Progress
#11
They can't run them on time due to issues with infrastructure investment, the DfT being at best incompetent or at worst malicious in timetabling, Tory DfT and Treasury ministers not being fit for purpose and the private sector TOCs being run by complete morons with the totally incorrect priorities.

Not because of tickets or disabled people.

This isn't some revolution, if you want to get a ticket from Kenilworth you either need a Swift card, a mobile ticket or to use the machine. It's already happening. Hell, in the WMCA and London the free travel cards already give free train travel as a replacement for the bus pass. Ultimately while the rail industry is in receipt of subsidies it needs to be efficient for the taxpayer which includes reducing unnecessary and outdated customer service options that cost more than they bring in and are phased out on parts of the UK network already.
Reply
#12
BB is correct on the vast majority of this.
Reply
#13
(01-09-2023, 01:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: They can't run them on time due to issues with infrastructure investment, the DfT being at best incompetent or at worst malicious in timetabling, Tory DfT and Treasury ministers not being fit for purpose and the private sector TOCs being run by complete morons with the totally incorrect priorities.

Not because of tickets or disabled people.

This isn't some revolution, if you want to get a ticket from Kenilworth you either need a Swift card, a mobile ticket or to use the machine. It's already happening. Hell, in the WMCA and London the free travel cards already give free train travel as a replacement for the bus pass. Ultimately while the rail industry is in receipt of subsidies it needs to be efficient for the taxpayer which includes reducing unnecessary and outdated customer service options that cost more than they bring in and are phased out on parts of the UK network already.

Providing the long term reasons that they don’t run on time doesn’t make adding something that will slow them down even more any smarter or sensible. If anything, it just underlined how unviable it is.

It’s a classic piece of quantitative thinking that sounds intelligent until it meets reality.

Ironically, much like Rishi’s compulsory Maths until 18 brainwave.
Reply
#14
It's an aspect amongst others that needs to be addressed for a better UK rail network. Ultimately so long as the industry is in receipt of taxpayer subsidies it needs to cut unnecessary operations. That goes for removal of profit and shareholder dividends for TOCs as well. Ultimately it's already phased in on the UK rail network so the barrier of it not working has been overcome and we have real data on operative performance instead of speculation and extrapolated results from the continent.

Ironically if the government let the individual TOCs negotiate with the RMT then I'd imagine that it would be enforced anyway as a concession to reach a negotiated deal as it's really not a hill worth dying on for most RMT members and doesn't actually effect safety or critical operations. But the government are a bunch of populist nincompoops that seem hell bent on scuppering every chance of a deal for some, to me at least, bizarre reason. Some TOCs have already managed to get the RMT to accept it so it's not unprecedented.
Reply
#15
Fundamentally I agree with everything you’re saying, just not the reality or speed at which it can or therefore should be implemented. It has similarities with Brexit- even if you buy into the paper argument, it’s foolish not to consider the obvious incompetence of implementation. By nature of the very points you raise, we know we have a very patchy and piecemeal structure surrounding all this. Get the basics functioning first and at the very least retain and appeal to staff as a career.
Reply
#16
Anyone who has the remotest idea or experience of trying to use public transport with a disability will tell you that cutting staff at stations who can help them access the train is going make using them harder not easier and surely that is ‘progress’. The article is absolutely right this is potentially discrimination, and I trust the myriad of charities that have signed the letter over anyone on here whose opinion is to the contrary.

No wonder most people with a disability will stick with their cars or taxi’s until they are priced off the road. Public transport is utter shite for anyone who doesn’t fit into the ‘norm’ and these changes will not make it easier for them.
Reply
#17
(01-09-2023, 07:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Anyone who has the remotest idea or experience of trying to use public transport with a disability will tell you that cutting staff at stations who can help them access the train is going make using them harder not easier and surely that is ‘progress’. The article is absolutely right this is potentially discrimination, and I trust the myriad of charities that have signed the letter over anyone on here whose opinion is to the contrary.

No wonder most people with a disability will stick with their cars or taxi’s until they are priced off the road. Public transport is utter shite for anyone who doesn’t fit into the ‘norm’ and these changes will not make it easier for them.

We already have unmanned stations, drivers can get out of their cabs to assist disabled passengers in accessing the train as is the case at the myriad of unmanned stations served by DOO services already in this country. This isn't about "the contrary", this is about the operational record both in the UK and in Europe which suggests it won't be a problem. Literally the only point in the article is "who will help us", the answer is the driver as is already the case on parts of the UK network.

The lack of lifts, ramps and stepless entry onto trains is a bigger issue for people with disabilities than staff for God's sakes. Literally all the questions in the article can be answered by "the driver" because that's already how it works on parts of the network. We already have an implemented answer.
Reply
#18
(01-09-2023, 07:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-09-2023, 07:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Anyone who has the remotest idea or experience of trying to use public transport with a disability will tell you that cutting staff at stations who can help them access the train is going make using them harder not easier and surely that is ‘progress’. The article is absolutely right this is potentially discrimination, and I trust the myriad of charities that have signed the letter over anyone on here whose opinion is to the contrary.

No wonder most people with a disability will stick with their cars or taxi’s until they are priced off the road. Public transport is utter shite for anyone who doesn’t fit into the ‘norm’ and these changes will not make it easier for them.

We already have unmanned stations, drivers can get out of their cabs to assist disabled passengers in accessing the train as is the case at the myriad of unmanned stations served by DOO services already in this country. This isn't about "the contrary", this is about the operational record both in the UK and in Europe which suggests it won't be a problem. Literally the only point in the article is "who will help us", the answer is the driver as is already the case on parts of the UK network.

The lack of lifts, ramps and stepless entry onto trains is a bigger issue for people with disabilities than staff for God's sakes. Literally all the questions in the article can be answered by "the driver" because that's already how it works on parts of the network. We already have an implemented answer.

So all the charities that have signed the letter are wrong, ill informed and lacking in experience? Who is going to help with the ramps, over crowded carriages, people blocking entrances, getting people down steps? The driver? Yeah ok
Reply
#19
(01-09-2023, 07:57 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-09-2023, 07:40 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(01-09-2023, 07:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Anyone who has the remotest idea or experience of trying to use public transport with a disability will tell you that cutting staff at stations who can help them access the train is going make using them harder not easier and surely that is ‘progress’. The article is absolutely right this is potentially discrimination, and I trust the myriad of charities that have signed the letter over anyone on here whose opinion is to the contrary.

No wonder most people with a disability will stick with their cars or taxi’s until they are priced off the road. Public transport is utter shite for anyone who doesn’t fit into the ‘norm’ and these changes will not make it easier for them.

We already have unmanned stations, drivers can get out of their cabs to assist disabled passengers in accessing the train as is the case at the myriad of unmanned stations served by DOO services already in this country. This isn't about "the contrary", this is about the operational record both in the UK and in Europe which suggests it won't be a problem. Literally the only point in the article is "who will help us", the answer is the driver as is already the case on parts of the UK network.

The lack of lifts, ramps and stepless entry onto trains is a bigger issue for people with disabilities than staff for God's sakes. Literally all the questions in the article can be answered by "the driver" because that's already how it works on parts of the network. We already have an implemented answer.

So all the charities that have signed the letter are wrong, ill informed and lacking in experience? Who is going to help with the ramps, over crowded carriages, people blocking entrances, getting people down steps? The driver? Yeah ok

Yes, the driver.

That is literally how it works on parts of the UK rail network already. You're not arguing a hypothetical here, you're arguing something that already exists and is in operation in this country.
Reply
#20
In some cases it does. In some cases it’s completely impractical. That ain’t gonna change with doctrine.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)