Today's ratings...
#1
Button - 1 - Fuck me sideways

TGH - 5 - Really poor recently. Moments of energy, but always out of position and gave it away too much. A few good switches of play. 
Kelly - 2 - Fuck me slightly less sideways than buttons score. 
Ajayi - 5 - 4 first half, 6 second. Rusty as to be expected. 
Ashworth - 3 - looked like Bruntys son when he got a run out in the testimonial. 

Reach - 5 - Nothing really wrong, consistently average. But an assist. 
Livermore - 3 - Leggy at the best of times but even less mobile today. 
Rogic - 4 - should never start. Quality from the bench against tiring players. 

Grady - 3 - Oh dear, it's making supporting him hard work. Time to cut our losses in the summer if he doesn't pick up. 
BTA - 6 - 2 goals, one a cracker. But all round game poor. Another better form the bench. 
Grant - 6 - Goal and assist. As usual. Gets slated but contributes. 

Subs:

Fuck knows I kinda give up watching enough to tell. O'Shea brought some class, as did Wallace. Dike gave us a target man. 

Corberan - 5 - Got it wrong swapping the the spine of the team.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#2
Pretty much spot on
Reply
#3
Button - 1 for putting his shirt on the right way round.

TGH - 5 never in a million years is he a RB, looked better in the second half when we had more options in midfield.
Kelly - 4 rusty, slow, looks a player who's played about ten games in three seasons. Great signing Steve.
Ajayi - 5 I'll allow this one as he's coming back from injury and he's solid enough at this level. I'm not sure he displaces O'Shea or Pieters when fit. He's got a way to go to get ahead of Bartley based on most recent showings.
Ashworth - 5 did absolutely nothing wrong, getting dragged at half time made it look worse than it was.

Livermore - 3 it's a shame he's cooked. Should never play for us again.
Rogic - 6 the only one in the first half in our midfield who could pass or tackle. Worryingly still doesn't look ready for 90mins.
Reach - 5 not a central midfield. He's alright but everything he does on a football pitch feels like it has absolutely no intent behind it, he's just kind of there.

Diangana - 2 outsmarted, outworked and out of his depth against a non-league fullback. Needs moving on for everyone's sake.
BTA - 7 took his goals well, should have scored a third but largely anonymous in the game and didn't offer us an outlet when needed in first half. Linked well with Dike. Point off for elbowing their lad.
Grant - 6 took his goal well, but another performance where I didn't really notice him other than that. Was he still on the pitch at the end?

Subs can all have a 6, Dike is a real handful, I hope we can keep him fit.

CC got it wrong with too many changes. Starting Molumby, O'Shea and Palmer and we'd have won that game.
Reply
#4
Very generous on Grant. A goal, then nothing - chucked young Ashworth under the bus by being a lazy prick.
Reply
#5
(01-07-2023, 07:31 PM)TTM2 Wrote: Very generous on Grant. A goal, then nothing - chucked young Ashworth under the bus by being a lazy prick.

All of his marks for setting one up and scoring the other. A lazy prick and we'd have lost 3-1 without him on the pitch. Baffling player.
Reply
#6
Very generous for Grady, didn't beat a non league left back once and was of no help to TGH

Powderpuff fairy
Reply
#7
Rogic isn't a 90 minute player, that was an issue at Celtic, why he was available I guess, even though he is a very talented player.
Reply
#8
Some comments id disagree with

Agreed on too many changes. But to me the stand out issue was having a highly ineffective pairing of Rogic & Reach next to Livermore in the midfield.

Livermore, in my opinion had a reasonable game, but we were completely overrun in centre of the park until changes were made at HT to give us more energy & legs in the centre of the park. Unfair to single him out given who he got paired with, excellent pass for our first goal & put himself about

When Molumby went in the centre with Livermore we were more solid

Diangana was poor & one of our 3 worst performers but I thought 2 players were worse

Rogic barely got nearly the ball in the time he was on the pitch - no surprise he was taken off after 50 mins. Not sure where the suggested tackles & passes were ?? I saw nothing in his game whatsoever

I’ve seen him play a few times & aside from 1 sublime finish & 2 passes I’ve seen nothing in him to think he deserves pitch time. When he plays we look worse than when he doesn’t. (Dire against Cov, the last time he started) No chance of being here after the summer in my opinion unless drastic improvement

Reach was appalling & in my view worst individual performance I’ve seen this season. Both in central midfield & LB, lost his confidence & was an obvious weak link. Wasteful I possession & at fault for at least one of Chesterfields goals

Gardner Hickman had a very good game & was one of our best players - amazed he’s being criticised

And by his low standards Grant had a reasonable time, surprisingly he went past the FB for our first goal with a step over. Haven’t seen it before, hopefully the coache’s influence. Then a goal, I’m one of his biggest critics & reverted to type second half (lost ball for their third goal)

Assante, easily our best player, hardly put a foot wrong first half & with 2 brilliantly taken goals he’s at least an 8 or probably a 9
Reply
#9
Marks as I saw it

Button 3 I see him getting pelters, he actually made two very good saves, an excellent one low down in the first half, very poor to parry out in the middle of our box for their third, confidence is shot and bang average is a compliment

TGH 5 Some good stuff with the ball and a good late assist but struggled defensively and often caught out of position

Ashworth 3 Really struggled and clearly targeted by Chesterfield, talented boy but just shows the jump from U23 level

Kelly 3 Started well and passing was crisp but as soon as we’re we’re on the back foot he looked miles off the pace, 2 year deal is absolute criminal business on our part

Ajayi 3 Looked off the pace from the get go, hopefully you can say will be better for the game, let’s leave it at that

Livermore 3 Can see why we struggled so badly with him in the team, everything going through him slows down any momentum in our build up, his passes are often behind players, his days are done

Reach 4 Good assist and always willing but some good, lots of bad and lazy for their 2nd

Rogic 4 His touch at times in the first half was as good as always but pace of the game was too much for him, hooked will do him no favors at all, really needs 90 minutes

Grady 2 Defended him to the hilt in the week but he was terrible today, couldn’t beat his man, no end product. He’s had some bad personal news lately, wonder if it’s affecting his mindset? Looks mikes off it

Grant 3 One goal, one assist and a 3, criminal non existent hold up play for their 2nd I think, offered nothing bar the early goal and assist, maybe needs games or maybe as I fear, a pretty poor footballer

BTA 7* Only one to come out with credit, two good finishes, worked hard all game and battled for everything

Subs

Molumby 6 Added some impetus without dictating much

Dike 5 Put himself about, couple of half chances

OShea 5 Defended well enough and brought the ball out of defense, sloppy pass at end summed up our display

Okay 7 Passed forward, played through the lines, everything Livermore can’t do

Wallace 5 A couple of dangerous deliveries

Got away with it really, started so well too but defensively we were all over the shop, with Burnley on Friday I can only see a similar team for the replay, and rightly so

We need a midfielder to replace Livermore, heaven help us if The Turk got injured

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#10
(01-07-2023, 07:35 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-07-2023, 07:31 PM)TTM2 Wrote: Very generous on Grant. A goal, then nothing - chucked young Ashworth under the bus by being a lazy prick.

All of his marks for setting one up and scoring the other. A lazy prick and we'd have lost 3-1 without him on the pitch. Baffling player.

It could be argued that of the two goals we conceded were down to a lack of him covering the full back. Grady was absolute dogshit but at least he bothered to track back once or twice.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)