional comment from somebody connected to a club, anything I post is based on my interpretation of info which is in the public domain, including the EFL’s own regulations which remarkably few have bothered to read (including journalists!).

I’m not surprised by the clubs’ vote at today’s meeting of EFL clubs (to be clear, it wasn’t an EFL meeting and I believe that’s going on separately. I couldn’t see that clubs would open their books to other clubs.  It has to be down to the EFL itself as “regulator”.  Does Gibson believe that 3 clubs are telling the EFL the truth about their finances?  Clearly not.

The big problem is that the 3 clubs can string the EFL along, mislead them, lie to them, get promoted by cheating. Next March’s audited accounts will then prove them to have lied, but too late - the horse has bolted and those clubs will take their chances.

What we can’t have is some clubs cheating (without being sanctioned) and prospering as a result, while other clubs abide by the rules.  Either the EFL must enforce their own rules or they must scrap them. One or the other.

Wasn't a personal dig but 8 pages on and still no-one has told anyone anything that we didn't know already and, yes, I understand the P&S rules too.
Reply
#77
Not sure if this is relevant...
http://www.footballnewshound.com/View.as...NI=4776740

https://www.skysports.com/football/news/...ance-plans
Reply
#78
(04-24-2019, 08:37 PM)billybassett Wrote: Not sure if this is relevant...
http://www.footballnewshound.com/View.as...NI=4776740

https://www.skysports.com/football/news/...ance-plans

My take on this is that the rules will be softened in June to allow the wealthy to spunk more cash, and anyone who is in breach this season will receive a slap on the wrists.

Personal opinion.
Reply
#79
So.....

FFP is completely pointless (no pun intended!). 

I can't think where any club has been denied the advantage they gained as a result of breaches.

They may as well scrap it and save all the bother.

Casino football is the future now it seems.
Reply
#80
Clubs have basically laughed at the laws and told everyone connected to piss off , we'll do as we want .
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: